Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Constitutional Law (34982)
- International Law (32265)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (29789)
- Criminal Law (27911)
- Environmental Law (18444)
-
- Intellectual Property Law (17072)
- Legal Education (16878)
- State and Local Government Law (16692)
- Courts (16647)
- Civil Rights and Discrimination (14896)
- Health Law and Policy (14627)
- Legislation (14560)
- Law and Society (14114)
- Administrative Law (14113)
- Comparative and Foreign Law (14050)
- Indigenous, Indian, and Aboriginal Law (13882)
- Human Rights Law (12316)
- Criminal Procedure (12064)
- Legal Profession (11684)
- Labor and Employment Law (11185)
- Business Organizations Law (10759)
- Arts and Humanities (10734)
- Sociology (10391)
- Legal History (10009)
- Legal Studies (9827)
- Jurisprudence (9247)
- Torts (9012)
- Science and Technology Law (8821)
- Property Law and Real Estate (8398)
- Institution
-
- Brigham Young University Law School (37205)
- University of Michigan Law School (21829)
- Duke Law (14425)
- Fordham Law School (13334)
- Maurer School of Law: Indiana University (11951)
-
- University of Oklahoma College of Law (11866)
- Yeshiva University, Cardozo School of Law (11515)
- Case Western Reserve University School of Law (10936)
- Southern Methodist University (10168)
- William & Mary Law School (9532)
- American University Washington College of Law (9074)
- Northwestern Pritzker School of Law (8932)
- UC Law SF (8867)
- University of North Carolina School of Law (8799)
- Notre Dame Law School (8249)
- Vanderbilt University Law School (8031)
- University of South Carolina (7596)
- University of Minnesota Law School (7364)
- University of Missouri School of Law (7266)
- Cornell University Law School (7209)
- University of Colorado Law School (7193)
- University of Kentucky (6982)
- Washington and Lee University School of Law (6925)
- Louisiana State University Law Center (6749)
- Marquette University Law School (6614)
- University of Chicago Law School (6494)
- Seton Hall University (6196)
- University of Washington School of Law (6130)
- University of Richmond (6022)
- Chicago-Kent College of Law (5729)
- Keyword
-
- Law (6238)
- Constitutional law (3540)
- International law (3379)
- Supreme Court (3330)
- Human rights (3205)
-
- Constitutional Law (3005)
- United States (2673)
- First Amendment (2663)
- Copyright (2559)
- Constitution (2538)
- Discrimination (2512)
- International Law (2282)
- Evidence (2258)
- Criminal law (2243)
- Regulation (2188)
- Jurisprudence (2141)
- United States Supreme Court (2103)
- University of Michigan Law School (2099)
- History (2072)
- Privacy (2071)
- Intellectual property (1970)
- Philosophy (1969)
- Legislation (1945)
- Politics (1910)
- Legal education (1897)
- Jurisdiction (1894)
- Ethics (1877)
- Courts (1820)
- Law students (1784)
- Contracts (1781)
- Publication Year
-
- 2026 (7579)
- 2025 (10543)
- 2024 (10969)
- 2023 (11463)
- 2022 (14827)
-
- 2021 (13133)
- 2020 (12812)
- 2019 (12038)
- 2018 (13590)
- 2017 (14046)
- 2016 (15271)
- 2015 (14369)
- 2014 (12634)
- 2013 (12812)
- 2012 (13465)
- 2011 (11717)
- 2010 (11499)
- 2009 (11211)
- 2008 (10753)
- 2007 (10551)
- 2006 (11365)
- 2005 (10092)
- 2004 (9683)
- 2003 (8863)
- 2002 (8338)
- 2001 (9172)
- 2000 (8631)
- 1999 (7767)
- 1998 (7674)
- 1992 (7926)
- Publication
-
- Faculty Scholarship (21546)
- Articles (11521)
- Michigan Law Review (11192)
- Faculty Publications (8709)
- American Indian and Alaskan Native Documents in the Congressional Serial Set: 1817-1899 (8590)
-
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (through 1995) (6781)
- Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (6683)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (1996–2006) (6653)
- North Carolina Law Review (6028)
- Louisiana Law Review (5640)
- Fordham Law Review (5038)
- Indiana Law Journal (4891)
- Scholarly Works (4752)
- West Virginia Law Review (4375)
- Marquette Law Review (4292)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (cases filed before 1965) (4290)
- Law and Contemporary Problems (4157)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (through 1999) (4057)
