Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Comparative and Foreign Law (5724)
- Human Rights Law (4940)
- International Trade Law (2869)
- International Humanitarian Law (2489)
- Environmental Law (2428)
-
- Criminal Law (2242)
- Military, War, and Peace (2050)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (1985)
- Constitutional Law (1744)
- Commercial Law (1519)
- Transnational Law (1401)
- Law and Society (1363)
- Law and Politics (1351)
- Law of the Sea (1205)
- Courts (1158)
- Dispute Resolution and Arbitration (1152)
- Intellectual Property Law (1147)
- Jurisprudence (1108)
- Political Science (1076)
- Law and Economics (1064)
- Natural Resources Law (980)
- Administrative Law (943)
- Water Law (900)
- Legal History (890)
- Jurisdiction (884)
- Health Law and Policy (883)
- International and Area Studies (880)
- Public Affairs, Public Policy and Public Administration (870)
- Institution
-
- American University Washington College of Law (2867)
- Case Western Reserve University School of Law (2050)
- Fordham Law School (1474)
- University of Georgia School of Law (1166)
- Southern Methodist University (1150)
-
- Maurer School of Law: Indiana University (1074)
- University of Michigan Law School (995)
- UC Law SF (952)
- Yeshiva University, Cardozo School of Law (900)
- Nova Southeastern University (879)
- U.S. Naval War College (874)
- Penn State Dickinson Law (776)
- Vanderbilt University Law School (731)
- University of Miami Law School (722)
- Universitas Indonesia (631)
- Northwestern Pritzker School of Law (624)
- University of Denver (581)
- Columbia Law School (571)
- University of the Pacific (567)
- University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law (554)
- Notre Dame Law School (436)
- University of North Carolina School of Law (427)
- Syracuse University (378)
- University of San Diego (372)
- BLR (368)
- Loyola University Chicago, School of Law (360)
- University of New Mexico (344)
- William & Mary Law School (342)
- Pace University (341)
- Seattle University School of Law (338)
- Keyword
-
- International law (2524)
- International Law (1947)
- Human rights (1492)
- United Nations (659)
- Law of Armed Conflict (656)
-
- Treaties (549)
- Law (484)
- United States (478)
- Environmental law (392)
- Accountability (374)
- Human Rights Law (371)
- Terrorism (363)
- China (353)
- Globalization (336)
- Jurisdiction (318)
- International Criminal Court (316)
- Use of Force (304)
- European Union (298)
- Sovereignty (295)
- Human Rights (284)
- Climate change (275)
- Operational Law (274)
- IFC (273)
- CAO (261)
- International (261)
- World bank (261)
- Law of the Sea (250)
- International Court of Justice (223)
- International criminal law (221)
- International trade (220)
- Publication Year
- Publication
-
- Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law (1554)
- Fordham International Law Journal (1304)
- Faculty Scholarship (1136)
- American University International Law Review (1014)
- UC Law SF International Law Review (890)
-
- Georgia Journal of International & Comparative Law (874)
- International Law Studies (874)
- ILSA Journal of International & Comparative Law (868)
- Law and Business Review of the Americas (660)
- Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law (641)
- Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies (603)
- Human Rights & Human Welfare (547)
- Global Business & Development Law Journal (501)
- Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business (453)
- Human Rights Brief (449)
- North Carolina Journal of International Law (427)
- Sustainable Development Law & Policy (413)
- Faculty Publications (405)
- Maryland Journal of International Law (404)
- University of Miami Inter-American Law Review (401)
- Penn State International Law Review (1982 - 2011) (392)
- Michigan Journal of International Law (390)
- Syracuse Journal of International Law and Commerce (376)
- ExpressO (358)
- San Diego International Law Journal (351)
- Scholarly Articles in Law Reviews & Journals (349)
- Articles (344)
- Scholarly Works (323)
- Penn State Journal of Law & International Affairs (2012 - Present) (312)
