Economic Theory Commons^™

Inet Grant Completion, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (2012, December 9). Final grant completion report for INET grant ID #IN011-00056 and #IN012-0040 (Memorandum) (2). New School University Archives.
• Institute for New Economic Thinking. (2012, November 29). Grant award letter to Mr. Anwar Shaikh (RE: INO12-00040) (Manuscript) (3, 4). New School University Archives.
• Institute for New Economic Thinking. (2012, November 17). Grant terms and conditions agreement (Grant ID #INO12-00040) (Manuscript signed by Anwar Shaikh, PhD, with a handwritten note dated December 21, 2012) (5, 6). New School University Archives.
• Department of the Treasury, Internal Revenue Service. (2012, November 10). Request for taxpayer identification number …

Text Ch 6 Profit Capital, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (2012, February 6). Theories of profit and capital (Unpublished manuscript).
• Keynes, J. M. (1976). A treatise on money. Macmillan.
• Braham, J. (2001). Sales without profits are meaningless. Business Week.
• Marx, K. (1977). Capital: A critique of political economy (Vol. 1). Vintage Books.
• Ishikura, H. (2004). Marx's circuit of capital and Keynes's monetary theory of production. Journal of Economic Studies.
• Varian, H. L. (1993). Intermediate microeconomics: A modern approach. W. W. Norton & Company.
• Shane, S. (2008). The illusions of entrepreneurship: The costly myths that entrepreneurs, investors, and policy makers live by …

Chapter 10 Price Value Revisions, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Ch. 10: Price/value revisions. NA-24-13.

• Add survey from Jefferis (attached).

• Add survey from Jeffries (attached).

• Email from Lefteris to Anwar Shaikh regarding chapter revisions and additional empirical studies. In this message, Lefteris notes that the attachment contains a summary of empirical studies from a 2010 paper with Paitaridis and that more recent papers with Theodore are already included in the references.

• Extract from Tsoulfidis and Paitaridis, “On the labor theory of value: Statistical artefacts or regularities?” This excerpt reviews empirical studies of price-value deviations and related debates.

• References for the chapter excerpt. …

  ---

  Go to article

Competition (Misc.), Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Duménil, G., Glick, M., & Lévy, D. (1997). The history of competition policy as economic history. The Antitrust Bulletin, 42(2), 373–416. Federal Legal Publications, Inc.
• Shaikh, A. (2011, November 22). ECO 104: Competition [Handwritten lecture notes, 2 pages, on lined notepaper, dated November 22, 2011; covering competition between industries, summary of phenomena, and empirical findings on profit rates]. Anwar Shaikh, Ph.D., Department of Economics, New School for Social Research. [Unpublished teaching notes.]
• Treen, M. (2010, August 16). FW: [New post] Andrew Kliman and the "Neo-Ricardian" attack on Marxism, Pt 1 [Email forwarded to Anwar Shaikh from …

Replacement Investment, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. September 10, 1973. Gross stock and net stock project (Handwritten research notes). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research.
• Shaikh, A. September 28, 1979. Deriving current dollar stock from BLS data (Handwritten correspondence notes). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research.
• Shaikh, A. May 10, 1980. BLS data on Jack Faucett adjustments (Handwritten folder notes). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research.
• Shaikh, A. December 1, 1982. Note on retirements vs. business failure (Handwritten manuscript notes). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research. …

Trade, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Trade, compiled by Anwar Shaikh, containing working papers, lecture notes, correspondence, and handwritten research notes on international trade, exchange rates, comparative and absolute advantage, purchasing power parity, and trade balances. The materials date from 2005 through 2012 and are associated with Anwar Shaikh’s research and teaching at the New School for Social Research in New York.
• Trade classical equations, Anwar Shaikh, 2012-05-07. Unpublished manuscript.
• Classical trade theory, Anwar Shaikh, 2001-10-24, revised 2008-10-07. Unpublished manuscript.
• Competition, exchange rates, and trade balances, Anwar Shaikh, undated. Unpublished manuscript.
• Automatic trade balance is a “doctrinaire delusion”, …

Competition Red, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Classical definition of costs by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• Notes on fixed capital and joint production by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• Models of adjustment of mkt prices to POP by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• Price, marginal cost and the business cycle by Jonathan Haskel, Christopher Martin, and Ian Small
• Four themes present in the discussion of PE by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• Competition of capital mobility by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• Profit rates within industry by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• The structure of Kalecki's theory by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• Average and incremental profit rates: US and OECD by Anwar Shaikh, PhD
• Correspondence to …