- SMU Law Review (4056)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– 2019) (4013)
- Case Western Reserve Law Review (3960)
- Missouri Law Review (3741)
- Vanderbilt Law Review (3653)
- Kentucky Law Journal (3638)
- South Carolina Law Review (3466)
- Notre Dame Law Review (3373)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (2000–2020) (3368)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (1965 –) (3367)
- Washington Law Review (3365)
- Washington and Lee Law Review (3361)
- Publication Type
Articles 3721 - 3750 of 544811
Full-Text Articles in Law
Richmond Law Magazine: Spring 2026
Richmond Law Magazine: Spring 2026
Richmond Law Magazine
Wendy Perdue: A Tribute to the Dean Departing After 15 Years
Career-defining Fellowship
Oliver Hill's Latest Legacy
Right to Internet Access
A “Consistent And Ongoing” Right: The Sixth Amendment Right To Counsel At Initial Bail Hearings, Gemma Sunnergren
A “Consistent And Ongoing” Right: The Sixth Amendment Right To Counsel At Initial Bail Hearings, Gemma Sunnergren
Cardozo Law Review
Despite the potentially devastating consequences of pretrial incarceration and the complexity of modern bail applications, many individuals charged with crimes across the country are not appointed counsel to guide them through their bail hearings. Traditionally, application of the Sixth Amendment’s right to counsel in various pretrial proceedings has been evaluated under the “critical stage” framework, finding defense counsel necessary when a proceeding puts one’s trial rights at risk or is sufficiently trial-like—i.e., adversarial and requiring complex legal arguments. In the absence of a clear Supreme Court ruling, states have been left to conduct their own analysis, with many declining to …
Listening To Survivors: A Community Conversation, Jonathan Jackson
Listening To Survivors: A Community Conversation, Jonathan Jackson
Dignity: A Journal of Analysis of Exploitation and Violence
No abstract provided.
Core Elements Of Policy Solutions, Audrey Morrissey
Core Elements Of Policy Solutions, Audrey Morrissey
Dignity: A Journal of Analysis of Exploitation and Violence
No abstract provided.
2025-2026 School Of Law Academic Honors & Awards, University Of San Diego School Of Law
2025-2026 School Of Law Academic Honors & Awards, University Of San Diego School Of Law
Academic Honors and Awards
No abstract provided.
J Mich Dent Assoc April 2026
The Journal of the Michigan Dental Association
Each month, the Journal of the Michigan Dental Association delivers news, information, and features about Michigan dentistry to our state's oral health community and the MDA's 6,200-plus members. It remains the main publication reaching Michigan dentists and is available worldwide through ADA Commons.
The April 2026 (Volume 108, No. 4) issue of the Journal is published in digital format to provide updates and insights for Michigan's oral health community and MDA members. Print editions occur every other month beginning with January.
This full issue provides a comprehensive overview of the Michigan dental landscape in 2026. Key features include a clinical …
Government & Insurance Update: Mda Advocacy Successes, James Budd Mpp
Government & Insurance Update: Mda Advocacy Successes, James Budd Mpp
The Journal of the Michigan Dental Association
This document summarizes the recent legislative achievements of the Michigan Dental Association’s advocacy team. Key highlights include the House passage of bills regulating dental specialty advertising to ensure transparency for patients and the elimination of the inactive Dental Specialty Task Force. The update also promotes the MDA’s legislative text alert system and online tools designed to help member dentists engage with lawmakers on "hot-button" issues. By staying informed through these platforms, Michigan dentists can support the MDA’s mission to improve practice conditions and access to care across the state.
Table Of Contents, Cardozo Law Review, Volume 47, Issue 4
Table Of Contents, Cardozo Law Review, Volume 47, Issue 4
Cardozo Law Review
No abstract provided.
