Law Commons^™

Delegated Decree Authority In Contemporary South America: Comparative Study Of The Radical Left And Their Threat To The Rule Of Law, Kerry Mohan

Kerry Mohan

International attention regarding Executive decree authority within Latin America has significantly increased following Hugo Chávez’ 2007 enabling law in Venezuela. This attention has largely been negative, as the international media has often vilified Chávez for promulgating decrees with the force of law. What the international media has continually failed to discuss, however, is that Chávez’ form of decree authority, “delegated decree authority” or “DDA,” has been common throughout Venezuela’s history and most of South America. This article seeks to determine DDA’s prevalence within South America, and in particular Venezuela, Ecuador, and Colombia, and determine whether DDA poses a threat to …

White Phosphorus: Smokescreen Or Smoke And Mirrors?, Ubaid Ul-Haq

Ubaid ul-Haq

Chemical and biological weapons have for centuries been relegated to a widely disfavored status among most nation States. Since these early times, it has been recognized that the use of these weapons, even during the chaotic realm of warfare, is unnecessary and unnatural. As such, there have evolved in the past 150 years several conventions that have codified this increasingly apparent sentiment of non-use, eventually culminating in the ideal of non-proliferation. Today, however, the changing atmosphere of the battlefield and the foreign tactics employed therein have led to a resurgence of the utility of using such weapons, particularly since certain …

Delegated Decree Authority In Contemporary South America: Comparative Study Of The Radical Left And Their Threat To The Rule Of Law, Kerry Mohan

Kerry Mohan

International attention regarding Executive decree authority within Latin America has significantly increased following Hugo Chávez’ 2007 enabling law in Venezuela. This attention has largely been negative, as the international media has often vilified Chávez for promulgating decrees with the force of law. What the international media has continually failed to discuss, however, is that Chávez’ form of decree authority, “delegated decree authority” or “DDA,” has been common throughout Venezuela’s history and most of South America. This article seeks to determine DDA’s prevalence within South America, and in particular Venezuela, Ecuador, and Colombia, and determine whether DDA poses a threat to …

Can Cia Interrogators Relying Upon Government Counsel Advice Be Prosecuted For Torture?, Adam M. Hochroth

Adam M Hochroth

In the spring of 2002, the CIA sought advice from the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) regarding an interrogation program for high-level al Qaeda detainees. The proposed program included the use of techniques such as walling, stress positions, confinement, sleep deprivation and waterboarding. On August 1, 2002, the OLC provided two memoranda of advice to the CIA on the lawfulness of the proposed program and the specific techniques intended. The OLC advised that the program and the techniques were lawful and did not constitute torture within the meaning of the Torture Statute, 18 U.S.C. §§2340–2340A. This article considers whether interrogators …

Applying Torture And Asylum Protections To Prevent The Deportation Of Persons With Hiv/Aids, Christine Chiu

Christine Chiu

Granting a foreign national with HIV/AIDS permission to remain in a country, whether temporarily or indefinitely, is a weighty decision. Faced with limited resources and often fervent public antagonism towards increased immigration, states must pick and choose whom to expel from its borders. This paper examines the extent to which HIV status is considered in determining whether a petitioner is eligible or even has a right to remain in a country. The analysis consists largely of a comparison of the asylum and torture protections afforded to petitioners with HIV/AIDS in the United States, Canada, and the European Court of Human …

Israel And The International Criminal Court: The United Nations Fact-Finding Mission On The Gaza Conflict And Its Role In The Arab-Israeli Conflict, Adam A. Hussein Mr.

Adam A Hussein Mr.

On September 15, 2009 the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) released the Report of the United Nations Fact Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict (UN Report). The UN Report garnered great interest in the international community, as it introduced the question of whether Israel and Palestine could be brought before the International Criminal Court for their acts in the aggression that began in late 2008. This paper discusses the UN Report’s findings, construction, and flaws. The paper then uses the UN Report to assess what role the UNHRC and ICC can play in the Middle East Conflict. After concluding …

A Constructive Proposal To Solve The ‘Dokdo’ Controversy Between Korea And Japan, Byung-Woon Lyou

Byung-Woon Lyou

No abstract provided.

