Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Constitutional Law (34986)
- International Law (32265)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (29795)
- Criminal Law (27913)
- Environmental Law (18447)
-
- Intellectual Property Law (17073)
- Legal Education (16878)
- State and Local Government Law (16692)
- Courts (16647)
- Civil Rights and Discrimination (14896)
- Health Law and Policy (14628)
- Legislation (14560)
- Law and Society (14114)
- Administrative Law (14113)
- Comparative and Foreign Law (14050)
- Indigenous, Indian, and Aboriginal Law (13883)
- Human Rights Law (12316)
- Criminal Procedure (12064)
- Legal Profession (11684)
- Labor and Employment Law (11186)
- Business Organizations Law (10759)
- Arts and Humanities (10734)
- Sociology (10391)
- Legal History (10009)
- Legal Studies (9827)
- Jurisprudence (9247)
- Torts (9012)
- Science and Technology Law (8821)
- Property Law and Real Estate (8398)
- Institution
-
- Brigham Young University Law School (37205)
- University of Michigan Law School (21829)
- Duke Law (14425)
- Fordham Law School (13334)
- Maurer School of Law: Indiana University (11951)
-
- University of Oklahoma College of Law (11866)
- Yeshiva University, Cardozo School of Law (11515)
- Case Western Reserve University School of Law (10936)
- Southern Methodist University (10168)
- William & Mary Law School (9532)
- American University Washington College of Law (9074)
- Northwestern Pritzker School of Law (8932)
- UC Law SF (8879)
- University of North Carolina School of Law (8799)
- Notre Dame Law School (8250)
- Vanderbilt University Law School (8031)
- University of South Carolina (7596)
- University of Minnesota Law School (7364)
- University of Missouri School of Law (7266)
- Cornell University Law School (7209)
- University of Colorado Law School (7196)
- University of Kentucky (6982)
- Washington and Lee University School of Law (6925)
- Louisiana State University Law Center (6749)
- Marquette University Law School (6614)
- University of Chicago Law School (6494)
- Seton Hall University (6196)
- University of Washington School of Law (6130)
- University of Richmond (6022)
- Chicago-Kent College of Law (5729)
- Keyword
-
- Law (6238)
- Constitutional law (3540)
- International law (3379)
- Supreme Court (3331)
- Human rights (3205)
-
- Constitutional Law (3006)
- United States (2673)
- First Amendment (2663)
- Copyright (2559)
- Constitution (2538)
- Discrimination (2512)
- International Law (2282)
- Evidence (2258)
- Criminal law (2243)
- Regulation (2188)
- Jurisprudence (2141)
- United States Supreme Court (2103)
- University of Michigan Law School (2099)
- History (2072)
- Privacy (2071)
- Intellectual property (1970)
- Philosophy (1969)
- Legislation (1945)
- Politics (1910)
- Legal education (1897)
- Jurisdiction (1894)
- Ethics (1877)
- Courts (1820)
- Law students (1784)
- Contracts (1781)
- Publication Year
-
- 2026 (7597)
- 2025 (10544)
- 2024 (10969)
- 2023 (11463)
- 2022 (14827)
-
- 2021 (13133)
- 2020 (12812)
- 2019 (12040)
- 2018 (13590)
- 2017 (14046)
- 2016 (15271)
- 2015 (14369)
- 2014 (12634)
- 2013 (12812)
- 2012 (13465)
- 2011 (11717)
- 2010 (11499)
- 2009 (11211)
- 2008 (10753)
- 2007 (10551)
- 2006 (11365)
- 2005 (10092)
- 2004 (9683)
- 2003 (8863)
- 2002 (8338)
- 2001 (9172)
- 2000 (8631)
- 1999 (7767)
- 1998 (7674)
- 1992 (7926)
- Publication
-
- Faculty Scholarship (21548)
- Articles (11521)
- Michigan Law Review (11192)
- Faculty Publications (8709)
- American Indian and Alaskan Native Documents in the Congressional Serial Set: 1817-1899 (8590)
-
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (through 1995) (6781)
- Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (6683)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (1996–2006) (6653)
- North Carolina Law Review (6028)
- Louisiana Law Review (5640)
- Fordham Law Review (5038)
- Indiana Law Journal (4891)
- Scholarly Works (4752)
- West Virginia Law Review (4375)
- Marquette Law Review (4292)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (cases filed before 1965) (4290)
- Law and Contemporary Problems (4157)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (through 1999) (4057)
- SMU Law Review (4056)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– 2019) (4013)
- Case Western Reserve Law Review (3960)
- Missouri Law Review (3741)
- Vanderbilt Law Review (3653)
- Kentucky Law Journal (3638)
- South Carolina Law Review (3466)
- Notre Dame Law Review (3373)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (2000–2020) (3368)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (1965 –) (3367)
- Washington Law Review (3365)
- Washington and Lee Law Review (3361)
- Publication Type
Articles 7381 - 7410 of 544832
Full-Text Articles in Law
Renegotiating The Energy Transition, Hannah J. Wiseman, Jennifer Baka, Kaitlyn Spangler
Renegotiating The Energy Transition, Hannah J. Wiseman, Jennifer Baka, Kaitlyn Spangler
University of Colorado Law Review
No abstract provided.
