Bioethics and Medical Ethics Commons^™

Prediction Of Methotrexate Neurotoxicity Using Clinical, Sociodemographic, And Area-Based Information In Children With Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia, Rachel D Harris, Olga A Taylor, Maria Monica Gramatges, Amy E Hughes, Mark Zobeck, Sandi Pruitt, M Brooke Bernhardt, Ashley Chavana, Van Huynh, Kathleen Ludwig, Laura Klesse, Kenneth Heym, Timothy Griffin, Rodrigo Erana, Juan Carlos Bernini, Ashley Choi, Yuu Ohno, Melissa A Richard, Alanna C Morrison, Han Chen, Bing Yu, Philip J Lupo, Karen R Rabin, Michael E Scheurer, Austin L Brown

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Background: Methotrexate is a critical component of pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) therapy that can result in neurotoxicity which has been associated with an increased risk of relapse. We leveraged machine learning to develop a neurotoxicity risk prediction model in a diverse cohort of children with ALL.

Methods: We included children (age 2-20 years) diagnosed with ALL (2005-2019) and treated in Texas without pre-existing neurologic disease. Clinical information was obtained by medical record review. Neurotoxicity occurring post-induction and prior to maintenance therapy was defined as neurologic episodes occurring within 21 days of methotrexate. Suspected cases were independently confirmed by 2 …

Maternal Loss Of Mouse Nlrp2 Alters The Transcriptome And Dna Methylome In Gv Oocytes And Impairs Zygotic Genome Activation In Embryos, Zahra Anvar, Michael D Jochum, Imen Chakchouk, Momal Sharif, Hannah Demond, Alvin K To, Daniel C Kraushaar, Ying-Wooi Wan, Michael C Mari, Simon Andrews, Gavin Kelsey, Ignatia B Van Den Veyver

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Background: NLRP2 is a subcortical maternal complex (SCMC) protein of mammalian oocytes and preimplantation embryos. SCMC proteins are encoded by maternal effect genes and play a pivotal role in the maternal-to-zygotic transition (MZT), early embryogenesis, and epigenetic (re)programming. Maternal inactivation of genes encoding SCMC proteins has been linked to infertility and subfertility in mice and humans, but the underlying molecular mechanisms for the diverse functions of SCMC proteins, and specifically the role of NLRP2, are incompletely understood.

Results: We profiled the DNA methylome of pre-ovulatory germinal-vesicle (GV) oocytes from Nlrp2-null, heterozygous (Het), and wild-type (WT) female mice and assessed the …

A Novel Cardiomyopathy Phenotype Linked To A Chd7 Missense Variant, In Young Park, Chih-Wei Hsu, Karim Bouazoune, Christina E Espindola, Madeline Hannah Mclaughlin Armond, Cristian Coarfa, Sandra L Grimm, James F Martin, Donna M Martin, Cheryl Lyn Walker

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Loss of function in the chromatin remodeler CHD7 causes CHARGE syndrome, characterized by variable penetrance and diverse abnormalities. However, establishing genotype-phenotype correlations has been challenging, as most CHD7 inactivating mutations are null alleles. Through CHD7 missense variant analysis at potential phosphorylation sites, we identified T730 (T720 in mice) as a critical residue associated with pathogenesis. Using a CHD7 T730 missense variant (Chd7T720A) and a frameshift null allele (Chd7fs) in a mouse model, we found that Chd7fs/fs mice were non-viable, while Chd7fs/+ mice exhibited haploinsufficiency-related circling behavior. Notably, Chd7fs/T720A mice died before postnatal …

Xbp1s-Edem2 Prevents The Onset And Development Of Hfpef By Ameliorating Cardiac Lipotoxicity, Oveena Fonseka, Rida Raja, Claire Ross, Sanskruti R Gare, Jiayan Zhang, Susanne S Hille, Katharine King, Andrea Ruiz-Velasco, Namrita Kaur, Xinyi Chen, Jessica M Miller, Riham R E Abouleisa, Qinghui Ou, Zhiyong Zou, Xiangjun Zhao, Cristian Sotomayor-Flores, Derk Frank, Eileithyia Swanton, Martin R Pool, Sara Missaglia, Daniela Tavian, Gabriele G Schiattarella, Tao Wang, Luigi Venetucci, Christian Pinali, Martin K Rutter, Bernard D Keavney, Elizabeth J Cartwright, Tamer M A Mohamed, Oliver J Müller, Wei Liu

