Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
East Asian Languages and Societies Commons™
Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Chinese Studies (4402)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (1841)
- History (1534)
- Asian History (1347)
- International and Area Studies (1240)
-
- Asian Studies (1132)
- Political Science (1043)
- International Relations (1000)
- Japanese Studies (693)
- Religion (348)
- Comparative Literature (313)
- Korean Studies (269)
- Philosophy (269)
- Education (243)
- Film and Media Studies (224)
- Creative Writing (215)
- Feminist, Gender, and Sexuality Studies (215)
- Sociology (208)
- Modern Literature (190)
- Classics (183)
- Art and Design (174)
- Linguistics (168)
- Anthropology (152)
- French and Francophone Language and Literature (148)
- English Language and Literature (147)
- Race, Ethnicity and Post-Colonial Studies (147)
- History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology (140)
- Theatre and Performance Studies (140)
- Institution
-
- Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art (1362)
- Lingnan University (1123)
- University of Nebraska - Lincoln (968)
- Brigham Young University (148)
- Western Michigan University (119)
-
- Portland State University (101)
- Cleveland State University (98)
- The University of San Francisco (94)
- Chulalongkorn University (74)
- City University of New York (CUNY) (73)
- Claremont Colleges (72)
- Gettysburg College (64)
- Bucknell University (63)
- University of Kentucky (46)
- SIT Graduate Institute/SIT Study Abroad (43)
- Purdue University (42)
- Yale University (42)
- Washington University in St. Louis (39)
- Swarthmore College (36)
- Indiana State University (33)
- Old Dominion University (33)
- Rhode Island School of Design (33)
- Universitas Indonesia (33)
- Coastal Carolina University (32)
- Georgia Southern University (32)
- University of Malaya (32)
- Abilene Christian University (31)
- University of Rhode Island (31)
- Western Kentucky University (30)
- Ateneo de Manila University (29)
- Keyword
-
- Classical Literary Theory and Criticism (240)
- China (210)
- Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory and Criticism (174)
- Japan (172)
- Studies in Western Literary Theory (106)
-
- Studies in Western Literary Theory and Aesthetics (58)
- Chinese (49)
- Poetry (49)
- Culture (48)
- Translation (48)
- South Korea (46)
- Western Literary Theory (44)
- Buddhism (43)
- Korea (43)
- BYU Asian Studies (39)
- Japanese (38)
- History (37)
- Western Literary Theory and Criticism (35)
- Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory (33)
- Western Literary Theory and Studies in Aesthetics (33)
- Identity (30)
- Education (28)
- Language (27)
- Gender (26)
- Globalization (26)
- Japanese literature (24)
- Anime (23)
- Politics (22)
- Taiwan (21)
- Nationalism (20)
- Publication Year
- Publication
-
- Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art (1362)
- China Beat Blog: Archive 2008-2012 (924)
- Dissertations from all years (296)
- 嶺南學報 Lingnan Journal of Chinese Studies (278)
- 嶺南學報 Lingnan Journal (1929-1952) (247)
-
- Transference (108)
- Chinese Language Teaching Methodology and Technology (91)
- 嶺南學報 Lingnan Journal of Chinese Studies (1999-2006) (86)
- Chulalongkorn University Theses and Dissertations (Chula ETD) (74)
- BYU Asian Studies Student Journal (73)
- Dissertations and Theses (54)
- How to Read Chinese Poetry Podcast (48)
- 嶺南大學中文系系刊 Bulletin of Chinese Studies (48)
- Asia Pacific Perspectives (43)
- Lingnan Theses (42)
- Publications and Research (41)
- EnviroLab Asia (40)
- Master's Projects and Capstones (38)
- History Faculty Publications (35)
- Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection (35)
- Masters Theses (34)
- All-Inclusive List of Electronic Theses and Dissertations (33)
- CLCWeb: Comparative Literature and Culture (31)
- Journal of Undergraduate Research (30)
- Arts & Sciences Graduate Student Theses and Dissertations (28)
- Philosophy and Religious Studies (28)
- Honors Theses (27)
- Journal of East Asian Libraries (26)
- Other Faculty Research and Publications (25)
- Perspectives in the Arts and Humanities Asia (24)
- Publication Type
- File Type
Articles 3961 - 3990 of 6002
Full-Text Articles in East Asian Languages and Societies
On Du Fu's Reception Of Yu Xin's Poetry And The Implications To Du's Poetic Theory, Yao Zhong
On Du Fu's Reception Of Yu Xin's Poetry And The Implications To Du's Poetic Theory, Yao Zhong
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Among the influences Du Fu had received from The Book of Poetry to Six Dynasties, Yu Xin from Southern and Northern Dynasties enlightened Du Fu the most in his poetry writing. Du Fu evaluated Yu Xin's poetry to be "fresh" and "mature" and his observation became generally accepted among later critics. Du Fu's reception of Yu Xin underwent a complicate internal process, and Yu Xin's stylistic change from "freshness" to "maturity" became fundamental in Du Fu's epitomized poetic development.
