Comparative and Foreign Law Commons^™

An Equal Rights Amendment For The Twenty-First Century: Bringing Global Constitutionalism Home, Julie C. Suk

Articles

The last few years have seen a renewed push to constitutionalize sex equality in the United States. A generation after the federal Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) failed to be ratified by the requisite number of states, the ERA is on the platform of the 2017 Women's March on Washington. Oregon added a sex equality guarantee to its state constitution in 2014, joining 22 state constitutions and most constitutions around the world. Feminist coalitions, Hollywood celebrities, and members of Congress are vocally endorsing an ERA revival. Why is an ERA desired now, when judges have interpreted the Fourteenth Amendment to prohibit …

Fallacies In The Current Methods Of Prosecuting International Commercial Bribery, Ira Handa

Cardozo Law Review

The note argues that the current legal framework for prosecuting international commercial bribery is inadequate and inconsistent compared to the robust regime established for international public bribery under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA). It advocates for comprehensive federal legislation specifically addressing international commercial bribery, modeled after the FCPA but tailored to the private sector, to bridge this gap and address the significant harms caused by such bribery.

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Journal Of International And Comparative Law, Vol. 25, Iss. 1

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

No abstract provided.

The Red Cross And Red Crescent Movement: Power Players In International And Domestic Natural Disaster Law, Kristen Dale

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the unique role of the American Red Cross (ARC) as a quasi-governmental organization in U.S. disaster response, highlighting its dual identity as both a federal instrumentality and a private corporation. This duality raises critical questions about accountability, independence, and neutrality, particularly in light of proposed oversight measures like the American Red Cross Transparency Act. The analysis explores how the ARC's role intersects with international frameworks and domestic policies, emphasizing the need to balance its operational efficiency with public accountability.

Masthead - Cardozo Journal Of International And Comparative Law, Vol. 25 (2016-17)

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

No abstract provided.

The Politics Of Comparative Constitutional Inquiry: At The Crossroads Of Law, Political Science, And Ideology, Michel Rosenfeld

Articles

No abstract provided.

We Don't Come From A Land Down Under: How Adopting Australia's Gun Laws Would Violate The Second Amendment Of The U.S. Constitution, Jonathan Weg

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the legal and policy implications of adopting Australia's strict gun laws in the United States, arguing that such measures would likely violate the Second Amendment, which guarantees the right to bear arms. While Australia's National Firearms Agreement (NFA) has successfully reduced gun violence, the U.S. constitutional framework, particularly the Second Amendment, poses significant legal barriers to replicating similar laws. The analysis highlights the cultural and legal differences between the two countries, emphasizing that compulsory gun buybacks and restrictions on firearms for self-defense would face constitutional challenges in the U.S.

Inverse Logic: The Shortcomings Of Preventing Corporate Tax Inversion Through Amending Section 7874, Kathy Wong

Cardozo Public Law, Policy & Ethics Journal

No abstract provided.

Birthright Citizenship On Trial: Elk V. Wilkins And United States V. Wong Kim Ark, Bethany R. Berger

Cardozo Law Review

In the summer of 2015, the majority of Republican candidates for president announced their opposition to birthright citizenship. The constitutional dimensions of that right revolve around two cases decided at the end of the nineteenth century, Elk v. Wilkins (1884) and United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898). The first held that an American Indian man born in the United States was not a citizen under the Fourteenth Amendment; the second, that a Chinese American man born in the United States was indeed a citizen under the amendment. This Article juxtaposes the history of these decisions. By showing the distinctive …

Obesity Regulation Under Home Rule: An Argument That Regulation By Local Governments Is Superior To Administrative Agencies, Patrick M. Steel

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Taiwan's Path To Independence: Resolving The "One China" Dispute, Kristine Yeh Koopman

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Note discusses the historical and legal contexts within which Taiwan is arguably its own state, and advances the notion that members of the international community must finally take a definitive stance as to whether Taiwan is its own sovereign state in order to resolve the "one China" dispute, rather than choosing to remain supposedly impartial. Section II of this Note provides an overview of Taiwan's path to statehood, democracy, and independence. Section III then examines the status of Taiwan in international settings and legal contexts, and highlights Taiwan's claims of independence, as well as China's claims for reunification. Lastly, …

The Day Doctrine Died: Private Arbitration And The End Of Law, Myriam E. Gilles

Articles

This story begins in 1980, when a budding anti-lawsuit movement found an energetic champion in a new conservative President. Over time, the movement became a dominant feature of political life, as its narrative of activist judges, jackpot justice, and a thriving lawsuit industry stirred partisan passions. And yet, some thirty years on, it is clear that the primary legacy of the anti-lawsuit movement is the movement itself--not legislative achievements, which have been few and far between, but committed adherents, including future Supreme Court Justices, lower court judges, and business leaders.