Deference To Administrative Agencies In Interpreting Treaties: Chevron, Charming Betsy, And Global Decisionmaking, Catherine E. Sweetser

Catherine E Sweetser

This Article examines how national courts in the United States should deal with domestic agency interpretations of international treaties. Under Chevron deference, a court defers to an agency interpretation where it believes that Congress when passing a statute intended to delegate lawmaking power to the agency. The Charming Betsy canon assumes that Congress also has an interest in complying with international norms and in binding the United States to follow international rules. In both these canons, Congressional intent becomes the touchstone. I first examine whether international law itself, as a rule of treaty interpretation, suggests that domestic agencies should receive …

Delegated Decree Authority In Contemporary South America: Comparative Study Of The Radical Left And Their Threat To The Rule Of Law, Kerry Mohan

Kerry Mohan

International attention regarding Executive decree authority within Latin America has significantly increased following Hugo Chávez’ 2007 enabling law in Venezuela. This attention has largely been negative, as the international media has often vilified Chávez for promulgating decrees with the force of law. What the international media has continually failed to discuss, however, is that Chávez’ form of decree authority, “delegated decree authority” or “DDA,” has been common throughout Venezuela’s history and most of South America. This article seeks to determine DDA’s prevalence within South America, and in particular Venezuela, Ecuador, and Colombia, and determine whether DDA poses a threat to …

Just Laws Versus Unjust Laws: Asserting The Morality Of Civil Disobedience, Amin George Forji

Amin George Forji

How is a citizen living under a merciless totalitarianism such as the Nazi but opposed to its philosophies expected to respond to the law? Where does his primary obligation as a citizen reside? Is it to the laws of the land that command total submission or to his convictions by which he is convinced that the system is totally unjust? Does one have a moral obligation to always obey the law? Conversely, should one obey an unjust law? Obviously, such an individual like Antigone in ancient Greece is naturally torn between two loyalties. (Note 1)If he obeys the law, he …

Delegated Decree Authority In Contemporary South America: Comparative Study Of The Radical Left And Their Threat To The Rule Of Law, Kerry Mohan

Kerry Mohan

International attention regarding Executive decree authority within Latin America has significantly increased following Hugo Chávez’ 2007 enabling law in Venezuela. This attention has largely been negative, as the international media has often vilified Chávez for promulgating decrees with the force of law. What the international media has continually failed to discuss, however, is that Chávez’ form of decree authority, “delegated decree authority” or “DDA,” has been common throughout Venezuela’s history and most of South America. This article seeks to determine DDA’s prevalence within South America, and in particular Venezuela, Ecuador, and Colombia, and determine whether DDA poses a threat to …

Delegated Decree Authority In Contemporary South America: Comparative Study Of The Radical Left And Their Threat To The Rule Of Law, Kerry Mohan

Kerry Mohan

International attention regarding Executive decree authority within Latin America has significantly increased following Hugo Chávez’ 2007 enabling law in Venezuela. This attention has largely been negative, as the international media has often vilified Chávez for promulgating decrees with the force of law. What the international media has continually failed to discuss, however, is that Chávez’ form of decree authority, “delegated decree authority” or “DDA,” has been common throughout Venezuela’s history and most of South America. This article seeks to determine DDA’s prevalence within South America, and in particular Venezuela, Ecuador, and Colombia, and determine whether DDA poses a threat to …

The U.B.S. Case: The U.S. Attack On Swiss Banking Sovereignty, Beckett G. Cantley

Beckett G Cantley

On August 1, 2006, the United States Senate’s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations (“PSI”), a branch of the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, released a report in conjunction with a Senate hearing that revealed alarming statistics regarding wealthy Americans’ love affair with offshore banking. The PSI report was a culmination of the subcommittee’s investigation into tax haven abuses, providing the most detailed look to date of high-level tax schemes. The report revealed such an alarming number of rich Americans are using offshore accounts to evade taxes that law enforcement is unable to control the growing misconduct. Senator Carl Levin …

Foreign Policy Practices And International Law Constraints In Korea, Won-Mog Choi

Won-Mog Choi

Korea’s bilateral foreign policy toward its neighboring states is firmly founded on the basis of the pragmatic realism. Korea has always prioritized national security and its alliance with the U.S. over any general rules of international law. By contrast, in the process of implementing Korea’s multilateral foreign policy, the norms of international law have been given serious consideration as Korea’s UN and ICC diplomacy and WTO dispute settlement policy demonstrates. Korea’s firm belief in the collective security system has also been reflected in countering terrorism. This reflects the reality that if Korea were to depart from the path of multilateral …

Was Selden Right? The Expansion Of Closed Seas And Its Consequences, Scott Shackelford

Scott Shackelford

This Article focuses on the relationship between the legal regimes governing offshore resources in the continental shelves and the deep seabed, particularly in reference to the extent to which continental shelf claims are encroaching on the deep seabed. The question of how well these respective legal regimes regulate resource exploitation will also be considered, along with an analysis of the underlying reasons driving change in these governance structures. I argue that the primary issue is one of whether vague rules, particularly UNCLOS Article 76, are working in terms of incentivizing sustainable, peaceful development of offshore resources.

