Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Teacher Education and Professional Development Commons™
Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Curriculum and Instruction (7529)
- Higher Education (6826)
- Higher Education and Teaching (6475)
- Educational Administration and Supervision (4775)
- Educational Assessment, Evaluation, and Research (4077)
-
- Educational Methods (3836)
- Educational Leadership (3783)
- Elementary Education and Teaching (3456)
- Science and Mathematics Education (3128)
- Secondary Education and Teaching (2856)
- Arts and Humanities (2795)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (2760)
- Junior High, Intermediate, Middle School Education and Teaching (2543)
- Other Teacher Education and Professional Development (2305)
- Other Education (2295)
- Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (2031)
- Higher Education Administration (1913)
- Pre-Elementary, Early Childhood, Kindergarten Teacher Education (1736)
- Educational Psychology (1621)
- Bilingual, Multilingual, and Multicultural Education (1598)
- Physical Sciences and Mathematics (1572)
- Special Education and Teaching (1474)
- Online and Distance Education (1368)
- Disability and Equity in Education (1362)
- Elementary Education (1342)
- Curriculum and Social Inquiry (1262)
- Secondary Education (1238)
- Adult and Continuing Education and Teaching (1230)
- Institution
-
- University of Nebraska - Lincoln (2070)
- Edith Cowan University (1368)
- Walden University (1265)
- Taylor University (847)
- Nova Southeastern University (804)
-
- Fort Hays State University (750)
- Western Michigan University (571)
- Virginia Commonwealth University (542)
- University of South Florida (537)
- University of New Mexico (529)
- Utah State University (491)
- Central Washington University (488)
- Bryn Mawr College (449)
- Eastern Illinois University (444)
- Illinois Math and Science Academy (417)
- University of Tennessee, Knoxville (417)
- Aga Khan University (413)
- Western Kentucky University (387)
- Georgia Southern University (380)
- Rowan University (379)
- Morehead State University (368)
- Universitas Negeri Malang (349)
- Australian Council for Educational Research (ACER) (345)
- SIT Graduate Institute/SIT Study Abroad (338)
- California State University, San Bernardino (328)
- University of Nevada, Las Vegas (297)
- City University of New York (CUNY) (295)
- Old Dominion University (291)
- Illinois State University (288)
- Coastal Carolina University (279)
- Keyword
-
- Education (1867)
- Teacher education (925)
- Professional development (832)
- Higher education (617)
- Teaching (513)
-
- Teachers (374)
- Leadership (373)
- Teacher Education (318)
- Technology (303)
- Literacy (294)
- Pedagogy (281)
- Teacher preparation (267)
- Collaboration (258)
- Mathematics (256)
- Assessment (245)
- Professional Development (238)
- Curriculum (229)
- Self-efficacy (226)
- Mentoring (215)
- Child Nutrition (201)
- Diversity (198)
- Elementary education (194)
- Reading (194)
- Equity (188)
- STEM (184)
- Writing (184)
- Preservice teachers (178)
- Teacher training (177)
- Learning (175)
- Middle school (175)
- Publication Year
- Publication
-
- Australian Journal of Teacher Education (1185)
- Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies (1146)
- Dissertations (779)
- Theses and Dissertations (770)
- Academic Leadership: The Online Journal (2003-2012) (723)
-
- To Improve the Academy: A Journal of Educational Development (500)
- Teacher Education, Educational Leadership & Policy ETDs (497)
- Department of Teaching, Learning, and Teacher Education: Faculty Publications (482)
- Electronic Theses and Dissertations (446)
- Teaching and Learning Together in Higher Education (431)
- Journal of Mathematics and Science: Collaborative Explorations (422)
- USF Tampa Graduate Theses and Dissertations (401)
- The Journal of the Assembly for Expanded Perspectives on Learning (400)
- Professional Learning Day (367)
- Abraham S. Fischler College of Education and School of Criminal Justice College Archive (360)
- Jurnal Pendidikan: Teori, Penelitian, dan Pengembangan (327)
- All Master's Theses (311)
- Growth: The Journal of the Association for Christians in Student Development (283)
- Research Days (279)
- MA TESOL Collection (273)
- UNL Faculty Course Portfolios (261)
- Teacher Education Journal of South Carolina (249)
- Faculty Research at Morehead State University (242)
- Seton Hall University Dissertations and Theses (ETDs) (230)
- Masters Theses (215)
- Professional and Organizational Development Network in Higher Education: Archives (206)
- Oral History Project (all interviews) (203)
- Institute for Educational Development, Karachi (193)
- The Councilor: A National Journal of the Social Studies (185)
- Doctoral Dissertations and Projects (182)
- Publication Type
Articles 991 - 1020 of 29309
Full-Text Articles in Teacher Education and Professional Development
Limbic Encephalitis, Children's Health School Services
Limbic Encephalitis, Children's Health School Services
School Guides
Educator guide about how to support students with limbic encephalitis.