- Indonesian Journal of International Law (291)
- Publication Type
- File Type
Articles 3301 - 3330 of 31980
Full-Text Articles in International Law
International Employment Law, Sajai Singh, Deirdre Lynch
International Employment Law, Sajai Singh, Deirdre Lynch
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International Litigation, Aaron Marr Page, Jonathan I. Blackman, Carmine D. Boccuzzi, Theodore J. Folkman, Phillip B. Dye Jr., Matthew D. Slater, Howard S. Zelbo, Igor V. Timofeyev, Charles A. Patrizia, Joseph R. Profaizer
International Litigation, Aaron Marr Page, Jonathan I. Blackman, Carmine D. Boccuzzi, Theodore J. Folkman, Phillip B. Dye Jr., Matthew D. Slater, Howard S. Zelbo, Igor V. Timofeyev, Charles A. Patrizia, Joseph R. Profaizer
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International Family Law, Robert G. Spector, Melissa A. Kucinski
International Family Law, Robert G. Spector, Melissa A. Kucinski
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International Courts & Judicial Affairs, Sara Ochs, Paula Henin, Haydee Dijkstal, Kabir Duggal, Katelyn Horne, Michael Rodriguez, Katherine Maddox Davis
International Courts & Judicial Affairs, Sara Ochs, Paula Henin, Haydee Dijkstal, Kabir Duggal, Katelyn Horne, Michael Rodriguez, Katherine Maddox Davis
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International Arbitration, Sujey Herrera, Marcus Quintanilla, Martine Forneret, Emily Scherker, Jeffrey Rosenthal, James A. Egerton-Vernon, Richard Deutsch, Ranjan Agarwal, Félix Poggio, Rafael Pereyra Zorraquin, Joyce Fong, Dan Perera, Rong Gu, Helen Tang, Weina Ye, Timur Ibrahim Sen, Andrew White, Jayesh H, Dawn Yamane Hewett, Julianne Jaquith, Chelsea Pollard, Ibrahim Sattout, Adnan Gaafar, Myriam Khedair, James Boykin, Stijn Winters, Amanda Lee, Peter Ashford, Sabrina Janzik, Christina Nitsche, Gerard Meijer, Valerie Verberne, Markian Malskyy, Oksana Karel, Daryna Hrebeniuk, Keara A. Bergin, Christopher P. Denicola
International Arbitration, Sujey Herrera, Marcus Quintanilla, Martine Forneret, Emily Scherker, Jeffrey Rosenthal, James A. Egerton-Vernon, Richard Deutsch, Ranjan Agarwal, Félix Poggio, Rafael Pereyra Zorraquin, Joyce Fong, Dan Perera, Rong Gu, Helen Tang, Weina Ye, Timur Ibrahim Sen, Andrew White, Jayesh H, Dawn Yamane Hewett, Julianne Jaquith, Chelsea Pollard, Ibrahim Sattout, Adnan Gaafar, Myriam Khedair, James Boykin, Stijn Winters, Amanda Lee, Peter Ashford, Sabrina Janzik, Christina Nitsche, Gerard Meijer, Valerie Verberne, Markian Malskyy, Oksana Karel, Daryna Hrebeniuk, Keara A. Bergin, Christopher P. Denicola
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International Trade, Jonathan Babcock, Chloe Baldwin, Theodore P. Brackemyre, Sylvia Y. Chen, Laura .. El-Sabaawi, Cynthia C. Galvez, Geoffrey Goodale, Derick G. Holt, Elizabeth S. Lee, Usha Neelakantan, Molly O'Casey, Brittney Powell, Zachary Simmons
International Trade, Jonathan Babcock, Chloe Baldwin, Theodore P. Brackemyre, Sylvia Y. Chen, Laura .. El-Sabaawi, Cynthia C. Galvez, Geoffrey Goodale, Derick G. Holt, Elizabeth S. Lee, Usha Neelakantan, Molly O'Casey, Brittney Powell, Zachary Simmons
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International M&A And Joint Ventures, Steven De Schrijver, Micha Van Den Abeele, Jason Saltzman, Gordon Cameron, Alex Yong Hao, Xi Guo, Konstantinos Tsimaras, Harry Stamelos, Avikshit Moral, Neha Thakkar, Luigi Pavanello, Vassily Rudomino, Anton Dzhuplin, Mark Howard, Daniel Rosenberg, Paul Stone, Geoffrey M. Goodale
International M&A And Joint Ventures, Steven De Schrijver, Micha Van Den Abeele, Jason Saltzman, Gordon Cameron, Alex Yong Hao, Xi Guo, Konstantinos Tsimaras, Harry Stamelos, Avikshit Moral, Neha Thakkar, Luigi Pavanello, Vassily Rudomino, Anton Dzhuplin, Mark Howard, Daniel Rosenberg, Paul Stone, Geoffrey M. Goodale
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International Contracts Committee, William P. Johnson, Willem Den Hertog, Martin Aquilina, Samuel G. Wieczorek
International Contracts Committee, William P. Johnson, Willem Den Hertog, Martin Aquilina, Samuel G. Wieczorek
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