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Background: Morbidity and mortality of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) is increased in metabolic disorders. However, options for preventing and treating these prevalent outcomes are limited. Intramyocardial lipotoxicity contributes to cardiac dysfunction. Here, we investigate the mechanisms underlying EDEM2 (endoplasmic reticulum degradation-enhancing alpha-mannosidase-like protein 2) regulation of cardiac lipid homeostasis and assess strategies that inhibit the incidence and progression of HFpEF.

Methods: Metabolic stress was induced in C57BL/6 male mice using a high-fat diet and Nω-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester. The recombinant adeno-associated virus 9 delivery system was used for loss- and gain-of-function studies. Palmitic acid and oleic acid …

Ocular Phenotyping Of Knockout Mice Identifies Genes Associated With Late Adult Retinal Phenotypes, Abraham Hang, Andy Shao, Michael Shea, Michel J Roux, Denise M Imai-Leonard, David J Adams, Takanori Amano, Oana V Amarie, Zorana Berberovic, Raphaël Bour, Lynette Bower, Brian C Leonard, Steve D Brown, Soo Young Cho, Sharon Clementson-Mobbs, Abigail J D'Souza, Mary Dickinson, Mohammad Eskandarian, Ann M Flenniken, Helmut Fuchs, Valerie Gailus-Durner, Jason Heaney, Yann Hérault, Martin Hrabe De Angelis, Chih-Wei Hsu, Shundan Jin, Russell Joynson, Yeon Kyung Kang, Haerim Kim, Hiroshi Masuya, Ki-Hoan Nam, Hyuna Noh, Lauryl M J Nutter, Marcela Palkova, Jan Prochazka, Miles Joseph Raishbrook, Fabrice Riet, Jason Salazar, John Richard Seavitt, Radislav Sedlacek, Mohammed Selloum, Kyoung Yul Seo, Je Kyung Seong, Hae-Sol Shin, Toshihiko Shiroishi, Tania Sorg, Michelle Stewart, Masaru Tamura, Heather Tolentino, Uchechukwu Udensi, Sara Wells, Wolfgang Wurst, Atsushi Yoshiki, Hamid Meziane, Glenn Yiu, Paul A Sieving, Louise Lanoue, K C Kent Lloyd, Colin Mckerlie, Ala Moshiri, International Mouse Phenotyping Consortium (Impc)

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Purpose: Analyze phenotypic data from knockout mice with late-adult retinal pathologic phenotypes to identify genes associated with development of adult-onset retinal diseases.

Methods: The International Mouse Phenotyping Consortium (IMPC) database was queried for genes associated with abnormal retinal phenotypes in the late-adult knockout mouse pipeline (49-80 weeks postnatal age). We identified human orthologs and performed protein-protein analysis and biological pathways analysis with known inherited retinal disease (IRD) and age-related macular degeneration (AMD) genes using Search Tool for the Retrieval of Interacting Genes/Proteins (STRING), PLatform for Analysis of single cell Eye in a Disk (PLAE), Protein Analysis Through Evolutionary Relationships (PANTHER), …

An Interview With Rita Charon, Nathan Carlin

Faculty and Staff Publications

This is an edited transcript of an interview with Rita Charon. Nathan Carlin conducted the interview in her apartment in New York City on October 18, 2024. They discussed a number of topics, including Charon's educational journey, her mentors, the founding of narrative medicine, the status of narrative medicine today as well as its future, the relationship between narrative medicine and literature and medicine, and the ethics of writing about patients.

A Meta-Analysis Of Diagnostic Yield And Clinical Utility Of Genome And Exome Sequencing In Pediatric Rare And Undiagnosed Genetic Diseases, Rajshree Pandey, Noemi Fluetsch Brennan, Kalliopi Trachana, Sarah Katsandres, Olaf Bodamer, John Belmont, David L Veenstra, Siyang Peng

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Purpose: To systematically evaluate the diagnostic yield and clinical utility of genome sequencing (GS) and exome sequencing (ES; genome-wide sequencing [GWS]) in pediatric patients with rare and undiagnosed genetic diseases.

