Administrative Law Commons^™

Picketing In The New Economy, Hiba Hafiz

Cardozo Law Review

The rise of the contingent and gig economies and of outsourced and subcontracted work has left many workers with insufficient bargaining power to successfully negotiate collective bargaining agreements with their direct employers. This problem is exacerbated by a statutory ban on worker picketing and boycotts of non-employers, or "secondaries," even where those employers collude with direct employers on wage-fixing or the suppression of union activity; have monopsony power over direct employers; or have substantial indirect control over worker wages through contractual arrangements.

This Article is a crucial intervention in modernizing the labor law on worker picketing in the New Economy. …

Once More Unto The Breach, Dear Friends - Levin On The Guidance Exception, Michael E. Herz

Online Publications

The late, great Kenneth Culp Davis was known for many things, but humility was not among them. He knew the answers; he knew them better than did the Supreme Court; and he knew that he knew them. So it is remarkable that there was a problem in administrative law he found “baffling.” That was the distinction between legislative rules, interpretive rules, and statements of policy.

How Subterranean Regulation Hinders Innovation In Assisted Reproductive Technology, Myrisha S. Lewis

Cardozo Law Review

Most scholars believe assisted reproductive technology is subject only to minimal regulation, especially by the federal government. This belief I contend, is wrong. In this Article, I examine agency documents, statements by officials, and letters that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has sent to physicians and researchers over the past fifteen years to reveal an overlooked regulatory program. The FDA has been targeting new forms of assisted reproductive technology that involve small genetic modifications (advanced assisted reproductive technologies or AARTs) through regulatory actions that receive little public, media, or scholarly attention. I term this method of regulation "subterranean …

"Too Big To Foia": How Agencies Avoid Compliance With The Freedom Of Information Act, Stephanie Alvarez-Jones

Cardozo Law Review

The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), while foundational for promoting government transparency, faces significant challenges in its administration, particularly through the judicially created "undue burden" claim, which allows agencies to evade disclosure. The note argues that courts' deference to agencies' claims of undue burden undermines FOIA's purpose of promoting openness. It proposes reforms, such as a public interest sliding scale, to balance the burden on agencies against the public's right to know, ensuring FOIA remains an effective tool for accountability.

Critical Race Ip, Anjali Vats, Deidré A. Keller

Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal

No abstract provided.

Heretical Archives: Heterotopic Institutions And Fictive Records, Peter Goodrich

Articles

No abstract provided.

General Association Of Merchants And Self-Employed Persons V. Minister Of Interior, Miriam Naor, Yoram Danziger, Isaac Amit, Neal Hendel, Noam Sohlberg, Esther Hayut, Daphne Barak-Erez

Translated Opinions

[This abstract is not part of the Court's opinion and is provided for the reader's convenience. It has been translated from a Hebrew version prepared by Nevo Press Ltd. and is used with its kind permission.]

Further hearing in the verdict given in HCJ 6322/14 in which a variety of claims were raised regarding two amendments to the By-Law of Tel Aviv-Jaffa (Opening and Closing Shops), 5740-1980 (hereinafter: the Amendments), addressing the opening of businesses on the Sabbath in Tel Aviv-Jaffa. The petitioners argued in favor of the constitutionality, reasonableness and proportionality of permitting businesses to open on the Sabbath. …

The Unmasking Of Balancing And Proportionality Review In U.S. Constitutional Law, Mark S. Kende

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article challenges the perception that U.S. constitutional law is overly formalistic, arguing that it often employs pragmatic approaches such as balancing and proportionality review, similar to those used in other countries. The author contends that unmasking these flexible methodologies would make U.S. constitutional law more coherent and enhance the Supreme Court's legitimacy. The analysis highlights how the Court implicitly or explicitly uses balancing in various areas, such as the Dormant Commerce Clause, abortion rights, and the Fourth Amendment, and advocates for a more open and structured proportionality framework.

Breaking News: New Form Of Superior Agency Guidance Discovered Hiding In Plain Sight, Michael E. Herz

Online Publications

For decades, controversy has brewed over agency (ab)use of and (over)reliance on guidance documents. On one account, agencies turn to guidance in an end run around notice-and-comment requirements, producing de facto legislative rules without either public input or, at least in some cases, judicial scrutiny. On another, guidance documents are good government in action, a helpful and illuminating benefit. In Preambles as Guidance, Kevin Stack does not take sides in this debate. But he does helpfully remind us that there is one type of guidance that (a) is not subject to the standard critique and (b) is often not …

The Constitutionality Of Sec Administrative Proceedings: The Sec Should Cure Its Alj Appointment Scheme, Kaela Dahan

Cardozo Law Review

The note examines the constitutional challenges surrounding the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) use of administrative law judges (ALJs), particularly under Section 929P of the Dodd-Frank Act. It argues that the SEC's ALJ appointment process violates the Appointments Clause, as current ALJs have not been properly appointed by SEC Commissioners. The note also highlights due process and Seventh Amendment concerns, as defendants in SEC administrative proceedings lack rights such as trial by jury and immediate appellate review. To maintain the integrity of its administrative processes, the SEC must adopt measures to ensure its ALJ appointments comply with constitutional requirements.

