Mexico's General Climate Change Law,
2012
Columbia Law School
Mexico's General Climate Change Law, Michael B. Gerrard, Anne Siders
Faculty Scholarship
Mexico’s General Climate Change Law (CCL) creates a coherent and ambitious national framework within which Mexico may fulfill its Copenhagen Pledge and establish itself as an international leader in climate change mitigation, but achieving these ends will require significant and on-going support from the Mexican government.
At Issue: Energy Efficiency,
2012
Columbia Law School
At Issue: Energy Efficiency, Michael B. Gerrard
Faculty Scholarship
Relatively simple measures, such as switching to more efficient lightbulbs and insulating commercial buildings, hold great promise in efforts to combat climate change. So what's the holdup?
American Natures: The Shape Of Conflict In Environmental Law,
2012
Columbia Law School
American Natures: The Shape Of Conflict In Environmental Law, Jedediah S. Purdy
Faculty Scholarship
There is a firestorm of political and cultural conflict around environmental issues, including, but running well beyond, climate change. Legal scholarship is in a bad position to make sense of this conflict because the field has concentrated on making sound policy recommendations to an idealized lawmaker, neglecting the deeply held and sharply clashing values that drive, or block, environmental lawmaking. This Article sets out a framework for understanding and engaging the clash of values in environmental law and, by extension, approaching the field more generally. Americans have held, and legislated based upon, four distinct ideas about why the natural world …
Agricultural Revolutions And Agency Wars: How The 1950s Laid The Groundwork For "Silent Spring",
2012
Texas A&M University School of Law
Agricultural Revolutions And Agency Wars: How The 1950s Laid The Groundwork For "Silent Spring", Roger E. Meiners, Andrew P. Morriss
Faculty Scholarship
This chapter from the book Silent Spring at 50 analyzes the 1950s struggle over US food policy between USDA and FDA and how that struggle set the stage for the impact of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring. Using a public choice/interest group analysis, the chapter examines how the two agencies reacted to the large scale transformation of US agriculture and food production during and following World War II. Just as agriculture underwent a dramatic productivity revolution that changed the face of American farming, marketing, new home appliances, and increased participation in the labor force by women radically changed the kinds of …
Silent Spring At 50,
2012
Texas A&M University School of Law
Silent Spring At 50, Roger Meiners, Pierre Desrochers, Andrew P. Morriss
Faculty Scholarship
This introduction from the book Silent Spring at 50 describes the various contributors’ insights into Rachel Carson’s landmark work. The authors come from a variety of disciplines, including conservation biology, English, law, and economics, and offer critical assessments of Silent Spring and its legacy. The first part has three chapters that put the book into the context of its time, examining it in light of Carson’s previous books on the sea (Wallace Kaufman); the larger tradition of authors warning against human hubris in environmental matters (Pierre Desrochers & Hiroko Shimizu); and the contest between “environmental religion” and “economic religion” that …
Chair's Message,
2012
Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law
V.3, 2012 Masthead,
2012
University of San Diego
Foreword,
2012
University of San Diego
Foreword, Dan Hua
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
On April 15, 2011, the San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law and the Energy Policy Initiatives Center co-hosted the Third Annual Climate & Energy Law Symposium. The Symposium examined various emerging law and policy approaches to encourage clean energy. At the Symposium, panels consisting of legal and policy experts from across the country addressed and debated a variety of key issues including the coordination of state and federal roles in the clean energy sector, the design of policies and markets for renewable energy and energy efficiency, and the balance between energy and environmental protection.
State Renewable Portfolio Standards: Is There A "Race" And Is It "To The Top"?,
2012
University of San Diego
State Renewable Portfolio Standards: Is There A "Race" And Is It "To The Top"?, Lincoln L. Davies
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
This Article proceeds in six parts. Part II offers a primer on RPSs, describing RPSs primary traits, how the laws are designed, why they are enacted, and how that relates to regulatory races. Part III overviews the literature on regulatory races, contrasting races to the bottom with races to the top. Part IV conceptualizes how state enactments of RPSs might be viewed as a race to the top. Part V examines evidence on whether RPSs can in fact be understood as a regulatory race. Using this evidence, Part V determines that state RPSs do not appear to be trending toward …
Why Not A Regional Approach To State Renewable Power Mandates?,
2012
University of San Diego
Why Not A Regional Approach To State Renewable Power Mandates?, Kirsten H. Engel
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
There is much to be said in favor of a regional approach with respect to renewable energy mandates. First, uniformity in the particulars of state RPS laws would assist the growing interstate renewable energy market. Second, allowing renewable power that is generated anywhere but delivered locally to satisfy the RPS of any of the states within the region, should enhance the reliability of the market for renewable power, increase the amount of intermittent power accommodated by the grid, and lower the price of renewable power. Each of these effects will strengthen the regional market for renewable power to the overall …
Energy And Animals: A History Of Conflict,
2012
University of San Diego
Energy And Animals: A History Of Conflict, Alexandra B. Klass
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
Environmental groups, federal and state agencies, and others who support the development of renewable energy have struggled in recent years with the adverse impacts of such development on animals and animal habitat. Although renewable energy development has the benefit of creating energy without the greenhouse gas emissions associated with traditional energy development, it does so through an intensive use of land, including federal public lands, thus competing with habitats for protected species and other wildlife. Conflicts between energy and animals, of course, are nothing new. Congress, agencies, and courts have attempted for decades to balance the public interest in domestic …
Port And Coastal State Control Of Atmospheric Pollution,
2012
University of San Diego
Port And Coastal State Control Of Atmospheric Pollution, Michael W. Reed
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
Controlling atmospheric pollution which originates beyond national borders always presents difficult issues. The problems are multiplied when the source is a merchant vessel, registered under a foreign flag of convenience and operating seaward of state and federal sovereign limits. Nevertheless, international law provides alternative approaches through which the coastal sovereign may protect its onshore environmental interests.
