Intellectual Property Law Commons^™

Statutory And Constitutional Problems With Judicially-Imposed Patent-Claim Limitations, Sloane Kyrazis

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

The safety valve standard articulated in In re Katz Interactive Call Processing Litigation is at odds with the provisions of the U.S. Patent Act and violates constitutional due process. Without requisite constitutional protections and those protections guaranteed by the U.S. Patent Act, patentees in complex modern patent litigation are at risk of having their patent rights deprived from contrary to the congressional intent articulated in the statute and without requisite process. The courts must balance their need for efficient administration of the law in patent cases by implementing equitable measures to ensure that patentees’ rights are not trampled on. Additionally, …

John Hemings' Monticello And Poplar Forest, J. Wesley Giglio

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

A discussion of John Hemings' creative architectural contributions to Monticello and Poplar Forest, Thomas Jefferson's Virginia Estates. Author argues that Hemings, an enslaved person and a master carpenter, made vital and creative contributions to the building of the two estates which merit legal recognition. Author discusses how legal ideas about moral rights and statutory protections in the Architectural Works Copyright Protection Act could be adapted to cure a historica and representative injustice.

The Best Laid Plans: How Dmca Sec. 1201 Went Awry, Smothering Competition And Creating Giants,And Where We Go Now, Tyler Fabbri

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

In 1998, Congress passed the Digital Millennium Copyright Act with the express intention of protecting the intellectual property of copyright holders from the growing threats of digital piracy and information sharing brought about by an increasingly digital society.

Among the law’s many provisions is §1201, which works to prohibit circumnavigation of digital protections copyright holders may put on protected works—in essence, innovators or competitors would be unable to develop technology or programs to bypass security measures put into place by primary creators. While this provision seems facially reasonable, it has effectively served as a means to quash adversarial interoperability.

Adversarial …

Secrets, Sovereigns, And States: Analyzing State Government's Liability For Trade Secret Misappropriation, Grant Cole

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Trade secrets are many business's most valuable assets. From Google’s algorithm to Coca-Cola’s secret recipe, trade secrets are becoming increasingly important to businesses and our economy. What if state governments could simply misappropriate these trade secrets without liability? Sadly, this situation is not uncommon. Many state governments have misappropriated trade secrets with virtual impunity. This is because the doctrine of sovereign immunity protects state governments from liability. This leaves businesses that deal with the government without a way to recover for the misappropriation of their trade secrets. This result is especially damaging because once a trade secret is no longer …

Cross-Jurisdictional Analysis Of Damage Awards In Copyright Infringement Cases, Ioana Vasiu, Lucian Vasiu

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Copyright infringement is a widespread phenomenon that produces massive financial losses to stakeholders. Based on an extensive examination of damage awards in copyright infringement cases from the United States, Canada, Singapore, and Italy, this article proposes a comprehensive cross-jurisdictional analysis. The analysis regards types, factors, methodologies, and arguments. This article's findings can be used to adjust the provisions regarding damage awards, to improve the litigation of such cases, to elaborate educational materials, for professional programs or law school clinics, and to develop better prevention policies. The proposed improvements could lead to a more unified approach to damage awards, increase the …

The Impact Of Implementing A 25-Year Reversion/Termination Right In Canada, Paul J. Heald

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

No abstract provided.

Evidence-Based Patent Damages, Taorui Guan

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

No abstract provided.

Don't Go Breakin' My (3d Bioprinted) Heart: Dissecting Patentability And Regulation Of 3d Bioprinted Organs, Anna Marie Whitacre

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

In light of the growing realism of 3D bioprinted organs, legal issues arising from these concerns can easily bleed into our society. This bleeding demands exploration. Should 3D bioprinted organs be regulated as natural organs or as medical devices? Are 3D bioprinted organs patentable? What happens if a 3D bioprinted organ is subject to a successful patent infringement suit? Does the recipient face a Repo Men fate?

The beginning of this note dissects the scientific underpinnings of 3D bioprinted organs. Part II explores statutory authority and controlling, or otherwise persuasive, case law that pertains to subject-matter patentability. Current rights associated …

Feeling Cute, Might [Have To] Delete Later: Defending Against The Modern Day Copyright Troll, Austin Joseph

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

The age-old clash between celebrities and paparazzi has reached a new high. With the trend moving towards the monetization of social media, evolution in mobile camera technology, and lighting-fast sharing capabilities, the need for paparazzi decreases with each year. Because paparazzi want to remain desirable, the infamous conduct of “copyright trolling” is sweeping the intellectual property scene. “Copyright trolling” is the act of searching social media and suing multiple celebrities when the celebrity post a photo of themselves without first paying the licensing fee. Within this year alone, multiple celebrities like Rebel Wilson, Ariana Grande, and Liam Hemsworth have been …

Shockingly Evil: The Cruel Invasive Appropriation And Exploitation Of Victims' Rights Of Publicity In The True Crime Genre, Ashton Williams

