Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Sociology (414)
- Arts and Humanities (363)
- International Relations (312)
- Public Affairs, Public Policy and Public Administration (259)
- International and Area Studies (233)
-
- Economics (216)
- History (216)
- American Politics (211)
- Law (143)
- Political Theory (133)
- Politics and Social Change (105)
- Peace and Conflict Studies (100)
- Education (91)
- Race, Ethnicity and Post-Colonial Studies (86)
- Comparative Politics (84)
- Other Political Science (82)
- Business (77)
- Defense and Security Studies (77)
- Social Justice (73)
- Models and Methods (61)
- Feminist, Gender, and Sexuality Studies (59)
- Psychology (54)
- Religion (53)
- Anthropology (50)
- Communication (49)
- Inequality and Stratification (49)
- Public Policy (48)
- Race and Ethnicity (48)
- Institution
-
- University of Texas at Arlington (137)
- Brigham Young University (62)
- College of Saint Benedict and Saint John's University (48)
- City University of New York (CUNY) (39)
- Claremont Colleges (38)
-
- Universitas Padjadjaran (36)
- Chapman University (35)
- Universitas Indonesia (30)
- Dominican University of California (21)
- University of Central Florida (21)
- US Army War College (19)
- Bates College (17)
- Seton Hall University (17)
- University of Nebraska at Omaha (17)
- Valparaiso University (17)
- Old Dominion University (16)
- Liberty University (15)
- Mississippi State University (15)
- Prairie View A&M University (15)
- Southern Methodist University (15)
- Illinois Wesleyan University (13)
- Portland State University (13)
- SUNY Geneseo (12)
- University of Mississippi (12)
- St. Mary's University (11)
- University of Denver (11)
- Fordham University (10)
- Nova Southeastern University (10)
- Providence College (10)
- The University of Akron (10)
- Keyword
-
- Politics (32)
- China (26)
- United States (25)
- Capitalism (19)
- Democracy (17)
-
- Immigration (17)
- Political Science (16)
- Trump (15)
- Elections (14)
- Critical Theory (13)
- Religion (13)
- Ukraine (13)
- Education (12)
- Neoliberalism (12)
- Russia (12)
- Israel (11)
- Nationalism (11)
- Public opinion (11)
- Authoritarianism (10)
- Deterrence (10)
- Geopolitics (10)
- AI (9)
- Donald Trump (9)
- Gender (9)
- Populism (9)
- Social Media (9)
- Social media (9)
- Artificial Intelligence (8)
- Conflict (8)
- Government (8)
- Publication
-
- Fast Capitalism (136)
- The Journal of Social Encounters (46)
- Comparative Civilizations Review (40)
- Jurnal Wacana Politik (36)
- CMC Senior Theses (24)
-
- Honors Theses (20)
- Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects (19)
- Journal of Nonprofit Innovation (19)
- The Penguin Review (19)
- Bates College Journal of Political Studies (17)
- Student Scholar Symposium Abstracts and Posters (17)
- The US Army War College Quarterly: Parameters (17)
- SHU World Review (15)
- The Griot - Southern Conference on African American Studies, Inc. (15)
- Midwest Social Sciences Journal (14)
- Space and Defense (14)
- Res Publica - Journal of Undergraduate Research (13)
- The Dialogue (13)
- Theses and Dissertations (13)
- Emancipations: A Journal of Critical Social Analysis (12)
- Honors Undergraduate Theses (12)
- The Political Realm: Journal of Undergraduate Research in Political Science and International Relations (11)
- Political Science & Geography Faculty Publications (10)
- Posters - 2026 (10)
- Scripps Senior Theses (10)
- Williams Honors College, Honors Research Projects (10)
- Global Africa: Journal of African and African Diaspora Studies (9)
- Publications and Research (9)
- Senior Theses (9)
- Doctoral Dissertations and Projects (8)
- Publication Type
- File Type
Articles 1021 - 1050 of 1158
Full-Text Articles in Political Science
Ho Chi Minh’S Thoughts On Gender Equality In The Political Sphere In Vietnam And Strategic Implications For Indonesia, Tri Minh Nguyen
Ho Chi Minh’S Thoughts On Gender Equality In The Political Sphere In Vietnam And Strategic Implications For Indonesia, Tri Minh Nguyen
Jurnal Wacana Politik
This paper provides an exhaustive examination of the theoretical foundations of Ho Chi Minh’s thought regarding gender equality and its institutionalization within the political fabric of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam. Focusing on the contemporary period (2021–2026), the analysis evaluates the efficacy of the Vietnamese model of State Feminism in achieving descriptive and substantive representation for women in legislative and executive bodies. Furthermore, the paper conducts a comparative analysis with the Republic of Indonesia, particularly following its 2024 general elections, to identify structural, cultural, and legal divergences. By synthesizing data from government reports, international indices, and academic literature, this study …
Democracy In Practice, Stefanos Milkidis
Democracy In Practice, Stefanos Milkidis
Open Educational Resources
In this assignment, students are asked to write a public-facing blog post that connects a theme from American government to a current issue, event, or personal experience. The goal is to practice civic dialogue and critical thinking, while contributing to a broader public conversation about American government, politics, and democracy.
