Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
Articles 1 - 2 of 2
Full-Text Articles in Evidence
Evidence -- 1964 Tennessee Survey, Lyman R. Patterson
Evidence -- 1964 Tennessee Survey, Lyman R. Patterson
Vanderbilt Law Review
The difficulty in dealing with presumptions arises in part from the fact that the term embraces a host of different meanings, varying with the purposes underlying the presumption in a given situation. Unfortunately, the courts seldom articulate the meaning which they are attributing to the term and consequently do little to clear up the confusion... In Arnett v. Fuston, a negligence action, plaintiff argued that a verdict of not guilty against one of the two co-defendants was not supported by any evidence, and that a presumption should apply against him "for his election to stand on his motion for directed …
Logical Or Legal Relevancy -- A Conflict In Theory, Herman L. Trautman
Logical Or Legal Relevancy -- A Conflict In Theory, Herman L. Trautman
Vanderbilt Law Review
Is there a rational theory which serves as a basis for determining the admissibility of circumstantial evidence?
Circumstantial evidence involves the offer in evidence of Fact A for the purpose of having the trier of fact (jury, judge, administrative agency or arbitrator) first believe that Fact A is true, and from it infer the existence or truth of Fact B. Fact B may be one of the ultimate questions of factor propositions raised by the pleadings, or it may be a more remote fact or proposition which when established, again forms the basis for a further inference in the chain …