Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Constitutional Law (34983)
- International Law (32265)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (29790)
- Criminal Law (27911)
- Environmental Law (18444)
-
- Intellectual Property Law (17072)
- Legal Education (16878)
- State and Local Government Law (16692)
- Courts (16647)
- Civil Rights and Discrimination (14896)
- Health Law and Policy (14627)
- Legislation (14560)
- Law and Society (14114)
- Administrative Law (14113)
- Comparative and Foreign Law (14050)
- Indigenous, Indian, and Aboriginal Law (13882)
- Human Rights Law (12316)
- Criminal Procedure (12064)
- Legal Profession (11684)
- Labor and Employment Law (11185)
- Business Organizations Law (10759)
- Arts and Humanities (10734)
- Sociology (10391)
- Legal History (10009)
- Legal Studies (9827)
- Jurisprudence (9247)
- Torts (9012)
- Science and Technology Law (8821)
- Property Law and Real Estate (8398)
- Institution
-
- Brigham Young University Law School (37205)
- University of Michigan Law School (21829)
- Duke Law (14425)
- Fordham Law School (13334)
- Maurer School of Law: Indiana University (11951)
-
- University of Oklahoma College of Law (11866)
- Yeshiva University, Cardozo School of Law (11515)
- Case Western Reserve University School of Law (10936)
- Southern Methodist University (10168)
- William & Mary Law School (9532)
- American University Washington College of Law (9074)
- Northwestern Pritzker School of Law (8932)
- UC Law SF (8867)
- University of North Carolina School of Law (8799)
- Notre Dame Law School (8249)
- Vanderbilt University Law School (8031)
- University of South Carolina (7596)
- University of Minnesota Law School (7364)
- University of Missouri School of Law (7266)
- Cornell University Law School (7209)
- University of Colorado Law School (7193)
- University of Kentucky (6982)
- Washington and Lee University School of Law (6925)
- Louisiana State University Law Center (6749)
- Marquette University Law School (6614)
- University of Chicago Law School (6494)
- Seton Hall University (6196)
- University of Washington School of Law (6130)
- University of Richmond (6022)
- Chicago-Kent College of Law (5729)
- Keyword
-
- Law (6238)
- Constitutional law (3540)
- International law (3379)
- Supreme Court (3330)
- Human rights (3205)
-
- Constitutional Law (3005)
- United States (2673)
- First Amendment (2663)
- Copyright (2559)
- Constitution (2538)
- Discrimination (2512)
- International Law (2282)
- Evidence (2258)
- Criminal law (2243)
- Regulation (2188)
- Jurisprudence (2141)
- United States Supreme Court (2103)
- University of Michigan Law School (2099)
- History (2072)
- Privacy (2071)
- Intellectual property (1970)
- Philosophy (1969)
- Legislation (1945)
- Politics (1910)
- Legal education (1897)
- Jurisdiction (1894)
- Ethics (1877)
- Courts (1820)
- Law students (1784)
- Contracts (1781)
- Publication Year
-
- 2026 (7580)
- 2025 (10543)
- 2024 (10969)
- 2023 (11463)
- 2022 (14827)
-
- 2021 (13133)
- 2020 (12812)
- 2019 (12039)
- 2018 (13590)
- 2017 (14046)
- 2016 (15271)
- 2015 (14369)
- 2014 (12634)
- 2013 (12812)
- 2012 (13465)
- 2011 (11717)
- 2010 (11499)
- 2009 (11211)
- 2008 (10753)
- 2007 (10551)
- 2006 (11365)
- 2005 (10092)
- 2004 (9683)
- 2003 (8863)
- 2002 (8338)
- 2001 (9172)
- 2000 (8631)
- 1999 (7767)
- 1998 (7674)
- 1992 (7926)
- Publication
-
- Faculty Scholarship (21547)
- Articles (11521)
- Michigan Law Review (11192)
- Faculty Publications (8709)
- American Indian and Alaskan Native Documents in the Congressional Serial Set: 1817-1899 (8590)
-
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (through 1995) (6781)
- Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (6683)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (1996–2006) (6653)
- North Carolina Law Review (6028)
- Louisiana Law Review (5640)
- Fordham Law Review (5038)
- Indiana Law Journal (4891)
- Scholarly Works (4752)
- West Virginia Law Review (4375)
- Marquette Law Review (4292)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (cases filed before 1965) (4290)
- Law and Contemporary Problems (4157)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (through 1999) (4057)
- SMU Law Review (4056)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– 2019) (4013)
- Case Western Reserve Law Review (3960)
- Missouri Law Review (3741)
- Vanderbilt Law Review (3653)
- Kentucky Law Journal (3638)
- South Carolina Law Review (3466)
- Notre Dame Law Review (3373)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (2000–2020) (3368)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (1965 –) (3367)
- Washington Law Review (3365)
- Washington and Lee Law Review (3361)
- Publication Type
Articles 13141 - 13170 of 544813
Full-Text Articles in Law
Bioethics Of Patents And Licensing, Tabrez Y. Ebrahim
Bioethics Of Patents And Licensing, Tabrez Y. Ebrahim
North Carolina Journal of Law & Technology
No abstract provided.