On The "Flavour" In Poetry Commentaries In Song Dynasty, Aiping Huang, Xun Sun
On The "Flavour" In Poetry Commentaries In Song Dynasty, Aiping Huang, Xun Sun
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
The concept of "flavour" develops into an important category of Chinese ancient poetics, during the process of which poetry commentaries in Song Dynasty played an important role in enriching its connotation. The paper divides "flavour" into two categories in light of its application into genres. In one category, flavour is used to comment on the times and poetry style in general. In another category, it is used to comment on specific texts from four aspects of reason, emotion, context and object, and investigate its connotation. The paper has also explored the aesthetic characteristics of "flavour" from the perspective of its …
On The Rationality And Casual Criticism In Poetry Commentaries In Song Dynasty, Shanshan Xie, Qiaobin Deng
On The Rationality And Casual Criticism In Poetry Commentaries In Song Dynasty, Shanshan Xie, Qiaobin Deng
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Casual commentaries and casual criticism are a prevalent mode of literary criticism at the turn from Tang Dynasty to Song Dynasty. Casual criticism developed into poetry commentaries whose contents centered around poem appreciation, and evolved into a mode of literary criticism that was characterized by random writings, with Liuyi Poetry Commentaries as its representative. Poetry commentary places criticism into appreciation, and by emphasizing on historical research on and critical examination of the text, it explores the poetic principles in commenting on dictions and exerts a profound influence on the ancient Chinese literary criticism.
The Modernized Representation Of Chinese Classical Literature In Taiwan Modern Poetry, Sheng Wu
The Modernized Representation Of Chinese Classical Literature In Taiwan Modern Poetry, Sheng Wu
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Many Taiwanese modern poets have made enlightening explorations in their poems through their incorporating Chinese national features to reflect national spirits and traditional cultures. In the modernized representation of classical literature, modern consciousness and techniques are employed to represent historical figures, classical texts and traditional themes. This paper discusses from three perspectives how modernized representation is realized: how historical figures and contemporary characters are brought into the same one space-time; how classical works are extended and recreated to integrate with contemporary texts to form inter-text; how the traditional themes are endowed with modern consciousness or are explored using modern techniques.
The Name And Nature Of The Psychology Of Art: An Exploration Of Interdisciplinary Studies Of Literature Since 1976, Fengjie Liu
The Name And Nature Of The Psychology Of Art: An Exploration Of Interdisciplinary Studies Of Literature Since 1976, Fengjie Liu
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
The disciplinary formation of psychology of art in China experienced three phases in terms of its name and nature, and two approaches have emerged with one from the psychological perspective and the other from literary perspective. The psychological perspective takes the relation between psychology and literary art as a psychological phenomenon, while the literary perspective takes it as a literary one. This paper tries to argue for a discipline to study the psychology of literary art and establish a subject boundary of the discipline. It argues that the limits of psychology in literary studies has to be recognized and that …
The Sound Of The Study Of "Literature": A Survey Of Issues Of Sound In Ancient Liteary Texts And Studies On Texts, Yinchi Chen
The Sound Of The Study Of "Literature": A Survey Of Issues Of Sound In Ancient Liteary Texts And Studies On Texts, Yinchi Chen
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Literature develops from the oral to the written, and ancient texts were not only written for silent study reading but also for sound interpretive reading. The paper exemplifies the different aspects of sound in Chinese classical literary texts, with particular attention to Tongcheng School's investigations into the sound issues in Qing Dynasty. The paper proceeds to delineate the possible relations between the sound issues in prose and in verse, and hopes to provide an example to the interplay between genres.