Microfoundations Revisions, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. March 11, 2011. Chapter 3: microfoundations revisions (Handwritten folder notes). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research.
• Shaikh, A. December 2, 2009. What's left of microeconomics? Microfoundations and emergent macro properties (Unpublished manuscript draft). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research.
• Shaikh, A. July 4, 2012. Micro talk NSSR (Handwritten lecture notes). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research.
• Shaikh, A. December 2, 2009. Rethinking microeconomics: a proposed reconstruction (Unpublished manuscript draft). Unpublished work. New York, NY: New School for Social Research.
• Shaikh, A. December 2, …

Loose Magazines, Notes, Dissertation, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (n.d.). Turbulent dynamics in advanced societies (Unpublished manuscript table of contents) (22-16_Loos... p. 2).
• Shaikh, A. (n.d.). Turbulent dynamics and pattern recurrence: Economic analysis in a global context (Unpublished manuscript table of contents) (22-16_Loos... p. 3).
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Turbulent dynamics and hidden patterns: Economic analysis in a global context (Unpublished manuscript table of contents) (22-16_Loos... p. 4).
• Shaikh, A. (n.d.). Mathematical equation on cumulative output fractions (Unpublished manuscript note) (22-16_Loos... p. 6).
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Current summary table of contents (Unpublished manuscript table of contents) (22-16_Loos... p. 7).
• Shaikh, A. (2010). The economic analysis …

Papers Ltv, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (2011, January 16). Profit themes (Unpublished manuscript notes) (23-39_Pape... p. 4).
• Shaikh, A. (1988, November 26). Steuart & two sources of profit: History—notes on prod/unprod labor in Marx (Unpublished manuscript notes) (23-39_Pape... p. 5).
• Shaikh, A. (1992). Values and value transfers: A comment on Itoh (Unpublished manuscript) (23-39_Pape... p. 10).
• Obrinsky, M. (1983). Profit theory and capitalism. University of Pennsylvania Press (23-39_Pape... p. 39).
• Shaikh, A. (2008, February 6). Production and nonproduction labor (Unpublished manuscript notes) (23-39_Pape... p. 44).

Currant Theory, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (2011). Current theory (Handwritten note by Anwar Shaikh, PhD). New School University Archives.
• Foley, D. (2010, November 27). Re: circuiste theory (Email). New School University Archives.
• Cardim de Carvalho, F. J. (2003). Circuit theory. In J. E. King (Ed.), The Elgar companion to post Keynesian economics (pp. 60–61). Edward Elgar Publishing.
• Realfonzo, R. (2003). Circuit theory. In J. E. King (Ed.), The Elgar companion to post Keynesian economics (pp. 61–64). Edward Elgar Publishing.
• Shaikh, A. (2011, January 19). Circuitist models comments.doc (Manuscript with handwritten notes). New School University Archives.
• Shaikh, A. (2004, March 12). Comments …

General Solution To Difference Equation, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• General solution difference equation, written by Anwar Shaikh, PhD, on April 22, 2011.
• General solution to differences equation, a manuscript file folder label inscribed with the identification code NA-23-63, prepared by Anwar Shaikh, PhD, on June 5, 2026.

Class (Chapter 9), Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Chapter 9: classical, neoclassical, austrian and post keynesian views on competition, an unpublished draft book chapter prepared by Anwar Shaikh, PhD, on June 5, 2026.
• Ch 9 (class), a manuscript file folder label inscribed with the identification code NA-23-62, prepared by Anwar Shaikh, PhD, on June 5, 2026.
• Corrections and marginal notation on classical pricing and cost functions, an unpublished set of handwritten manuscript comments prepared by Anwar Shaikh, PhD, on June 5, 2026.

Godley Conference Paper, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Godley conference paper (file folder). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, manuscript in progress, 2011.
• Economic policy in a growth context. Anwar Shaikh, Macroeconomics and Growth, 2008, Palgrave Macmillan.
• Notes on New Cambridge and Ruggles (unpublished manuscript). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, May 01, 2011.
• Effect of depletion rates on KGC and KNC estimates (data analysis commentary). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, February 22, 2011.
• I have spent many a happy hour here at the Levy (handwritten notes). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, 2011.
• On Godley & KK (handwritten notes). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, 2011.
• The role of the savings rate in Godley's macroeconomics (manuscript outline). …