International Antitrust, Miguel Del Pino, Elizabeth Avery, Dilys Teng, Bruno Drago, Paola Pugliese, Milena Mundim, Adam S. Goodman, Simon Kupi, Peter Wang, Yizhe Zhang, Laurie-Anne Grelier, Peter Camesasca, Naval Satarawala Chopra, Aman Singh Sethi, Shigeyoshi Ezaki, Vassili Moussis, Kiyoko Yagami, Naoki Uemura, Youngjin Jung, Luke Shin, Hemi Lee, Lara Granville, Jasvinder Nakhwal, Jonathan Tickner, Lisl Dunlop, Shoshana Speiser
International Antitrust, Miguel Del Pino, Elizabeth Avery, Dilys Teng, Bruno Drago, Paola Pugliese, Milena Mundim, Adam S. Goodman, Simon Kupi, Peter Wang, Yizhe Zhang, Laurie-Anne Grelier, Peter Camesasca, Naval Satarawala Chopra, Aman Singh Sethi, Shigeyoshi Ezaki, Vassili Moussis, Kiyoko Yagami, Naoki Uemura, Youngjin Jung, Luke Shin, Hemi Lee, Lara Granville, Jasvinder Nakhwal, Jonathan Tickner, Lisl Dunlop, Shoshana Speiser
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
Export Controls And Economic Sanctions, Beau Barnes, John Boscariol, Randy Cook, Abigail Cotterill, Gwendolyn Jaramillo, Barbara Linney, Sarah Oliai, Timothy O'Toole, Christopher Stagg, Lawrence Ward
Export Controls And Economic Sanctions, Beau Barnes, John Boscariol, Randy Cook, Abigail Cotterill, Gwendolyn Jaramillo, Barbara Linney, Sarah Oliai, Timothy O'Toole, Christopher Stagg, Lawrence Ward
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
Customs Law, Rebecca Rodriguez
International Legal Developments Year In Review: 2018, Jason S. Palmer, Kimberly Y. W. Holst
International Legal Developments Year In Review: 2018, Jason S. Palmer, Kimberly Y. W. Holst
The Year in Review
No abstract provided.
Decolonizing The Corpus: A Queer Decolonial Re-Examination Of Gender In International Law's Origins, David Eichert
Decolonizing The Corpus: A Queer Decolonial Re-Examination Of Gender In International Law's Origins, David Eichert
Michigan Journal of International Law
This article builds upon queer feminist and decolonial/TWAIL interventions into the history of international law, questioning the dominant discourses about gender and sexual victimhood in the laws of armed conflict. In Part One, I examine how early European international law writers (re)produced binary and hierarchical ideas about gender in influential legal texts, discursively creating a world in which wartime violence only featured men and women in strictly defined roles (a construction which continues to influence the practice of law today). In Part Two, I decenter these dominant discourses by looking outside Europe, questioning what a truly “international” law would look …
Veterinary Reporting And Immunity Laws In The United States: How This Model Law Could Positively Impact National Veterinary Practices And International Animal Law, Rachel Al-Alami
Global Business Law Review
This Note highlights the importance of animal law, including its impact on human violence and international businesses involving animals. The issues in veterinary reporting of suspected animal abuse must be addressed, as it has a direct effect on exposing the link between animal violence and human violence. Each state is encouraged to adopt the legislation proposed by this Note; it aims to reform the laws surrounding veterinary reporting of suspected animal abuse, and it provides veterinary professionals with immunity for reporting in good faith. This Note discusses the background of animal law, including the current state of affairs for both …
Tax Harmony: The Promise And Pitfalls Of The Global Minimum Tax, Reuven Avi-Yonah, Young Ran (Christine) Kim
Tax Harmony: The Promise And Pitfalls Of The Global Minimum Tax, Reuven Avi-Yonah, Young Ran (Christine) Kim
Michigan Journal of International Law
The rise of globalization has become a double-edged sword for countries seeking to implement a beneficial tax policy. On one hand, there are increased opportunities for attracting foreign capital and the benefits that increased jobs and tax revenue brings to a society. However, there is also much more tax competition among countries to attract foreign capital and investment. As tax competition has grown, effective corporate tax rates have continued to be cut, creating a “race-to-the-bottom” issue.