The purpose of this paper is to lay out the problems, both factual and legal, and discuss means by which they may be resolved. California is used as a case study. The state has long suffered from excessive air pollution. Congress acknowledged the state?s …
Clean Energy And The Price Preemption Ceiling,
2012
University of San Diego
Clean Energy And The Price Preemption Ceiling, Jim Rossi
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
Part I of this Article provides an illustration of the feed-in tariff one clean energy innovation many state and municipal governments have enacted to encourage investment in renewable energy. In a nutshell, the feed-in tariff is a secure contract for renewable power at a set price over a term of years that provides a return to investors in these projects, such as a homeowner installing a solar panel or wind turbine. Part II of this Article describes preemption issues that have risen with feed-in tariffs under two federal statutes the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978, which requires utilities …
Regulation, Climate Change, And The Electric Grid,
2012
University of San Diego
Regulation, Climate Change, And The Electric Grid, Davod B. Spence
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
In Part I of this essay, I outline some of the background characteristics of the electric grid, the way it is operated, and the way regulators and grid operators manage the sale and transmission of electricity across it. In Part II, I explore the opportunities and potential problems associated with integrating intermittent, renewable sources of electric generation into the grid. This discussion includes a review of a number of recent studies examining the GHG emissions effects of using fossil fueled generation to back up wind power, as well as the U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission?s (FERC) recent rulemakings addressing this …
The Politics Of Clean Energy: Moving Beyond The Beltway,
2012
University of San Diego
The Politics Of Clean Energy: Moving Beyond The Beltway, Joseph P. Tomain
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
This Article argues that the United States can achieve a new and smart energy policy and that we are taking active steps in this direction. Off of the Hill, at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, there is clear thinking about clean energy. Consider President Obamas choice for Secretary of Commerce, John Bryson. Bryson has been the CEO of a public electric utility, a founder of the Natural Resources Defense Council, and sits on the boards of such organizations as Boeing and Disney and clean energy firms like Coda Automotive and BrightSource Energy exactly the right job description for a clean energy advocate. …
Effective Renewable Energy Policy: Leave It To The States?,
2012
University of San Diego
Effective Renewable Energy Policy: Leave It To The States?, Steven Weissman
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
The federal system employed in the United States offers many models for cooperation between the federal government and the states in pursuit of important policy objectives. Under the Clean Air Act, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency can establish air quality standards and delegate enforcement to the states. The Coastal Zone Management Act empowers states to establish plans for management of ocean waters close to shore and to have a say related to offshore projects that are in federal jurisdictional waters. The Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 allows coal states to set and enforce their own rules related …
Space Commercialization: The Need To Immediately Renegotiate Treaties Implicating International Environmental Law,
2012
University of San Diego
Space Commercialization: The Need To Immediately Renegotiate Treaties Implicating International Environmental Law, Alexander G. Davis
San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law
Outer space is truly the final frontier for both scientific exploration and frontier-style commercialization. Given its extra-national nature, international treaties have formed the basis of space law, but these treaties predate any notion of the true potential for space commercialization. The private sector has relied on this regulation-free industry when developing its spacecraft, mission structure, and operating procedures, often to the detriment of Earth's and its surrounding environment, with space debris, i.e. space junk or space trash, and greenhouse gas emissions being the primary externalities. This Comment provides a background on the commercial space industry and applicable law and treaties, …
Addressing Global Climate Change In An Age Of Political Climate Change,
2011
Brigham Young University Law School
Addressing Global Climate Change In An Age Of Political Climate Change, Brigham Daniels
BYU Law Review
For a number of years, many within the environmental legal community have advocated an all-out attack strategy of forcing the United States to address climate change by bringing novel lawsuits under existing environmental laws. In 2007, with the seminal case of Massachusetts v. EPA, it appeared that those advocating this strategy had a winning game plan. That sense grew and solidified when the Obama Administration came to power. However, over the past several years, we have seen a countervailing movement embodied in a growing resentment towards EPA and climate change policy in general. This movement has mobilized into a powerful …
Environmental Crisis And The Paradox Of Organizing,
2011
Brigham Young University Law School
Environmental Crisis And The Paradox Of Organizing, Gregg P. Macey
BYU Law Review
Public organizations, including those involved in contingency planning, have tremendous influence over the ultimate scale and scope of an environmental crisis. Yet our understanding of how organizational behavior can either rein in or exacerbate crises continues to lag behind advances in technology. This Article considers the role of public organizations in the blowout of the Macondo well in the Gulf of Mexico. Its theoretical lens is the “paradox of organizing,” a frame that I suggest should be applied to interorganizational responses to low-probability, high-consequence events. The struggle to differentiate tasks and subunits and then piece them together during moments of …
Navigating The Intersection Of Environmental Law And Disaster Law,
2011
Brigham Young University Law School
Navigating The Intersection Of Environmental Law And Disaster Law, Daniel Farber
BYU Law Review
In an environmental disaster, a disaster causes environmental harm, or an environmental change causes an acute risk to humans, or a combination of both takes place. Examples include the BP oil spill, the London killer fog of 1952, the 2003 European heat wave, and the 2011 Japanese tsunami. Climate change will intensify the connection between disaster issues and the environment. Given the interwoven nature of disasters and the environment, we should consider what environmental law and disaster law can learn from each other. Environmental law has the most to teach disaster law about risk management and prevention. Disaster law, in …