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

America's obsession with the true crime genre has evoked an explosion in volume and variety of recreations of the country's most prolific crimes. The never-ending re-enactments constantly barrage the victims and family members of those who suffered at the hands of the killers. The nightmare of the crimes they already endured never cease, as victims are forced to relive their worst torments via movies, television shows, and podcasts discussing the crimes. Producers and directors are currently free to appropriate and capitalize off of individuals' images without so much as a consultation. From dramatic depictions by actors to docuseries evaluations of …

"You Got Too Much Dip On Your Chip!" How Stagnant Copyright Law Is Stifling Creativity, Taylor Bussey

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Over time, our concept of what qualifies as an author has changed–specifically with the dominance of the internet. Tangentially, our idea of what it means to be a joint author has changed. What once would have required physical proximity now can be accomplished via the internet in a matter of seconds. Authors from all around the globe can collaborate. Geographic limitations present virtually no constraint on the number of individuals that can contribute to a work. Human creativity, however, has remained the same. When creating, authors naturally draw on their human experience. Without tailoring modern copyright law to modern trends …

The Economic Burdens Of Life: Trade Secrecy And The Insulin Pricing Crisis In The United States, Emily Hanson

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Approximately one in every ten Americans lives with diabetes, a condition that inhibits the body’s ability to regulate blood sugar. The majority of those with diabetes rely on insulin injections to control the condition and avoid the dire health consequences that can quickly result from insufficient insulin. The price of insulin has risen 700% in the past two decades, with burdensome if not disastrous consequences for individual patients and for public health more generally. Federal law provides a pathway for manufacturers of follow-on pharmaceuticals, including insulin, to obtain abbreviated approval from the FDA without repeating costly clinical trials by showing …

The Principles Of Esports Engagement: A Universal Code Of Conduct, Yen-Shyang Tseng

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Section I of this article provides a brief background of esports and the ESA. Section II states the four principles of esports engagement announced by the ESA. Section III applies these four principles by reviewing specific problems that have plagued the video game and esports industries, such as toxicity (especially towards women and other minorities), swatting, cheating, and other malicious behavior. This article concludes by discussing implementation of a universal code of conduct in esports based on the principles of esports engagement.

On Equipoise, Knowledge, And Speculation: A Unified Theory Of Pleading Under The Defend Trade Secrets Act -- Jurisdiction, Identification, Misappropriation, And Inevitable Disclosure, William Lynch Schaller

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

No abstract provided.

Table Of Contents

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

No abstract provided.

Hocus Pocus: The Magic Within Trade Secret Law, Marianna L. Markley

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

This Note will discuss why trade secret law is the most appropriate form of IP protection for magicians seeking to protect their secrets. First it will discuss the background information on IP protections offered to magicians, specifically within copyright, patent, and trade secret law. After examining previous cases in which magicians have sought protection for their work using each of these different types of IP laws, it will then analyze why trade secret law is the best form of IP protection for magicians.

"Westerngeco" And The Patent Act: An Analysis Of The Patent Act And The Presumption Against Extraterritoriality, Samuel Tanner Lowe

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

The goal of this Note will be to take up where the Court left off in WesternGeco LLC v. ION Geophysical Corp. and provide an adequate answer to the question of how the presumption against extraterritoriality affects patents. First, I will provide background on the history of patents, the presumption against extraterritoriality, and the WesternGeco LLC case. Next, I will contend that the Patent Act does not rebut the presumption against extraterritoriality. In light of this interpretation, I will argue that Congress should not rewrite the law so as to rebut the presumption because to do so would extend the …

It's Scandalous! -- Limiting Profane Trademark Registrations After "Tam" And "Brunetti", Gary Myers

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Over the course of the last two years, the Supreme Court has engaged in a long-overdue assessment of the constitutionality of federal trademark law prohibitions on the registration of offensive marks. In its unanimous 2017 decision in Matal v. Tam, the Court held that the disparagement clause is a content-based provision that violates the First Amendment. In 2019, the Court in Iancu v. Brunetti held that the refusal to register the mark “FUCT” on grounds that it was immoral or scandalous would also violate the First Amendment. These cases offered an opportunity for the Court to clarify the proper role …

Table Of Contents

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

No abstract provided.

The Ip Of Ipas, Stephen Wolfson, Brian Roth, Chase Scott, Dustin Watts, Charles Hicks, Shivani Patel

Other Colloquium, Conferences, and Symposia

Hosted by the Journal of Intellectual Property Law, this panel brought Brian Roth (Southern Brewing Co.), Chase Scott (Taylor, Feil, Harper & Lumsden, P.C.), and Dustin Watts (Terrapin Beer Co.) together with Stephen Wolfson (Research & Copyright Services Librarian, UGA Law School) and students from the Journal of Intellectual Property Law to discuss how breweries are navigating intellectual property issues. Free koozies to commemorate the event were distributed.

Extraordinary Ideas Now Ordinary Income: Incentives Created By The Tax Cut And Jobs Act's New Treatment Of Self-Created Intellectual Property, Savannah Story

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

No abstract provided.