"The Reality Is, It All Came Back To Catch Us": Urban Population Increase And Water Conservation In The Arid West, Madison Dobson
"The Reality Is, It All Came Back To Catch Us": Urban Population Increase And Water Conservation In The Arid West, Madison Dobson
University of Colorado Law Review
No abstract provided.
Affirmatively Misled: The Commutation Instruction That Distorted Louisiana’S Death Penalty, G. Ben Cohen
Affirmatively Misled: The Commutation Instruction That Distorted Louisiana’S Death Penalty, G. Ben Cohen
Akron Law Faculty Publications
In 1997, Louisiana voters amended the state constitution to mandate that capital juries be instructed on the governor’s power to commute life and death sentences. This amendment, urged by the Louisiana District Attorneys Association, followed a Louisiana Supreme Court ruling that found an earlier clemency instruction violated the state constitution. The instruction was fundamentally false. Louisiana governors, it turns out, lacked the unilateral authority to commute sentences; such actions require a favorable vote from the Parole Board. This reality became starkly clear in 2023, when the clemency petitions of fifty-six condemned prisoners—many sentenced by juries affirmatively given this instruction—were terminated …
State Responsibility For Violations Of International Humanitarian Law And Human Rights Law By Private Security Companies In Africa: The Case Of The Wagner Group And Africa Corps, Shannon Joy Bosch, Matthew Kimble
State Responsibility For Violations Of International Humanitarian Law And Human Rights Law By Private Security Companies In Africa: The Case Of The Wagner Group And Africa Corps, Shannon Joy Bosch, Matthew Kimble
Research outputs 2022 to 2026
The outsourcing of traditionally military functions in Africa to private military companies (PMCs) such as the Wagner Group and the Africa Corps has been accompanied by violations of international humanitarian law and international human rights law. According to the International Law Commission's Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, state responsibility for these violations can be imputed to the states that employ PMCs to function as their agents, to exercise government authority or to act in the vacuum left by official authorities. States that do not intervene to prevent these abuses fail their obligations of due diligence through …
The Silent Language Of Trauma: Defendant Behavior, Juror Bias, And Expert Testimony, Jensen Goldman
The Silent Language Of Trauma: Defendant Behavior, Juror Bias, And Expert Testimony, Jensen Goldman
Scripps Senior Theses
Trauma can profoundly influence behavioral presentation, yet jurors often rely on demeanor as a diagnostic cue for guilt, credibility, and remorse. Such reliance poses risks within a legal system that seldom equips jurors to interpret trauma related behaviors accurately. The proposed study will examine how two trauma-linked affective presentations– overemotionality and flat affect– shape juror perceptions of credibility and guilt, and whether expert psychological testimony about trauma-related affect can mitigate these biases. Online survey participants will read one of five trial vignettes with varying defendant conditions (flat affect vs. overemotional) and varying expert testimony conditions (present or not present) and …
Values Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism, Carliss N. Chatman, Sergio Alberto Gramitto Ricci
Values Primacy & Total Governance Through Activism, Carliss N. Chatman, Sergio Alberto Gramitto Ricci
Hofstra Law Faculty Scholarship
In the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder, public companies swiftly pledged sweeping equity commitments—only to abandon them under political and market pressure. These reversals were not aberrations. They were opportunistic, performative, and reactionary marketing responses. They expose a governance regime in which stakeholder interests are structurally reversible because they remain doctrinally optional, lacking the institutional interlock needed to create binding accountability across stakeholder roles.