Political Elections In The New Wave Of Media: The Celebrification Of The Presidency, Camille B. Moore
Political Elections In The New Wave Of Media: The Celebrification Of The Presidency, Camille B. Moore
Anthós
This article examines the impact of social media on journalism leading up to the 2024 United States presidential election and how expectations of candidates have changed. By exploring the degradation of discourse in news and how polarization and cognitive biases have intensified with the widespread adoption of social media, previous candidate conventions have begun to crumble. This has, and will continue to have, a large impact on voting and democracy in America, as scholars have noted since the beginning of the 2000’s, in examining a shift in news preferences as pop culture gains influence. This work further examines recent scholarship …
Table Of Contents
The Griot - Southern Conference on African American Studies, Inc.
No abstract provided.
Editor's Pen, Ronald E. Goodwin
Editor's Pen, Ronald E. Goodwin
The Griot - Southern Conference on African American Studies, Inc.
No abstract provided.
“The World Is Yours”: Blackplanet.Com And The Black Birth Of The Social Media Age, Malachi D. Crawford, W. Denae Muhammad Murphy, Bequita Pegram
“The World Is Yours”: Blackplanet.Com And The Black Birth Of The Social Media Age, Malachi D. Crawford, W. Denae Muhammad Murphy, Bequita Pegram
The Griot - Southern Conference on African American Studies, Inc.
This article examines the rise of BlackPlanet.com as a foundational force in the birth of the Social Media Age. Launched in 1999 by Omar Wasow, BlackPlanet quickly became the largest and most influential online social networking platform for African Americans, challenging assumptions about the so-called “digital divide.” Despite limited household internet access among Black communities, the site experienced extraordinary growth, reaching nearly 13 million users by 2004 (see user growth data in Table 1)
Crawford et al . Through customizable personal pages, forums, messaging, and community-building tools, BlackPlanet pioneered participatory digital culture before the rise of MySpace and Facebook. The …
Book Reviews, Mea Boykins, Kimberly F. Monroe, Denzel Oliver, Latif A. Tarik
Book Reviews, Mea Boykins, Kimberly F. Monroe, Denzel Oliver, Latif A. Tarik
The Griot - Southern Conference on African American Studies, Inc.
No abstract provided.