Thus Have I Heard: The Auditory Hallucination Poems Of Miyazawa Kenji, Jon P. Holt
Thus Have I Heard: The Auditory Hallucination Poems Of Miyazawa Kenji, Jon P. Holt
World Languages and Literatures Faculty Publications and Presentations
This presentation examines the works of writer Miyazawa Kenji (1896-1933).
Live Confucian: The Newsletter Of The Confucius Institute Of Pace University September 2012, Confucius Institute Pace University
Live Confucian: The Newsletter Of The Confucius Institute Of Pace University September 2012, Confucius Institute Pace University
Live Confucian
A newsletter of the Confucius Institute, Pace University.
The Confucius Institute at Pace University is dedicated to providing Chinese language and cultural education, resources,and services to meet the needs of people from all backgrounds.
Is China A Responsible Developing Country? Climate Change Diplomacy And National Image Building, Sanna Kopra
Is China A Responsible Developing Country? Climate Change Diplomacy And National Image Building, Sanna Kopra
Global Asia Journal
A state’s image is an important resource for wielding national power in global politics. Its prestige and reputation often influence the interactions with other states. As an emerging superpower, China is under pressure to shoulder more responsibility for tackling global climate change. The West has criticized China as a “climate criminal” that threatens global climate stability. In response, the Chinese government implemented a series of comprehensive programs to improve its image abroad. This paper examines China’s national image building in the realm of international climate politics. It draws on the official rhetoric and policy statements to discuss the innovative strategies …
'Land Of Kami, Land Of The Dead': Paligenesis And The Aesthetics Of Religious Revisionism In Kobayashi Yoshinori's 'On Yasukuni', James Mark Shields
'Land Of Kami, Land Of The Dead': Paligenesis And The Aesthetics Of Religious Revisionism In Kobayashi Yoshinori's 'On Yasukuni', James Mark Shields
Faculty Contributions to Books
In 2005, Japanese manga artist and conservative provocateur Kobayashi Yoshinori published a graphic work entitled Shin gōmanizumu sengen special: Yasukuniron (Neo-Gōmanism Manifesto Special: On Yasukuni), which tackles the much-debated ‘problem’ of Yasukuni Shrine, the militaristic religious complex that has become a lightning-rod for debates regarding Japanese historical memory – especially with regard to the military expansionism in East Asia that led to the Asia-Pacific War (1931–45). Frequently overlooked in discussions of Yasukuni, however, are a number of complex issues related to its religious doctrines – in particular, the interpretation of Shinto presented at Yasukuni and the dominant ideology of Japan’s …
Review: Hank Glassman, The Face Of Jizō: Image And Cult In Medieval Japanese Buddhism., James Mark Shields
Review: Hank Glassman, The Face Of Jizō: Image And Cult In Medieval Japanese Buddhism., James Mark Shields
Other Faculty Research and Publications
Review of Hank Glassman, The Face of Jizō: Image and Cult in Medieval Japanese Buddhism.
Reforming The Chinese Sports System: A Case Study Of The Hebei Provincial Tennis Team - The Perspective And Analysis Of A Foreigner Working In The System, Matthew Bryan Haugen
Reforming The Chinese Sports System: A Case Study Of The Hebei Provincial Tennis Team - The Perspective And Analysis Of A Foreigner Working In The System, Matthew Bryan Haugen
Boise State University Theses and Dissertations
This thesis is a case study of the Hebei tennis program, which works under the auspices of the Chinese governmental sports system. The research is intended to take the reader on a chronological journey through the Chinese sports system, beginning with the infrastructure of the program, the identification and selection process of players, the methodology of education, training, and competition, the benefits and hardships, and its future as a state-controlled entity.