Meanwhile, and also in the early 1980s, federal courts began …

Firmly Grasping The Knife: An Investigation Of The Asymmetric Application Of Chinese Antitrust Law As A Protectionist Tool, Jillian Bray

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note argues that China's Antimonopoly Law (AML), while modeled after Western antitrust laws, is often applied in a protectionist manner, disproportionately targeting foreign companies to shield domestic industries and state-owned enterprises. This selective enforcement contrasts with the U.S. antitrust system, which prioritizes fair competition and consumer welfare. The note advocates for aligning AML enforcement with international standards to promote a level playing field and foster long-term economic growth.

Cache-22: The Fine Line Between Information And Defamation In Google's Autocomplete Function, Kacy Popyer

Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal

No abstract provided.

Copyright Piracy And The Indian Film Industry: A "Realist" Assessment, Arpan Banerjee

Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal

In India, the academic discourse surrounding intellectual property (IP) has been marked by great skepticism. Global IP laws have been viewed as a Western imposition detrimental to national interests. In this paper, I will make the case for a "realist" approach to film piracy in India, i.e., an approach that is rooted in legal pragmatism and draws from the New Legal Realism (NLR) movement. I will suggest a rough template for such an approach, referring to seven broad elements: a) international relations realism; b) contextualization of IP; c) contextualization of copyright; d) the views and interests of the film industry …

Tweeting #Justice: Audio-Visual Coverage Of Court Proceedings In A World Of Shifting Technology, Itay Ravid

Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal

The debate over whether to allow cameras into courtrooms refuses to fade away. In 2015 alone, U.S. federal courts completed a five-year experiment with cameras in courts, New Zealand published new guidelines for audio-visual coverage, and Scotland completely revised its former broadcast policy. These jurisdictions, and others around the globe, constantly struggle to design model practices that successfully balance freedom of the press, transparency, and public access to information, with rights to a fair trial and privacy. The constant need to rethink coverage policies can be attributed in large part to the advancement of technology, providing the media innovative tools …

Panel I: Fleeing Violence From Latin America, Olga Byrne, Elizabeth Carlson, Walter Ewing, Alice Farmer, Tiffany Nelms, Teresa Woods

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

No abstract provided.

Disciplining The Right Of Publicity's Nebulous First Amendment Defense With Teachings From Trademark Law, Wee Jin Yeo

Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal

Academic commentators, practitioners and students alike have written a flurry of articles on the First Amendment defense in right of publicity law, as courts cannot seem to agree on the appropriate balancing test that should be used to weigh celebrities 'publicity rights against the public's rights to use celebrity personas as communicative tools. Various tests have been proposed as the panacea, but are ultimately unsatisfactory, due to inadequacies that prevent them from striking a normatively desirable balance.

This Article suggests that the core normative justification behind the right of publicity is the prevention of unjust enrichment. Thus, following recent developments …

Dirty Laws: A Critique Of The Audiovisual Media Services Regulations 2014 And Section 63 Of The Criminal Justice And Immigration Act 2008, Daniel Haley

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

The United Kingdom's recently enacted anti-pornography laws, the Audiovisual Media Services Regulations 2014 and section 63 of the Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, are inconsistent with the European Convention on Human Rights, United Kingdom case law, and United Kingdom public policy. The Audiovisual Media Services Regulations 2014, which bans the sale of a wide array of domestically produced pornography, and the Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, which criminalizes the possession of "extreme pornography, " are among the most restrictive anti-pornography laws in the democratic world. These laws were passed in response to the rise of the Internet, which …

Panel Ii: Fleeing Violence From The Middle East And North Africa, Alice Farmer, Zaid Hydari, Edwin Rekosh, Thomas Streinz

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

No abstract provided.

It's Not Jim Crow, It's Jail: Questioning The Role Of Race In The Origins Of Punitive Policy, John T. Bennett

Cardozo Public Law, Policy & Ethics Journal

No abstract provided.

