Law Commons^™

Confronting Structural Inequality In State Labor Law, Andrew Elmore

Articles

Low-wage workers face a structural problem in seeking to improve their work standards: While companies have substantial labor market power to impose work terms and conditions, workers require affirmative state support to collectively press their workplace demands. But their employers can mobilize private capital and property rights, often with judicial deference, to fend off state intrusions into the workplace. While the National Labor Relations Act aims to resolve this structural problem by protecting the rights of workers to join unions, strike, and collectively bargain, employers, backed by judicial support for managerial prerogatives and property rights, can often leverage NLRA weaknesses …

Politicizing Antisemitism Amidst Today's Educational Culture Wars, Lili Levi

Articles

The traditional narrative of American Jewry emphasizes American exceptionalism with respect to antisemitism. But there have been clear signs of a resurgence of public antisemitism in the United States even before the massive rise in antisemitic expression and incidents associated with the Israel-Hamas war of fall 2023.

One of the notable aspects of the rise and normalization of antisemitic expression is the deployment of antisemitism as a political tool. For example, in addition to Democrats and Republicans accusing each other of complicity in antisemitism, both federal policy since the Trump era and state anti-antisemitism legislation have targeted campus antisemitism in …

Foreign Owned Canadian Corporations, Jinyan Li, Paul Lamarre

Articles & Book Chapters

Canadian income tax rules applicable to foreign owned Canadian corporations have become increasingly complex, in part owing to the implementation of recommendations of the OECD/G20 BEPS project to address the issue of base erosion and profit shifting. This paper considers these anti-avoidance rules, including the hybrid mismatch arrangement rules, excessive interest and financing expense limitation rules and various surplus stripping rules.

Overcoming The Pragmatic Approach Of The United Nations Guiding Principles On Business And Human Rights In Relation To The Fossil Fuel Industry, Barnali Choudhury

Articles & Book Chapters

Business has been good for Big Oil. Last year, the five largest Western oil companies raked in over USD$200 billion in profits. Last year, the global carbon emissions from the fossil fuel industry also peaked. Companies produced over 36 billion tons of carbon dioxide emissions during the year and global warming hit a new sustained high. Increasing temperatures also caused socio-economic impacts such as deaths, displacement of people, loss of employment and adverse impacts on food security.

While numerous studies have drawn links between the corporate activities of the fossil fuel industry and the devastating environmental and human rights impacts …

Environmental Law For A Just Transition, Dayna Nadine Scott

Articles & Book Chapters

The environmental justice movement, which turns our attention to fairness in the distribution of environmental benefits and burdens and in the processes, biases and
structures that determine those distributions, is challenging the foundations of environmental law.
• ‘Extractivism’ – a mode of accumulation that necessitates both a high pace and a large scale of taking of natural resources such as fossil fuels – is deeply embedded in environmental law, producing uneven costs/benefits and intense, concentrated impacts on people and ecosystems. Even as we move towards a greener economy, environmental laws and regulations governing such areas as facility siting, pollution permitting, …

We Shall Overcome: The Evolution Of Quotas In The Land Of The Free And The Home Of Samba, Stella Emery Santana

Seattle University Law Review

When were voices given to the voiceless? When will education be permitted to all? When will we need to protest no more? It’s the twenty-first century, and the fight for equity in higher education remains a challenge to peoples all over the world. While students in the United States must deal with the increase in loans, in Brazil, only around 20% of youth between the ages of twenty-five and thirty-four have a higher education degree.

The primary objective of this Article is to conduct an in-depth comparative analysis of the development, implementation, and legal adjudication of educational quota systems within …

Pacific Islands And The U.S. Military: The Legal Borderlands Of The Environmental Movement, Sonia Lei

Seattle University Law Review

Climate change remains an urgent, ongoing global issue that requires critical examination of institutional polluters. This includes the world’s largest institutional consumer of petroleum: the United States military. The Department of Defense (DoD) is a massive institution with little oversight, a carbon footprint spanning the globe, a budget greater than the next ten largest nations combined, and overly generous exemptions to environmental regulations and carbon reduction targets. This Comment examines how this lack of accountability and oversight plays out in the context of three Pacific islands that have hosted U.S. military bases for decades. By considering the environmental impact of …

Older Women Workers, The Pandemic, Employment Discrimination And Lifetime Disadvantage, Susan Bisom-Rapp