In 2021, 137 countries forming the OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework on BEPS passed a major milestone in reforming international tax by successfully introducing the framework …
Let Them Eat Rights: Re-Framing The Food Insecurity Problem Using A Rights-Based Approach, Benedict Sheehy, Ying Chen
Let Them Eat Rights: Re-Framing The Food Insecurity Problem Using A Rights-Based Approach, Benedict Sheehy, Ying Chen
Michigan Journal of International Law
Food insecurity is a global issue. Large parts of the global population are unable to feed themselves adequately with hundreds of millions of people suffering from hunger and malnutrition. This problem is recognized widely by governments, industry and civil society and is usually understood using one of three approaches or frames: a basic production problem solved by technology and increased industrialization of agricultural, and an economic problem solved by economic growth and a commercial problem resolved by expanding markets. Much of the discussion and policy advice is based on the premise that hunger is primarily a wealth issue and, that …
Asylum-Seekers Are Not Bananas Either: Limitations On Transferring Asylum-Seekers To Third Countries, Tally Kritzman-Amir
Asylum-Seekers Are Not Bananas Either: Limitations On Transferring Asylum-Seekers To Third Countries, Tally Kritzman-Amir
Michigan Journal of International Law
Despite the similarities between the movement of people and the movement of goods, many developed nations have maintained high barriers to migration even as barriers to trade have fallen sharply. However, as Jennifer Gordon points out, both bilateral and multilateral treaties governing migration have proliferated within this weaker global patchwork of regulation. For example, the ability of developed states to gain concessions on other matters such as trade or investment has led to the proliferation multilateral agreements, while bilateral agreements have arisen due to a desire to refrain from integrating migrant workers in destination states.
This paper focuses on a …
Implications Of The Selection Of Islamic Law In European Private International Law, Grace Brody
Implications Of The Selection Of Islamic Law In European Private International Law, Grace Brody
Michigan Journal of International Law
The English Court of Appeal in Beximco v. Shamil Bank chose to apply only English law in a breach of contract case, even though the choice of law clause in the contract at issue also selected Islamic law. The court cited three main reasons for this decision. First, article 3(1) of the Rome I Convention “contemplates” that a contract can be governed only by the “law of a country,” and there is no mention of the application of a “non-national system of law such as Sharia law.” Second, Islamic law does not consist of “principles of law” but instead a …
Litigating Terror In The Sinai After The Egyptian Spring Revolution: Should States Be Liable To Foreign Investors For Failure To Prevent Terrorist Attacks?, Robert Howse, Amin R. Yacoub
Litigating Terror In The Sinai After The Egyptian Spring Revolution: Should States Be Liable To Foreign Investors For Failure To Prevent Terrorist Attacks?, Robert Howse, Amin R. Yacoub
Michigan Journal of International Law
The ambiguity of the due diligence standard of the Full Protection and Security obligation in investment treaties persists to this day. A recent ICSID tribunal found a developing state liable for breaching the Full Protection and Security obligation due to its inability to protect a foreign investment against terrorist attacks in a remote deserted area. In this article, we analytically criticize the Ampal v. Egypt arbitral award against the comprehensive factual matrix behind the case. Based on our criticism of Ampal, we argue that developing states should not be liable for failing to prevent or stop terrorist attacks under the …
Pacta Sunt Servanda And Empire: A Critical Examination Of The Evolution, Invocation, And Application Of An International Law Axiom, Jiang Zhifeng
Pacta Sunt Servanda And Empire: A Critical Examination Of The Evolution, Invocation, And Application Of An International Law Axiom, Jiang Zhifeng
Michigan Journal of International Law
In public international law, pacta sunt servanda is the foundational principle that international agreements are binding on treaty parties and must be kept. Insufficient attention, however, has been given to the role played by this international law axiom in organizing and shaping the international legal order. Accordingly, this note undertakes a critical historical analysis of how pacta sunt servanda was, and continues to be, applied as a legal basis and used as an argumentative method for the formation and maintenance of empire despite its conceptual evolution across time. Importantly, it does not argue that pacta sunt servanda should be abandoned …