Analyzing Critical Mineral Supply For Lithium-Ion Battery Demand To 2050, Shaely Sullivan
Analyzing Critical Mineral Supply For Lithium-Ion Battery Demand To 2050, Shaely Sullivan
Cal Poly Humboldt theses and projects
Battery storage is fundamental in the global initiative to mitigate anthropogenic climate change by decarbonizing the electric power grid and transportation sector. Battery storage stabilizes intermittent energy sources, such as solar and wind, and enables clean transportation through electric vehicles. Lithium-ion batteries are the most widely used battery chemistry globally due to their performance capabilities. Therefore, demand for lithium-ion batteries is projected to increase exponentially over the next several decades, driven by the growth of electric vehicles. This thesis projects global demand for electric vehicles and stationary storage, to assess the supply risks for critical minerals essential to lithium-ion batteries. …
Examining The Results Of Revolutions In The Third World: A Case Study Of The Iranian, Libyan, And Nicaraguan Revolutions, Noah A. Mohammedelamien
Examining The Results Of Revolutions In The Third World: A Case Study Of The Iranian, Libyan, And Nicaraguan Revolutions, Noah A. Mohammedelamien
Honors Undergraduate Theses
This thesis examines the post-revolutionary trajectories of Libya, Iran, and Nicaragua to explain why some Third World revolutionary projects preserve and use elements of their founding ideology while others fragment, personalize, or diffuse over time. Rather than focusing on the causes of revolution alone, it analyzes the durability of religious-socialist ideological continuity after revolutionary upheaval. Using a (MDSD) comparative historical and institutional approach grounded in primary and secondary sources, the study evaluates five key dimensions across the cases: religious-socialist ideological fusion, religious elite loyalty, popular religious mobilization, institutional embedding of ideology, and external pressure. The findings suggest ideological continuity is …
Constructing Descriptive Representation: A Study Of Contemporary Political Figures In The United States, Emma Zalewski
Constructing Descriptive Representation: A Study Of Contemporary Political Figures In The United States, Emma Zalewski
Honors Theses
Political representation in the United States depends not only on who the officeholders are, but on how they publicly perform identities such as gender, race, class, religion, and profession in ways that shape trust and legitimacy. Existing work on descriptive representation and performativity explains why shared identities matter, but it often treats identity too much like a fixed demographic category rather than a strategic and audience-sensitive rhetorical practice, leaving the question of how politicians actually deploy identity across different political settings unexplored. This project addresses that gap by showing that identity claims are best understood as deliberate performances that vary …
The Discrepancies In Voter Perception Of Male And Female Political Candidates: Biases Of Characteristic Traits And Policy Priority, Julia Piver
Honors Theses
Gender remains a defining factor in how political candidates are perceived by the American electorate, shaping not only evaluations of characteristic traits but also perceived policy priority. These discrepancies are rooted and propelled by traditional gender roles from the 1900s. This thesis shows that the perceptions of female and male political candidates differ depending on the informational environment as well as the voter demographics. I used both a quantitative nationally representative survey and a qualitative interview of students on Bucknell's campus. The date revealed that individuals in lower information environments are more likely to enact gender stereotypes along traditional gender …
No Coup, No Conscience: Coup-Proofing In The Armenian Genocide, Rachel Svoyskiy
No Coup, No Conscience: Coup-Proofing In The Armenian Genocide, Rachel Svoyskiy
CMC Senior Theses
The Armenian Genocide functioned as a form of coup-proofing under the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP). Existing scholarship emphasizes nationalism, wartime radicalization, and security dilemmas, but does not fully account for why the military complied, why dissenters were removed, or how Armenian property became tied to political loyalty. Applying Hicham Bou Nassif’s framework of coup-proofing, this study examines four tactics the CUP used to secure military obedience while carrying out mass violence. First, the regime framed Armenians as an existential threat to align the officer corps ideologically with the state. Second, it promoted the material interests of military and …
Framing The War On Terror: Media Narratives And U.S. Foreign Policy After 9/11, Neva Essex
Framing The War On Terror: Media Narratives And U.S. Foreign Policy After 9/11, Neva Essex
History and Political Science | Senior Theses
The media plays an essential role in developing an informed public and the shaping of information. Foreign policy and the coverage of the U.S. movements abroad drastically changed with the 9/11 terrorist attacks. This paper seeks to examine the ways in which media coverage of presidential rhetoric in regard to the U.S. response to terrorism changed over the course of the George W. Bush and Barack Obama administrations. With the use of qualitative narrative analysis of print news media sources and official statements made from the White House, this paper will identify the patterns and changes which occurred over the …
Immigration Policy Priorities In The Carter And Reagan Administrations, Sulgi Kim
Immigration Policy Priorities In The Carter And Reagan Administrations, Sulgi Kim
History and Political Science | Senior Theses
Historically, immigration policy has been important for the United States. It has shaped the nation’s economy, demographics, and political landscape. In each presidential administration, immigration has been addressed differently, shaped by a combination of political, economic, and international factors. While scholars such as Higham (1956), Zolberg (2008), and Pineau and Waters (2016) have examined the events leading up to and the effect of various immigration policies, the literature has not focused on a critical actor in immigration policy: the president. This thesis asks what factors shaped the immigration policy priorities of Presidents Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan? This study used …
Finding Aid For The Leslie H. Southwick Campaign Memorabilia Collection
Finding Aid For The Leslie H. Southwick Campaign Memorabilia Collection
Archives & Special Collections: Finding Aids (alphabetical)
The Leslie H. Southwick Campaign Memorabilia Collection focuses on presidential and Mississippi political campaigns dating from 1856-2017, although the bulk of content is from 1960-2004. Formats include pamphlets and other campaign literature, bumper stickers, textiles, posters, campaign buttons, and other candidate and political party souvenirs.