Faculty Scholarship

As a group, older women workers were among those most severely impacted by the COVID-19 crisis. Drawing from both intersectionality and cumulative disadvantage theory, the Model of Lifetime Disadvantage created by Bisom-Rapp and Sargeant helps frame the position of these workers in the labor market prior to and during the pandemic. The model also explains why and how disjointed, incremental legal interventions are unable to meet the challenge of gendered ageism, which surged during the crisis. Disasters produce impacts unevenly on individuals and communities. Older women are a diverse group, whose social position is mediated by race, ethnicity, sexual orientation …

Section 45q Tax Credits For Carbon Capture, Utilization, And Storage Projects, Chris Girouard, Tim Glasgow

Wyoming Law Review

In order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the United States, the federal government has provided financial support to incentivize taxpayers to develop and utilize technologies for capturing and storing carbon oxide. In addition to making annual appropriations to the U.S. Department of Energy for carbon capture and storage research, Congress enacted Section 45Q of the Internal Revenue Code to provide qualifying taxpayers with an income tax credit for each metric ton of carbon oxide that is captured and stored or utilized. This Article aims to provide an overview of the history and requirements of Section 45Q and the methods …

Proceedings Of The Fifteenth International Humanitarian Law Roundtable, Year In Review Lecture: The Cutting Edge Of International Humanitarian Law, Mark Drumbl

Scholarly Articles

The Year in Review lecture is titled in a way that I might interpret slightly differently in viewing what has been over the past year. I hope to distill out a couple of bigger themes, a couple of bigger threads that perhaps wove their way throughout the past year as reflected in some of the words that have been exchanged since we all got together here in Chautauqua. I want, in a sense, to tie and weave those threads into the conference theme, which we haven’t heard that much about. This is: The cutting edge of international humanitarian law.

Book Review, Mia Swart, On Bonifratròw Street: How A Boy From Lwów Escaped The Nazis (2024), Mark A. Drumbl

Scholarly Articles

On Bonifratròw Street is a book about biography, history, and law. It begins with Katz’s childhood in Lwów, Poland, before World War II. The story unwraps the backgrounds of his parents and other family members, notably his biological father, whose presence and then absence loom large in his life. The book then moves to the war. It details Katz’s life in a variety of places, including Lodz and Warsaw, among others, seen from his perspective as a teenager at the time. The book ends with Katz’s post-war emigration to the US, where he joined a distant relative. Defying odds and …

Striking A Balance: Why Federal And State Laws Should Be Revised To Effectively Deter Puppy Mills, Kaitlyn Cameron

Animal Law Review

The Animal Welfare Act (AWA) was passed in 1966 with the purpose of ensuring the humane care and treatment of animals. The AWA delegates licensing responsibilities to the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the Animal Plant and Health Inspection Services (APHIS), who have the authority to investigate violations of the AWA and penalize relevant organizations, such as puppy mills, when necessary. Unfortunately, the AWA sets forth minimum standards for the humane care and treatment of these animals and the USDA has exercised its own discretion in penalizing violations of the AWA. The AWA establishes standards for compliance, but …

Time To Free The 'Evidence': Animal Cruelty Prosecutions, Pre-Conviction Forfeiture, And Brady Violations, Gary J. Patronek

Animal Law Review

This Article presents empirical research to investigate the traditional practice of holding seized animal victims of maltreatment in protective custody until their disposition is resolved pursuant to a criminal proceeding. This is of particular concern because protective custody usually entails confinement in an animal shelter or similar institutional setting. Extended confinement under these circumstances is undesirable–especially when dealing with large numbers of animals–because such confinement causes stress that may inadvertently result in secondary victimization of the animals. Furthermore, institutional confinement poses substantial logistical challenges and imposes substantial economic costs for those tasked with caring for the animals. The impetus for …

Exploited: The Unexpected Victims Of Animal Agriculture, Caitlin Kelly

Animal Law Review

Awareness of how nonhuman animals suffer in animal agriculture has been growing for years. But are they the only victims? Selling the products and parts of hundreds of millions of animals in the United States every year requires someone to manage those animals. It requires someone to kill those animals. And it requires someone to dismember those animals long before they ever reach the neat rows of plastic wrapped packaging at the grocery store. To accomplish this process at an industrial scale means hundreds to thousands of animals are together in barns which reek of their waste and create biohazards …

Front Matter

Animal Law Review

Front Matter includes Front Matter includes Title Page, Masthead, advisors, and Table of Contents for Animal Law Review Volume 30, Issue 2, 2024.