How Privacy Distorted Standing Law, Felix T. Wu

Articles

No abstract provided.

An Empirical Study Of Implicit Takings, James E. Krier, Stewart E. Sterk

Articles

Takings scholarship has long focused on the niceties of Supreme Court doctrine, while ignoring the operation of takings law “on the ground” – in the state and lower federal courts, who together decide the vast bulk of all takings cases. This study, based primarily on an empirical analysis of more than 2,000 reported decisions over the period 1979 through June 2012, attempts to fill that void.The study establishes that the Supreme Court’s categorical rules govern almost no cases, and that takings claims based on government regulation almost invariably fail. By contrast, when takings claims arise out of government action other …

Kiryat Ata Municipality V. Koren, Uzi Vogelman, Miriam Naor, Anat Baron

Translated Opinions

A person who has a debt to a local authority requests that it issue a certificate that is necessary in order to transfer land rights, however the latter refuses to do so until the old debt is paid. When will it be ruled that the debt expired by virtue of  prescription, or that the authority so delayed in collecting the debt that it can no longer demand payment as a condition to granting the certificate? This is the question raised in this appeal of the decision of the Administrative Affairs Court  ordering the cessation of collection proceedings initiated by the …

Movement For Quality Government In Israel V. Prime Minister, Salim Joubran, Yoram Danziger, Neal Hendel

Translated Opinions

This was a petition challenging the decision to appoint Knesset Member Rabbi Aryeh Machlouf Deri (hereinafter: Deri) to the office of Minister of the Interior in the Israeli Government. The petition was submitted against the background of Deri’s conviction of corruption offences, among them offenses of bribe taking and breach of trust, committed in the period during which he held several senior positions in the Ministry of the Interior at the end of the 1980s. It should be noted that pursuant to Deri’s appointment as Minister of the Economy and Minister for the Development of the Negev and the Galilee, …

Nepa And Uncertainty In Low-Risk, High-Impact Scenarios: Nuclear Energy As A Case Study, Irene Weintraub

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Innovation Prizes In Practice And Theory, Michael J. Burstein, Fiona Murray

Articles

Innovation prizes in reality are significantly different from innovation prizes in theory. The former are familiar from popular accounts of historical prizes like the Longitude Prize: the government offers a set amount for a solution to a known problem, like £20,000 for a method of calculating longitude at sea. The latter are modeled as compensation to inventors in return for donating their inventions to the public domain. Neither the economic literature nor the policy literature that led to the 2010 America COMPETES Reauthorization Act — which made prizes a prominent tool of government innovation policy — provides a satisfying justification …

Movement For Quality Government V. Prime Minister, Elyakim Rubinstein, Salim Joubran, Noam Sohlberg, Uzi Vogelman, Esther Hayut

Translated Opinions

[This abstract is not part of the Court's opinion and is provided for the reader's convenience. It has been translated from a Hebrew version prepared by Nevo Press Ltd. and is used with its kind permission.]

The Petitions disputed the legal validity of the Gas Outline adopted by the Government in the framework of Government Decision 432 in regard to the treatment of the gas reserves (hereinafter: the Gas Outline). The state and the gas companies holding the franchises defended the Gas Outline.

The Supreme Court, sitting as High Court of Justice (in an expanded bench of five justices) ruled …

Obesity Regulation Under Home Rule: An Argument That Regulation By Local Governments Is Superior To Administrative Agencies, Patrick M. Steel

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Prosecuting The Cia: Does The Computer Fraud And Abuse Act Allow For Liability?, Sam Taterka

Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal

No abstract provided.

Hashavim H.P.S. Business Information, Ltd. V. The Courts' Administration, Elyakim Rubinstein, Esther Hayut, Uzi Vogelman

Translated Opinions

[This abstract is not part of the Court's opinion and is provided for the reader's convenience. It has been translated from a Hebrew version prepared by Nevo Press Ltd. and is used with its kind permission.]

This case concerned a petition challenging the decision of the Courts Administration (the Respondent) making access to its judgment database contingent upon signing a “guarantee” that comprised, inter alia, a prohibition upon indexing the information in a manner that would allow it to be found through web search engines such as Google and Bing. The Petitioner is a commercial company whose primary activity is …

Chevron Is Dead; Long Live Chevron, Michael Herz

Articles

The Supreme Court's decision in Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. continues to obsess academics and courts alike. Despite all the attention, however; the "Chevron revolution" never quite happens. This decision, though seen as transformatively important, is honored in the breach, in constant danger of being abandoned, and the subject of perpetual confusion and uncertainty. This Essay seeks both to bury and to praise Chevron.