It is a multidisciplinary thesis that uses the Hebei tennis program and my job as the head coach to provide analysis and perspective of daily life in the Chinese …
From "God From Lofty Mountains" To "God From Shaman Dance": Natural Aesthetics In Pre-Qin Dynasty, Shilun Zhong
From "God From Lofty Mountains" To "God From Shaman Dance": Natural Aesthetics In Pre-Qin Dynasty, Shilun Zhong
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Natural aesthetics in the pre-Qin period (before 221-207 B.C.) is a blend of elements from religion, ethic, art and witchcraft. The idea of "God from lofty mountains" reflects the worship of nature underlined by natural moral law. Human beings feel the overpowering awe of lofty mountains, and the feeling of awe transforms into the sublimity of ethics and morality in the society. "God from lofty mountains" represents people‘s desire and belief in the West Zhou period in their efforts to discover the rules of social development in the nature, but human's value is obscured in the combination between the essence …
Three Arguments Relating The Study Of Ci-Poetry, Zhongyi Xia
Three Arguments Relating The Study Of Ci-Poetry, Zhongyi Xia
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Chinese ci-poetry as a different poetic form from shi-poetry has its distinctive aesthetic characteristics and a unique pattern of stylistic innovation. A full understanding of this claim is essential to a historical analysis and evaluation of the theorectical commentaries on ci-poetry from the ancient famous scholars. The famous claim that ci-poetry is but shi-poetry set to music can be investigated from the perspective of "verifying the music from the lyrics," and its legitimacy lies on the one hand in the aesthetic sentiments and the life-disposition complexity in lyrics-music complex and on the other hand in various anthologies, commentaries, reading notes …
"Poetry-Rituals-Happiness" In Chinese Thought And Aesthetics As A Discipline, Chengwan Lao, Meng Qi
"Poetry-Rituals-Happiness" In Chinese Thought And Aesthetics As A Discipline, Chengwan Lao, Meng Qi
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Aesthetics as a discipline was constructed under the system of Western philosophy,and then introduced into Chinese intellectual field. In terms of conceptualization of ideas,perhpas the concept of "happiness (le)" can be understood as equivalent to the Western concept of aesthetics. Aesthetics as a discinple in opposition to logic was established by Baumgarten,but its origin was rooted in Plato's concept of "beauty" and Aristotle's "form" in the four-cause elements. Western culture has a materialistic pursuit which emphasizes the essense of the objects as the expression of intuition of existence, and this pursuit in the form of rigorous examination of objects shows …
Encountering The World, Brown Marshall, Yin Bai
Encountering The World, Brown Marshall, Yin Bai
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
David Damrosch's writings on world literature envision readers "making themselves at home abroad." This essay argues against his Thoreauvian optimism, given a world that is too large to grasp or to become a home. World literature cannot be naturalized. Drawing on examples from Leibniz, Achebe, Walcott, and Petrarch, the essay proposes that world literature is best identified in terms not of the value of authors and works, nor of the situations portrayed through the characters and plots, but of the nature of the readerly experience. It examines the style of representation in world literature, which Brian Lennon's book In Babel's …
Raymond Williams And His Contrapuntal Reading Of Literary Representations, Weihua He
Raymond Williams And His Contrapuntal Reading Of Literary Representations, Weihua He
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
As two of the most fundamental spaces for inhabitation, "the country" and "the city", together with the life dramas with them as the background, are central themes of literary representation. Writers tend to celebrate the country because of its association with the peaceful pastoral life; on the other hand, the city, which stands for a secular and depraved way of life, becomes a sinister place in numerous literary works. People have taken these associations in literary representations for granted, forgetting that they are actually ideological constructions. In The Country and the City, Raymond Williams reads such spatial repre-sentations in literary …
Adorno's Aesthetic Reason And The Intellectual Dimension Of Aesthetic Critique: A Contemporary Approach To The Critique Of Enlightenment Rationality, Xia Zhao