This Article explores how stakeholder power is already embedded in corporate governance through interlocking initiatives grounded in shared values. Stake-holder activism—boycotts, proxy votes, viral campaigns—is not merely expressive; it is an overlooked form of governance. Drawing …
Foreword, Rhodes Evans
Table Of Contents, University Of Colorado Law Review
Table Of Contents, University Of Colorado Law Review
University of Colorado Law Review
No abstract provided.
Breakthrough Climate Constitutionalism?, Sam Bookman
Breakthrough Climate Constitutionalism?, Sam Bookman
University of Colorado Law Review
No abstract provided.
Chaco Roads: Connecting Cultural Heritage And Environmental Justice, Vanessa Ann Racehorse
Chaco Roads: Connecting Cultural Heritage And Environmental Justice, Vanessa Ann Racehorse
University of Colorado Law Review
No abstract provided.
Exploring The Principles And Values Of Co-Operative Economics And Sustainability To Inform Positive Solutions With Communities Impacted By Incarceration, Mary A. Sutton
Antioch University Dissertations & Theses
The United States incarcerates more people than any other country. Each month, tens of thousands of people across the country are released from prison or jail. Most return to communities that are economically, socially, and environmentally disenfranchised. The cycling of targeted populations in and out of the carceral system has imposed devastating consequences and inequities on poor Black and Brown communities, consequences that will reverberate for generations. The literature indicates a need for a critical sustainability assessment tool to examine incarceration policies and measure their real impacts on individuals, families, and communities. There is a need for sustainable solutions to …
American Loopholes: What Are They, And How Do We Close Them?, Tanner L. Martin
American Loopholes: What Are They, And How Do We Close Them?, Tanner L. Martin
Wyoming Law Review
This Comment examines the existence and impact of alleged loopholes within American gun control laws and explores how these gaps may affect Constitutional rights, legal enforcement, and public safety. In addition to identifying trends in American gun ownership, including patterns of purchasing, possession, and regulatory compliance, this Comment analyzes the current legal standards that determine who is disqualified from owning or possessing a firearm under federal law. These categories include individuals with certain criminal convictions, domestic violence restrictions, or mental health adjudications, and how those legal standards are applied in practice.
Beyond the legal framework, this Comment also considers the …
The Flawed Criminalization Of Corner-Crossing In Wyoming, Ryan A. Semerad
The Flawed Criminalization Of Corner-Crossing In Wyoming, Ryan A. Semerad
Wyoming Law Review
No abstract provided.