Finding Aid For The Ralph C. Kennedy Collection
Finding Aid For The Ralph C. Kennedy Collection
Archives & Special Collections: Finding Aids (alphabetical)
The Ralph C. Kennedy collection contains presidential campaign and inauguration memorabilia acquired during the course of Kennedy’s career in the U.S. Secret Service.
Why Does The U.S. Still Practice The Death Penalty? An Application Of Waltz's Three Images, Anika Tracy
Why Does The U.S. Still Practice The Death Penalty? An Application Of Waltz's Three Images, Anika Tracy
University Honors Program Senior Projects
The United States is the only Western democracy that still practices the death penalty, and legal scholars, domestic politics scholars, and comparativists have written extensively about American capital punishment. In this thesis, I will synthesize this scholarship to present a multifaceted explanation for America’s uniquely continued use of the death penalty through Kenneth Waltz’s three “images” or levels of analysis. While Waltz’s three levels of analysis is an established theory in the field of international relations (IR), the utilization of IR theory for an analysis of American capital punishment is particularly enriching because death penalty abolition is a norm in …
Climate, Energy, Economy: Interconnected Perspectives From Politics, Business, And The Public, Isabella Harper Heinzen
Climate, Energy, Economy: Interconnected Perspectives From Politics, Business, And The Public, Isabella Harper Heinzen
Theses and Dissertations
When considering the economic and social costs and benefits of a global, intergenerational, and environmental issue, rigid analysis often falls short. The topics discussed in this thesis aim to address the complex moral, economic, and political concerns regarding climate change to provide a holistic view of the issue and the role humans play. The first section on the scientific consensus addresses concerns regarding the existence and severity of climate change, finding where the responsibility lies for humans. The second section analyzes the energy context in modern society to understand the call for a transition from oil and gas to renewable …
Applying Groupthink To Digital Spaces: The Rise Of Online Conspiracy Theory Networks, Lily Karen Schow
Applying Groupthink To Digital Spaces: The Rise Of Online Conspiracy Theory Networks, Lily Karen Schow
Theses and Dissertations
This thesis examines the transformation of political paranoia and collective decision-making in the United States from the twentieth century to the digital age. Building on Richard Hofstadter’s concept of the “paranoid style” and Irving Janis’s theory of groupthink, it argues that the dynamics of conspiratorial thinking and collective misjudgment have not disappeared but have been reconfigured by digital communication systems. While Hofstadter identified paranoia as a recurring rhetorical mode and Janis analyzed groupthink as a pathology of small, cohesive decision-making groups, this study contends that both frameworks require adaptation to account for contemporary digital environments. The analysis traces how historical …
“America Is For Americans Only”: Journalistic Professionalism, Populism, And Latino Ethnic Media In The 2024 U.S. Presidential Election, Maria Villarroel
“America Is For Americans Only”: Journalistic Professionalism, Populism, And Latino Ethnic Media In The 2024 U.S. Presidential Election, Maria Villarroel
Theses and Dissertations
This dissertation examines how journalistic professionalism shaped news coverage of Latino-related issues during the 2024 U.S. presidential election across mainstream and Latino ethnic media outlets. In a polarized political environment, immigration and the “Latino vote” were not only central campaign issues but also sites of radicalized rhetoric that frequently targeted Latino communities and journalists. In this context, journalists were tasked with reporting on highly contentious, hostile narratives while adhering to professional norms. This study argues that these norms influenced how journalists selected, framed, and contextualized political rhetoric, and how media coverage further elevated immigration and Latino communities as key electoral …
Educational Inequality In Health Insurance Coverage Before And After The Affordable Care Act, Madelaine R. Adamich
Educational Inequality In Health Insurance Coverage Before And After The Affordable Care Act, Madelaine R. Adamich
Journal of Earth and Life Science