Are Technology And The Law On The Same “Wavelength”?: Examining The New Frontier Of Brainwaves And Data Privacy, John G. Browning
Are Technology And The Law On The Same “Wavelength”?: Examining The New Frontier Of Brainwaves And Data Privacy, John G. Browning
North Carolina Journal of Law & Technology
No abstract provided.
Reimagining Social Media Through Middleware: A Structural Path To Competition And User Agency, Madhavi Singh
Reimagining Social Media Through Middleware: A Structural Path To Competition And User Agency, Madhavi Singh
North Carolina Journal of Law & Technology
No abstract provided.
Introduction – Emerging Pollutants In Water: Threats, Challenges, And Research Needs, Sarantuyaa Zandaryaa, Ali Fares, Gabriel Eckstein
Introduction – Emerging Pollutants In Water: Threats, Challenges, And Research Needs, Sarantuyaa Zandaryaa, Ali Fares, Gabriel Eckstein
Faculty Scholarship
Water is indispensable for life, health, and environmental sustainability, as underscored by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Traditional water quality assessments have historically focused on pathogens, nutrients, and heavy metals. However, recent decades have witnessed growing concerns over Contaminants of Emerging Concern (CECs), a diverse class of pollutants with potential risks to human health and ecosystems. CECs encompass pharmaceuticals, personal care products, endocrine-disrupting compounds, and microplastics, entering water bodies via wastewater, industrial discharge, and agricultural runoff. Their persistence and adverse effects pose significant challenges to water treatment technologies. This manuscript explores the scientific understanding, environmental fate, and societal implications …
Who Owns The Heat? Property Rights In Geothermal Energy, Gabriel Eckstein
Who Owns The Heat? Property Rights In Geothermal Energy, Gabriel Eckstein
Faculty Scholarship
Landowners can have ownership claims to oil, gas, water, and other tangible natural resources located in their subsoil. But can they also claim rights to the thermal energy found below their land? With 50,000 times more heat energy within the top 10,000 meters (around 33,000 feet) of the Earth’s surface than contained in all of the world’s oil and natural gas resources combined, geothermal energy is a tremendously promising, clean, and renewable energy resource. Yet, ambiguities in property rights related to the development and ownership of geothermal energy resources raise questions about who is entitled to benefit from that potential. …
Legal Market Decartelization, Milan Markovic, Nuno Garoupa
Legal Market Decartelization, Milan Markovic, Nuno Garoupa
Faculty Scholarship
American lawyers’ grip on the legal market is receding. Scholars and policymakers increasingly agree that the public has little to lose and potentially much to gain from legal market decartelization - the weakening of the lawyers’ monopoly over the legal services market. Harkening to deregulatory initiatives abroad and in Arizona and Utah, reformers contend that removing restrictions on the corporate delivery of legal services and unauthorized practice of law will slash costs and expand access to justice.