Chevron is not a revolutionary shift of authority from the judiciary to the executive. That Chevron is dead. The Chevron that survives is an appropriate allocation of decisionmaking responsibility among the three …

Constituencies And Contemporaneousness In Reason-Giving: Thoughts And Direction After T-Mobile, Donald J. Kochan

Cardozo Law Review

This Article presents a framework for reason-giving requirements in administrative law that includes a demand on agencies that reasons be produced contemporaneously with an agency's decisions where multiple constituencies (including regulated entities), not just the courts (and judicial review), are served and respected as consumers of the reasons. The Article postulates that the January 2015 U.S. Supreme Court decision in T-Mobile South, LLC v. City of Roswell may prove to be groundbreaking and stir this framework to the forefront of administrative law decision-making. There are some fundamental, yet very understated, lessons in the T-Mobile opinion that prompt further attention and …

Acus - And Administrative Law - Then And Now, Michael Herz

Articles

The Administrative Conference of the United States (ACUS) both shapes and reflects the intellectual, policy, and practical concerns of the field of administrative law. Its recommendations are therefore a useful lens through which to view that field. Also, because of an unfortunate hiatus, ACUS has gotten underway not once but twice. Those two beginnings provide a kind of natural experiment, and they make a revealing contrast. This article traces the transformations of American administrative law, as well as the field’s perpetual concerns, by comparing the initial recommendations of ACUS 1.0 (1968 to 1970) with the initial recommendations of ACUS 2.0 …

Yadid V. The Coordination Committee Of The Organizations Of Persons Of Moroccan Origin In Israel By The Committee Chairperson Rafael Ben Shushan, Noam Sohlberg, Miriam Naor, Hanan Melcer

Translated Opinions

The Israeli Knesset adopted the Victims of Nazi Persecution (Restrictions on Fees for Handling Pension Claims under an Administrative Decision) (Amendment No. 20) Bill, 5775-2014. The questions presented by this petition are as follows: A. Does the amendment infringe the constitutional rights of the Petitioners in a manner that is repugnant to the Limitations Clause? B. Is the retroactive application of the amendment just and proper under the circumstances? C. Was there any fundamental flaw in the legislative procedure of the amendment that would justify its annulment?

The Supreme Court, sitting as High Court of Justice, denied the petition, holding: …

Al-Qi'an V. State, Elyakim Rubinstein, Neal Hendel, Daphne Barak-Erez

Translated Opinions

[This abstract is not part of the Court's opinion and is provided for the reader's convenience. It has been translated from a Hebrew version prepared by Nevo Press Ltd. and is used with its kind permission.]

An Application for Permission to Appeal, which was adjudicated as an appeal, on a decision to grant the Respondent's motions to evict the Applicants from the land it owns in the northern Negev. Background: The Applicants belong to a Bedouin tribe that has been residing in the area in dispute for approximately 60 years. In the framework of the proceedings in the lower instances, …

Hussein V. Cohen, Asher Grunis, Salim Joubran, Yoram Danziger, Miriam Naor, Elyakim Rubinstein, Hanan Melcer, Esther Hayut

Translated Opinions

Facts: The appeals focused upon the question of whether properties in East Jerusalem that belong to residents of Judea and Samaria are deemed “absentee property” as defined under the Absentees’ Property Law.

Held: In dismissing the appeals, the Supreme Court held that the Absentees’ Property Law applies to properties in East Jerusalem whose owners, beneficiaries or holders are residents of Judea and Samaria. However, in light of the significant difficulties attendant to implementing the Law in accordance with its language, in general, the authorities should refrain from exercising their statutory authority in regard to such properties except in the most …

New Wine, Old Bottles, And A Do-Nothing Congress, Michael E. Herz

Online Publications

The Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 was adopted to protect against hazards to and interference with navigation. It prohibited “creation of any obstruction to the navigable capacity of any of the waters of the United States” or altering or filling navigable waters (§10) and also made it unlawful “to throw, discharge, or deposit . . . any refuse matter” into navigable waters “whereby navigation shall or may be impeded or obstructed,” although the Corps of Engineers could permit such a discharge if “anchorage and navigation will not be injured thereby” (§13). For two-thirds of a century, those provisions operated …

Zoabi V. Knesset's Ethics Committee, Miriam Naor, Esther Hayut, Elyakim Rubinstein, Hanan Melcer, Salim Joubran

Translated Opinions

This is a statement of reasons for the judgment handed down on Dec. 10, 2014, denying the petition of Petitioner 1, Member of Knesset Hannen Zoabi, in regard to the decision of the Knesset Ethics Committee that found that Petitioner 1 had violated Rule 1A of the Knesset Ethics Rules, and ordered her suspension from participation in meetings of the Knesset plenum and committees, other than for voting, for a period of six months. This decision was made following two statements to the media made by the Petitioner. One was a statement made in a radio interview several days after …

Trade Secret Hacking, Online Data Breaches, And China’S Cyberthreats, Peter K. Yu

Cardozo Law Review de•novo

Taking advantage of the forum provided by this timely Symposium, this Article closely examines the ongoing debate on China’s sustained effort in using online hacking and other intrusive techniques to steal trade secrets and proprietary data from U.S. businesses. Part I outlines the five common narratives that have thus far been advanced to recount this widely criticized effort. Sensing the narratives’ negative overtones, Part II offers five modest suggestions on how a more positive debate can be constructed to help identify ways to reduce online hacking and data breaches as well as to enhance the protection of trade secrets and …

Equity In Substantial Evidence, Or Using Article 78 Judicial Review To Achieve Justice For Public Housing Occupants, Janelle Greene

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

No abstract provided.