The 3rs And Non-Human Animals In Biomedical Research: The Next 65 Years, Paul Locke, Richelle Romanchik, Breanne Kincaid, Emily Golden

Animal Law Review

It has been 65 years since the publication of Russell and Burch’s “The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique,” which established the ‘3Rs’—refinement, reduction, and replacement—as the key principles applicable to decision making about, and the use of, non-human animals in laboratory settings. The 3Rs are universally accepted by responsible scientists throughout the world and form the basis for many national legal and regulatory systems governing animal use in laboratories. This Article will discuss broadly how the 3Rs have evolved over the past seven decades since the publication of Russell and Burch’s seminal work, and examine the 3Rs in light of …

Alchemizing The Bar: An Examination Of Global Ethical Considerations For Using Alternatives To Animals In Research, Testing, And Education, Lenore M. Montanaro

Animal Law Review

Countries regulate scientific research in various ways. Such structures are the result of input from scientists, attorneys, physicians, advocates, and others. These schemes may also derive from outcomes of the research itself. Some countries do not incorporate or require the ethical use of an animal—or an alternative to the use of an animal—to be considered. Others do incorporate, and even require, the ethical use of animals in research. In alignment with The Three Rs—replacement, reduction, and refinement of animals used in science—technological capabilities now allow scientists to increasingly use alternatives, such as microphysiological systems, rather than animal models. This Article …

The Exceptional Dead: Human Remains As Property, Non-Property, And Cultural Property In Armed Conflict, Ronald Alcala

American University Law Review

International humanitarian law mandates that the dead must be respected and protected in armed conflict. Among other things, parties to an armed conflict must ensure that the dead are treated with dignity and that their bodies are not despoiled, pillaged, mutilated, or otherwise maltreated. Not all human remains located on the battlefield, however, will have a direct nexus to the fighting. Some, like those of Prince Grigory Potemkin, a historical figure whose bones were seized by Russian forces from a Ukrainian church in 2022, might even pre-exist an ongoing conflict. Whether rules applicable to the dead apply to such remains …

Meme-Manipulation: Towards Reinvigorating The Regulation Of Speculative Devices, John W. Bagby, Nizan Geslevich Packin

American University Law Review

As DJT shares skyrocket by thirty percent following the assassination attempt on now President Donald Trump, the financial world stands as a testament to how meme stocks and social media-driven speculation can create seismic market shifts, often blurring the lines between organic market activity and coordinated, systematic manipulation. In an era where memes dictate market movements and social media influencers wield unprecedented power, the fusion of meme stocks, SPACs, and cryptocurrency speculation has transformed financial markets into volatile arenas. This Article delves into the electrifying world of speculative trading, where viral online campaigns and cutting-edge technologies create seismic shifts in …

Artificial Intelligence Is Like A Perpetual Stew, Nathan Reitinger

American University Law Review

Artificial intelligence is inescapable. It is in our phones, fridges, and most of the businesses we engage with use it to “improve” their services. From deciding on what YouTube video to watch next to driving vehicles or firing weapons, artificial intelligence is a linchpin in our society. But what is artificial intelligence? And, more importantly, why does that matter? It matters because we are currently unprepared to deal with the paradigm-shifting legal issues brought about by artificial intelligence. And without this understanding, we are nearly certainly going to make mistakes. The bright side is that artificial intelligence is not complicated. …

Petition Power, Erika Lietzan

American University Law Review

The law cannot be kept secret. We cannot comply with rules that we do not know. Nor can we question their legitimacy, which is both our right and our duty as citizens. And yet, a substantial body of law applied in this country is difficult for anyone but federal agency insiders to piece together. Rather than publishing regulations that lay out standards of conduct for the future, many agencies interpret the law, and articulate and implement new policies, as they go. Those subject to the law they implement are left to piece the rules together by studying whatever information is …

Adultery Provisions In Matrimonial Agreements, Elizabeth R. Carter

American University Law Review

Can a contract discourage your spouse from cheating or compensate you for a broken heart? Adultery penalties in marriage contracts seek to do exactly that. An adultery penalty is a financial penalty in a marriage contract triggered by a spouse’s infidelity. While many practitioners advise clients against adultery provisions in marriage contracts, some clients demand them. However, are adultery provisions enforceable? Should they be? This Article considers the sociolegal history of adultery and provides new insight into the enforceability and wisdom of adultery penalties. This Article also provides novel arguments that adultery provisions should not be enforced and calls upon …

Confusion Over Trademark Extraterritoriality ... And Beyond, Timothy R. Holbrook, Anshu Garg

American University Law Review

The Supreme Court afforded the Lanham Act extraterritorial reach over seventy years ago in Steele v. Bulova, but its recent extraterritoriality jurisprudence called that decision into question. This Article explains the history of trademark extraterritoriality and the splits that emerged among the circuit courts of appeals. It then canvases all of the Supreme Court’s recent decisions on the presumption against extraterritoriality and their effort to reinvigorate and standardize the law in that regard.