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Aesthetic reason is as a key concept in Adorno's aesthetic thinking and belongs to the fundamental category in the aes-thetic modernity tradition. Adorno's idea of aesthetic reason leads to both the undermining and reconstructing of its original conception, and it aims to propose an approach to the redemption of the Enlightenment rationality through unique aesthetic reflection. While initiating a radical project for aesthetic redemption, Adorno's idea reveals the intellectual dimension of aesthetic critique of modernity, which, in today's rethinking of the post-modern discourse and exploration into the revival of Enlightenment spirit, offers vital clues for interpreting certain aesthetic phenomena and …
Globalization And The Culture Of Tourism: A Complex Connectivity From The Postmodern Perspective, Jing Yang
Globalization And The Culture Of Tourism: A Complex Connectivity From The Postmodern Perspective, Jing Yang
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
From the perspective of globalization,the representation of "connectivity" shows in the essence and extension of expanding tourism culture, and it constantly changes in response to the changes in the cultural dimension of globalization. An exploration into the process of connectivity will reveal the role of culture in intricate network of contacts. The ways by which globalization and the culture of tourism connect to culture are different, and both may promote people's national identification and personal cultural accomplishment. The paper hopes to expand the horizon of the cultural dimension of globalization through its topical focus and point out some practical significance …
ShouldCi-Poems Be Included InComplete Tang Poems, Yufeng Xie
ShouldCi-Poems Be Included InComplete Tang Poems, Yufeng Xie
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Ideally speaking, the compilation of Complete Tang and Five Dynasties Shi-Poems could have been done in parallel with that of Complete Tang and Five Dynasties Ci-Poems, so that all the rhymed literature could be collected. However, such an endeavor requires an operational distinction between shi-poem and ci-poem. The common understanding to the distinction between them is built on the musical style or yanlue, but due to the scarcity of music data of Tang and Five Dynasties, it is hard to deny subjectivity and random in practice when distinguishing between shi-poems and ci-poems. The result is that very often shi-poems go …
Investigating The Connotations Of The Genre Of Paixie In Ancient Chinese Poetry, Yi Wang
Investigating The Connotations Of The Genre Of Paixie In Ancient Chinese Poetry, Yi Wang
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
This paper analyzes and delineates the different definitions of Paixie as a literary genre through examining the critical and creative works (mainly poetry) from ancient Chinese literature. Through tracing the original connotation of Paixie and examining the various definitions from later periods, the paper points out that paixie as a genre not only refers to the entertaining forms such as satires and parodies with high-brow and low-brow styles but also includes miscellaneous writing of varied forms and playful writings such as palindromes or names of herbs. From the works by such famous and refined poets as Du Fu, it can …
Literary Theory Today, Culler Jonathan
Literary Theory Today, Culler Jonathan
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
No abstract provided.
Reappraisal Of The Aesthetic Thoughts Of Giambattista Vico, Liyuan Zhu, Ming Li
Reappraisal Of The Aesthetic Thoughts Of Giambattista Vico, Liyuan Zhu, Ming Li
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
In Chinese academia, the research into the aesthetics of Giambattista Vico has not been well developed after Zhu Guangqian's inaugural exploration. This paper tries to investigate the following problems. What has restricted the further exploration into Vico's aesthetics? Is it reasonable to regard Vico as a theorist of aesthetics with his own original aesthetic thoughts, while he was generally considered as a historical philosopher and a jurist? Our further probe into Vico's thoughts leads us to the belief that "perception" lies at the foundation of Vico's aesthetics. The discussion of "perception" and "poetic wisdom" is the most important part of …
Aesthetic Analogy Between The Human Being And The Nature FromThe Book Of Poetry And Li Sao ToA New Account Of Tales Of The World, Jun Zhang
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Two modes of aesthetic analogy developed in The Book of Poetry and Li Sao are "analogy between human virtues and things" and "analogy between human beings and things." These two modes are similar in their tenors and vehicles, and share the same structure, and they are built on the analogy between the beauty of character and the beauty of nature. The aesthetic thought exhibits an unification between the heaven and the human being. However, the paper argues that the two modes essentially follow two different princiles in aesthetics with different cultural spirits. The analogy betwen virtues and things is a …