Methods: We conducted a meta-analysis of studies published between 2011 and 2023. To address study heterogeneity, comparative analyses included within-cohort studies using random-effects models.

Results: We identified 108 studies including 24,631 probands with diverse clinical indications. The pooled diagnostic yield among within-cohort studies (N = 13) for GWS was 34.2% (95% CI: 27.6-41.5; I2: 86%) vs 18.1% (95% CI: 13.1-24.6; I2: 89%) for non-GWS, with 2.4-times odds of diagnosis (95% …

Joint Analysis Of The Npod-Virus Group Data: The Association Of Enterovirus With Type 1 Diabetes Is Supported By Multiple Markers Of Infection In Pancreas Tissue, Sarah J Richardson, Teresa Rodriguez-Calvo, Jutta E Laiho, John S Kaddis, Julius O Nyalwidhe, Irina Kusmartseva, Sofia Morfopoulou, Joseph F Petrosino, Vincent Plagnol, Kathrin Maedler, Margaret A Morris, Jerry L Nadler, Mark A Atkinson, Matthias Von Herrath, Richard E Lloyd, Heikki Hyoty, Noel G Morgan, Alberto Pugliese, Npod-Virus Group

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Aims/hypothesis: Previous pathology studies have associated enterovirus infections with type 1 diabetes by examining the enterovirus capsid protein 1 (VP1) in autopsy pancreases obtained near diabetes diagnosis. The Network for Pancreatic Organ Donors with Diabetes (nPOD) has since obtained pancreases from organ donors with type 1 diabetes (with broad age and disease duration) and donors with disease-associated autoantibodies (AAbs), the latter representing preclinical disease. Two accompanying manuscripts from the nPOD-Virus Group report primary data from a coordinated analysis of multiple enterovirus indices. We aimed to comprehensively assess the association of multiple enterovirus markers with type 1 diabetes.

Methods: The nPOD-Virus …

Detection Of Enterovirus Rna In Pancreas And Lymphoid Tissues Of Organ Donors With Type 1 Diabetes, Jutta E Laiho, Sami Oikarinen, Sofia Morfopoulou, Maarit Oikarinen, Ashlie Renner, Daniel Depledge, Matthew C Ross, Ivan C Gerling, Judith Breuer, Joseph F Petrosino, Vincent Plagnol, Alberto Pugliese, Antonio Toniolo, Richard E Lloyd, Heikki Hyöty, Npod-Virus Group

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Aims/hypothesis: The nPOD-Virus group collaboratively applied innovative technologies to detect and sequence viral RNA in pancreas and other tissues from organ donors with type 1 diabetes. These analyses involved the largest number of pancreas samples collected to date. The aim of the current work was to examine the presence of enterovirus RNA in pancreas and lymphoid tissues of organ donors with and without type 1 diabetes.

Methods: We analysed pancreas, spleen, pancreatic lymph nodes and duodenum samples from the following groups: (1) donors with type 1 diabetes (n=71) with (n=35) or without (n=36) insulin-containing islets; (2) donors with single or …

A Multi-Site Study Of Clinician Perspectives In The Lifecycle Of An Algorithmic Risk Prediction Tool, Rita Dexter, Kristin Kostick-Quenet, Jennifer Blumenthal-Barby

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Recent advancements in the performative capacities of artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML), and algorithmic-based tools open up numerous applications in modern medicine. There are, however, few studies that track the whole lifecycle of a digital healthcare tool as it evolves from conception, to design, and deployment in real world settings-especially with a focus on the social dynamics amongst the end-users of the tool: clinicians. In this paper, we present data from a multi-site, 5-year study focused on the development and deployment of an algorithmic risk calculator (HeartMate 3 Risk Score) into a validated and efficacy tested clinical decision support …

