Dispute Resolution and Arbitration Commons^™

When Contractual Good Faith Meets A Controversial M&A Issue: The Sandbagging Practice In International Arbitration, Maxime Panhard

The International Lawyer

No abstract provided.

Mending The Wound Or Pulling It Apart? New Proposals For International Investment Courts And Fragmentation Of International Investment Law, Jaemin Lee

Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business

Robust discussions on standing investment courts are currently taking place at various fora. In particular, negotiations to include bilateral investment courts in IIAs are in full swing and leading to the creation of such courts. On the other hand, negotiation for a multilateral investment court has yet to start. Even if negotiation begins, it is not clear how long it will take and whether it will indeed lead to a successful conclusion. As such, for a significant amount of time in the future, it is bilateral investment courts that states administer to resolve investment disputes. Bilateral investment courts, however, will …

Gender And Justice In Family Law Disputes: Women, Mediation, And Religious Arbitration, Amelia K. Philips

Arbitration Law Review (2009 - Present)

No abstract provided.

Ethics In International Arbitration, Peter Halprin, Stephen Wah

Journal of Dispute Resolution

The growth of international arbitration has expanded both the pool of arbitrators as well as the counsel involved in international arbitration. This growth has resulted in arbitrators, counsel, and parties of various cultural and legal traditions participating in disputes. Because different cultural and legal traditions may come into conflict, there is increasing focus and discussion regarding what guidelines or rules, if any, should govern international arbitrations. The discussion regarding whether any guidelines or rules should govern arbitration asks whether a forum for dispute resolution built on the concepts of neutrality, party autonomy, and procedural flexibility should be governed by strict …

Vatican Mediation And The Venezuelan Crisis, Emma Altheide

Journal of Dispute Resolution

Part II will discuss the dispute between Argentina and Chile in the 1970s concerning property rights in the Beagle Channel, as well as the restoration of diplomatic relations between the United States and Cuba in 2015. Part III will outline the events leading to the crisis in Venezuela, where President Nicolás Maduro has brought the government to the brink of authoritarian rule. This section will assess the Vatican’s offer to mediate in Venezuela in light of the country’s current climate and previous instances of Vatican mediation. Part IV will examine the Vatican as a mediator, analyzing the attributes that may …

Why We Can’T “Just All Get Along”: Dysfunction In The Polity And Conflict Resolution And What We Might Do About It, Carrie Menkel-Meadow

Journal of Dispute Resolution

These are very troubled times. The polity is seriously divided; people who march for white supremacy and hate are called “nice and very good people” by an unhinged, but Constitutionally elected, President; relations between citizens of color and police are at a high level of hostility and distrust; Congress is unable to pass virtually any legislation; and policy differences over immigration, trade, taxation, and health care are so great that even a ruling party cannot get anything done. Perhaps the greatest challenge for our democracy now is learning how to deal with great value differences in the polity, enough so …

Value And Judgment In Investment Treaty Arbitration, Frederic Gilles Sourgens

Journal of Dispute Resolution

Are international treaties consenting to the resolution of disputes between foreign investors and the host states to their investment still a good idea? Recent and not so recent criticism of such treaty provisions calls into question whether investor-state tribunals can act as neutral arbiters of such disputes. This criticism argues that tribunals are biased in favor of the business interests of investors—and therefore disfavor the state’s right to regulate. Responses to this criticism frequently have alleged the opposite: The arbitral tribunals constituted under international treaties are, if anything, too friendly towards the interests of states. They fail to protect the …

Stories Of Experience: Economic Inequality In Mediation, Robert Rubinson

All Faculty Scholarship

No abstract provided.

Rule Of Law In The U.A.E.: The Peaceful Path To Nation-Building In Abu Dhabi And The U.A.E. Through Global Best Practices, Valerie J. Pelton

The International Lawyer

No abstract provided.

Overcoming Roadblocks To Reaching Settlement In Family Law Cases, John M. Lande

Faculty Publications

In “litigation as usual,” settlement often comes only after adversarial posturing, the original conflict escalates, the relationships deteriorate, the process takes too long and costs too much, and nobody is really happy with the resolution. This article describes roadblocks to negotiation and ways to overcome them to reach good settlements in family law cases.

Truth In A Post-Truth Society: How Sticky Defaults, Status Quo Bias, And The Sovereign Prerogative Influence The Perceived Legitimacy Of International Arbitration, S. I. Strong

Faculty Publications

Through empirical and theoretical studies conducted by political scientists, philosophers, psychologists, and economists, this Article demonstrates how three phenomena - sticky defaults, status quo bias, and the sovereign prerogative-work in parallel to create enduring, but demonstrably incorrect, perceptions about the legitimacy of international arbitration. Interdisciplinary research also provides a potential solution in the form of a heuristic known as the Reversal Test, which acts as an objective diagnostic tool to identify the influence of unconscious cognitive distortions such as the status quo bias. Through this analysis, this Article not only addresses one of the core paradoxes in international dispute resolution, …

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Journal Of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 19, Iss. 2

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

Eighteenth Annual International Advocate For Peace Award, Leymah Gbowee

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

On April 27, 2018, the Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution presented the Eighteenth Annual International Advocate for Peace Award to Leymah Gbowee. What follows is a transcription of the award ceremony, including Leymah Gbowee's acceptance speech.

