Law Commons^™

Masthead - Cardozo Women's Law Journal, Vol. 3 (1996)

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

No abstract provided.

An Argument For Universal Pediatric Hiv Testing, Counseling And Treatment, Colin Crawford

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

The article argues that mandatory pediatric HIV testing, counseling, and treatment are essential to address a public health emergency, overriding constitutional concerns. The author, Colin Crawford, asserts that early detection and treatment significantly improve the lives of HIV-positive children, making it a compelling state interest that should take precedence over privacy and autonomy concerns.

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Women's Law Journal, Vol. 3, Iss. 2

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

No abstract provided.

Making Equality Law More Effective: Lessons From The German Experience, Ninon Colneric

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

The article examines the evolution and effectiveness of equality law in Germany, particularly focusing on gender equality. It highlights the significant influence of European Community (EC) law on German legislation and discusses the challenges in implementing these laws to achieve substantial gender equality. The analysis reveals that while progress has been made, there are persistent issues in effectively enforcing these laws.

Equal Rights-Compatibility Of Family And Career-Legal Comparison: East Germany (Gdr) And Federal Republic Of Germany Today, Anita Grandke

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

The article examines the evolution of gender equality in East Germany from the post-WWII era through the 1990 unification with West Germany, highlighting how East Germany's progressive laws promoting women's rights were rolled back after unification, leading to significant setbacks for women in employment, family life, and legal protections.

Reach And Substance Of The Principle Of Equal Treatment In Social Security Law Under European Community And German Constitutional Law, Ursula Rust

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

The article examines the principle of equal treatment in social security law under European Community (EC) law and German constitutional law, highlighting their differences in scope and application. While both legal systems prohibit sex-based discrimination, EC law, primarily through Directive 79/7, applies narrowly to specific risks and allows significant exceptions, particularly for survivor and family benefits. In contrast, German constitutional law provides broader protections under the Basic Law, which directly binds the legislature and judiciary to ensure equal rights, though it also struggles with addressing indirect discrimination effectively.

The Mark Of Cain: No Second Chance For Teachers Convicted Of Sex Offenses Against Students, Eric J. Kuperman

Cardozo Journal of Equal Rights & Social Justice

The note argues that teachers convicted of sex offenses against students should be subject to a national registration and notification system, akin to Megan's Law, due to the inadequacy of current systems in preventing these individuals from continuing to teach and offending again. The author emphasizes the need to protect children from sexual predators in educational settings, highlighting the failure of schools and courts to effectively address the issue.

Masthead, Cardozo Journal Of International And Comparative Law, Vol. 4 (1996)

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

No abstract provided.

Acknowledgment

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

No abstract provided.

Human Rights, International Law, And Domestic Courts, Edward D. Re

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article explores the role of domestic courts, particularly in the United States, in enforcing international human rights norms and the challenges posed by sovereign immunity. It argues that U.S. courts should give greater effect to international legal norms, especially in cases involving human rights violations by foreign states. The analysis critiques the U.S. Supreme Court's narrow interpretation of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) in Saudi Arabia v. Nelson and advocates for a more expansive approach to ensure accountability for human rights abuses.

The Economic And Political Logic Of Mass Privatization In Czechoslovakia And Poland, George Bogdan

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article examines the mass privatization programs implemented in Czechoslovakia (later the Czech Republic) and Poland during their transitions from communism to democracy and capitalism. It compares the design, implementation, and outcomes of these programs, highlighting the economic and political factors that shaped their approaches. The analysis focuses on how the unique historical, economic, and political contexts of each country influenced their privatization strategies and the effectiveness of these strategies in achieving marketization and institutional reform.

The Future Of The Past: Recovering Cultural Property, Lawrence M. Kaye

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The article addresses the legal challenges and evolving frameworks for recovering stolen cultural property, emphasizing the interplay between national and international laws. It argues that while significant progress has been made, particularly in the U.S., through judicial precedents and international conventions like the 1970 UNESCO and 1995 UNIDROIT Conventions, a unified global response is essential to combat the illicit trade effectively.