Leukemia, Children's Health School Services
Leukemia, Children's Health School Services
School Guides
Educator guide about how to support students with leukemia.
Lupus, Children's Health School Services
Lupus, Children's Health School Services
School Guides
Educator guide about how to support students with lupus.
Lymphoma, Children's Health School Services
Lymphoma, Children's Health School Services
School Guides
Educator guide about how to support students with lymphoma.
Major Depressive Disorder, Children's Health School Services
Major Depressive Disorder, Children's Health School Services
School Guides
Educator guide about how to support students with major depressive disorder.
Inflammatory Bowel Disease, Children's Health School Services
Inflammatory Bowel Disease, Children's Health School Services
School Guides
Educator guide about how to support students with inflammatory bowel disease.
Functional Neurological Disorder, Children's Health School Services
Functional Neurological Disorder, Children's Health School Services
School Guides
Educator guide about how to support students with functional neurological disorder.
Data Culture's Influence On Instructional Change And Continuous School Improvement, Sara Guth
Data Culture's Influence On Instructional Change And Continuous School Improvement, Sara Guth
Theses, Dissertations and Capstones
The use of data for decision making and taking an evidence-based approach to instruction has been the gold standard for schools and their continuous improvement efforts for many years in elementary education. The system of military-connected schools is no different. This unique system has taken steps to support the development of a data culture in its schools to include providing clear guidance in its Blueprint for Continuous Improvement, designating weekly release time for students so that educators may engage in Focused Collaboration time, and designing structures and resources to support teams with this practice such as the Focused Collaboration …
Perceptions And Practices Of Incorporating Student-Centered Menu Items In School Meals, Kristi L. Lewis Phd, Rdn
Perceptions And Practices Of Incorporating Student-Centered Menu Items In School Meals, Kristi L. Lewis Phd, Rdn
Institute of Child Nutrition, Applied Research Division
Student-centered menu planning prioritizes learners’ preferences, nutritional needs, cultural relevance, and engagement in the development of school nutrition program offerings. Menus that reflect student preferences and incorporate student input are associated with increased meal participation and consumption. This study examined school nutrition professionals’ perceptions, best practices, and strategies for incorporating students’ voices into school-based menu planning and modification.
Using a participatory research approach, school nutrition professionals, administrators, United States Department of Agriculture Food and Nutrition Service representatives, and State agency staff participated as expert panelists and survey respondents. A literature review and qualitative expert panel responses informed the development of …
Meeting The Challenges Of Serving Scratch-Prepared Foods In School Nutrition Programs, Keith Rushing Phd, Rd, Ruaa Al Juboori Phd, Mackinsey Shahan Phd, Rdn
Meeting The Challenges Of Serving Scratch-Prepared Foods In School Nutrition Programs, Keith Rushing Phd, Rd, Ruaa Al Juboori Phd, Mackinsey Shahan Phd, Rdn
Institute of Child Nutrition, Applied Research Division
The increasing prevalence of ultra-processed foods (UPFs) in children’s diets presents a significant public health concern due to associations with obesity, metabolic disorders, poor cardiometabolic health, and reduced academic performance. Scratch cooking in school meal programs has emerged as a promising strategy for improving meal quality by emphasizing preparation from basic, minimally processed ingredients. Although research indicates that scratch-prepared meals can improve nutritional quality and student acceptance, implementation remains challenging due to operational, financial, and workforce barriers.
