Comparative and Foreign Law Commons^™

The Dysfunctional Progeny Of Eugenics: Autonomy Gone Awol, Matthew D. Martin Iii

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article examines the ethical and legal implications of state-mandated sterilization, tracing its evolution from eugenic practices in the early 20th century to modern forms of reproductive control. It argues that such policies, whether justified by eugenics or population control, consistently violate human rights and raise significant moral concerns. The analysis critiques the Supreme Court's decision in Buck v. Bell as a landmark example of judicial endorsement of pseudoscientific discrimination, while also exploring contemporary issues like prenatal genetic testing and coercive family planning policies.

Can The Australian Model Be Applied To U.S. Moral Rights Legislation?, Joan Pattarozzi

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note argues that the U.S. should adopt a more comprehensive framework for moral rights in copyright law, drawing inspiration from Australia's balanced approach, to better protect authors' personal and reputational interests while addressing concerns about market disruption and litigation. It highlights the U.S.'s current emphasis on economic rights, its limited implementation of moral rights under the Visual Artists Rights Act (VARA), and the potential for Australia's model to serve as a template for U.S. legislation.

A Final Plea For "Death With Dignity": A Proposal For The Modification And Approval Of The Assisted Dying For The Terminally Ill Bill In The United Kingdom, Lindsay Pfeffer

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

Increasing respect for personal autonomy in health-related decision-making, major alterations in the assisted suicide laws of other European countries (especially Switzerland and the Netherlands), and the rising popularity of Swiss suicide clinics have introduced the need for the British legislature to reevaluate the United Kingdom's stance on assisted suicide and to adjust medical practices to contemporary social needs. The introduction and obstruction of a bill in the House of Lords for the legalization of physician-assisted suicide for terminally ill individuals has provoked opposition from the British medical community and serious concern on behalf of members of the government regarding the …

Tearing Down The Great Wall: The New Generation Investment Treaties Of The People's Republic Of China, Stephan W. Schill

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The People's Republic of China (PRC or China) has emerged as the world's premier destination of foreign investment in the developing world and is continuously strengthening its position as a source of outward foreign investment, notably in Asia and Africa. In this context, the PRC has concluded over 110 bilateral investment treaties (BITs) that grant protection against expropriation and establish other standards of treatment for foreign investors in China and Chinese investors abroad. While the PRC was originally hesitant regarding international investment protection, the country started, beginning in the late 1990s, entering into new generation BITs that break with her …

The Case For A Flat-Earth Law School, Erik M. Jensen

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The essay argues against the increasing emphasis on globalization in legal education, advocating for a return to a focus on American law. It critiques the trend of prioritizing international, transnational, and comparative law, asserting that this shift undermines the foundational knowledge of domestic law necessary for effective legal practice. The author contends that while international law has its place, it should not overshadow the core principles of American law, which remain central to the majority of legal careers.

Selective Prosecution In Russia - Myth Or Reality?, Yelina Kvurt

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the issue of selective prosecution, focusing on the case of Mikhail Khodorkovsky, and argues that the Russian legal system lacks an explicit defense against such practices, which violate constitutional guarantees of equality before the law. It advocates for the adoption of a legal standard to address selective prosecution, drawing parallels with the U.S. legal framework while acknowledging the need to adapt it to Russia's unique judicial context.

Reforming Federal Personal Injury Litigation By Incorporation Of The Procedural Innovations Of Scotland And Ireland: An Analysis And Proposal, Daniel H. Erskine

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

Federal procedure has embraced the referral of civil cases outside the court system to alternative dispute resolution. This article argues that by utilizing courts to settle cases through civil procedure, courts realize their central role in ensuring the quality of settlements produced through the judicial administration of justice. The purpose of this article is to provide litigants with an optional procedure to expeditiously resolve federal personal injury cases. The system proposed in this article incorporates Scottish and Irish civil procedural reforms into a coherent method for judicial officers to declare the settlement value of a personal injury action without referring …