The Territorial Continuum: American Samoa, Criminal Adjudication, And Territorial Administration, Emmanuel Hiram Arnaud
The Territorial Continuum: American Samoa, Criminal Adjudication, And Territorial Administration, Emmanuel Hiram Arnaud
Cardozo Law Review
The standard account of American territorial expansion posits that territorial acquisition moved along a spectrum of sovereignty. The federal government acquired new inhabited land through conquest or purchase, and the Constitution tasked Congress with organizing and administering the new territories until they were ready to become states. That pattern came to an abrupt halt in 1898 when, at the conclusion of the Spanish-American War, the Supreme Court, fearing the extension of citizenship to and the permanent integration of non-White populations into the American polity, suddenly pronounced that the Constitution authorized the holding of colonies. The Court thus sentenced new territories, …
Hyperbole In The Capital Stack: Are We Misreading Lender Intent? Liability Management Transactions And The Implied Covenant Of Good Faith And Fair Dealing, Daniel R. Janel
Cardozo Law Review
The hasty characterization and overall sentiment surrounding Liability Management Transactions (“LMTs”) as “hostile” strategies that promote “lender-on-lender violence” attempt to misapply the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing under New York law, which serves as a gap-filler rather than a “contract buster.” Although the covenant’s proper function is to protect parties’ reasonable expectations that they will receive the fruits of their bargain, it does not purport to rewrite or impose on carefully negotiated credit agreements. Sophisticated parties enter into meticulously crafted credit agreements with full awareness of the breadth and scope of their provisions. Only after finding themselves …
From Waiver To Shield: The Routine Misapplication Of The Federal Tort Claims Act’S Discretionary Function Exception, Alexander Sitnikov
From Waiver To Shield: The Routine Misapplication Of The Federal Tort Claims Act’S Discretionary Function Exception, Alexander Sitnikov
Cardozo Law Review
When a pedestrian trips and falls on a defective sidewalk, liability usually turns on negligence. But when the property surrounding the sidewalk belongs to the federal government, tort liability often vanishes altogether. This result is just one of the many shortcomings of the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) and one of its most controversial and heavily litigated provisions: the discretionary function exception (“DFE”). This Note explores the current judicial interpretations of the FTCA and DFE, which often work in conjunction with state laws and federal regulations. Despite the central public policy rationale and congressional intent surrounding the FTCA and its …
الوساطة الجزائية ودورها في إنهاء الدعوى الجزائية (دراسة مقارنة), فاطمة راشد السبوسي
الوساطة الجزائية ودورها في إنهاء الدعوى الجزائية (دراسة مقارنة), فاطمة راشد السبوسي
Theses
Criminal mediation, criminal proceedings, restorative justice, UAE Criminal Procedure Law, alternatives to criminal litigation
This thesis addresses the topic of criminal mediation as one of the modern mechanisms adopted by contemporary criminal legislation as an alternative to traditional criminal proceedings. The study focuses on the United Arab Emirates, where the Federal Decree-Law No. (38) of 2022 on Criminal Procedure codified criminal mediation, particularly in Articles 352 and following. This raises questions regarding the adequacy and appropriateness of the legal framework regulating this system.
The research problem lies in assessing the extent to which the UAE legal system effectively organizes criminal …
جريمة تزوير المستند الالكتروني طبقا للمرسوم بقانون اتحادي رقم (46) لسنة 2021 بشأن المعاملات الإلكترونية وخدمات الثقة, كلثم راشد المزروعي
جريمة تزوير المستند الالكتروني طبقا للمرسوم بقانون اتحادي رقم (46) لسنة 2021 بشأن المعاملات الإلكترونية وخدمات الثقة, كلثم راشد المزروعي
Theses
The Crime of Electronic Document Forgery under UAE Legislation: A Legal and Judicial Analysis in Light of Digital Transformation
This study examines the crime of electronic document forgery in light of rapid digital transformation and the challenges it poses to legal systems, particularly in the United Arab Emirates. The research problem lies in the absence of a comprehensive legal framework, the difficulty of classifying technologically evolving forms of forgery, and the challenges associated with proving such crimes using digital evidence.