The purpose of this study was to identify challenges school nutrition professionals face when offering scratch-prepared meals, assess the national prevalence of these …
Mentoring Dispositions To Support Pre-Service Teacher Development, Bailey Bontrager, Jesse Senechal
Mentoring Dispositions To Support Pre-Service Teacher Development, Bailey Bontrager, Jesse Senechal
ICRE Publications
The quality of pre-service teacher mentoring depends not only on program structures but on the dispositions mentors bring to the relationship. This practice brief presents a framework of three mentor dispositions (collaborative, supportive, and flexible/open) that support positive experiences for pre-service teachers during field placements. The framework was developed through a systematic review of Teacher Residency Program (TRP) literature and informed by interviews with pre-service teachers in a local TRP. For each disposition, the brief identifies specific mentor actions and illustrates them through the voices of pre-service teachers describing their experiences as mentees. The brief concludes with recommendations for applying …
Crossing Borders For Transformative Professional Learning About Health And Physical Education Policy Through The Policy Process Case Method, Jenna R. Lorusso, Kellie Baker, Chris Clark, Muhammad Jafar, Dylan Scanlon, Laura Alfrey, David Aldous
Crossing Borders For Transformative Professional Learning About Health And Physical Education Policy Through The Policy Process Case Method, Jenna R. Lorusso, Kellie Baker, Chris Clark, Muhammad Jafar, Dylan Scanlon, Laura Alfrey, David Aldous
Research outputs 2022 to 2026
The Policy Process Case Method (PPCM) is a recent innovation for (health and physical) education professionals to transform their complex policy experiences into practical insights. This method engages professionals across roles and geographical borders in sustained reflexive dialogue to collaboratively interrogate their policy experiences through policy theories. In this ∼1.5-year PPCM investigation, our group (i.e. two curriculum officers, one department head, and one researcher, from four nations) engaged in the following process. First, each practitioner shared a policy experience, including advocating for school policy change, developing provincial/state curricula, and implementing provincial/state curricula. The researcher identified relevant policy theories through which …
Supporting Risky Outdoor Play Through Professional Development: A Quasi-Experimental Study Of Tk–6 Educators’ Attitudes, Justin Ross Burrill
Supporting Risky Outdoor Play Through Professional Development: A Quasi-Experimental Study Of Tk–6 Educators’ Attitudes, Justin Ross Burrill
Cal Poly Humboldt theses and projects
Children’s opportunities for active outdoor risky play have declined in many educational settings, despite evidence that manageable risk supports physical activity, self-regulation, confidence, resilience, and social participation. Educator attitudes and school culture may play an important role in determining whether children are offered developmentally appropriate opportunities for challenge, exploration, and autonomy. This quasi-experimental, single-group pretest-posttest study examined whether participation in a single-session professional development workshop was associated with changes in educators’ tolerance of risk in children’s play. Thirty educators attended a workshop focused on risky play, hazard-risk differentiation, inclusion of children with disabilities, loose-parts play, environmental affordances, and practitioner-informed implementation …
An Evaluation Of Aquatic Interventions To Support Increased Physical Fitness Levels For Children With Cerebral Palsy, Grace Kasberger
An Evaluation Of Aquatic Interventions To Support Increased Physical Fitness Levels For Children With Cerebral Palsy, Grace Kasberger
Cal Poly Humboldt theses and projects
This study was designed to determine the most appropriate aquatic interventions to best improve physical fitness levels in children with cerebral palsy (CP). Children with CP often experience reduced aerobic capacity, muscular strength, and functional mobility, which can limit participation in traditional land-based physical activities such as walking and playing. Aquatic environments provide safe and resistance-based environments that can reduce joint loading, spasticity, and provide training. This systematic review examined a variety of different aquatic interventions (e.g. HIIT, aerobic based, strength training, flexibility, and the Halliwick Method) to improve physical fitness in children with CP. Data collection focused on outcomes …
Teachers’ Ethical Decision-Making Under Constraint: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis Of Professional Risk, Aaron A. Baker
Teachers’ Ethical Decision-Making Under Constraint: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis Of Professional Risk, Aaron A. Baker
Faculty Publications - College of Education