Assessing The Rule Of Law In Russia, Kathryn Hendley

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The mainstream scholarly literature and the mass media agree that Russia has made little progress in moving toward the "rule of law." Their negative assessment of the value of law in Russia is buttressed by a recent series of high-profile cases in which the results were clearly manipulated by the Kremlin. This article argues that such cases are aberrations and should not be viewed as reflective of the capacity of the Russian legal system. It documents the profound institutional reforms undertaken over the past two decades. Judged on those terms, it has surely moved closer to the ideal of the …

Rock, Paper, Scissors, Trademark? A Comparative Analysis Of Motion As A Feature Of Trademarks In The United States And Europe, Lesley Matty

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

Motion trademarks, or motion marks, represent a unique form of nontraditional trademarks that use movement to distinguish goods and services. Despite their recognition in the U.S. and Europe, motion marks face significant challenges in registration and enforcement due to limited case law and unclear protection standards. This note explores the legal and practical complexities surrounding motion marks, advocating for improved registration processes and alternative legal strategies, such as dilution claims, to enhance their protection.

Medical Torture: End Of Life Decision-Making In The United Kingdom And United States, Jon D. Feldhammer

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the legal and ethical challenges surrounding end-of-life medical decisions in the United States and the United Kingdom, highlighting the failure of both countries to effectively implement patients' end-of-life plans. It argues that the current legal frameworks in both nations often lead to prolonged, painful, and futile medical treatments, violating patient dignity and human rights. The analysis critiques the lack of consensus on medical futility and proposes a legislative model to balance patient autonomy, physician discretion, and ethical medical practice.

Justice & Foreign Affairs: Taking The European Neighbourhood Partner Countries To The European Court Of Justice, Lior Zemer, Sharon Pardo

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article argues that the European Union (EU) should extend the jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) to cover disputes arising from agreements with Neighborhood Partner Countries (NPC) under the European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP). This extension is essential for upholding the EU's constitutional principles, ensuring judicial review, and maintaining the coherence of EU external relations. The authors advocate for the ECJ as the most suitable judicial forum to address these disputes, emphasizing its role in reinforcing the EU's legal identity and capacity building.

Who Will Control Frankenstein?: The Korean Chaebol's Corporate Governance, Jeong Seo

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

In a chaebol, because a dominant family exercises control with only a small equity-holding, a sharp disparity exists between cashflow rights and voting rights. The controller reduces managerial agency costs but creates his own agency costs. Furthermore, the disparity exacerbates the controller's agency costs. Outsider shareholders' voting rights are ineffectual in eradicating this problem. Therefore, external monitoring devices over the chaebol controller are required.

Korea has relied on government regulation-including attempts to change chaebols' ownership structures-to address this problem. Unfortunately, without well-functioning capital markets, the regulation has proved ineffective. As observed in the SK scandal, a market for …

Designs For Immunity: A Comparison Of The Criminal Prosecution Of United States Presidents & Italian Prime Ministers, Brianne Biggiani

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the differing approaches of the United States and Italy in granting criminal prosecution immunity to their leaders, emphasizing the role of institutional strength and historical context. It argues that while the U.S. policy of temporary presidential immunity is justifiable due to its robust checks and balances, Italy's weaker governance structure and history of corruption make similar immunity measures inappropriate. The analysis highlights the importance of tailoring legal frameworks to a nation's specific political and cultural conditions.

Numerical Comparative Law: Do We Need Statistical Evidence In Law In Order To Reduce Complexity?, Mathias M. Siems

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article explores the use of numerical methods in comparative law, questioning whether statistical approaches can effectively simplify legal complexity without oversimplification. It examines both the potential benefits and drawbacks of quantifying legal systems, arguing that while numerical methods can enhance practical utility, they must be used cautiously to avoid neglecting legal complexity and contextual factors.

Globalization & Law: Beyond Traditional Methodology Of Comparative Legal Studies And An Example From Private International Law, Fabio Morosini

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article explores the impact of globalization on comparative legal studies and private international law, arguing that traditional methodologies in comparative law must evolve to address the challenges posed by globalization. It emphasizes the need for interdisciplinary approaches, particularly incorporating economic analysis, to better understand and adapt to the changing legal landscape. The analysis focuses on the European Union as a case study, demonstrating how European Community law influences the private international law of its member states and advocating for methodological innovations to maintain the relevance of comparative legal studies in a globalized world.