Black Labor Matters, Michael Z. Green
Black Labor Matters, Michael Z. Green
American University Law Review
Black and organized workers increasingly find themselves threatened by two key outside forces: one seeking to stop anti-racism efforts via diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices and the other curtailing employees’ union organizing. This Article argues that a response must be grounded in uniquely local strategies by two specific worker coalitions. One coalition—the New Black Workers Movement (NBWM)—arose from Black Lives Matter civil rights protests in 2020 that captivated the workplace and heightened awareness about anti-Blackness and concerns of systemic racism. The other coalition—the New Labor Workers Movement (NLWM)—developed in 2020 as a workplace response to a global pandemic that …
Protecting Pregnancy: From The Pregnancy Discrimination Act To The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, L. Camille Hébert
Protecting Pregnancy: From The Pregnancy Discrimination Act To The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, L. Camille Hébert
American University Law Review
Women have long faced challenges in balancing their employment with childbearing, facing loss of employment opportunities because of their potential for pregnancy and loss of actual employment when they became pregnant. Over the past six decades, Congress and the U.S. Supreme Court have taken actions with the potential to provide equal employment opportunity for women affected by pregnancy, but those efforts have largely failed because of the actions of lower federal courts in interpreting legislation and the Court’s decisions in ways to reduce protection for pregnancy. The most recent congressional action to protect pregnancy, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, was …
Citators In The Ai Age: Preserving The Human Component Through Court-Created Citators, Cody B. James
Citators In The Ai Age: Preserving The Human Component Through Court-Created Citators, Cody B. James
Faculty Law Review Articles
Citators have long worked behind the scenes, shaping case law and influencing how judges and lawyers view precedent. Yet their creation has been the sole realm of private publishers. As artificial intelligence (AI) is further integrated into citators’ creation, the human role is at risk of being automated. This article examines citators’ influence over substantive law, the human-in-the-loop justifications for preserving human involvement in citators’ creation, and the argument for courts to produce their own citators. By reclaiming this function, the courts can help enhance their legitimacy and preserve the human role in creating structures of legal information in the …
A Two-Pronged Approach To Addressing Unmet Legal Needs On The Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, Elaine Yellow Horse, Jillian Yellow Horse
A Two-Pronged Approach To Addressing Unmet Legal Needs On The Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, Elaine Yellow Horse, Jillian Yellow Horse
South Dakota Law Review
This Article, which marries theory and praxis, provides a focused literature review and concrete solutions for immediate implementation. It begins by exploring the existing scholarship pertaining to unmet legal needs and (in)access to justice in Indian country. It considers the overlapping yet distinct roles of licensed attorneys and lay advocates, prosecutors, and judges and how tribes have endeavored to draw the lines around these roles. After reviewing this background, the Article pivots and contributes a more nuanced perspective that concentrates on the legal system on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in particular. Rather than endorsing a single apparent answer to …
Access To Justice In Indian Country: Empowering Pro Se Criminal Defendants Through Holistic Defense And Resource Creation, Ilse Turner, Johanna Farmer
Access To Justice In Indian Country: Empowering Pro Se Criminal Defendants Through Holistic Defense And Resource Creation, Ilse Turner, Johanna Farmer
South Dakota Law Review
The question of the right to counsel for indigent criminal defendants has consumed various courts and academic journals for decades. Part of this question has revolved around the rights of indigent defendants being prosecuted in tribal courts. There has been scholarly attention devoted to the study of the rights of indigent defendants in tribal courts and the impacts of case law and congressional acts on these rights. This Article seeks to expand the scholarly works around indigent defendants in tribal courts and provide tangible solutions tribes can begin to execute without an act of Congress. This Article will discuss the …
Innovative Sovereignty: California Tribes' Use Of The Nonprofit Corporation, Stephen F. Diamond, Jennifer W. Kuan
Innovative Sovereignty: California Tribes' Use Of The Nonprofit Corporation, Stephen F. Diamond, Jennifer W. Kuan
South Dakota Law Review