Escaping The Logic Of Anarchy: A New Model Of Collective Security, Bryan H. Druzin

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Past attempts to create collective security, such as the League of Nations and the United Nations, have failed. This article argues that this is because the anarchic structure of the international system does not permit a top-down approach to the problem. It is argued that the solution is to create a collective security model that is bottom-up rather than top-down.

This article proposes a model of collective security that uses positive feedback generated by network effects to trigger the bottom-up emergence of a global collective security organization. Driven by fear and self-interest, weak states join this fledgling organization, increasing its …

Arbitral Institutions Through The Magnifier: On The Nature Of Their Decisions And Exposure To Suit, Silke Noa Elrifai, Amr Arafa Hasaan, Laura Lozano

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Arbitral institutions play an essential role in the administration of arbitration disputes. Their arbitration rules give potential disputing parties a clear understanding of the sequence of their dispute. The rules highlight both the obligations the arbitral institution agrees to assume towards the parties as well as the institution's asserted rights. Although the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law ("UNCITRAL") Model Law inspired the rules of many arbitral institutions, no institution works in a legal vacuum. They are embedded in the national legal framework of their respective locales. As a result, each set of institutional rules reflects the domestic laws, …

The Process Of Peace: Using Community Dispute Resolution To Improve The Relationship Between Police And Community In Minnesota, Kelsey Schwarzrock

Mitchell Hamline Law Journal of Public Policy and Practice

No abstract provided.

Truth, Justice, And The Shaanxian Way: Revisiting The Story Of Qiu Ju, Ilhyung Lee

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Qiu Ju da guansi is a Chinese film by renowned director Zhang Yimou. Known as The Story of Qiu Ju in the West, the main character is a woman in rural China who seeks a satisfactory resolution after her husband is physically assaulted by the local representative of a state agency. After its release in 1992, the film received significant attention from reviewers, and, over the years, commentators from various disciplines. This Article builds on that commentary, with a focus on the film's lessons about culture, dispute resolution, the legal process, and their intersection. After a summary of the story's …

The Muslim/Arab Sulha And The Restorative Justice Model Same Purpose, Different Approach, Doron Pely, Golan Luzon

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Article establishes sulha, the traditional Arab and Islamic dispute resolution practice, as a restorative justice ("RJ") mechanism. The Article compares sulah with western RJ: both practices strive for the same goal, repairing damaged relations, highlights the conceptual and functional similarities, including support for victims, and the importance of perpetrator responsibility. The Article introduces the concept of reintegrative honoring theory ("RHT")-a novel concept that describes the reliance of sulha relies on restoration of victims' sense of honor. Finally, the Article compares RHT with western reintegrative shaming theory ("RST").

How Pre-Dispute Arbitration Clauses Chill Whistleblowing And End-Run Dodd-Frank Whistleblowing Protections, Noah Weingarten

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Note proceeds in six parts. First, it examines the mechanics of the SEC whistleblower program, its success, and the importance of whistleblowers. Second, it analyzes whistleblower retaliation protections and contrasts the protections under DoddFrank with those under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 ("SOX"). Third, it analyzes how the SEC protects whistleblowers under its regulatory powers. Fourth, it analyzes the importance of retaliation claims from the whistleblower's perspective. Fifth, it analyzes how and why companies employ pre-dispute arbitration clauses to get a more favorable forum to entertain retaliation claims and how federal courts have been enforcing these arbitration clauses. Finally, …

A New Legal Framework For Employee And Consumer Arbitration Agreements, Imre S. Szalai

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Article is divided into three main sections. The first section provides an overview of the FAA, and the second section explores how arbitration clauses with oppressive terms give rise to multiple harms. The concluding section of the Article demonstrates the many problems that arise from a court's mere severance of harsh terms, and discusses how the history, policy, and text of the FAA require courts to adopt an invalidation approach. As a result of the automatic and complete invalidation of the entire arbitration agreement for containing a harsh term, a consumer or employee, like the victims of sexual harassment …

The Devil's Advocate Also Wears Prada: The Impracticality Of Adr In Counterfeiting Disputes And The Prospect Of Arbitration, Anan Kahari

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

The purpose of this Note is to posit that arbitration, tailored for counterfeiting disputes, could potentially serve as a reliable method for fashion companies to combat counterfeiting. Part II discusses the background of IP rights and the relationship between counterfeiting and fashion. Part III highlights the traditional advantages of ADR and how some of those advantages may become disadvantages when applied to counterfeiting disputes. Lastly, Part IV argues that arbitration can be designed to be applicable to counterfeiting disputes described in this Note.