Due Diligence In A Pandemic: State Accountability For Covid-19 Under International Law, Andrea Cocchini, Gonzalo Villalta Puig
Due Diligence In A Pandemic: State Accountability For Covid-19 Under International Law, Andrea Cocchini, Gonzalo Villalta Puig
Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies
The coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic has tested the response capacity of the international community. This article analyses the due diligence principle and the various international legal instruments that restate it in an assessment of the possible actions that states could have taken to avoid or, at least, contain the initial outbreak of the pandemic.
International Investment Governance And Achieving A Just Zero-Carbon Future, Ella Merrill, Martin Dietrich Brauch, Lisa E. Sachs
International Investment Governance And Achieving A Just Zero-Carbon Future, Ella Merrill, Martin Dietrich Brauch, Lisa E. Sachs
Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment
As developing countries continue to be the most negatively affected by climate change and the energy transition, it is increasingly critical that they receive foreign direct investment and financial support to build climate resilience, adapt to climate impacts, avoid carbon lock-in and fossil fuel dependence, and leverage their rich endowments of renewable and extractive resources to prepare for the zero-carbon future.
There is a disconnect and fundamental misalignment between international investment law and the international climate change regime, comprising the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the Paris Agreement. Existing investment treaties—including their centerpiece, investor–state dispute settlement …
Supporting Good Governance Of Extractive Industries In Politically Hostile Settings: Rethinking Approaches And Strategies, Leila Kazemi, Ricardo Soares De Oliveira
Supporting Good Governance Of Extractive Industries In Politically Hostile Settings: Rethinking Approaches And Strategies, Leila Kazemi, Ricardo Soares De Oliveira
Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment
This discussion paper is the product of a workshop entitled “Supporting Good Governance of Extractive Industries in Politically Hostile Settings: A View from Sub-Saharan Africa,” organized by the Oxford Martin School (OMS) Programme on African Governance and the Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment (CCSI) and supporting research. The workshop brought together global and local researchers and practitioners with a wide range of experience with extractives governance, particularly, though not exclusively, in the sub-Saharan African region. The meeting built on prior research and discussions held as part of CCSI’s project on the Politics of Extractive Industries, dedicated to supporting the field …
A New Chapter In China's Stance On Labour Protection? An Assessment Of The China–Eu Cai, Yueming Yan
A New Chapter In China's Stance On Labour Protection? An Assessment Of The China–Eu Cai, Yueming Yan
Research Collection Yong Pung How School Of Law
China overhauled its pre-existing image of being insufficiently friendly to sustainable development in international investment agreements (IIAs) with its sweeping, specific, and strong commitments to labour rights protection in the Comprehensive Agreement on Investment (CAI) recently concluded with the European Union. This article provides an assessment of these labour provisions and examines their impact on China’s national, regional, and global stances on labour protection. Firstly, it analyses the features and purposes of different types of labour provision and the integrated mechanism for settling disputes on labour issues. This article then identifies the gap between China’s commitments under the CAI and …
Regional Immigration Enforcement, Fatma Marouf
Regional Immigration Enforcement, Fatma Marouf
Faculty Scholarship
Regional disparities in immigration enforcement have existed for decades, yet they remain largely overlooked in immigration law scholarship. This Article theorizes that bottom-up pressure from states and localities, combined with top-down pressures and policies established by the President, produce these regional disparities. The Article then provides an empirical analysis demonstrating enormous variations in how Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s twenty-four field offices engage in federal enforcement around the United States. By analyzing data related to detainers, arrests, removals, and detention across these field offices, the Article demonstrates substantial differences between field offices located in sanctuary and anti-sanctuary regions, as well as …