Towards The Law Of Legal Services, Andrew M. Perlman

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Utility Model Patent: An Essential And Improving Patent Scheme In China, Victor Wang

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note argues that China's utility model patent (UMP) system, despite criticism, serves as a beneficial tool for both domestic and foreign inventors, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). While commentators often view the UMP as detrimental to innovation policies, the system's low inventiveness threshold, quick file-to-grant process, and affordability make it a practical solution for protecting incremental inventions. The note contends that the UMP aligns with China's current status as a developing nation and supports its innovation ecosystem, contrary to claims that it hinders progress.

In The Aftermath Of Resolution 1373: Tackling The Protective Veil Of Counter-Terrorism, Johanny Santana

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The absence of a universally accepted definition of terrorism has enabled states to exploit counterterrorism measures to justify human rights abuses, as exemplified by Uganda and India. A clear international definition is essential to prevent such abuses and enhance accountability under frameworks like the International Criminal Court.

Trade Secret Hacking, Online Data Breaches, And China’S Cyberthreats, Peter K. Yu

Cardozo Law Review de•novo

Taking advantage of the forum provided by this timely Symposium, this Article closely examines the ongoing debate on China’s sustained effort in using online hacking and other intrusive techniques to steal trade secrets and proprietary data from U.S. businesses. Part I outlines the five common narratives that have thus far been advanced to recount this widely criticized effort. Sensing the narratives’ negative overtones, Part II offers five modest suggestions on how a more positive debate can be constructed to help identify ways to reduce online hacking and data breaches as well as to enhance the protection of trade secrets and …

Dispute Resolution Clauses In International Sponsored Research Contracts, Dennis Lazarev

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Pharmaceutical companies are the greatest non-governmental sponsors of biomedical research in academia. Increasingly they sponsor foreign entities, typically universities or non-commercial research institutions. Another type of cross-border sponsorship occurs when two research institutions engage in a collaborative research effort. In either case disputes may arise. The most common types of disputes are the rights to the intellectual property developed in the course of sponsored research, and the scope of research activities that an agreement covers. Parties to these cross-border sponsorship arrangements have rarely incorporated dispute resolution clause in their contracts. This Article will argue that arbitrationis an approach far superior …

Judges As Gatekeepers To Mediation: The Russian Case, Kathryn Hendley

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

In this Article, I investigate the role of judges in mediation in Russia. Using a mixed-methods approach that draws on my fieldwork in Russian courts as well as a 2013 survey of Russian judges, I explore their attitudes towards mediation and their willingness to recommend it to litigants. I use the survey data to inquire into the factors that tend to predict both their attitudes and behavior vis-avis mediation. The analysis reveals a remarkable division between judges' attitudes and their behavior. The surveyed judges are generally enthusiastic about the introduction of mediation, but this enthusiasm is not always reflected in …

The Legitimacy Crisis And The Future Of Courts, Orna Rabinovich-Einy

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

There is an overall legitimacy crisis in courts. The sources of this crisis have, to a large extent, been misconstrued. While there has been significant writing depicting the diminished quality, effectiveness, and fairness of courts, these phenomena have, for the most part, been viewed as distinct problems that warrant discrete solutions. This article shows that these problems are all manifestations of an overall legitimacy crisis that stems from the blurring of the originally stark distinctions between courts and alternatives. Traditionally, formal and informal dispute resolution processes had their own sources of legitimacy, each grounded in their respective distinctive (often opposing) …

Why Instrumentalism Matters, Kyron J. Huigens

Articles

Alon Harel argues that the acts of a public official acting with "fidelity of deference," are "necessary," "non-contingent," "intrinsic," "constitutive," integrative," "expressive," or "inherent" features of legal punishment. Accordingly, he calls his argument "noninstrumental." This can be taken as an argument for logical necessity, definition, extension, or modest or immodest conceptual necessity. Only the last interpretation fits Harel's text, but such an argument fails because instrumentality is necessarily present in any event in the natural world, including punishment. Harel does not say which aspects of natural instrumentality he means to exclude from his argument, or how, or why.

Repatriation Of Korean Cultural Property Looted By Japan-Can A Sincere Apology Resolve The Centuries-Old Korea/Japan Disputes?, Melissa (Youngjae) Koo

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Note will focus on the disputes between Korea, both North and South Korea, and Japan surrounding Korean cultural property looted by Japan and will explore concrete solutions for resolving such issues through alternative dispute resolution-more specifically, an apology. It will consider two predominant exampies of cultural property looting, which occurred during Japanese invasions of Korea-first, at the end of the sixteenth century and, the second, from 1910 to 1945. Additionally, Japan has frequently been characterized as being a "significant market" for stolen cultural property. It is reported that there are at least 34,157 objects of Korean origin in Japan, …