Sec Hedge Fund Regulatory Implications On Asian Emerging Markets: Bottom Line Or Bust, Sherry M. Shore

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the dual role of hedge funds as both contributors to financial crises and potential drivers of economic growth, emphasizing the need for balanced regulatory approaches that mitigate systemic risks while harnessing their benefits. It highlights the challenges of implementing effective regulation, particularly in emerging markets, and critiques the SEC's recent regulatory measures as potentially counterproductive. The analysis underscores the importance of understanding the structural and economic conditions that facilitate hedge fund activities to inform policy decisions.

Article 9 Of The Japanese Constitution And The Rule Of Law, Kenneth L. Port

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article argues that Article 9 of the Japanese Constitution was originally intended to prevent Japan from maintaining any military forces, whether for offensive or defensive purposes. Despite this, Japan now has the fourth-largest military in the world, creating a contradiction between the Constitution's intent and current reality. The article contends that the Self-Defense Forces (SDF) are unconstitutional and proposes converting them into a disaster relief organization to align with the original pacifist vision of Article 9.

Corporate Speech In A Democracy: What Can Nigeria Learn From Abroad?, Ige Omotayo Bolodeoku

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article critiques Nigeria's absolute ban on corporate political activism as unrealistic and counterproductive, advocating for a more nuanced regulatory framework. It proposes allowing corporate political participation with safeguards like disclosure requirements and shareholder involvement, drawing insights from U.S., U.K., and Canadian approaches to balance free expression with corruption prevention.

Whither The Udrp: Autonomous, Americanized, Or Cosmopolitan?, Laurence R. Helfer

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article explores the future trajectory of the Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP), outlining three potential evolutionary pathways: an autonomous UDRP distinct from national laws, an Americanized UDRP aligned with U.S. legal frameworks, or a cosmopolitan UDRP influenced by diverse national laws. Each pathway has significant implications for the UDRP's role in resolving domain name disputes globally.

Recent Developments In European Takeover And Corporate Law, Andrea Guaccero

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article examines recent developments in European corporate law, focusing on the harmonization of takeover laws and broader corporate governance reforms. It highlights the challenges and opportunities arising from the integration of national legal systems within the European Union, emphasizing the balance between uniformity and national sovereignty. The analysis draws parallels with U.S. corporate law and explores the role of directives, regulations, and court rulings in shaping a cohesive European legal framework.

The Free Movement Of Goods Within An Ec-Wide Market: Still A Work In Progress, Franz Leidenmühler

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

Right now, somewhere on the territory of a Member State of the European Community, a lorry carrying strawberries from another EC country is attacked by a group of masked men, who force the conductor off the road and render tons of strawberries unusable. Is it an ordinary criminal act to be treated within national criminal law or an invocation of the free movement of goods guaranteed by EC law? Not long ago, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled in a landmark judgment that the free movement of goods requires the Member States to act against such private conduct that …

China's Protection Of Famous And Well-Known Marks: The Impact Of China's Latest Trademark Law Reform On Infringement And Remedies, Alisa Cahan

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines China's efforts to enhance the protection of famous and well-known trademarks, particularly in light of its accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO) and its obligations under the TRIPs Agreement. It highlights the challenges China faces in aligning its trademark laws with international standards, including inconsistent enforcement, cultural attitudes toward intellectual property, and the impact of regional protectionism. Despite legislative reforms, such as the 2002 amendments to the Trademark Law and the Implementing Regulations, enforcement remains uneven, affecting both domestic and foreign trademark owners.