The study aims to analyze the legal nature of electronic document forgery, distinguish it from traditional forgery, identify its elements …
Structuring The Notional Imprisonment Period When The Accused Is Unfit To Plead – Abdul Ghufran Bin Abdul Wahid V Public Prosecutor, Abhishek Behera, Aaron Yoong
Structuring The Notional Imprisonment Period When The Accused Is Unfit To Plead – Abdul Ghufran Bin Abdul Wahid V Public Prosecutor, Abhishek Behera, Aaron Yoong
Research Collection Yong Pung How School Of Law
This case comment examines how Abdul Ghufran bin Abdul Wahid v Public Prosecutor [2025] 3 SLR 1572 brings clarity to Singapore’s “fitness to plead” regime by structuring the nominal imprisonment period (“NIP”) as a principled, non-punitive ceiling on confinement for unfit accused persons. It explains the General Division of the High Court’s four-step framework, the elevation of prevention over rehabilitation at the NIP stage, and the constrained role of mental disorders in adjusting the provisional term. It further highlights the decisive influence of psychiatric evidence and explores how the framework mediates between consistency, individualised justice, and public protection.
Online Safety (Relief And Accountability) Bill: Further Experiments In Balancing Rights And Responsibilities, Siyuan Chen, Zavier Yu Wu, Jie Ting Lee
Online Safety (Relief And Accountability) Bill: Further Experiments In Balancing Rights And Responsibilities, Siyuan Chen, Zavier Yu Wu, Jie Ting Lee
Research Collection Yong Pung How School Of Law
Singapore’s latest legislation to address online harms, the Online Safety (Relief and Accountability) Bill, was passed in Parliament in November 2025. The legislation, which takes a complainant-centric approach, provides the Commissioner of Online Safety a broad range of powers so that timely redress can be given for reports of online harms such as image abuse, sexual harassment, doxxing, and stalking. Various torts that impose duties on administrators and platforms have also been created. Legislation of this nature invariably raises issues about whether an appropriate balance between freedom and responsibility has been struck. This Legislative Comment analyses some of the more …
Negotiating At A Distance: The Impact Of Communication Media And Negotiator Traits, Dorcas Quek Anderson, Tra My Ngo
Negotiating At A Distance: The Impact Of Communication Media And Negotiator Traits, Dorcas Quek Anderson, Tra My Ngo
Research Collection Yong Pung How School Of Law
Purpose – Prior research has yet to provide a coherent theoretical framework explaining how communication media hinder or advance negotiation success, and many dated studies are unlikely to be relevant. This study aims to examine the impact of four communication media on negotiation outcomes. It also examines the potential moderating effects of the following negotiator characteristics: conflict management style, personality traits and indirect communication style.Design/methodology/approach – A total of 400 participants formed 200 dyads to negotiate a mixed- motive relational conflict through face-to-face (FTF) interaction, videoconferencing, audio call or synchronous text messaging. Linear mixed regression was used to assess the …
The Shame Of Mass Torts, Anthony J. Sebok
Is Tax “Law”?, Luís C. Calderón Gómez
Is Tax “Law”?, Luís C. Calderón Gómez
Articles
Although taxation remains a hotly contested issue in debates by both politicians and political theorists—over the optimal size of government, distributive (and sometimes corrective) justice, or even the legitimacy of current private property arrangements—taxation has been largely ignored by legal theorists, to the detriment of both tax law and legal theory. This Article argues that tax law, driven by its battle against tax evasion, is in deep conflict with widely accepted conceptions of “legality”—that is, the qualities that make a rule distinctively and normatively “law.” This matters because legality is a key buttress in jurisprudential and political theory accounts that …
Law, Conflict, And Hybrid Warfare: A Teaching Imperative For A Changing World, Cynthia Alkon, Andrea K. Schneider
Law, Conflict, And Hybrid Warfare: A Teaching Imperative For A Changing World, Cynthia Alkon, Andrea K. Schneider
Articles
Lawyers increasingly find themselves at the frontlines of the battlefield, just not in the traditional sense. Hybrid warfare is a conflict form that combines traditional military offensive measures with nontraditional methods, including the harnessing of legal systems to achieve strategic goals. Lawyers have always been at the frontline of typical legal risk assessment, thinking about a client’s risk of liability or regulation costs generally. Now, lawyers must stand at the ready for a lot more: lawyers must be prepared for cyber-attacks, disinformation campaigns using artificial intelligence, the use of court systems to suppress reporting or shield bad actors, and so …