Feminism And The Birth Of Sexual Crime As International Crime And The Challenge Of Its Implementation In The Future, Zunnuraeni Zunnuraeni, Rehulina Tarigan, Erlies Septiana Nurbani, Aisyah Wardatul Jannah
Feminism And The Birth Of Sexual Crime As International Crime And The Challenge Of Its Implementation In The Future, Zunnuraeni Zunnuraeni, Rehulina Tarigan, Erlies Septiana Nurbani, Aisyah Wardatul Jannah
Indonesian Journal of International Law
The existence of international sexual crimes in international court jurisprudence and the international law instruments have evolve as an extensive crime from the abundance crime of outrages upon personal dignity, yet still have to front some challenges to attain triumph in its enforcement. This article aims to observe the sexual crimes as international crime in some aspect, namely, its development and the contribution of feminism, the challenges on the law enforcement against international criminal law and the position of feminism in addressing those challenges. In every stage of sexual crimes evolution as international crimes, feminism hold important contribution. Their impact …
States Responsibility To Eradicate Violence Against Women Through The Due Diligence Framework In Human Rights: A Review Of Protection And Punishment In The Case Of Indonesia, Zenny R. Dewantary, Noraida Endut
States Responsibility To Eradicate Violence Against Women Through The Due Diligence Framework In Human Rights: A Review Of Protection And Punishment In The Case Of Indonesia, Zenny R. Dewantary, Noraida Endut
Indonesian Journal of International Law
In 2016, Zarizana Abdul Aziz and Janine Moussa developed the ‘Due Diligence Framework of States Responsibility in the Elimination of Violence against Women (VAW)’, based on a study their team conducted worldwide beginning in 2011. The framework establishes five domains of due diligence in assessing states responsibility (the “5Ps”) in eliminating VAW: prevention; protection; prosecution; punishment of perpetrators, and provision of redress and reparation for victims/survivors. States are responsible to uphold human rights protection for all people, particularly in eliminating VAW without any discrimination. Indonesia constituted protection measures through laws pertaining to VAW but there are barriers in effectively protecting …
Necessity Of Establishing A Un Specialized Agency For Protection Of Gender Equality, Maziyar Shokrani, Nirmala Many
Necessity Of Establishing A Un Specialized Agency For Protection Of Gender Equality, Maziyar Shokrani, Nirmala Many
Indonesian Journal of International Law
A number of recent global issues such as COVID, rise of the Taliban in Afghanistan, inter-state and intra-state conflicts, and gender inequality in Iran show the unprecedented violence against women and other disadvantaged segments of the societies around the globe despite the restless efforts of existing organizations such as the UN Women to protect women’s right, and in broader sense promote gender equality. The lack of efficiency is partly due to its institutional capacities e.g. lacking independence, founding treaty, law-making/treaty making powers and, developed institutional structures and enforcement powers. This article investigates the shortcomings of the UN Women in fulfilling …
Indonesia’S Extraterritorial Obligation To Protect The Human Rights Of Individuals From Transboundary Haze Pollution, Yogi Bratajaya, Diajeng Wulan Christianti, Ahmad Gusman Catur Siswandi
Indonesia’S Extraterritorial Obligation To Protect The Human Rights Of Individuals From Transboundary Haze Pollution, Yogi Bratajaya, Diajeng Wulan Christianti, Ahmad Gusman Catur Siswandi
Indonesian Journal of International Law
Ever since the late 1980s, forest fires located in Indonesia have resulted in haze pollution which engulfs the Southeast Asian region almost annually. This paper argues that Indonesia is extraterritorially obligated to ensure the human rights of individuals outside its territory as a result of its failure to prevent the haze pollution. It analyzes the extraterritorial application of Article 2(1) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), arguing that an individual whose human rights have been adversely affected by transboundary environmental harm is deemed ‘subject to the jurisdiction’ of the originating state. Applying this interpretation, individuals located …