Experience And History: Hoggart'sThe Uses Of Literacy, Xiangyu Cheng
Experience And History: Hoggart'sThe Uses Of Literacy, Xiangyu Cheng
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Richard Hoggart's The Uses of Literacy is generally taken to be an initiation of English cultural studies, and it also became one of the starting points of the "cultural controversy" emerged from the "first" New Left. The focal issues include whether Hoggart and this work fall under Leavisism, and what historical situation his work was born, but the historical specificities and implications have not been given due examination so that the research literature on Hoggart has fallen into an either-or cycle. The paper takes into consideration the historial background of Hoggart's The Uses of Literary and reveals the historical specificities …
Fiction As Illocutionary Act: John Searle's Theory Of Fiction, Qing Feng
Fiction As Illocutionary Act: John Searle's Theory Of Fiction, Qing Feng
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
According to John R. Searle's Speech Act Theory, fiction assumes to be real illocutionary acts and Searle claims that fictional discourses imitate and parasitize on ordinary discourses. Gregory Currie and Gérard Genette criticize Searle's arguments and revise his theory of fiction. This paper contents that Searle's theory of fiction can prove to be a humanist philosophical perspective that emphasizes on the author's intentions, meanings of utterances and the context. The paper proceeds to argue that further research on the essential features of fiction can be done on the basis of investigating the merits and demerits of Searle's theory.
On "Real Author" And "Implied Author", Yuyu Liu, Yanni Lei
On "Real Author" And "Implied Author", Yuyu Liu, Yanni Lei
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Ever since its proposition by Wayne Booth,the concept of "implied author" has been drawing constant attention amongliterary critics. The term has been attributed different, and even competing, meanings, including "the second self" of the real author and the assumed image of the author inferred purely from the text. This paper on the one hand argues that the implied author is neither the conscious creation of the real author nor his/her second self. On the other hand, the paper attempts to propose a more possible interpretation for the"implied author," based on a derivation and revision of Eco's theory of textual interpretation. …
Potential Of Poetic Dialogue: Guo Xiangzheng's Innovative Appropriation Of Li Bai, Tingting Zhao
Potential Of Poetic Dialogue: Guo Xiangzheng's Innovative Appropriation Of Li Bai, Tingting Zhao
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
Guo Xiangzheng (1035-1113) was a prolific poet of the Song Dynasty who was hailed as a protege of poetry and whose incredible imagination resembled that of Li Bai. Unfortunately,many literary scholars have oversimplified Guo's work as a mere derivative of Li Bai's. This paper intends to renew scholarly interest in Guo's poetry by illustrating his innovation and sophistication in utilizing Li Bai's poems and style. Through his use of different poetic devices, Guo creates varied dialogues with his audience across a broad span of time in order to achieve political and personal purposes. During his years between nineteen and twenty-six, …
The Evil Of Rhetoric: A Critique Of Augustine's Criticism On Rhetoric In Confessions, Xiaobai Chu
The Evil Of Rhetoric: A Critique Of Augustine's Criticism On Rhetoric In Confessions, Xiaobai Chu
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
The classical rhetors, from Gorgias to Cicero, all considered that the rhetoric can create a refined community through the use of philosophical truth. However, St. Augustine denied this optimistic view. This paper tries to analyze what St. Augustine saw as the evil of rhetoric and examines his interpretations of the consciousness of community formed by rhetoric.
The Transformation Of The Self-Congnitive Mechanism In The Left-Wing Intellectuals After The 1927 Revolution, Guanghai Zhang
The Transformation Of The Self-Congnitive Mechanism In The Left-Wing Intellectuals After The 1927 Revolution, Guanghai Zhang
Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art
With the rapid emergence of the petty bourgeoise ideology following the failure of the Great Revolution in 1927, left-wing Chinese intellectuals were widely engaged into debate and reflection on issues about the petty bourgeoisie. The movement was on the one hand rooted theoretically on Marxist theory and on the other hand originated from the reflection over the failure of the 1927 Revolution, while at the same time it was swayed by CCP's class policy. Petty bourgeoisie's revolutionary potential came to be under question following the failure of the 1927 Revolution, and its original sin was overemphasized. However, differences existed among …