Law, Terrorism, And Social Movements: The Tension Between Politics And Security In Germany's Anti-Terrorism Legislation, Shawn Boyne

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article explores Germany's approach to combating terrorism from the late 1960s to the 1980s, emphasizing the interplay between security measures and civil liberties. It argues that political power struggles, rather than the terrorist threat itself, often drove antiterrorism legislation. The analysis highlights how laws such as the Berufsverbot and criminal code revisions were used to suppress dissent, leading to public backlash and eventual reforms. In contrast to the U.S., which framed its post-9/11 response as war, Germany maintained judicial oversight and avoided suspending constitutional rights. Public opinion played a pivotal role in shaping these policies, ultimately fostering a stronger …

The New Iraq: Revising Iraq's Commercial Law Is A Necessity For Foreign Direct Investment And The Reconstruction Of Iraq's Decimated Economy, Judith Richards Hope, Edward N. Griffin

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article examines the legal reforms implemented by the Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) in post-conflict Iraq, particularly CPA Order No. 39, which liberalizes foreign investment. These reforms are crucial for attracting foreign direct investment (FDI) to revive Iraq's economy, which has been devastated by war, sanctions, and central planning. The article highlights the importance of creating a stable legal environment, including equal treatment for foreign and domestic investors, streamlined corporate governance, and adherence to international standards. However, it also points out gaps in protections against confiscation and the need for further reforms in areas such as business immigration and tax …

No Borders. No Boundaries. No Limits. An Analysis Of Corporate Law In The European Union After The Centros Decision, Laura Jankolovits

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The Centros decision, rendered by the European Court of Justice in 1999, significantly advanced the principle of freedom of establishment within the European Union by prohibiting Member States from discriminating against companies incorporated in other Member States. The ruling effectively limited the ability of Member States to impose their own corporate laws on foreign companies operating within their borders, fostering a more integrated market. However, this decision also raised concerns about the potential for a "race to the bottom" in corporate law, as companies could now choose jurisdictions with more favorable regulations. The note argues that while the Centros decision …

Study Of The International Food Security Regime: Food Aid To North Korea During The Famine Of 1995-2000, Jongeun Lee

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the persistent food insecurity in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) and the challenges of international food aid efforts, highlighting systemic issues such as monitoring limitations, political debates over aid effectiveness, and the need for reform in the international food security regime. It argues that while organizations like the World Food Programme (WFP) have expanded their operations in the DPRK, structural barriers, including the government's restrictions and donor countries' shifting commitments, undermine the long-term impact of food aid. The note emphasizes the urgency of addressing these challenges to prevent further humanitarian crises and promote sustainable food …

Re-Treating Intellectual Property? The Wai 262 Proceeding And The Heuristics Of Intellectual Property Law, Graeme W. Austin

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article explores the WAI 262 proceeding, a legal challenge by Maori tribes alleging breaches of the Treaty of Waitangi by New Zealand's intellectual property laws. It argues that the Crown's obligations under the Treaty require a re-evaluation of intellectual property frameworks to respect Maori self-determination and cultural rights.

Looking Beyond Intellectual Property In Resolving Protection Of The Intangible Cultural Heritage Of Indigenous Peoples, Robert K. Paterson, Dennis S. Karjala

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article examines the challenges indigenous peoples face in protecting their intangible cultural property, such as songs, legends, and ceremonies, under existing intellectual property (IP) and legal regimes. It argues that while indigenous claims for protection are legitimate, recognizing new IP rights may not be necessary or appropriate. Instead, the authors propose that existing legal frameworks, such as contract law, privacy, trade secret, and trademark law, could provide more effective and balanced solutions. They advocate for a nuanced approach that respects indigenous cultural heritage while maintaining compatibility with public domain interests and free expression.

Introduction, Peter K. Yu

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The introduction explores the challenges of protecting traditional knowledge, folklore, and indigenous practices within the global intellectual property framework. It argues that the success of such protection depends on selecting the appropriate international forum for negotiations, fostering a nonzero-sum mindset among negotiators, addressing cognitive barriers, and ensuring the active participation of indigenous communities. The introduction emphasizes the need for a balanced approach that considers the diverse interests of various stakeholders, including developed and developing countries, indigenous peoples, and international organizations.

Legal Protection Of Indigenous Culture In Australia, Ronald Sackville

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article examines the legal protection of Indigenous culture in Australia, highlighting both progress and persistent challenges. While significant strides have been made, such as constitutional amendments and the recognition of native title, the legal system still struggles to adequately protect Indigenous cultural rights, particularly in reconciling them with existing intellectual property and heritage protection frameworks.