Native American tribes have long sought, but not always received, federal recognition as sovereign Indian Nations. Recognition confers substantial financial and legal benefits including access to federally funded health services, education and housing. Sovereign status allows tribes to pursue business activity. Tribal sovereignty, however, has significant limitations. The recognition process is costly, time-consuming, highly politicized, and often uncertain. Federal law enforcement and health services that should follow recognition are chronically underfunded. We examine the efforts of Indian tribes in California’s Monterey County to use the nonprofit corporation form to establish clear property rights to land. We interview key participants and …
Increasing Access To Justice Through The Use Of Indigenous Restorative Justice And Trauma Informed Practices, Carrie E. Garrow, Danielle J. Mayberry, Micaelee Horn
Increasing Access To Justice Through The Use Of Indigenous Restorative Justice And Trauma Informed Practices, Carrie E. Garrow, Danielle J. Mayberry, Micaelee Horn
South Dakota Law Review
Tribal judiciaries are paramount to tribal sovereignty and accessed by court users for many purposes. Access to justice ensures that everyone should be able to understand and assert their rights in a fair tribal justice system. This can be a challenge for rural areas, but even more so in Indian Country due to the complex web of factors such as legal and jurisdictional complexities, the colonization of Indian Nations by federal and state governments, and resource restraints. Due to these barriers and as an effort to serve their communities, tribal justice systems develop mechanisms that are solution based and at …
Under-Enforcement Of Tribal Land Use Regulations, Ezra Rosser
Under-Enforcement Of Tribal Land Use Regulations, Ezra Rosser
South Dakota Law Review
This brief Article explores the advantages and disadvantages of the under-enforcement of land use regulations by the Navajo Nation. Though scholarship on economic development, including tribal economic development, tends to emphasize the importance of well-defined and predictable rules, homeowners and entrepreneurs seeking land use permissions confront an environment on the reservation marked by under-enforcement. As this Article shows, the limited resources available to many tribal members help explain the tribe’s decision to selectively under-enforce otherwise required land use permitting processes. The purpose of this Article is to neither praise nor condemn an under-enforcement strategy, but instead to provide a framework …
Pretrial Justice In Indian Country And Bordertowns-Including Rural Tribal Communities In The Bail Reform Conversation, Jordan Gross
Pretrial Justice In Indian Country And Bordertowns-Including Rural Tribal Communities In The Bail Reform Conversation, Jordan Gross
South Dakota Law Review
Pretrial detention rates in the United States are down, except in rural counties. Indigenous people are both over-represented and under-protected in settler-colonial criminal justice systems. Yet the criminal justice needs and experiences of rural and Indigenous people are largely overlooked in criminal justice reform research and discourse. I examined the role of rurality in bail administration in Pretrial Justice in Out-of-the-Way Places – Including Rural Communities in the Bail Reform Conversation. There I explained how bail reform measures centered on urban and suburban needs and demographics fail to address pretrial justice challenges and opportunities unique to rural communities. This Article …
Freedom Of Tribal Association, Andrea Nishi
Freedom Of Tribal Association, Andrea Nishi
South Dakota Law Review
In Morton v. Mancari, the Supreme Court upheld a statute granting hiring preference to Indian candidates on the grounds that it did so not on the basis of race but on the basis of affiliation with a tribe as a political entity. As the Court recognized, if such a law were struck down on equal protection grounds, the basis for all federal policy protecting Indian interests would be undermined. In Mancari, this reasoning was used to uphold a law that benefitted Indian candidates pursuant to the federal government’s recognized trust responsibility to Indian tribes. The logic of Mancari has since …
Artificial Intelligence, Tribal Sovereignty, And The Criminal Justice System, Kevin Angelo Brown
Artificial Intelligence, Tribal Sovereignty, And The Criminal Justice System, Kevin Angelo Brown
South Dakota Law Review
As artificial intelligence (“AI”) has become increasingly integrated into everyday life in Indian Country and into governmental functions, including policing, courts, and corrections, it is creating new circumstances that can undermine tribal sovereignty. The 575 federally recognized Tribal Nations are under significant pressure to maintain their sovereignty while adapting to new AI-based technologies. With the implementation of AI, tribes should retain control over how it is used to benefit their communities, without compromising their legal rights or well-being, particularly in light of past harms caused by inadequate legal protections that allowed technological developments to damage tribal health, environments, economies, and …
The Tribal Wills At Usd's Knudson School Of Law: A Study In Mutuality, Nimbleness, And Persistence, Thomas E. Simmons
The Tribal Wills At Usd's Knudson School Of Law: A Study In Mutuality, Nimbleness, And Persistence, Thomas E. Simmons
South Dakota Law Review
No abstract provided.