Russia & Legal Harmonization: An Historical Inquiry Into Ip Reform As Global Convergence And Resistance, Boris N. Mamlyuk

Boris Mamlyuk

This Article examines several waves of intellectual property (IP) regulation reform in Russia, starting with a specific examination into early Soviet attempts to regulate intellectual property. Historical analysis is useful to illustrate areas of theoretical convergence, divergence and tension between state ideology, positive law, and “law in action.” The relevance of these tensions for post-Soviet legal reform may appear tenuous. However, insofar as IP enforcement has been one of the largest hurdles for Russia’s prolonged accession to the WTO, these historical precedents may help to explain the apparent theoretical or political disconnect between the WTO and Russia. If Russian policymakers …

Is Chapter 15 Universalist Or Territorialist? Empirical Evidence From United States Bankruptcy Court Cases, Jeremy Leong

Jeremy Leong

No abstract provided.

Understanding Exclusion Of The Cisg: A New Paradigm Of Determining Party Intent, William P. Johnson

William P. Johnson

No abstract provided.

Fictitious States, Effective Control, And The Use Of Force, Brian C. Finucane

Brian C Finucane

This Article examines the security threat posed by “fictitious” states and non-state actors as well as the legal regime governing military responses to this threat. As the Article explains, many of the world’s states are legal fictions because they lack the key feature of statehood in international law: the effective control of their nominal populations and territories. Although the problem is most vividly illustrated by the United States’ ongoing conflict with Al Qa’ida in Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia, the problem is far broader. In fact effective states which control all of their territory and population are in fact anomalous. As …

Corruption As Institution: Roadblocks To U.S.-Funded "Business Formalization" Programs In Niger, Thomas A. Kelley Iii

Thomas A Kelley III

Suddenly it seems that US-funded international aid programs are all about building rational, predictable institutions to stimulate business in poor countries. The Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC), a relatively new and increasingly important US aid organization, and the more venerable United States Agency for International Development (USAID), are initiating programs in poor countries around the world based on the assumption that their future stability and prosperity depends on unleashing and guiding the entrepreneurial spirit of small and medium-sized enterprises, and that this can be accomplished by improving the institutions – most notably the laws and legal enforcement mechanisms – that regulate …

Emergent Disability & The Limits Of Equality: A Critical Reading Of The Un Convention On The Rights Of Persons With Disabilities, Elizabeth R. Ribet

Elizabeth R Ribet

The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities marks a shift in international legal relationships to and conceptions of disability. The Convention is the first binding international instrument of its kind related to disability. Its premises differ from the earlier World Programme on Disability, and more closely integrate the frameworks of U.S. domestic equal protection and disability civil rights law. Drawing on critical race and feminist theoretical literature, this paper critically examines the implications of internationalizing a U.S. disability law framework, with particular attention to the problem of "emergent disability", or disability which is specifically produced as a …

Emergent Disability & The Limits Of Equality: A Critical Reading Of The Un Convention On The Rights Of Persons With Disabilities, Elizabeth R. Ribet

Elizabeth R Ribet

The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities marks a shift in international legal relationships to and conceptions of disability. The Convention is the first binding international instrument of its kind related to disability. Its premises differ from the earlier World Programme on Disability, and more closely integrate the frameworks of U.S. domestic equal protection and disability civil rights law. Drawing on critical race and feminist theoretical literature, this paper critically examines the implications of internationalizing a U.S. disability law framework, with particular attention to the problem of "emergent disability", or disability which is specifically produced as a …

Emergent Disability & The Limits Of Equality: A Critical Reading Of The Un Convention On The Rights Of Persons With Disabilities, Elizabeth R. Ribet

Elizabeth R Ribet

The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities marks a shift in international legal relationships to and conceptions of disability. The Convention is the first binding international instrument of its kind related to disability. Its premises differ from the earlier World Programme on Disability, and more closely integrate the frameworks of U.S. domestic equal protection and disability civil rights law. Drawing on critical race and feminist theoretical literature, this paper critically examines the implications of internationalizing a U.S. disability law framework, with particular attention to the problem of "emergent disability", or disability which is specifically produced as a …