Reflexivity, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Reflexivity (file folder). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, manuscript in progress, 2011.
• General point (handwritten notes). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, November 2011.
• End of my talk (handwritten presentation outline). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, November 2011.
• Reflexivity and the theory and practice of social change (unpublished workshop paper). George Soros, November 03, 2011.
• Reflexivity, path dependence, and disequilibrium dynamics. Anwar Shaikh, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 2010, M.E. Sharpe, Inc.
• Mark 2: Still stable (handwritten notes). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, March 28, 2010.
• The crisis & what to do about it (web article). George Soros, November 06, 2008.
• Unrepentant (letter to the …

Chapter 11, Competition And Finance Revisions, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. Chapter 11 competition and finance revisions outline (Unpublished manuscript).
• Shaikh, A. (2012). Handwritten notes on interest rates and profit rate equalization equations (Unpublished manuscript).
• Parchure, R. A reconstruction of interest rate theory (Unpublished manuscript).

Competition Blue, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Roncaglia, A. (2006). Paolo Sylos Labini (1920-2005): A tribute. EAEPE Newsletter, (35).
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Appendix 7.1.xlsx. Unpublished manuscript.
• Dhawan, R. (2001). Firm size and productivity differential: Theory and evidence from a panel of US firms. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 44(3).
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Marx's example of a hand printing press vs. a lithograph. Unpublished manuscript.
• Shaikh, A. (2011). The writing of the Grundrisse. Unpublished manuscript.

Classical Theory Output Level, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (n.d.). Classical theory: output level (Unpublished manuscript) (22-23_Clas... p. 1).
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Output level classical theory.xlsx (Unpublished dataset) (22-23_Clas... p. 2).
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Output level in economic theories (Unpublished manuscript) (22-23_Clas... p. 5).
• Godley, W., & Shaikh, A. (2002). An important inconsistency at the heart of the standard macroeconomic model. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 24(3), 423–441. Taylor & Francis (22-23_Clas... p. 20).
• Gandolfo, G. (1985). Economic dynamics: Methods and models. North-Holland (22-23_Clas... p. 20).

Inflation, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Inflation & fluid flow analogy (file folder). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, 2011.
• Thruput NIPA and excess demand (manuscript outline). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, May 15, 2011.
• Thruput as growth limit (manuscript outline). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, May 2011.
• Lectures on the theory of production. Luigi L. Pasinetti, Columbia University Press, 1977, Columbia University Press.
• Thruput model (handwritten notes). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, February 24, 2011.
• Alberto Nan & fas: Prop defense (handwritten notes). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, February 24, 2011.
• Water flow, electrical circuit and inflation analogy (unpublished manuscript). Anwar Shaikh, PhD, May 15, 2011.
• In my inflation equation (handwritten notes). …

Chapter 6 And Chapter 8 Tables, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (2010). Chapter 6 numerical examples: Labor values, direct prices, and prices of production (Unpublished Mathcad worksheet) 
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Chapter 8 reference tables: Price equalization, profit rate disequalization, and technical choice contenders (Unpublished Excel spreadsheet)

Economic Patterns In Capitalism, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes.

• Economic patterns in capitalism fall 2011: U.S. economic charts. (2011, Fall). Unpublished document compilation.

• Shaikh, A. (2000, September). The fundamental equation of prices [Unpublished manuscript].

• Sardoni, C. (1994, December 15–17). Marx’s theory of money and interest: Between Robertson and Keynes? [Unpublished conference paper]. Karl Marx’s Third Volume of Capital: 1894–1994 Conference, University of Bergamo, Bergamo, Italy.

• Panico, C. (1988). Marx on the interest rate (Chap. 2) [Photocopy]. In Interest and profit in the theories of value and distribution. Palgrave Macmillan.

• Panico, C. (1988). Marx on the relation between interest and profit …

Inet Proposal Stage 2, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

his collection includes:

• Institute for New Economic Thinking. (2011). Standard pre-grant inquiry (PGI) form for grant #3232 (Manuscript). New School University Archives.
• Puller, N. (2011, July 11). Email correspondence regarding INET pre-grant inquiry for #3232 (Email). New School University Archives.
• Shaikh, A. (2011). Project budget for sponsor INET (Period: June 1, 2011 to August 31, 2012) (Manuscript). New School University Archives.
• Shaikh, A. (2011, April 24). Institute for New Economic Thinking proposal stage II cover letter (Manuscript). New School University Archives.
• Shaikh, A. (2011, April 14). New School institutional giving grant proposal form (Manuscript with handwritten note "Scanned & emailed"). …

Measurement Of Profit, Capital & Rop, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Ch 7: Measurement of profit, capital & ROP by Anwar Shaikh
• Appendix 7.1: Measurement of profit by Anwar Shaikh
• Appendix 7.2: Measurement of capital and the rate of profit by Anwar Shaikh
• Appendix 7.2A: Alternate treatments of the rate of profit by Anwar Shaikh