Fighting The Faceless Foe Known As The Online Trademark Counterfeiter: Forum Shopping Tactics In The Digital Age, Chelsea R. Feagle

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

This Note proceeds in two main parts. Part II provides a background for understanding trademark counterfeiting claims and remedies. It first examines the federal trademark protections alongside the state trademark protections and details the way in which they differ. Part II then breaks down the number of online trademark counterfeit cases filed in the United States and notes the percentage of those cases which are filed predominately in three federal district courts. Because it is difficult to comprehensively track this data, the principle import of the referenced statistical breakdown should be understood only as attempting to draw general conclusions from …

The Defend Trade Secrets Act And Foreign Theft: The Application Of The Act To Extraterritorial Misappropriation, John Dustin Hawkins

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

This Note explores the evolution of federal trade secret law in the United States, particularly the enactment of the Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016. Part II discusses the legislative history of the Act, as well as key provisions and definitions of the Act, which are critical when considering the DTSA's extraterritorial application. Additionally, this Note considers the tests used by courts to determine extraterritorial application in other areas of U.S. law. Part III explains why a uniformly-applied balancing test would best serve the courts in determining the extraterritorial application of the DTSA to reach foreign conduct.

The Eu Copyright Directive: "Fit For The Digital Age" Or Finishing It?, Andrew Tyner

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Since its proposal in 2016, the Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on Copyright in the Digital Single Market ("the Directive" or "the Copyright Directive") has been controversial. While the Directive was rooted in good intentions, intended to "improv[e] the bargaining position ... and the control rightsholders have on the use of their copyright-protected content" in the digital space,' critics loudly proclaimed it as the death of the internet as we know it. Notable architects and pioneers of the Internet, including Tim Berners- Lee (inventor of the World Wide Web) and Jimmy Wales (founder of Wikipedia), penned …

The Ip Of Ipas: A Look Into Trademark Infringement In The Craft Beer Industry, Shivani Patel

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Alcohol isn't just a mind-altering drink: It has been a prime mover of human culture from the beginning, fueling the development of arts, language, and religion."' Alcohol production and consumption can be traced to civilizations dating back thousands of years all around the world, and it has become so essential to our society that experts have gone on to joke that humans should be called "Homo imbibens." Within the current alcohol industry, two essential qualities that are becoming more common are creativity and variety.

Alcohol has become a defining aspect of human culture and our sense of society. It has …

Who Owns The Law? Why We Must Restore Public Ownership Of Legal Publishing, Leslie A. Street, David R. Hansen

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

Each state has its own method for officially publishing the law. This article looks at the history of legal publishing for the fifty states before looking at how legal publishing even in moving to electronic publishing may not ensure public access to the law. The article addresses barriers to free access to the law in electronic publishing including copyright, contract law, and potentially, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. The article concludes with prescriptions for how different actors, including state governments, publishers, libraries, and others can ensure robust public access to the law moving forward.

Table Of Contents

Journal of Intellectual Property Law

No abstract provided.

U.S. Supreme Court I.P. Cases, 1810-2019: Measuring & Mapping The Citation Networks, Joseph S. Miller

Scholarly Works

Intellectual property law in the United States, though shaped by key statutes, has long been a common-law field to a great degree. Many decades of decisional law flesh out the meaning of broad-textured, sparely worded statutes. Given the key roles of patent law and copyright law, both federal, the Supreme Court of the United States is i.p. law’s leading apex court. What are the major topical currents in the Supreme Court’s i.p. cases, both now and over the course of the Court’s work? This study uses network-analysis tools to measure and map the entirety of the Court’s i.p. jurisprudence. It …

The Flavor Of Open Access Over Rice: Tech Transforms & Transmutes Ed, Rachel S. Evans

Articles, Chapters and Online Publications

Rachel Evans crafts a short history of Open Educational Resources and provides a list of tools and other sites for exploring and creating Open Access Textbooks and other materials. The post also recounts a recent Open Access event at UGA Law Library and compares the perils of generationally divided views on access to quality yet affordable education to the clash of tradition and modernity in a particular film The Flavor of Green Tea Over Rice. To close the piece she encourages members to participate in the recently shared ALL-SIS (Academic Law Libraries Special Interest Section) survey about Open Educational Resources …

Code Revision Commission V. Public.Resource.Org And The Fight Over Copyright Protection For Annotations And Commentary, David E. Shipley

Georgia Law Review

This Article analyzes Code Revision Commission v. Public.Resource.Org, a 2018 decision in which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit applied the public edicts doctrine and held that Georgia’s copyright on the annotations, commentary, and analyses in the Official Code of Georgia Annotated is invalid. The U.S. Supreme Court granted Georgia’s Petition for a Writ of Certiorari on June 24, 2019. About a third of states claim copyright in the annotations to their codes, so the potential impact of this decision is substantial.

This Article’s thesis is that the Eleventh Circuit was wrong and should be reversed. It …