Preempting Pre-Approval: Clarifying Preemption Doctrine For Product-Liability Suits Against Brand-Name Drug Manufacturers, Nicholas G. Wallenburg
Preempting Pre-Approval: Clarifying Preemption Doctrine For Product-Liability Suits Against Brand-Name Drug Manufacturers, Nicholas G. Wallenburg
Vanderbilt Law Review
One of the most important issues for product-liability lawsuits against drug manufacturers today is federal preemption. Plaintiffs injured by prescription drugs regularly turn to state tort law for a remedy. Defendants in these cases—often brand-name drug manufacturers—frequently invoke preemption doctrine to argue that the Food and Drug Administration’s (“FDA”) rigorous approval process for prescription drugs has displaced state causes of action. While the text of the Food, Drug, and Cosmetics Act does not clearly address this issue, the U.S. Supreme Court has relied on a so-called “impossibility” theory of preemption: When a drug manufacturer cannot comply with the duties imposed …
Targeting Unfairness, Omolara Bewaji Joseney
Targeting Unfairness, Omolara Bewaji Joseney
Vanderbilt Law Review
Companies often engage in racially targeted marketing practices whereby they target and tailor their advertisements to racially segmented consumer populations. As a result, a targeted racial group of consumers may receive advertisements for a product or service that is intentionally customized to appeal to them (a “pull”) or may be specifically untargeted or excluded from receiving advertisements as members of a nontargeted racial group (a “push”). This Article examines the marketing environment created by these pull-push dynamics as a consumer protection concern. Legal scholarship on targeted advertising has focused either on its risks to privacy due to the growing reliance …
“You Can’T Post That!”: Constitutionality Of Non-Disparagement Orders Barring Divorced Parents’ Social Media Posts, Kaitlyn B. Hammond
“You Can’T Post That!”: Constitutionality Of Non-Disparagement Orders Barring Divorced Parents’ Social Media Posts, Kaitlyn B. Hammond
Vanderbilt Law Review
When a marriage goes wrong, a court may use a non-disparagement order to prevent a party from speaking negatively about another in some way, either permanently or temporarily. Family courts often use non-disparagement orders to protect parties or their children from psychological harm during divorce or child-custody proceedings. In such cases, non-disparagement orders forbid parents from denigrating one another in front of their children and/or third parties. To protect the child, non-disparagement orders are often imposed upon both parents by the court. But courts do not always protect children and other parties from disparagement in this way. Although non-disparagement orders …
The Myth Of Credit Card Competition, Benjamin Dinovelli
The Myth Of Credit Card Competition, Benjamin Dinovelli
Vanderbilt Law Review
You pay an invisible tax every time you swipe your credit card to pay—whether to buy groceries, grab a coffee, or access transportation. Credit card companies charge merchants to process your transaction, who in turn increase their own prices. These swipe fees are both extractive—higher than the cost of service and the fees in most other countries—and regressive—placing more of the cost burden on lower-income consumers and smaller merchants. Such outcomes are typically associated with firms having material market power. Yet, this market has competition: Consumers choose various cards offered by multiple card issuers, including banks and networks like American …
Zombie Litigation: Claim Aggregation, Litigant Autonomy And Funders' Intermeddling, Maya Steinitz
Zombie Litigation: Claim Aggregation, Litigant Autonomy And Funders' Intermeddling, Maya Steinitz
Faculty Scholarship
The main debate surrounding litigation funding in recent years has focused on the question of disclosure of funding agreements. While the issue is important, predominantly because of its effects on the course and outcome of individual cases, far more important are bigger, interrelated questions that have systemic effects on the civil justice system, the legal profession, and the nature of the attorney-client relationship. The rise of litigation funding has had profound effects. The subsequent rise of portfolio funding—which I here propose to view as a new form of undisclosed and unregulated claim aggregation—has broader-still effects including clients’ potential, and at …
The Territorial Continuum: American Samoa, Criminal Adjudication, And Territorial Administration, Emmanuel Hiram Arnaud
The Territorial Continuum: American Samoa, Criminal Adjudication, And Territorial Administration, Emmanuel Hiram Arnaud
Faculty Scholarship