Drawing on economic theory and recent market developments, this Article offers a cautionary rejoinder. Understandable concerns about cartelization and lawyer rent-seeking have led …
Tomorrow’S Climate Law, Today, Daniel E. Walters
Tomorrow’S Climate Law, Today, Daniel E. Walters
Faculty Scholarship
The prospects for domestic legislation or international treaties that would require governments, businesses, and individuals to stop emitting the greenhouse gases that cause global climate change are particularly bleak these days. Even as the United States has recently passed its most ambitious climate legislation to date in the Inflation Reduction Act and related “green industrial policy” legislation, these successes were ultimately a compromise with politicians who refused to consider more direct controls on emissions. Assuming they survive the second Trump Administration, the green subsidies and nudges contained in these laws, coupled with a groundswell of private environmental governance, will do …
Debt Tokens, Andrea Tosato, Diane Lourdes Dick, Christopher K. Odinet
Debt Tokens, Andrea Tosato, Diane Lourdes Dick, Christopher K. Odinet
Faculty Scholarship
The worlds of crypto and bankruptcy have collided. Once-prominent, fast-growing, and even politically influential platforms for trading cryptocurrencies have imploded spectacularly. Gone are the glossy advertisements, celebrity endorsements, and proclamations that blockchain operates as a law unto itself. Instead, insolvent crypto businesses—including the crypto exchange giant FTX—find themselves in bankruptcy court, no different from any other failed enterprise. These bankruptcies reveal a startling reality: individual investors who placed their trust in these platforms have been stripped of their digital assets. In their stead, they hold hard-to-collect claims against these defunct platforms.
Amid the chill of the crypto winter, bankruptcy has …
Capital Formation, The Sec, And Accredited Investors, Neal F. Newman, Lawrence J. Trautman, Brian Elzweig
Capital Formation, The Sec, And Accredited Investors, Neal F. Newman, Lawrence J. Trautman, Brian Elzweig
Faculty Scholarship
Protecting the investing public, while simultaneously facilitating the efficient flow of capital needed by all new and growing businesses continues as a primary responsibility of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Enhancing the capital formation process is a necessary step in the creation of jobs and growth of any economy. Central to the SEC’s regulatory schematic is the proposition that some particularly sophisticated and wealthy investors require less protection than those with less knowledge, experience, and resources. During December 2023, for just the third time, the SEC staff issued a report examining the status of the natural person accredited …
Artificial Intelligence, Autonomous Creation, And The Future Path Of Copyright Law, Peter K. Yu
Artificial Intelligence, Autonomous Creation, And The Future Path Of Copyright Law, Peter K. Yu
Faculty Scholarship
Most literature at the intersection of copyright and AI has focused primarily on what copyright law is or ought to be. Frequently overlooked is the question of what copyright law will be in the AI space. Understanding this question is crucial because the path of copyright law chosen by the United States will have a major impact on the country's economic and technological future.
This article begins by scrutinizing two lines of arguments that have been advanced to deny copyright protection to AI-generated works: constitutional and incentive-based. The article then discusses a third line of arguments—harmonization-based arguments—and identifies select instances …
Guide To Sec And Business Open Source Corporate Intelligence, Lawrence J. Trautman, Brian Elzweig, Neal F. Newman
Guide To Sec And Business Open Source Corporate Intelligence, Lawrence J. Trautman, Brian Elzweig, Neal F. Newman
Faculty Scholarship
An agency of the U.S. intelligence community observes, "The explosion of open source intelligence (OSINT) in recent years has transformed how governments and people around the world consume and process information about society and global issues." It is likely that "We all use open-source and probably don't even realize it, but we also use it for different reasons. You might use open-source information to do a credibility check and to find out more about the person selling you something on Facebook marketplace." Others "may research someone… met on a dating app or before hiring someone for a job." Every use …
Saving Agency Adjudication, Aaron L. Nielson, Christopher J. Walker, Melissa F. Wasserman