International Society For Cell & Gene Therapy Expanded Access Working Group Position Paper: Key Considerations To Support Equitable And Ethical Expanded Access To Investigational Cell- And Gene-Based Interventions, Elena Maryamchik, Laertis Ikonomou, Beth E Roxland, Felix Grignon, Bruce L Levine, Bambi J Grilley

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

This position paper reviews the Expanded Access pathway for cell and gene therapies, examining its critical role at the nexus of patient need, regulatory frameworks, and scientific advancement. Spearheaded by the International Society for Cell & Gene Therapy's Expanded Access Working Group, it explores how investigational therapies are accessed outside of clinical trials for patients with serious or life-threatening conditions when no approved alternatives exist. Access to cell and gene therapy products are of specific interest to patients because many times the products are bespoke, being used to treat serious and/or incurable conditions, and are potentially curative. As the field …

Genome-Wide Analyses Identify 30 Loci Associated With Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder, Nora I Strom, Zachary F Gerring, Marco Galimberti, Dongmei Yu, Matthew W Halvorsen, Abdel Abdellaoui, Cristina Rodriguez-Fontenla, Julia M Sealock, Tim Bigdeli, Jonathan R Coleman, Behrang Mahjani, Jackson G Thorp, Katharina Bey, Christie L Burton, Jurjen J Luykx, Gwyneth Zai, Silvia Alemany, Christine Andre, Kathleen D Askland, Julia Bäckman, Nerisa Banaj, Cristina Barlassina, Judith Becker Nissen, O Joseph Bienvenu, Donald Black, Michael H Bloch, Sigrid Børte, Rosa Bosch, Michael Breen, Brian P Brennan, Helena Brentani, Joseph D Buxbaum, Jonas Bybjerg-Grauholm, Enda M Byrne, Judit Cabana-Dominguez, Beatriz Camarena, Adrian Camarena, Carolina Cappi, Angel Carracedo, Miguel Casas, Maria Cristina Cavallini, Valentina Ciullo, Edwin H Cook, Jesse Crosby, Bernadette A Cullen, Elles J De Schipper, Richard Delorme, Srdjan Djurovic, Jason A Elias, Xavier Estivill, Martha J Falkenstein, Bengt T Fundin, Lauryn Garner, Christina Gironda, Fernando S Goes, Marco A Grados, Jakob Grove, Wei Guo, Jan Haavik, Kristen Hagen, Kelly Harrington, Alexandra Havdahl, Kira D Höffler, Ana G Hounie, Donald Hucks, Christina Hultman, Magdalena Janecka, Eric Jenike, Elinor K Karlsson, Kara Kelley, Julia Klawohn, Janice E Krasnow, Kristi Krebs, Christoph Lange, Nuria Lanzagorta, Daniel Levey, Kerstin Lindblad-Toh, Fabio Macciardi, Brion Maher, Brittany Mathes, Evonne Mcarthur, Nathaniel Mcgregor, Nicole C Mclaughlin, Sandra Meier, Euripedes C Miguel, Maureen Mulhern, Paul S Nestadt, Erika L Nurmi, Kevin S O'Connell, Lisa Osiecki, Olga Therese Ousdal, Teemu Palviainen, Nancy L Pedersen, Fabrizio Piras, Federica Piras, Sriramya Potluri, Raquel Rabionet, Alfredo Ramirez, Scott Rauch, Abraham Reichenberg, Mark A Riddle, Stephan Ripke, Maria C Rosário, Aline S Sampaio, Miriam A Schiele, Anne Heidi Skogholt, Laura G Sloofman, Jan Smit, María Soler Artigas, Laurent F Thomas, Eric Tifft, Homero Vallada, Nathanial Van Kirk, Jeremy Veenstra-Vanderweele, Nienke N Vulink, Christopher P Walker, Ying Wang, Jens R Wendland, Bendik S Winsvold, Yin Yao, Hang Zhou, Estonian Biobank, 23andme Inc, Arpana Agrawal, Pino Alonso, Götz Berberich, Kathleen K Bucholz, Cynthia M Bulik, Danielle Cath, Damiaan Denys, Valsamma Eapen, Howard Edenberg, Peter Falkai, Thomas V Fernandez, Abby J Fyer, J M Gaziano, Dan A Geller, Hans J Grabe, Benjamin D Greenberg, Gregory L Hanna, Ian B Hickie, David M Hougaard, Norbert Kathmann, James Kennedy, Dongbing Lai, Mikael Landén, Stéphanie Le Hellard, Marion Leboyer, Christine Lochner, James T Mccracken, Sarah E Medland, Preben B Mortensen, Benjamin M Neale, Humberto Nicolini, Merete Nordentoft, Michele Pato, Carlos Pato, David L Pauls, John Piacentini, Christopher Pittenger, Danielle Posthuma, Josep Antoni Ramos-Quiroga, Steven A Rasmussen, Margaret A Richter, David R Rosenberg, Stephan Ruhrmann, Jack F Samuels, Sven Sandin, Paul Sandor, Gianfranco Spalletta, Dan J Stein, S Evelyn Stewart, Eric A Storch, Barbara E Stranger, Maurizio Turiel, Thomas Werge, Ole A Andreassen, Anders D Børglum, Susanne Walitza, Kristian Hveem, Bjarne K Hansen, Christian Rück, Nicholas G Martin, Lili Milani, Ole Mors, Ted Reichborn-Kjennerud, Marta Ribasés, Gerd Kvale, David Mataix-Cols, Katharina Domschke, Edna Grünblatt, Michael Wagner, John-Anker Zwart, Gerome Breen, Gerald Nestadt, Jaakko Kaprio, Paul D Arnold, Dorothy E Grice, James A Knowles, Helga Ask, Karin J Verweij, Lea K Davis, Dirk J Smit, James J Crowley, Jeremiah M Scharf, Murray B Stein, Joel Gelernter, Carol A Mathews, Eske M Derks, Manuel Mattheisen