We then provide a detailed exploration of the Supreme Court’s decision in Abitron Austria GmbH v. Hetronic International, Inc. Next, we critique the decision and explore its …

Prison Administrative Law, Erin Braatz

American University Law Review

This Article examines a matching pair of gaps in the legal literature on prisons and the administrative state. On the one hand, prison law focuses on constitutional protections for prisoners. As such, it emphasizes the minimum conditions the Constitution ensures for the nearly two million individuals currently incarcerated throughout the United States. What this focus misses, however, is the administrative nature of these institutions. With vast powers delegated to prison departments, prison law often fails to fully engage with the administrative nature of power and decision-making within prison departments. This administrative structure shapes the conditions that prevail inside American prisons. …

Taking A Step Back: Have We Already Seen Judicial Takings?, Anna Sargent

American University Law Review

In Stop the Beach Renourishment, Inc. v. Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Justice Scalia’s plurality opinion held that the Takings Clause is not addressed to a single government actor, but rather applies to all government actions, including those effected by the judicial branch. Consequently, regardless of which branch affects the taking, just compensation is required. Despite promulgating the existence of judicial takings, the Court then went on to say that no established property right was “taken” for Fifth Amendment purposes. Without an application or a clear-cut delineation, Justice Scalia’s promulgation of judicial takings was rendered as merely advisory to …

Venture Capital Culpability: Potential Liabilities For Venture Capital Investment Of Fraudulent Portfolio Companies, Calzia, Kyle D.

Santa Clara High Technology Law Journal

Due to the possible detrimental effects of broadening liability for venture capitalists, any change would need to balance the dangers of limiting economic growth with the public policy motives of protecting shareholders. An expansion of securities law in Section 10b and Rule 10b-5 could open venture firms to liability as aider-abettors to securities fraud, specifically when venture firms continue to offer financial or directional assistance after having reason to know of securities fraud by their portfolio companies. Additionally, stricter examinations of agency relationships and director duties that are required from venture firm partners that sit on portfolio boards could see …

Law And Literature In Pennsylvania: A Changing Landscape, Juliette Gaggini

Honors Theses

This thesis examines themes of American national identity perpetuated in Pennsylvania surrounding private property through historical, literary and legal analysis. Ideals of private property and land ownership are broken into three transitions throughout Pennsylvania history: the American frontier and initial land claiming by settlers, mass-deforestation and the introduction of widespread agriculture, and finally industrialization and the introduction of mining and fracking. Each of these transitions highlights the physical changes to the region and how they were influenced by American ideals of private property, productivity, and profitability.

Throughout this thesis, I analyze both literary and legal texts to examine societal beliefs …

Protecting Worker Health Data Privacy From The Inside Out, Elizabeth A. Brown

UC Law Business Journal

This article investigates three new opportunities for complementary public, private, and design-centric protections of worker health data, an overlooked yet critical area of data privacy regulation. The expansion of biometric monitoring, of the $50 billion femtech industry, and the commercial value of health data also underscore the need for greater protection of worker health data. Now that states are developing more comprehensive data privacy laws, it is critical to consider innovative solutions that build on the best of these laws nationwide. Especially after the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision, the health data of women workers has become especially prone to misuse. …

Jack Daniel's And The Unfulfilled Promise Of Trademark Use, Stacey Dogan, Jessica Silbey

Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal

The article examines the Supreme Court's decision in Jack Daniel's v. VIP Products and its implications for the use of trademarks in artistic and expressive works. The Court's ruling established a "trademark use" doctrine, distinguishing between uses of trademarks as a designation of source for goods and non-trademark, expressive uses. While the decision does not overturn the Rogers v. Grimaldi test, it creates uncertainty in applying Rogers to expressive works, leading to inconsistent lower court decisions and threatening First Amendment protections for creative uses of trademarks.

Municipal Abortion Bans: When Local Control Clashes With State Power, Laura D. Hermer

Faculty Scholarship

Anti-abortion activists are using different strategies in different states. Some focus on restricting zoning for abortion clinics. Others address the licensure of abortion providers. Some purport to create a cause of action for private individuals to sue neighbors and others in their municipality who get an abortion. Still, others seek to enforce the federal Comstock Act, alleging that it prohibits the mailing of abortifacients and preempts state abortion law to the contrary.

This Article evaluates the likely success of each of these strategies in two states in which they are currently being tried: Nebraska and New Mexico. Part I will …