Access To Justice: Accelerating The Abandonment Of Fgm/C, Gretchen Kail

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Note discusses the role comprehensive legislation traditionally plays through a top-down approach and proposes the use of bottom-up approaches to better leverage national laws and new legal norms to support collective societal action. The discussion views legislation and FGM/C through a social norm lens: "a comprehensive, multi-sectorial, culturally sensitive approach that incorporates a social perspective to impact collective change."

Section II of this Note defines FGMIC as a health issue, a human rights violation, and a social norm. Section III discusses relevant international and regional human rights frameworks; state obligations; divergent views on the effects and usefulness of national …

Masthead, Cardozo Journal Of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 20 (2018–19)

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Journal Of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 20, Iss. 1

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

Authority-Based Mediation, Amos Gabrieli, Nourit Zimerman, Michal Alberstein

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

The paper describes and defines, for the first time, a unique mediation procedure-the authority-based mediation. This procedure was developed by one of the authors of this paper, and is characterized by handling highly complex conflicts in multi-party disputes, which are mostly referred to mediation by the court. Authoritybased mediation is conducted in an evaluative manner, combining in-depth legal discussion with a soft dialog that relates to emotions and interests and results in a settlement, usually following one extended mediation meeting.

Based on a combination of observations conducted in the mediation room and reflections of the mediator himself in relation to …

Public Policy Under Article V(2)(B) Of The New York Convention: Is There A Transnational Standard?, Nivedita Chandrakanth Shenoy

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This paper focuses on Article V(2)(b) of the Convention under which recognition and enforcement of an arbitral award may be refused if the competent authority in the country where recognition and enforcement is sought finds that "the recognition or enforcement of the award would be contrary to the public policy of that country." Article V is addressed to the States in which recognition and enforcement is sought and the language in Article V(2)(b) indicates an intention to provide ultimate control to that State to decide whether it will admit a foreign arbitral award into its legal order and use its …

Developing Communities Of Dialogue, Jonathan R. Cohen

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

We live in an age where American political discourse has become highly antagonistic. Such hostile discourse may influence not just our politics but also our private lives, for the abrasiveness that we witness in political life can readily spill over into our homes, our schools, and the other realms that we inhabit. How can we resist the spread of such antagonism? This Essay makes two basic claims. First, it is important that we consider dialogue as both an individual phenomenon and as a community-based phenomenon. How we speak with one another is a function of both our individual proclivities and …

Is Disgorgement A Penalty In The Antitrust-Enforcement Realm?: Exploring Mediation As The Ftc's Response To Kokesh In The Context Of Reverse Payment Settlements, Jennifer Kim

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Note seeks to answer the following question: How can the FTC respond to the potential influence of Kokesh by utilizing mediation to settle with and recover monetary relief from brand drug companies? Part II of this Note discusses the FTC's role in competition cases historically, as well as the Commission's proactive pursuit of monetary remedies, primarily disgorgement relief. It also provides a general overview of the Hatch-Waxman Act and its influence on the rise of patent infringement litigation, which, in effect, resulted in the rise of "pay-for-delay" settlements between brand and generic drug companies. Part III dissects the Supreme …

Proposing A Federal Post-Natural Disaster Mediation Program, Michelle Shaykevich

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Section II explores the history of state and federal natural disaster mediation programs. Currently, there are three primary disaster mediation processes used by states. First, and most common, are ad-hoc programs. These programs are developed after a natural disaster has occured. Second is a program utilized exclusively by North Carolina, whereby an institutional organization maintains a "state of readiness" in the event of a declared disaster. The third type is a mediation program that is run by the state but specifically excludes the mediation of flood insurance claims. Regarding federal post-natural disaster mediation programs, Section II discusses current legislative and …

Rethinking The Law Of Legal Negotiation: Confidentiality Under Federal Rule Of Evidence 408 And Related State Laws, Richard C. Reuben

Faculty Publications

Federal Rule of Evidence 408 and related state laws are among the most important rules to implement the national policy favoring the settlement of legal disputes. These rules bar the introduction of statements made during negotiations leading to the resolution of legal disputes. However, comprehensive analysis of the rule's text, doctrinal history, and modem context demonstrates that the rule no longer meets its noble goals. Rather, the rule has evolved textually from a remarkably narrow and complex categorical presumption of inadmissibility with limited exceptions to a simpler rule that gives courts considerable deference to admit such evidence when they deem …