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) affects ~1% of children and adults and is partly caused by genetic factors. We conducted a genome-wide association study (GWAS) meta-analysis combining 53,660 OCD cases and 2,044,417 controls and identified 30 independent genome-wide significant loci. Gene-based approaches identified 249 potential effector genes for OCD, with 25 of these classified as the most likely causal candidates, including WDR6, DALRD3 and CTNND1 and multiple genes in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) region. We estimated that ~11,500 genetic variants explained 90% of OCD genetic heritability. OCD genetic risk was associated with excitatory neurons in the hippocampus and the cortex, along …

Promises And Pitfalls Of Preimplantation Genetic Testing For Polygenic Disorders: A Narrative Review, Jaime A Roura-Monllor, Zachary Walker, Joel M Reynolds, Greysha Rivera-Cruz, Avner Hershlag, Gheona Altarescu, Sigal Klipstein, Stacey Pereira, Gabriel Lázaro-Muñoz, Shai Carmi, Todd Lencz, Ruth Bunker Lathi

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Preimplantation genetic testing for polygenic disorders (PGT-P) has been commercially available since 2019. PGT-P makes use of polygenic risk scores for conditions which are multifactorial and are significantly influenced by environmental and lifestyle factors. If current predictions are accurate, then absolute risk reductions range from about 0.02% to 10.1%, meaning that between 10 and 5,000 in vitro fertilization patients would need to be tested with PGT-P to prevent one offspring from becoming affected in the future, depending on the condition and the number of embryos available. Survey and interview data reveal that patients and the public have largely favorable views …

It Is Not Clear How Well Physical Activity Promotion Materials Are Understood: Findings From A Rapid Literature Review, Jafra D. Thomas, Jasmine C. Wong, Regina F. Hockert, Yi Sheng Wu, Winston Kennedy

Topics in Exercise Science and Kinesiology

Topics in Exercise Science and Kinesiology Volume 6: Issue 1, Article 6, 2025. Efforts to promote physical activity and other health-related behaviors are more effective when resource materials are understood by a wide and diverse audience. Before our lab’s previous investigations (Thomas et al., 2024), only one study seemed to use the cloze procedure to directly test the comprehension (i.e., readability) of physical activity promotion material (Cardinal & Seidler, 1995). Thus, this rapid literature review sought to (a) determine the extent the cloze procedure has been used to study physical activity promotion material comprehension in lay adults and (b) collate …