Saving Agency Adjudication, Aaron L. Nielson, Christopher J. Walker, Melissa F. Wasserman
Articles
When discussing the federal judiciary, commentators typically fixate on the 800 or so “Article III” judges who are nominated by the President, confirmed by the Senate, and enjoy life tenure and salary protection. Yet most federal adjudication does not take place in federal courthouses at all. Instead, it occurs in nondescript hearing rooms in administrative agencies—if not telephonically. Indeed, the more than 12,000 agency adjudicators scattered across the federal government collectively issue millions of decisions per year on subjects ranging from Social Security and veterans benefits to immigration and patent rights. In recent years, however, scholars and agency adjudicators have …
Too Much Time Alone: Disciplinary Segregation As A Cruel And Unusual Punishment, Elijah Swolgaard, Spencer Schlag
Too Much Time Alone: Disciplinary Segregation As A Cruel And Unusual Punishment, Elijah Swolgaard, Spencer Schlag
Brigham Young University Prelaw Review
Disciplinary segregation has historically been used as an arbitrary form of punishment in American prison systems. The severe psychological effects of this confinement allow it be classified as a cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment and generally lead to higher recidivism rates. This Note argues that in order to prevent these effects from occurring, disciplinary segregation should be ruled unconstitutional. Previous scholarship has argued for removal of solitary confinement generally. In contrast, this Note argues for the removal of disciplinary segregation specifically, while maintaining the use of necessary forms of solitary confinement such as administrative segregation. This will …
Abuse, Neglect, And Abandonment: The Need To Protect Immigrant Minors Through Standardized Definitions, Bailey Morris Gurr, Lila Bird Williams
Abuse, Neglect, And Abandonment: The Need To Protect Immigrant Minors Through Standardized Definitions, Bailey Morris Gurr, Lila Bird Williams
Brigham Young University Prelaw Review
Special Immigrant Juvenile Status (SIJS) applications are inconsistently adjudicated across states due to varying definitions of abuse, neglect, and abandonment. This inconsistency creates geographic disparities in protection, leaving vulnerable immigrant minors at risk of deportation; in the worst-case scenario, children who meet the criteria in one state may be denied in another and sent back to unsafe or life-threatening conditions. This paper argues for federal oversight to standardize SIJS criteria by amending the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) to establish unambiguous definitions of abuse, neglect, and abandonment, ensuring fair and consistent adjudication nationwide. Legal scholars widely recognize the …
The Cost Of Capital: Lowering The Cost Of Capital For Climate And Sdg Finance In Emerging Markets And Developing Economies (Emdes), Jeffrey D. Sachs, Lisa E. Sachs, Ana M. Camelo Vega, Bradford M. Willis
The Cost Of Capital: Lowering The Cost Of Capital For Climate And Sdg Finance In Emerging Markets And Developing Economies (Emdes), Jeffrey D. Sachs, Lisa E. Sachs, Ana M. Camelo Vega, Bradford M. Willis
Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment
Today, some of the world's fastest-growing economies face some of the highest borrowing costs – even for clean energy and development projects with strong fundamentals. This is not a function of global capital scarcity. Trillions are available. The problem lies in systemic barriers that prevent capital from flowing to where it’s most urgently needed. The high cost of capital in EMDEs not only undermines critical financing for the energy transition and sustainable development; it also limits the ability for US- and EU-based financial institutions to invest in and finance projects in EMDEs, despite institutional and stakeholder appetite and interest for …
The Harms Of Expanding Physician-Assisted Suicide, Katherine Drabiak
The Harms Of Expanding Physician-Assisted Suicide, Katherine Drabiak
Health Matrix: The Journal of Law-Medicine
Currently, nine states and the District of Columbia have passed laws in the U.S. to legalize and regulate the practice of physicianassisted suicide (“PAS”). Proponents initially garnered public support by portraying PAS as distinct from suicide, framing it as a rare mechanism for patients with terminal illness to achieve a peaceful death, enhance autonomy, and reduce suffering. Original state laws contained numerous eligibility requirements designed as safeguards to provide stringent limits. However, over the past few years proponents of PAS have systematically worked to expand PAS and erase these limits by increasing eligible providers, reducing waiting periods, and eliminating residency …