Health insurance and health care accessibility have historically been ongoing issues within the United States. Two key factors associated with the likelihood of an individual being insured are educational attainment and income. The 2010 Affordable Care Act (ACA), which has been the largest overhaul of health care in the US to date, aimed to reduce disparities in health insurance coverage and health care accessibility. My research analyzes the extent to which the ACA succeeded in reducing disparities related to educational attainment. To examine the ACA’s effects, I utilize the US Census Bureau’s American Community Survey data from 2008 and 2015 …
Contractual Democracy From Statehouse To School Board: Shifts In Legislation And School Board Authority In Kentucky, Hannah M. Edelen
Contractual Democracy From Statehouse To School Board: Shifts In Legislation And School Board Authority In Kentucky, Hannah M. Edelen
University of Kentucky Doctoral Dissertations
School boards have long been regarded as a cornerstone of American democracy, providing local governance over public education. While considerable scholarship highlights the increasing involvement of state and federal governments in education, relatively few studies examine with specificity how legislatures shape the local authority of these governance structures. This study investigates how the Kentucky State Legislature has influenced the authority of local school boards over three legislative sessions (2020–2022) and how board members perceive their evolving role. Using a multi-method approach and conceptualized in principal-agent theory, this research contributes to understanding how legislatures shape the governing responsibilities of school boards …
Soft Diplomacy Today...Global Influence Tomorrow, Michael Sutnick
Soft Diplomacy Today...Global Influence Tomorrow, Michael Sutnick
NYLS Law Review
@font-face {font-family:"Cambria Math"; panose-1:2 4 5 3 5 4 6 3 2 4; mso-font-charset:0; mso-generic-font-family:roman; mso-font-pitch:variable; mso-font-signature:-536870145 1107305727 0 0 415 0;}@font-face {font-family:Aptos; panose-1:2 11 0 4 2 2 2 2 2 4; mso-font-charset:0; mso-generic-font-family:swiss; mso-font-pitch:variable; mso-font-signature:536871559 3 0 0 415 0;}p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal {mso-style-unhide:no; mso-style-qformat:yes; mso-style-parent:""; margin-top:0in; margin-right:0in; margin-bottom:8.0pt; margin-left:0in; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:12.0pt; font-family:"Aptos",sans-serif; mso-ascii-font-family:Aptos; mso-ascii-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-fareast-font-family:Aptos; mso-fareast-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-hansi-font-family:Aptos; mso-hansi-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-bidi-font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-bidi-theme-font:minor-bidi; mso-font-kerning:1.0pt; mso-ligatures:standardcontextual;}.MsoChpDefault {mso-style-type:export-only; mso-default-props:yes; font-family:"Aptos",sans-serif; mso-ascii-font-family:Aptos; mso-ascii-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-fareast-font-family:Aptos; mso-fareast-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-hansi-font-family:Aptos; mso-hansi-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-bidi-font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-bidi-theme-font:minor-bidi;}.MsoPapDefault {mso-style-type:export-only; margin-bottom:8.0pt;}div.WordSection1 {page:WordSection1;}
The United States stands at a critical juncture where its global influence depends on adapting visa and tourism …
How Does Residing In A Battleground State Explain Republican Elites Election-Denial Rhetoric On Social Media?, Caedmon P. Brewer
How Does Residing In A Battleground State Explain Republican Elites Election-Denial Rhetoric On Social Media?, Caedmon P. Brewer
Theses and Dissertations--Political Science
After the 2020 election the U.S. democratic process was challenged by Republican challengers many of which were office holders including the president. Many of these criticisms were shared and perpetuated in online spaces What encourages elites to post on social media about election denialism? This paper attempts to partially answer the question by performing an analysis on Facebook posts made by 1,154 congressional candidates between 2023 and 2024 using a dictionary search method to flag posts for election denialism. I propose a theory that suggests the combination of political, financial, and media attention given to battleground states encourages candidates in …
Northern Luzon In A Taiwan Flashpoint: The Philippines’ Place In U.S. Strategy, Carson Keller
Northern Luzon In A Taiwan Flashpoint: The Philippines’ Place In U.S. Strategy, Carson Keller
Graduate Theses/Dissertations