Ethical dilemmas are a routine feature of teaching in diverse and politically contested school contexts. Drawing on interpretative phenomenological analysis of interviews with seven experienced teachers, this study examines how ethical judgment is lived in practice. Participants rarely struggled to determine what was right; instead, they described tension between moral clarity and limited capacity to act amid institutional constraint, perceived risk, and prior consequences. These conditions shaped what actions felt professionally viable. Teachers responded by managing relationships, regulating emotion, and adapting to context while balancing care and risk. The findings specify how constraint operates within ethical judgment itself, shaping what …
Reading The Birds: Critical, Multimodal, And Queer Meaning-Making In Literacy Teacher Education, Kris Benefield
Reading The Birds: Critical, Multimodal, And Queer Meaning-Making In Literacy Teacher Education, Kris Benefield
CGU Theses & Dissertations
This qualitative dissertation explores critical, multimodal, and queer literacies and related pedagogies in teacher education. In it, I engage in both critical analysis and theorizing at the intersection of teacher education, literacy, and pedagogy, producing insights and tools that may be of use to teachers, teacher-educators, and researchers interested in resisting oppression in and through literacy and composition education. The findings contribute to the research on literacy teacher education by detailing the situated processes involved in both critical meaning-making and pedagogical enactment among a group of K-12 teachers in and beyond two literacy methods courses. I draw on thematic analysis …
The Effect Of Occupational Roles, Burnout, And Efficacy On Job Satisfaction Among K-12 Teachers, Chloe Schwahn
The Effect Of Occupational Roles, Burnout, And Efficacy On Job Satisfaction Among K-12 Teachers, Chloe Schwahn
Masters Theses
The aim of this study was to investigate variables that may impact the ratings of job satisfaction by practicing Illinois K-12 teachers specifically examining if the variables of occupational roles, burnout, efficacy, and other relevant covariates are correlated and/or have predictive utility on teacher job satisfaction. A secondary goal was to raise awareness about the stressors teachers face in their work environments. Survey materials included a demographics questionnaire, an occupational roles catalog, the Copenhagen Burnout Inventory, the Teacher Sense of Efficacy Scale, and the Teacher Job Satisfaction Scale. Seventy-six practicing Illinois K-12 teachers completed the study. Results of the current …
Teachers' Perceptions And Professional Uses Of Artificial Intelligence In Education, Lexie Coartney
Teachers' Perceptions And Professional Uses Of Artificial Intelligence In Education, Lexie Coartney
Masters Theses
This study explores Illinois teachers’ perceptions and professional uses of artificial intelligence (AI) in education. A mixed methods approach was implemented, including a survey completed by 137 Illinois teachers and four interviews. The research questions examined teachers' perceptions of AI, their professional use of AI, and their approach to students’ use of AI. Findings concluded that participants generally hold positive perceptions of AI, especially its time-saving abilities and being supportive, while also holding concerns including reliability, accuracy, and ethical issues. Results showed that 77% (n = 106) of teachers use AI tools mostly for lesson planning, creating assessments, differentiation, …
Career Readiness Indicators In High School Influenced By Leaders In Alabama, Kevin J. Wieseman
Career Readiness Indicators In High School Influenced By Leaders In Alabama, Kevin J. Wieseman
Murray State Theses and Dissertations
This phenomenological study investigated how educational leaders conceptualize and influence Career Readiness Indicators (CRI) in Alabama high schools. As Alabama places increasing emphasis on College and Career Readiness (CCR), this research explored how leaders’ lived experiences affect initiatives designed to prepare students for postsecondary achievement. Drawing on Transformational Leadership Theory and Distributed Leadership Theory, the study examined leadership practices associated with work-based learning, soft skills development, academic preparedness, and career-readiness outcomes. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with educational leaders from Alabama school systems recognized for exemplary CCR performance. Data were analyzed using a phenomenological approach to identify shared leadership experiences and …
International Teacher Attrition: A Qualitative Meta-Synthesis Through The Job Demands-Resources Framework, Lakeysha Rena Joseph Toliver
International Teacher Attrition: A Qualitative Meta-Synthesis Through The Job Demands-Resources Framework, Lakeysha Rena Joseph Toliver
Murray State Theses and Dissertations
Abstract
Teacher attrition has emerged as a persistent crisis for workforce sustainability across international education systems. This crisis is threatening instructional continuity and deepening inequities that extend across the P-20 continuum. A substantial amount of research has been conducted on teacher attrition in individual countries worldwide. Isolated national studies rarely shed light on the structural patterns driving educators out of the profession, leaving policymakers without a clear cross-contextual understanding of why teachers leave. This qualitative meta-synthesis examined how the interaction between occupational demands and institutional supports shapes teacher attrition across international education contexts, using the Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) framework to …