Uncitral, Security Rights And The Globalisation Of The Us Article 9, Gerard Mccormack Professor

Gerard McCormack

Abstract – “UNCITRAL, Security Rights and the globalisation of the US Article 9” UNCITRAL, the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, has recently produced a Legislative Guide on more particularly on secured transactions, or secured credit law as it is variously called. The Guide follows the broad contours of Article 9 of the United States Uniform Commercial Code though it is not an exact copy. It aims to harmonise and modernise the law of secured credit across the globe. In UNCITRAL’s view, the Legislative Guide will aid the growth of individual businesses and also in general economic prosperity. Harmonisation …

Making Wto Remedies Work For Developing Nations: The Need For Class Actions, Phoenix X. Cai

Phoenix X. Cai

Making WTO Remedies Work for Developing Nations: The Need for Class Actions

Abstract

Developing nations comprise more than four-fifths of the membership of the World Trade Organization (“WTO”). Yet, they seldom participate in the WTO’s powerful dispute settlement process. This is problematic because the WTO is essentially a self-enforcing system of reciprocal trade rights that relies on proactive monitoring and enforcement by all members. Use of the self-enforcement mechanism – by initiating cases under the WTO’s Dispute Settlement Understanding (“DSU”) - is critical.

There are five primary reasons why developing nations do not actively invoke the DSU. This Article argues …

Self Restraint And National Security, Nathan Alexander Sales

Nathan Alexander Sales

Why does the government sometimes tie its own hands in national security operations? This article identifies four instances in which officials believed that the applicable laws allowed them to conduct a particular military or intelligence operation but nevertheless declined to do so. For example, policymakers have barred counterterrorism interrogators from using any technique other than the fairly innocuous methods listed in the Army Field Manual. Before 9/11, officials rejected the CIA’s plans to use targeted killings against Osama bin Laden and other terrorist leaders. Judge advocates sometimes use policy considerations to restrict military strikes that would be lawful. And in …

Towards Cultural Autonomy In Tibet, George Zheng

George Zheng

Accommodating cultural distinctiveness of minority ethnic groups in multi-ethnic states has been an issue of theoretical importance and practical urgency for decades. China is the most populous multi-ethnic country in the world with a unique institutional design for ethnic minorities. However, this institutional design, namely, Minzu Quyu Zizhi (Regional Ethnic Autonomy), has not been properly studied before being criticized or ignored by the western commentators. In the western world, the Tibet issue has been extensively discussed in the context of human rights and “universal” constitutional principles, but rarely in the context of Chinese constitutional law. This article aims to fill …

Avoiding The "Big Black Hole" Of Development Aid: The Legal Promise And Inherent Challenges Of Community-Directed Development, Allison Wells

Allison Wells

In the face of recent natural disasters in places such as Haiti and Pakistan, as well as the chronic underdevelopment in many regions of the world, development aid funnels billions of dollars around the globe every year in an effort to improve the lives of suffering populations. However, the distribution of those funds is constantly controversial, and much is said about the potential for mismanagement in international development, as well as the risk of political paternalism in dictating what needy communities are lacking. Community-Directed Development (CDD) is a growing trend in international aid that improves upon many of these pitfalls …

How Powerful Is The Ioc? – Let’S Talk About The Environment, Marc A. R. Zemel

Marc A. R. Zemel

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) is in a unique position as the supreme administrator of an immensely popular international mega-event and a self-proclaimed champion of environmental issues and sustainable development. Every two years, cities from all over the world spend millions of dollars for the mere privilege of competing to host the Olympic Games, and those cities must play by the IOC’s rules. In addition, Article 2 of the Olympic Charter, the constitution-like instrument governing the IOC and the Olympic Movement, requires the IOC to ensure that the Olympics are held to promote sustainable development and show concern for the …

Due Process And Counterterrorism, Amos N. Guiora

Amos N. Guiora

In this article, I examine counterterrorism from the perspective of detention, interrogation and trial and in particular how these three are articulated and implemented. The broader question is whether the contemporary counterterrorism paradigm is based in due process or a legal (not necessarily lawful) regime that minimizes individual rights. That is, does civil, democratic society discard core principles in the face of an on-going, viable threat or are political rights and national security rights effectively balanced in order to protect both. Answering this question requires analyzing the interface between threats and rights; in particular, the extent to which society responds …