While the defense of Taiwan from a potential invasion by the People’s Republic of China (PRC) has long been a topic of debate and scrutiny in U.S. strategic thinking, the role of its southern neighbor, the Philippines, has received far less attention. This thesis argues that northern Luzon would constitute key terrain in a cross-strait conflict and may become an early target of People’s Liberation Army (PLA) operations. Its proximity to Taiwan and position along the Luzon Strait, particularly the Bashi Channel, places it at the center of efforts to control access to the hypothetical battlespace. Drawing on PLA and …
Gene Editing And The Accessibility Of Bioterrorism: Rethinking Global Biosecurity In The Post-Covid-19 Era, Nicholas Morales
Gene Editing And The Accessibility Of Bioterrorism: Rethinking Global Biosecurity In The Post-Covid-19 Era, Nicholas Morales
Graduate Theses/Dissertations
COVID‑19 demonstrated how a single biological event can strain health systems, disrupt supply chains, undermine national security, and erode public trust. This shock occurred as biotechnology became dramatically more accessible: gene editing and synthetic biology tools once limited to specialized laboratories are now widely available through inexpensive equipment, open‑source data, and decentralized expertise.
This expanded access accelerates innovation but also broadens the threat landscape. The ability to reconstruct pathogens using publicly available sequences and mail‑order DNA shows that complex biological synthesis is no longer confined to state programs. These risks are amplified by opaque biotechnology activities in China, Russia, and …
Gender-Diverse State Legislative Candidates In The United States: Identity Used Strategically On Campaign Websites, Nicholas Mossman
Gender-Diverse State Legislative Candidates In The United States: Identity Used Strategically On Campaign Websites, Nicholas Mossman
Honors Theses
In this honors thesis, I evaluate how transgender, nonbinary, and other gender-diverse state legislative candidates in the United States use their campaign websites to communicate messages related to gender identity to voters, and the potential effects of communication on electoral success. I used a dataset of eighty-nine candidates between 2014 and 2024, and coded fifty-four candidate websites to measure how candidates describe their personal identity and communicate about issues related to gender identity, like LGBTQ+ nondiscrimination and gender-affirming care. While existing research evaluates how voters respond to LGBTQ+ candidates, this thesis examines how candidates potentially attract voters through their campaign …
“What Are The Security Issues Surrounding Cislunar Space And Lunar Resources? How Do Theories Of International Politics And Territory Apply To Those Issues?”, Ina Loka
Honors Theses
In the recent decades, cislunar space has attracted significant interest among the biggest spacefaring nations, Russia, China, and the United States. Cislunar space is no longer a distant subject solely associated with scientific studies. It has become a crucial domain in the conduct of military operations and its importance has been increasingly emphasised in these states’ military doctrines. In an environment where the intentions of other actors are hard to determine and where there is a high degree of uncertainty, these three states are ramping up their (counter)space capabilities in order to protect themselves from any adversarial attacks, and to …
The Palestine Papers: Words As Data, Michael J. Reimer Dr
The Palestine Papers: Words As Data, Michael J. Reimer Dr
Department of Political Science and Law Faculty Scholarship and Creative Works
The Palestine Papers are the internal documents of the Palestinian negotiators from 1999 -2011. This paper does a qualitative analysis of these documents.
Experiential Spillover In Public Views Of Police And Courts, Emma Henderson, Matthew Mettler, Jeffery J. Mondak, Mark Peffley
Experiential Spillover In Public Views Of Police And Courts, Emma Henderson, Matthew Mettler, Jeffery J. Mondak, Mark Peffley
Political Science Faculty Publications
Personal experiences with public officials influence how those officials are perceived. We question whether these experiential effects extend to other officials. If people draw on what they know to make inferences about unfamiliar evaluative targets, then interactions with one actor may shape evaluations of other independent actors. Focusing on police and courts, analyses of data from two surveys reveal that personal interactions with public officials produce spillover effects on appraisals of officials in different sectors. The findings indicate that experiential spillover constitutes an underappreciated force in public opinion, one that operates outside the control of the actors being evaluated.