The Role Of White Racial Identity Development In Leadership Practices: An Interpretive Phenomenological Study In White Educational Leaders, Kaitlyn Ryan
Theses and Dissertations
This qualitative study examined how white educational leaders experience and make meaning of their racial identity development as they lead adult professional learning focused on racial equity and culturally responsive practice. Grounded in Helms’s White Racial Identity Development (WRID) model and guided by Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA), the study explored the lived experiences of ten white leaders across PK–12 and Institution of Higher Education (IHE). Data were collected through three semi‑structured interviews per participant and analyzed using IPA’s six‑step process. Five major themes emerged: transformational experiences that shifted leaders’ understanding of race and privilege; the critical role of white affinity …
Digital Learning For English Learners: A Selected Annotated Bibliography For English Learner Research, Policy, And Practice, Center For Equity For English Learners
Digital Learning For English Learners: A Selected Annotated Bibliography For English Learner Research, Policy, And Practice, Center For Equity For English Learners
Annotated Bibliographies
Digital Learning for English Learners: A Selected Annotated Bibliography for English Learner Research, Policy, and Practice is comprised of 17 annotations from recent and seminal literature regarding digital learning resources for English Learners (ELs) and Multilingual Learners (MLs). These annotations build on the annotations regarding digital learning in CEEL’s 2022 annotated bibliography, Ensuring Equity and Excellence for English Learners: An Annotated Bibliography for Research, Policy, and Practice (Center for Equity for English Learners, 2022) to include publications from 2022-2025. This selected annotated bibliography serves as a resource for researchers, policymakers, educators, and advocates who are working for equity and …
What Kids Have To Say About Math: Results From Focus Groups With Middle Schoolers, H. Colleen Sinclair, Kyle Wilson, Avery Ellis, Norma Martinez
What Kids Have To Say About Math: Results From Focus Groups With Middle Schoolers, H. Colleen Sinclair, Kyle Wilson, Avery Ellis, Norma Martinez
Reports
Middle school mathematics achievement remains a critical concern in Louisiana. Despite notable recent gains in recovery and signs of resilience, students continue to perform below national averages (ranking 38th in the country). To better understand the factors that support or hinder student success, this report presents findings from six student focus groups conducted in spring 2025 with 39 middle school students at two urban schools in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. The goal was to elevate students’ voices regarding their motivation, anxiety, classroom experiences, and ideas for improving math instruction. Overall, students expressed generally positive feelings toward math, and notably, a strong …
Examining Explicit Professional Development As A Means To Change Inclusive Mindsets, Mitchell E. Elatkin
Examining Explicit Professional Development As A Means To Change Inclusive Mindsets, Mitchell E. Elatkin
Theses and Dissertations
Inclusive education requires educators to hold beliefs that support the participation and success of students with disabilities in general education settings. Although federal policy mandates access to the least restrictive environment, educator attitudes toward inclusion continue to influence the implementation of inclusive practices. The purpose of this mixed-methods study was to examine whether explicit professional development (PD) focused on inclusive mindsets influenced school stakeholders’ attitudes toward inclusion across a school year. Participants included representatives from various roles within a charter school organization in the Midwest. The researcher collected data through two administrations of the Adapted Teacher Attitudes Toward Inclusion Survey …
Understanding Interculturality And Enacting Culturally Based Pedagogies: A Mixed Methods Study Of In-Service World Language Educators In Secondary Classrooms, Heather L. Sandy
Understanding Interculturality And Enacting Culturally Based Pedagogies: A Mixed Methods Study Of In-Service World Language Educators In Secondary Classrooms, Heather L. Sandy
Theses and Dissertations
This research study explored the relationship between an understanding of interculturality and culturally based pedagogies among world language teachers. The study examined the relationship between language teachers’ upbringing, their development of intercultural competence, and their self-efficacy in culturally responsive teaching practices. It addressed a practical knowledge gap concerning the intersection of interculturality and culturally based practices, specifically among secondary education teachers of Spanish and Mandarin Chinese in the United States.