The standard account of American territorial expansion posits that territorial acquisition moved along a spectrum of sovereignty. The federal government acquired new inhabited land through conquest or purchase, and the Constitution tasked Congress with organizing and administering the new territories until they were ready to become states. That pattern came to an abrupt halt in 1898 when, at the conclusion of the Spanish-American War, the Supreme Court, fearing the extension of citizenship to, and the permanent integration of, non-White populations into the American polity, suddenly pronounced that the Constitution authorized the holding of colonies. The Court thus sentenced new territories, …
Birthdate Phaseout, Katharine B. Silbaugh
Birthdate Phaseout, Katharine B. Silbaugh
Faculty Scholarship
This Article explores the Nicotine Free Generation ("NFG") policy, an emerging endgame strategy for tobacco products that employs a completely novel legal design. Tobacco remains the leading cause of preventable death, killing almost half of its users and imposing $600 billion in social costs each year. We see two basic choices for regulating sales: prohibition or a legal age-gate, such as twenty-one, for retail sales. NFG charts a third way. Recognizing the dire harm of tobacco and the serious consequences of abrupt prohibition, NFG lays the groundwork for a gradual transition to a sales sunset. In place of the twenty-one …
Grading Machines: Can Ai Exam-Grading Replace Law Professors?, Kevin L. Cope, Jen Frankenreiter, Scott Hirst, Eric A. Posner, Daniel Schwarcz, Dane Thorley
Grading Machines: Can Ai Exam-Grading Replace Law Professors?, Kevin L. Cope, Jen Frankenreiter, Scott Hirst, Eric A. Posner, Daniel Schwarcz, Dane Thorley
Faculty Scholarship
In the past few years, large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant technical advances, such that legal-advocacy organizations are increasingly adopting them as complements to—or substitutes for—lawyers and other human experts. Several studies have examined LLMs' performance in taking law school exams, finding mixed results. Yet there have been no published studies systematically analyzing LLMs' competence at one of law professors' chief responsibilities: grading law school exams. This paper presents results of an analysis of how LLMs perform in evaluating student responses to legal analysis questions of the kind typically administered in law school exams. The underlying data come from …
On Predicting And Stopping Dystopia, Evan Selinger, Woodrow Hartzog
On Predicting And Stopping Dystopia, Evan Selinger, Woodrow Hartzog
Faculty Scholarship
Is it reasonable to be dystopian about how the future will likely unfold? We think so. For some time, we have been arguing that facial recognition technology is a perfect tool of oppression, and that its pernicious affordances are leading society down a slippery slope toward the evisceration of privacy by obscurity. This is a soft form of “determinism”—the notion that while technology is not an unstoppable force and the future is not preordained, there nevertheless are identifiable factors, such as the invitingness of affordances, human nature, and incentives that drive technology in certain directions and make some social outcomes …
The Human Right To A Healthy Environment: Corporate Responsibility In Critical Mineral Extraction, Erika George
The Human Right To A Healthy Environment: Corporate Responsibility In Critical Mineral Extraction, Erika George
Faculty Scholarship
This paper argues that the emerging human right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment should guide the governance of critical minerals by incorporating the corporate responsibility to respect human rights throughout supply chains to ensure a racially just energy transition. It frames the climate crisis within the history and political economy of racial capitalism, contending that without rights-based guardrails, mineral supply chains risk reproducing the extractive harms and racialized disparities of the fossil fuel era, including labor abuses, displacement, water depletion, and violence disproportionately borne by racialized and Indigenous communities. Methodologically, the paper combines doctrinal analysis of international norms …
Giving Meaningful Effect To Victims’ Rights: The Canadian Victims Bill Of Rights As Quasi-Constitutional Legislation, Benjamin Perrin
Giving Meaningful Effect To Victims’ Rights: The Canadian Victims Bill Of Rights As Quasi-Constitutional Legislation, Benjamin Perrin
All Faculty Publications
This research paper is the first detailed examination of the quasi-constitutional status of the Canadian Victims Bill of Rights ("CVBR") and the implications for its interpretation and application. It aims to provide a doctrinal account of this extraordinary legal recognition and to serve as a resource for scholars, judges, lawyers, and other justice system participants to ensure that the CVBR is interpreted and applied consistently with its aim of serving as a catalyst for transformative change to how the criminal justice system has historically treated victims.