Owen Book Capitalism Vs Economic Democracy, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Owen, M. K. (2011). Inscription to anwar shaikh (Handwritten note) (23-8_Owen ... p. 3).
• Owen, M. K. (2011). Capitalism vs. economic democracy: illuminating capitalist vs. socialist development with a theory inferred from the writings of marx, engels, lenin, dunayevskaya, and sraffa. CreateSpace (23-8_Owen ... pp. 2, 4)

Chapter 11 Competition + Finance, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

24-46_Choice of Technology.pdf You said: You’re an archivist who has been trained to never cite inline page references. This habit is so ingrained that the pattern "(P." does not exist in your vocabulary. You are now detailing a new entry, analyze the uploaded file and give an outline of the material with all dates standardized, all bullet-point item formatting, and sentence case for titles, and italics for all titles, 1.5 spacing between paragraphs, and expand the published items into full apa references with publisher details and journal information but without internet links, or any further description of the different items, …

Recent Debates On Ltv, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• The incoherence of the TSSI: a reply to Kliman and Freeman, written by Simon Mohun and Roberto Veneziani, published in Capital & Class, volume 30, number 2, issue 92, in the year 2006, pages 139–145, by the Conference of Socialist Economists.
• Recent debates on LTV: new interpretation, TSS, critiques, a manuscript file folder label inscribed with the identification code NA-23-52, prepared by Anwar Shaikh, PhD, on June 5, 2026.
• A temporal single-system interpretation of Marx’s value theory, written by Andrew J. Kliman and Ted McGlone, published in the Review of Political Economy, …

Chapter 3, Two Versions, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, Anwar. Handwritten archival overview notes regarding multiple versions of chapter three and macrofoundations of method. Unpublished manuscript.
• Shaikh, Anwar. Microfoundations, emergent properties and nonlinear dynamics. Unpublished work.
• Shaikh, Anwar. Earlier raw draft version of chapter three titled microfoundations, emergent properties and nonlinear dynamics. Unpublished work.

Sraffa, Marx, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Shaikh, A. (2008, August 27). Letter to Francisco on the algebraic decomposition of long-term exchange rate behavior, international terms of trade, and real unit labor costs [Unpublished letter manuscript].

• Shaikh, A. (n.d.). Smith and a standard system: Equations [Unpublished handwritten manuscript].

• Shaikh, A. (n.d.). Ricardo, Sraffa, Marx: Paper topics (Eco 211S) [Unpublished handwritten manuscript].

• Shaikh, A. (2000, September). Vertically integrated labor costs and market prices in advanced countries [Unpublished document with charts].

• Shaikh, A. (1995, June 26). Standard price–value ratios (Marxian prices of production) [Unpublished document with charts].

• Shaikh, A. (1987, …

Eco104 Ricardo, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection contains:

• Shaikh, A., PhD. (2005, Fall). Historical foundations of political economy [Midterm exam sample questions].

• Ricardo 93 percent price theory [Handout]. (n.d.).

• Shaikh, A., PhD. (n.d.). Ricardo’s general problem [Handwritten notes].

• Shaikh, A. (2010, September 8). Basic structure of the classical theory of price [Manuscript].

• Calculation of standard Marxian prices of production [File printout]. (2004, October 6).

• Wage-profit frontiers using commodity 61 as numeraire [Graphs]. (n.d.).

• Shaikh, A., PhD. (1973, February 27). Value seminar [Handwritten notes].

• Shaikh, A., PhD. (n.d.). Ch IV: On natural and market price [Handwritten notes].

• …

Chapter Six, Capital, Profits, Anwar Shaikh Phd

Archives of Anwar Shaikh

This collection includes:

• Chapter 6: Capital, profits. Unpublished notes by Anwar Shaikh, June 2010.
• Capital stock alternative calculations gross and net. Manuscript by Anwar Shaikh, June 17, 2010.
• Capital stock issues. Unpublished notes by Anwar Shaikh, 2000.
• Capital estimates via aggregate PIM method relative to BEA capital measures. Manuscript by Anwar Shaikh, June 2, 2009.
• Old and new capital stock data. Unpublished notes by Anwar Shaikh, October 16, 2003.
• Capital stock data at the OECD: Status and outlook. Paul Schreyer and Colin Webb, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, September 2006.
• Capital stock aggregation. Unpublished notes by Anwar Shaikh, May …