The data sources focused on the qualitative aspects of interculturality, culturally based teaching practices, and world language pedagogy, with quantitative results to enhance qualitative data. The qualitative data collection included …
Hidden Gems Of Clay County: “Snap + Say Something” Inquiry Protocol, David Wolff
Hidden Gems Of Clay County: “Snap + Say Something” Inquiry Protocol, David Wolff
OER Materials
The goal of this assignment was to design an immersive, place‑based learning experience that helps preservice teachers engage with primary sources connected to the history and culture of Clay County, Minnesota. In collaboration with the Historical and Cultural Society of Clay County, preservice teachers visited the Hjemkomst Center and used autophotography to document artifacts, exhibits, and moments that helped them understand what makes Moorhead and the wider Clay County community a unique and meaningful place. Alongside their photographs, they wrote reflections explaining why each image captures an aspect of Clay County as a “special place.” This approach is intended …
Wild Rice Life Cycle: An Integrated Science, Social Studies, And Ela Lesson, Rhett Zima, Lily Deming
Wild Rice Life Cycle: An Integrated Science, Social Studies, And Ela Lesson, Rhett Zima, Lily Deming
OER Materials
This lesson is designed to deepen students’ understanding of wild rice, a plant native to Minnesota, by integrating life science concepts such as structure, function, life cycles, and seed dispersal with prior knowledge from English Language Arts and Social Studies. Using the 5E instructional model (Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, and Evaluate), students participate in a structured, inquiry-based learning experience. They begin by connecting to prior knowledge and generating questions, then investigating the life cycle and growth patterns of wild rice through hands-on exploration. As students build their understanding, they analyze how the plant’s seed dispersal supports its survival and reproduction. …
Teacher Burnout In 2026 - Context, Student Effects, And Interventions, Colin David Thies
Teacher Burnout In 2026 - Context, Student Effects, And Interventions, Colin David Thies
All Electronic Theses and Dissertations
In order to aid teachers in 2026, this paper aims to identify what teachers and administrators can do to protect against and treat teacher burnout in K-12 schools. To achieve this, research was conducted on the post-pandemic context of teacher burnout, the secondary effects of teacher burnout on students, individual and organizational interventions. Teacher burnout is a multifaceted ailment, and many of the factors behind burnout can be beyond one’s control. There is no single answer, though there is an emphasis on emotions, as research suggests emotions may be greatly important to both succumbing to and treating teacher burnout. Thus, …
Supporting Core Instruction: A Mixed Methods Study Of Foundations Of Math Training For Elementary Teachers, Naomi C. Mallory
Supporting Core Instruction: A Mixed Methods Study Of Foundations Of Math Training For Elementary Teachers, Naomi C. Mallory
Doctor of Education Dissertations
Effective Tier 1 mathematics instruction within a Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS) depends on the teacher’s ability to implement research-based instructional practices with confidence and fidelity (Berkeley et al., 2020; Cleaver, 2023). The purpose of this study was to explore educators' perspectives on how explicit, research-based mathematics professional development influenced their perceived capacity to deliver effective core instruction. Specifically, the study explored how the Foundations of Math (FoM) professional development course affected teachers’ confidence and instructional decision-making. This study was conducted within one public school district and included elementary educators who had participated in the FoM course. Data were collected …
A Closer Look At Quality: A Mixed Methods Study On International Teachers’ Perceptions Of Educational Technology-Focused Professional Development In South Carolina, Melissa Mcclary
Doctor of Education Dissertations
Educational technology (EdTech) is widely promoted as a means of improving instruction; however, limited research has examined how international teachers are supported through EdTech-focused professional development (PD) in South Carolina (SC) schools. Using a convergent mixed methods design, this study explored international teachers' perceptions of EdTech PD quality through the lens of Desimone's (2009) core features of effective PD and Expectancy-Value Theory (EVT). Quantitative data were collected from 81 respondents using the Teacher Professional Development (TPD) Monitor Survey (Richter & Richter, 2024), complemented by 16 semi-structured interviews. Survey results indicated high overall ratings, with clarity and structure, practical relevance, and …