Dividend Distribution Tax: More Than Meets The Eye - A Critical Analysis Of Polycab India Ltd. V. Assistant Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Ashrita Prasad Kotha
Dividend Distribution Tax: More Than Meets The Eye - A Critical Analysis Of Polycab India Ltd. V. Assistant Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Ashrita Prasad Kotha
Articles
The case emanates from the dividend distribution tax (DDT) paid by Polycab on shares held by International Finance Corporation (IFC), one of its shareholders. IFC was set up by an international agreement to support the private sector in developing countries and was granted tax immunity on its income and transactions under the founding multilateral treaty and supporting domestic law. Polycab sought refund of DDT owing to IFC's immunity. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) ruled in favour of Polycab by considering dividend distribution within the immunity clause and reading in an exemption into the income tax legislation. Significantly, the DDT …
Enhancing Military Health System Organizational Efficiency And Quality Of Care Through A Social-Ecological Framework, Eric L. Peipelman
Enhancing Military Health System Organizational Efficiency And Quality Of Care Through A Social-Ecological Framework, Eric L. Peipelman
College of Graduate Studies: Theses & Dissertations
Timely and fair adjudication of incivility-related actions within the Department of Defense (DoD) and Military Health System (MHS) is increasingly crucial for maintaining accountability, mission readiness, and quality of care. Ongoing delays in resolving workplace complaints and inefficiencies in resource-heavy adjudications highlight the need to shift from reactive complaint handling toward proactive civility promotion and transparent decision-making. This Integrated Learning Experience (ILE) introduces the Peipelman Civility Discussion and Assessment Toolkit (PCDAT)—a comprehensive, evidence-based framework designed to improve civility, optimize resources, and enhance communication, even in the MHS. Based on the Social-Ecological Model (SEM) and adapted from the Workplace Power and …
Omnibus Law Sebagai Strategi Mengatasi Disharmonisasi Peraturan Di Indonesia, Tuti Tri Hastuti S., Zainal Arifin Hoessein
Omnibus Law Sebagai Strategi Mengatasi Disharmonisasi Peraturan Di Indonesia, Tuti Tri Hastuti S., Zainal Arifin Hoessein
Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan
This article discusses the challenges in implementing the Omnibus Law (OL) both as a regulatory system and as a tool for harmonizing regulations within Indonesia’s legal positivist tradition and its complex, non-simple regulatory hierarchy, from the perspectives of legislative consolidation theory, regulatory coherence theory, and multilevel regulation theory. This study is based on the assumption that OL, within the framework of legal positivism (norm hierarchy system), faces problems in applying these three theories. The research employs normative juridical and comparative methods, analyzing national regulations and international research findings. The results indicate, first, that the positioning of OL, which does not …
Pertanggungjawaban Perusahaan Pengangkut Pada Tindakan General Average Terhadap Kerugian Kargo Yang Diangkut, Sandra A. M. Lova, Zahry Vandawati Chumaida
Pertanggungjawaban Perusahaan Pengangkut Pada Tindakan General Average Terhadap Kerugian Kargo Yang Diangkut, Sandra A. M. Lova, Zahry Vandawati Chumaida
Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan
Maritime transportation plays a vital role in supporting trade, yet risks such as perils of the sea or ship accidents caused by unseaworthiness often lead to disputes, particularly when General Average is declared. This practice, recognized since Roman times, has evolved into a legal concept in marine insurance to distribute deliberate sacrifices made for the safety of the vessel and its cargo. This study aims to analyze the liability of carriers in General Average actions and to evaluate the concept as a fair mechanism for loss distribution. The research employs a normative juridical method with statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches, …
Dualisme Tujuan Pembebanan Uang Pengganti: Analisis Putusan Angelina Sondakh Di Berbagai Tingkat Peradilan, Valencia Puspa Novandra Ali, Tamsil .
Dualisme Tujuan Pembebanan Uang Pengganti: Analisis Putusan Angelina Sondakh Di Berbagai Tingkat Peradilan, Valencia Puspa Novandra Ali, Tamsil .
Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan
Studi ini meneliti perbedaan interpretasi dan penerapan hukuman tambahan berupa restitusi (uang pengganti) dalam kasus korupsi melalui analisis komparatif keputusan Angelina Sondakh di pengadilan tingkat pertama, pengadilan banding, pengadilan kasasi, dan pengadilan peninjauan yudisial. Muncul interpretasi ganda antara memandang restitusi sebagai kompensasi atas kerugian keuangan negara dan sebagai mekanisme untuk menyita keuntungan ilegal. Judex facti menolak penerapan restitusi dengan alasan bahwa tidak terjadi kerugian negara dalam kasus suap dan gratifikasi, sementara judex juris di tingkat kasasi menafsirkan restitusi sebagai instrumen pemulihan aset yang ditujukan untuk keuntungan yang diperoleh secara ilegal. Orientasi konseptual yang bertentangan ini menghasilkan perbedaan signifikan dalam penjatuhan …