Crafting A Corporate Code From Scratch, Uriel Procaccia

Cardozo Law Review

In the summer of 1982 1 was contacted by the incumbent Minister of Justice of the State of Israel, Mr. Moshe Nissim. Nissim asked me to accept the commission of drafting a brand new and fully cohesive corporate code to replace our current, antiquated Companies Ordinance. I consented at once. Having consented, it occurred to me to reflect on the meaning of that little word, "cohesive," which was used-quite inadvertently, I presume-in Minister Nissim's solicitation. I finally came to interpret it as a sort of puzzle, or perhaps a quiz, which the resulting product, the corporate code, was crafted to …

Constitutional Constancy: Why Congress Should Cure Itself Of Amendment Fever, Kathleen M. Sullivan

Cardozo Law Review

The annual Benjamin N. Cardozo Lecture was delivered at the House of the Association on October 25, 1995, in memory of Benjamin N. Cardozo.

The Myth Of Testamentary Freedom, Melanie B. Leslie

Articles

No abstract provided.

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Law Review, Volume 17, Issue 3

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Against Market Rationality: Moral Critiques Of Economic Analysis In Legal Theory, Jane B. Baron, Jeffrey L. Dunoff

Cardozo Law Review

Sometimes, apparently unrelated bodies of thought turn out to contain and express common themes. To our surprise, we found a set of common themes and concerns running through three bodies of theory that might otherwise appear unconnected: environmental ethics, civic republicanism, and commodification. In very different contexts, authors in all three areas seemed to ask some very similar questions. Collected together, these questions comprise a novel critique of the economic analysis of law-a "moral" critique that is quite different from technical and distributional critiques that have been offered in the past.

Schrodinger’S Cat, Eugenics, And The Compulsory Sterilization Of Welfare Mothers: Deconstructing An Old/New Rhetoric And Constructing The Reproductive Right To Natality For Low-Income Women Of Color, Beverly Horsburgh

Cardozo Law Review

In Part I of this Article, I briefly trace the history of racism, sexism, and class bias in western scientific thought as well as the legal consequences that ensued in this country from scientific prejudice. In Part II, I turn to eugenics in our own time and explore the sterilization abuse of poor women of color as a disguised form of eugenics. I argue that the lack of popular sympathy for the reproductive problems of these women, due to their negative dehumanizing stereotyping and the pervasive influence of sociobiology, facilitates public acceptance of harsher measures in the future. I refer, …

Rethinking A Corporation’S Obligations To Creditors, Steven L. Schwarcz

Cardozo Law Review

No single body of law presently governs a corporation's obligations to creditors. However, disparate laws, starting from different perspectives, contribute to a patchwork of obligations that is poorly understood. Consequently, corporate directors have little guidance when balancing creditor and shareholder rights under corporate restructurings, securitizations, and leveraged transactions.

Commentators who have grappled with this issue focus almost exclusively on the fiduciary duty of a corporation's board of directors to shareholders. Some argue that only shareholders should be entitled to the duty; others argue that the duty should be extended to creditors under various circumstances. This Article maintains that both approaches …

Compensating Caregiving Relatives: Abandoning The Family Member Rule In Contracts, Jonathan S. Henes

Cardozo Law Review

The law presumes that a person who performs a valuable service for another will be compensated. However, a limited exception to this principle exists when the services are performed between family members. This exception, also known as the family member rule, is a nineteenth century creation that arose from the courts' understanding of the dynamics of the nineteenth century household. However, the household of the nineteenth century has all but disappeared from contemporary society. With the disappearance of this household, the issue that arises is whether the family member rule is still necessary. This Note argues that it is not …

No Leg To Stand On: The General Retainer Exception To The Ban On Nonrefundable Retainers Must Fall, Pamela S. Kunen

Cardozo Law Review

Part I of this Note reviews various attorney-client fee arrangements, with particular attention to forms of retainers. Part II traces the development of the rule banning nonrefundable retainers and of the so-called general retainer exception to this rule. Part III examines the general retainer first in terms of its two conventional but conflicting views-as an ordinary business agreement versus an attorney-client contract-and then pursues a deeper historical and descriptive examination of the device than is reflected in either conventional view. Because that examination leads to the conclusion that general retainers are attorney-client agreements, part IV scrutinizes them as such and …

Circuit Court Erie Errors And The District Court's Dilemma: From Roto-Lith And The Mirror Image Rule To Octagon Gas And Asset Securitization, Nikiforos Mathews