The Global Clinical Trials Ecosystem: A Critical Evaluation And Future Outlook, Sydney-Ariel D. Muneses

Undergraduate Honors Theses

As global clinical trials expand, inconsistencies in regulatory and ethical frameworks are increasingly evident, raising concerns about economic sustainability and participant protections. Existing research attributes this surge to pharmaceutical companies seeking cost efficiencies in emerging markets but acknowledges the challenges posed by fragmented oversight across international jurisdictions. To examine these limitations, a modified Delphi approach was used to gather expert insights from key stakeholders in global clinical trials. Findings highlighted systemic inefficiencies and ethical gaps, emphasizing the need for regulatory harmonization to balance scientific rigor, economic feasibility, and equitable participant treatment. By identifying critical shortcomings and proposing strategies to align …

Navigating The Future Of Polygenic Risk Scores: Insights From Child And Adolescent Psychiatrists, Page M Trotter, Amanda R Merner, Lauren A Ginn, Abigail C Martinez, Ana L Battaglino, Kaitlynn P Craig, Jason Bach, Katherine J Freedberg, Takahiro Soda, Eric A Storch, Gabriel Lázaro-Muñoz, Stacey Pereira

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Polygenic risk scores (PRS) are a method of calculating genetic risk for polygenic, or multi-gene, disorders. These scores have potential impacts in the realm of child and adolescent psychiatry, given the high prevalence of psychiatric disorders among youth. However, there are concerns about PRS implementation among key stakeholders, namely child and adolescent psychiatrists (CAP). We conducted interviews with 29 U.S.-based CAP to investigate clinician attitudes toward the use of PRS. The data herein correspond to a future scenario we provided CAP in which PRS are accurate and portable to patients of different racial and ethnic backgrounds. We found that CAP …

Science Tikkun: A Bioscience Pandemic Framework In A Hebrew Tradition Of Global Repair, Peter Hotez

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Over the past decade we have seen a steady increase in dangerous pandemic threats. They include two major Ebola epidemics and cholera in Africa; dengue, Zika, yellow fever in the Americas; a COVID-19 pandemic; and H5N1 in Texas. This is happening because of a confluence of modern forces including urbanization, deforestation, and climate change. Yet as pandemics emerge on a crowded and warming planet, anti-science disinformation and antisemitism impede our response. Science tikkun is an overarching framework for repair and redress. It honors the legacy of Maimonides, Teilhard de Chardin, and others who have sought reconciliation between science and religion.

Intraoperative Code Status: Moving From Misinformation To Respect For Patient Autonomy, Jacob Applegarth, Nathan M. Novotny, Ngan Nguyen, Abram Brummett

Conference Presentation Abstracts

No abstract provided.

Should Physicians Take The Rap? Normative Analysis Of Clinician Perspectives On Responsible Use Of 'Black Box' Ai Tools, Ben H Lang, Kristin Kostick-Quenet, Jared N Smith, Meghan Hurley, Rita Dexter, Jennifer Blumenthal-Barby

Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Staff Publications

Background: Increasing interest in deploying artificial intelligence tools in clinical contexts has raised several ethical questions of both normative and empirical interest. One such question in the literature is whether "responsibility gaps" (r-gaps) are created when clinicians utilize or rely on such tools for providing care, and if so, what to do about them. These gaps are particularly likely to arise when using opaque, "black box" AI tools. Compared to normative and legal analysis of AI-generated responsibility gaps in health care, little is known, empirically, about health care providers views on this issue. The present study examines clinician perspectives on …

The Contribution Of Catholic Compromise Principles In Global Health, Scott N. Helstad

Electronic Theses and Dissertations

The Roman Catholic tradition has developed comprehensive ethical principles to address complex practical scenarios that encounter foundational value compromises. These are referred to as compromise principles and they have both a narrow and a broad focus. Narrowly, these compromise principles are critical for Catholic healthcare organizations in the United States with regard to the guidelines of the US Bishops in their Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services. More broadly, these compromise principles are relevant in the secular realm regarding global health. This dissertation examines these varying perspectives, hence its title, “The Contribution of Catholic Compromise Principles …