Medical Necessity And Prior Authorization: The Unregulated Power Of Insurers, Virginia Lefever
Medical Necessity And Prior Authorization: The Unregulated Power Of Insurers, Virginia Lefever
Health Matrix: The Journal of Law-Medicine
The absence of a uniform federal definition of “medical necessity” in employer-sponsored health plans has allowed insurers to create their own coverage standards, often resulting in inconsistent and opaque determinations that limit access to essential care. This Note argues that ERISA’s silence on medical necessity grants insurers excessive discretion, enabling restrictive prior authorization policies that disadvantage patients and providers alike. By analyzing judicial interpretations, regulatory gaps, and the disparate standards imposed by insurers, this Note makes the case for a federally mandated definition of medical necessity applicable to all employer-sponsored plans. A standardized definition would promote transparency, reduce litigation, and …
Her Fundamentals: Justice Abella And Section 2(B) Of The Charter, Jamie Cameron
Her Fundamentals: Justice Abella And Section 2(B) Of The Charter, Jamie Cameron
Articles & Book Chapters
Justice Abella’s legendary aspirations for human rights all but defined her jurisprudence, and under s,2 she earned praise elsewhere for her opinions on religious freedom (s.2(a) of the Charter) and the right to strike under s.2(d)’s guarantee of associational freedom. Apart from Doré v. Barreau de Québec, her s.2(b) jurisprudence on freedom of expression has attracted less scholarly attention. This article highlights Justice Abella’s leadership under s.2(b) in protecting expressive freedom’s democratic values, developing a more robust form of proportionality balancing under s.1, and advocating for doctrinal recognition of freedom of the press and media as an independent …
"Price Discrimination" Discrimination, Talia B. Gillis
"Price Discrimination" Discrimination, Talia B. Gillis
Faculty Scholarship
Credit price personalization, where lenders set prices based on individual borrower and loan characteristics, is a common practice across many loan types, with conventional accounts of its harms focusing on the ways in which risk-based pricing, or setting prices based on borrowers’ credit risk, can lead to disparities for protected groups like racial minorities and women. This Article examines an often-overlooked yet potentially harmful form of price personalization — charging borrowers different rates based on their willingness-to-pay, known as price discrimination — and argues that this practice can exploit vulnerable borrowers, including protected groups like racial minorities and women, by …
Time For States To Flex Their Legal Muscles, Michael B. Gerrard
Time For States To Flex Their Legal Muscles, Michael B. Gerrard
Faculty Scholarship
In these dark several years ahead, with all three branches of the federal government moving backwards on environmental protection, the states can do much to stem the retreat.
J Mich Dent Assoc April 2025
The Journal of the Michigan Dental Association
Each month, The Journal of the Michigan Dental Association provides news, information, and features about Michigan dentistry to our state's oral health community and the MDA's 6,200+ members. It stands as the primary publication reaching Michigan dentists. The April issue marks the end of an era, as the MDA announced it would discontinue providing a print issue and focus on digital distribution.
This month’s issue includes a cover feature on going non-par, a feature article on pterygoid implant placement and restoration, candidate’s biographical statements, and information on a new membership benefit for health and well-being. Regular departments include the New …
Mobile Hyflex, Mairéad Seymour
Mobile Hyflex, Mairéad Seymour
Case studies: Digital Education
I utilised the mobile hyflex technology with a group of taught postgraduate students attending a 2 hour research methods lecture. Students were required to complete preparatory work in advance which formed the basis of group discussion and group tasks. Sessions were divided between lecture delivery, individual exercises and small group discussion or group tasks. I delivered a hybrid approach using the mobile technology provided by the NTUTORR initiative and the virtual classroom function in Brightspace.