Cardozo Law Review

Part I of this Note examines the mistake made by the Tenth Circuit in Octagon Gas. It further discusses the related problem inherent in a district court's belief that it is bound by a circuit court's previous Erie decision in light of the recent Winter Panel decision. Part II demonstrates that, despite the doctrine of precedent, district courts are not invariably bound by the diversity decisions of their circuit courts under the modem Erie doctrine, and therefore, should independently determine the state issues before them. Part III returns to Winter Panel and examines how the District Court of Massachusetts …

Gestation, Intent, And The Seed: Defining Motherhood In The Era Of Assisted Human Reproduction, Malina Coleman

Cardozo Law Review

This Article examines whether legal motherhood should be based on the preconception intentions of the two women who contribute a reproduction function, on genetic contribution, or on gestation. After assessing the costs and benefits that the various rules generate, the Article recommends that intent should be the determinative factor, but only if a system of rules is in place to protect against overreaching in surrogacy agreements. Otherwise, motherhood should be based on gestation alone.

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Law Review, Volume 17, Issue 2

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Forms Of Constitution Making And Theories Of Democracy, Andrew Arato

Cardozo Law Review

There are those who still think that constitution making is a task that rests wholly within the realm of lawyers. Indeed, all constitutional texts in modem times have been drafted by lawyers. Behind the texts, however, are the most important political actors and forces of a given society, persuading some interpreters to take the view that constitution making represents the work of the political, of political politics, and of le pouvoir constituant. In such a conception, whoever holds the "constituent power," or acts in its name, hires the lawyers. But does the method of constitution making really matter? Either …

The United Kingdom, The European Court Of Human Rights, And Constitutional Review, A. W. Bradley

Cardozo Law Review

The aim of this Article is to consider whether there is now in the United Kingdom the embryo of a procedure for constitutional review that results from the United Kingdom's adherence to the European Convention on Human Rights as well as the burgeoning case law being developed by the European Court of Human Rights. To the extent that such an embryo exists, I hope to show that this is a development which has not been directly willed by the United Kingdom Parliament, nor by successive United Kingdom governments. Assuming that this process deserves to be described as piecemeal constitution making, …

Grounds Of Unconstitutionality: The Italian Case, Riccardo Guastini

Cardozo Law Review

Validity and invalidity are properties of legal rules. Both concepts refer to relationships-relationships between a given rule and the second-order rules that govern its creation and contents.

Indeed, it is a well-known feature of modern legal systems that law regulates, among other things, the creation of law itself. This amounts to saying that each legal system includes a large variety of second-order rules that govern the production of further legal rules along with "ordinary" rules of behavior, such as the rules of criminal law. Second-order rules regulate both the rule-making process and, to a certain extent, the contents of forthcoming …

Constitutional Justice And Democracy, Michel Troper

Cardozo Law Review

The issue of the compatibility of constitutional justice and democracy is considered in a particular way in France, for reasons relating both to the history of the legal culture and tothe peculiarities of the Constitutional Council, the institution which reviews the constitutionality of legislation.

The Mortgage Contingency Clause: A Trap For The Residential Real Estate Purchaser Using A Mortgage Broker, Craig Steven Delsack

Cardozo Law Review

Mr. and Mrs. Buyer found the perfect apartment to purchase to start their life together as husband and wife. The seller's attorney prepared the sales contract by filling in the blanks of a standard residential real estate form contract. Both parties signed the contract and the Buyers delivered a check representing a ten percent earnest money deposit. The contract contained a mortgage contingency clause permitting the Buyers to cancel the contract in the event that the Buyers could not, after applying for a loan from an institutional lender, obtain a mortgage with a ninety percent loan ratio. To save time …

“A One Way Ticket To Palookaville”: Supreme Court Takings Jurisprudence After Dolan And Its Implication For New York City’S Waterfront Zoning Resolution, Jill Illan Berger Inbar

Cardozo Law Review

This Note will use the Waterfront Ordinance as a vehicle for examining the new heightened scrutiny standard introduced in Dolan. Part I provides an overview of takings jurisprudence and the traditional pre-Nollan and pre-Dolan standards, which were applied to determine whether an exercise of police power oversteps its bounds and interferes with private property rights guaranteed under the Fifth Amendment. Part II reviews the new standards espoused by the Supreme Court in Nollan and Dolan. Part III describes the purpose of New York City's 1993. Waterfront Zoning Ordinance and discusses its history, objectives, and provisions. Part …