Administrative Law Commons^™

Attorney General V. Hornstein, Shimon Agranat, Moshe Silberg, David Goitein

Translated Opinions

Section 25(1) of the Road Transport Ordinance and section 99(1) of the Municipal Corporations Ordinance provide as follows:

"25(1) A municipal...council may, with the consent of the district commissioner and the licensing authorfty, make bye-laws in regard to the following matters-...

(b) the regulation by prohibition or otherwise of vehicles when stationary within the municipal... area."

"99(1) A municipal council may make by-laws to enable or assist it to carry out any of the matters it is required or empowered to do under...any other Ordinance... and may by such by-laws provide for the payment of any fees...by any person...in connection …

Berman Et Al. V. Minister Of Interior, Moshe Silberg, Yoel Sussman, Alfred Witkon

Translated Opinions

The district of Nahlath Yitzhak consisting of 250 families had for very many years been part of Tel Aviv Municipality. Since 1949 a movement to sever this connection had gathered strength and in 1950 a petition to this end, signed by 353 residents, had been delivered to the Ministry of the Interior. Tel Aviv had claimed that the petitioners were not authorized to speak for all the residents and the matter was left in abeyance until 1956, when it once more became active on the delivery of a similar petition signed by 491 persons. The Minister then appointed a commission …

Weiss V. Inspector General, Moshe Landau, Yitzhak Olshan, Yoel Sussman

Translated Opinions

The petitioners were members of the Israel Police Force. They were sent to the "Gaza strip" when it was occupied by Israel armed forces after the Sinai Campaign to do normal police work there. In contravention of an order forbidding the purchase of goods, they bought nylon material, medicines, cameras and films. They were charged before a Court of Discipline which was set up under the Police Ordinance. The petitioners contended that the court had no jurisdiction to hear charges against them because, inter alia, the Police Ordinance only dealt and could only deal with offences committed in Israel and …

Burka'an V. Minister Of Finance, Haim Herman Cohn, David Bechor, Meir Shamgar

Translated Opinions

An order nisi required that Respondent 2 (The Company for the Reconstruction and Development of the Jewish Quarter) show cause as to why it should refrain from granting a lease to the Petitioner for one of the apartments regarding which the Respondent published an “offer of apartments to the public”, and why the provision under which the offering is limited to Israeli citizens and new olim [immigrants under the Law of Return] should not be revoked.

The High Court of Justice held:

A. The Respondent’s demand that the lessees of apartments in the Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem’s Old City be …

Yehoshua V. Appeals Tribunal Under The Invalids Law, Yitzhak Olshan, Zvi Berinson, Alfred Witkon

Translated Opinions

The petitioner applied to the High Court for an order of certiorari against the Appeals Tribunal set up under the Invalids (Pensions and Rehabilitation) Law, 1949, and prayed to set aside the decision of the Tribunal rejecting his appeal against the refusal of the competent authority to recognise his right to a pension. He alleged that the Tribunal had ignored certain medical evidence.

Held (by Olshan P. and Berenson J., Witkon J. dissenting):

(1) The High Court has no jurisdiction to review the decision of the Appeals Tribunal, and the application must be refused.

Zeraubavel v. Appeals Tribunal under Fallen …

Sapoznikov V. The Court Of Discipline Of The Israel Police, Yoel Sussman, Moshe Silberg, Yitzhak Olshan

Translated Opinions

Under section 18 of the Police Ordinance the Inspector-General may constitute Courts of Discipline to try police officers charged with disciplinary offences, the section prescribing the offences which may be the subject of such charges. One of those offences is thus described (in section 18(1)(i)): "any offence contrary to the good order and discipline of the Force.. ." The High Commissioner in Council was empowered by section 50(1)(e) to make rules "for the definition of offences to the prejudice of good order and discipline", and under that power made the Police (Disciplinary Offences) (Definition) Rules, 1941. Offence No. 23 of …

Roznek V. Dawman, Simha Assaf, Alfred Witkon, Yitzhak Olshan

Translated Opinions

The parents of a girl of five years of age agreed in the course of divorce proceedings that the child should be placed in an orphanage, and that both parents should be entitled to visit her there. The mother remarried, and subsequently applied to the District Court for custody of the child on the ground that it would be in the child's interests that she should live with her mother. The father entered an appearance, but failed to file a defence, and the District Court, after considering the merits of the case, dismissed the application. The mother appealed and contended …

Sheib V. Minister Of Defence, Shneor Zalman Cheshin, Yitzhak Olshan, Alfred Witkon

Translated Opinions

A teacher, Dr. Sheib, applied to the Principal of the Reali Montefiore School, Haifa, for employment as a teacher and was accepted subject to confirmation by the Department of Education in the Ministry of Education and Culture.

Pursuant to a general request contained in a circular sent to the principals of all classes of schools by the Director of the Department of Education, that teachers should not be employed save with the consent of the Inspector of Secondary Schools, the acceptance of Dr. Sheib as a teacher had been made conditional by the Principal upon such consent being obtained. Dr. …

Zeev V. Acting District Commissioner Of The Urban Area Of Tel Aviv, Moshe Smoira, Yitzhak Olshan, Shneor Zalman Cheshin

Translated Opinions

The Acting District Commissioner of Tel Aviv purporting to act as the Competent Authority under Mandatory regulations requisitioned an apartment in Tel Aviv for the use of a government official His action was challenged on the grounds, first, that the Mandatory regulations in question had been impliedly repealed by s. 9 of the Law and Administration Oridnance of 19481) which empowered the Provisional Council to make regulations of the same kind, and secondly, that the appointment of the Acting District Commissioner as Competent Authority, being an act having legislative effect within the meaning of s.20 of the Interpretation Ordinance, 1945, …

Leon V. Acting District Commissioner Of Tel-Aviv (Yehoshua Gobernik), Moshe Smoira, Yitzhak Olshan, Simha Assaf

Translated Opinions

The Law and Administration Ordinance 1948, provides that the law which existed in Palestine on May 14, 1948, "shall remain in force... subject to such modifications as may result from the establishment of the State and its authorities".

The Acting District Commissioner of Tel Aviv, as the competent authority under the Defence Regulations of 1939, made pursuant to the (English) Emergency Powers (Defence) Act 1939, requisitioned a flat situated at no. 3, Chen Boulevard, Tel Aviv, by order dated 6 September 1948. The requisition was for the benefit of the Attorney-General who, previously to his then recent appointment to that …