Defining Diversity: Challenges To Diversity, Equity, And Inclusion Efforts In A Post-Affirmative Action America, Hannah Brown
Defining Diversity: Challenges To Diversity, Equity, And Inclusion Efforts In A Post-Affirmative Action America, Hannah Brown
Missouri Law Review
Finals season is a time of high stress in law schools. In fact, it is not uncommon for students to fantasize about miraculously convincing a court that a four-hour exam constitutes a form of intentional infliction of emotional distress. Such commentary remains firmly in comedic territory, not reality. Occasionally, however, law students with grievances beyond those expressed in the dramatic remarks above devote time and energy to seeking legal action against their respective law schools. The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York encountered such a situation in Doe v. New York University, where a student alleged …
Dangerous Digital Standing: Applying Spokeo And Transunion To Online Privacy Harms, Michael E. Ten Eyck
Dangerous Digital Standing: Applying Spokeo And Transunion To Online Privacy Harms, Michael E. Ten Eyck
Vanderbilt Journal of Entertainment & Technology Law
In recent years, the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) has been used to sue website-holding companies for utilizing chat bots that record online conversations. Such claims have already generated high-profile class actions and multidistrict litigations, with many more expected. Because CIPA violations often occur writ large when websites retain data from their chat boxes, and the statute imposes relatively high damages, there exists an incentive for plaintiffs’ attorneys to seek out aggregated claims, generating time-consuming litigation. Meanwhile, the harms suffered by those bringing suit fall under the category of intangible privacy harms. The US Court of Appeals for the …
Charter Schools And Students With Disabilities: Admissions Equity, Kelly L. Carrick
Charter Schools And Students With Disabilities: Admissions Equity, Kelly L. Carrick
Senior Theses
Many states are now offering parents a choice in where their child attends school, typically offering charter schools as the alternative to public schools. With charter school enrollment on the rise, questions have begun to arise regarding the acceptance rates of students with disabilities, specifically, how do students with disabilities fare in the process of being admitted to charter schools? This research examines the admissions policies of charter schools, the admission rates for students with disabilities, as well as the legality and equity of this topic. Previous research has found that charter schools typically do not accept as many students …
Holding Ground In The Cerulean Tide: Minority Party Legislators' Strategies For Advancing Climate Policies In Landslide States, Sukjae Lee
Dissertations and Doctoral Documents, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, 2023–
This dissertation addresses a key puzzle: Why do states sometimes adopt nationally polarized policies, such as climate change legislation, even when doing so does not align with strict partisan interests? The analysis focuses on “landslide states,” where a single party overwhelmingly dominates, and the minority party cannot realistically expect to gain a majority. In these environments, reduced partisan conflict allows minority party legislators to break from traditional partisan paths. As a result, I argue that electoral motivations drive them to signal moderation by advancing liberal policy agendas or incorporating provisions that minimize backlash from their core constituents in landslide states. …
How Do School-Level Dynamics Impact Mainstreaming Practices In American Schools?, Natalie M. Watson
How Do School-Level Dynamics Impact Mainstreaming Practices In American Schools?, Natalie M. Watson
Department of Sociology: Dissertations, Theses, and Student Research
How do school-level dynamics impact the everyday experiences of students with disabilities, compared to their abled peers? Extant research has mostly focused on the experiences of individual students with disabilities, and their teachers. We know far less about how school-level dynamics shape students’ experiences. Historically, American schools formally separated students with and without disabilities, though the specific mode varied over time -- ranging from explicit institutionalization to segregation in special education programs. At least since the passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act in 1990, efforts to educate students with disabilities alongside their abled peers in mainstreamed settings have increased …
“The Craze For Legal Proceedings”: Another Look At Schloendorff V. New York Hospital, Paul A. Lombardo
“The Craze For Legal Proceedings”: Another Look At Schloendorff V. New York Hospital, Paul A. Lombardo
Health Matrix: The Journal of Law-Medicine
In 1914, Judge Benjamin Cardozo wrote an appellate decision in the case of Schloendorff v. Society of the New York Hospital containing the assertion, “Every human being of adult years and sound mind has a right to determine what shall be done to his own body.” This quotation later became a touchstone for discussions of the principle of informed consent. Previous scholarship has questioned the use of Schloendorff as a byword of patient self-determination, but more recently discovered records suggest yet another way to understand the famous case. Material from the archive of the New York Hospital—where Mary Schloendorff’s surgery …
Art As The Prosecutor's Weapon: The Use Of Rap Lyrics Evidence At Trial, Mikah K. Thompson, Sierra Raheem
Art As The Prosecutor's Weapon: The Use Of Rap Lyrics Evidence At Trial, Mikah K. Thompson, Sierra Raheem
Faculty Works
Are rap lyrics worthy of the same protections that other forms of creative expression enjoy, or is there something inherent to rap lyrics that renders them autobiographical, confessional, and reflective of the author’s true intentions and desires? This Article will attempt to answer that question. In doing so, the authors will take the reader on a voyage through a history that is not widely known among the attorneys, judges, expert witnesses, and jurors who are frequently called upon to interpret the art form known as Hip Hop.
This journey requires an exploration of our country’s history of chattel slavery, for …