Digital Commons Network^™

Popularity Contest: Is An Independent Judiciary Compatible With Popular Constitutionalism?, Lulu S. Faulk

Indiana Law Journal

Can the theory of popular constitutionalism—where the people have authority to shape constitutional law—exist alongside judicial independence? On the surface, these two ideas seem like contestants in a popularity contest: Popular constitutionalism embraces the will of the people in defining constitutional law, while judicial independence insists that judges disregard any and all external pressure in an effort to uphold the tenets of the Constitution even when they are unpopular. The contrast of these competing ideas is all the more evident with recent Supreme Court decisions such as Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, demonstrating a deviation from majority opinion in …

Fall 2024

Ergo

No abstract provided.

Corporate Civil Disobedience, Susanna K. Ripken

Indiana Law Journal

Classic theories of civil disobedience endorse the right of individuals to commit illegal acts to protest unjust laws and policies. Acts of civil disobedience have historically played a central role in exposing injustice and producing vital legal and social change. The literature on civil disobedience is vast; political and legal theorists have long recognized the contributions of individual legal resisters in the ongoing pursuit of a just society. Little attention has been given, however, to intentional lawbreaking by organizational entities that seek to protest unjust, illegitimate, or discriminatory laws. This Article addresses that gap by exploring the prospect of corporate …

The Future Of Work In The Era Of Ai, Orly Lobel

Indiana Law Journal

Artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing both work itself and the processes of employment—hiring, recruitment, evaluation, compensation, performance analysis, retention, and job mobility. This Essay, based upon the 2024 Indiana Law Journal annual William R. Stewart Lecture, examines the effects of AI on work and argues for a holistic approach that harnesses the benefits of automation while addressing the inevitable systemic changes that AI is rapidly bringing to the labor market. The Essay examines two industries in which AI is already changing labor market demands: trucking and the performing arts. The Essay argues that while the automation can often increase efficiency …

Taylor Is First Indiana Law Student To Receive Sports Lawyers Association Student Writing Award, James Owsley Boyd

Keep Up With the Latest News from the Law School (blog)

A rising 3L at the Indiana University Maurer School of Law is one of 10 law students nationwide—and the first IU student ever— to receive the Sports Lawyers Association’s Student Writing Competition Award.

Amelia Taylor won the honors for her work “A Critical Analysis of Name, Image, and Likeness Policies and Their Implications for International Student-Athletes.”

While American student-athletes have been allowed to earn compensation through NIL deals since July 2021, international student-athletes have faced major hurdles due to immigration laws and policies.

“I chose to focus on international students’ NIL rights because this issue is often overlooked, with media …

Sotomayor Cites Maurer Faculty Member In Scotus’ Decline To Hear Alabama Bite Mark Case, James Owsley Boyd

Keep Up With the Latest News from the Law School (blog)

The case of an Alabama man convicted of murdering his wife in 1985 will not be reviewed by the U.S. Supreme Court, despite evidence that, nearly 40 years later, has been “wholly discredited.”

The Supreme Court denied certiorari in the case of McCrory v. Alabama, but Justice Sonia Sotomayor cited research from Indiana University Maurer School of Law Professor Valena Beety in her concurring agreement with the court’s decision.

Charles M. McCrory was convicted for the murder of his wife, Julie Bonds, based in large part on expert testimony from an odontologist who matched McCrory’s teeth to two bite marks …

Marginalized Laborers: A Study Of The Realities And Challenges Faced By International Domestic Workers In Kuwait, Adbalrahman Saud Alwaalan

Maurer Theses and Dissertations

The primary impetus for undertaking this inquiry into the legal status of international domestic workers in Kuwait is to furnish them with sufficient legal protection. By conducting a thorough analysis of the system, identifying its shortcomings, and evaluating its overall effectiveness, the proposed research aims to offer a comprehensive legal resolution to address the issue at hand.

Examining the various labor laws, regulations, and policies in Kuwait will facilitate a thorough understanding of the efficacy of the nation’s existing legal framework. Upon comprehending these sources, a detailed assessment of the extent to which they adhere to international human rights norms …

Thusi Selected As John Hope Franklin Prize Recipient, James Owsley Boyd

Keep Up With the Latest News from the Law School (blog)

The Law and Society Association will honor an Indiana University Maurer School of Law professor this week at its 2024 Annual Meeting in Denver from June 6-9.

Professor India Thusi will receive the John Hope Franklin Prize, recognizing exceptional scholarship in the field of Race, Racism and the Law.

Thusi’s winning work, “The Racialized History of Vice Policing,” was published in the UCLA Law Review in 2023.

“The article provides an enduring scholarly contribution at the intersection of policing, abolition, and legal history,” according to the LSA. “Thusi adopts an abolitionist framework and provides a much-needed analysis of vice policing …

Authenticating Social Media Evidence In Chinese Criminal Procedure Law -- A Comparative Study, Yage Huang

Maurer Theses and Dissertations

Authentication requires the proponent to provide sufficient proof that the proposed social media evidence is, indeed, what it is claimed to be. The rapid proliferation of social media evidence has posed significant challenges for its authentication. This dissertation explores the authentication challenges for social media evidence in a comprehensive manner.

This research employs a qualitative research methodology, including theoretical and analytical methods, to examine the theoretical approaches, statutory provisions, and recent judicial rulings related to the authentication of social media evidence within the legal frameworks of China and the United States. Through a comparative analysis, this study reveals significant commonalities …

The 14th Circuit, Jayanth K. Krishnan

Articles by Maurer Faculty

2025 will mark the fifteenth anniversary of Professor Stephen Legomsky’s landmark article proposing “radical surgery” on American immigration adjudication. Professor Legomsky argued for creating an Article III Court of Appeals for Immigration (CAI), replacing both the Justice Department’s Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) and the immigration jurisdiction of the regional circuit courts.

For Professor Legomsky, his restructuring would: (1) reduce costs, delays, and needless duplications inherent in how the BIA and regional circuits functioned; (2) enhance uniformity of immigration case law; (3) ensure greater independence by a now nationwide Article III appellate court; (4) allow for this new court to …

Acs Selects Allyson Mcbride As Next Generation Leader, James Owsley Boyd

Keep Up With the Latest News from the Law School (blog)

The American Constitution Society has named Indiana University Maurer School of Law second-year student Allyson McBride a Next Generation Leader—one of 34 across the United States—the organization announced April 11.

She is the third Indiana Law student in as many years to earn the prestigious recognition.

Vol. 66, No. 12 (April 8, 2024)

Indiana Law Annotated

No abstract provided.

Survival Labor, Yvette Butler

Articles by Maurer Faculty

This Article makes one simple, novel claim: crime is labor when it generates income, allows individuals to pursue self-sufficiency, or allows them to fulfill societal expectations of providing for or caring for dependents. When individuals engage in survival crimes, instead of seeing them as criminals, we should see them as workers engaged in survival labor.

The carceral system continues to disproportionately harm racial minorities and people living in poverty. The foundations of many laws regulating racialized bodies and the policing of those bodies has created a culture where blackness is equivalent to criminality. While a penal abolitionist framework is helpful …

Vol. 66, No. 11 (April 1, 2024)

Indiana Law Annotated

No abstract provided.

Vol. 66, No. 10 (March 25, 2024)

Indiana Law Annotated

No abstract provided.

Vol. 66, No. 09 (March 18, 2024)

Indiana Law Annotated

No abstract provided.

Vol. 66, No. 07 (February 26, 2024)

Indiana Law Annotated

No abstract provided.

Vol. 66, No. 05 (February 12, 2024)

Indiana Law Annotated

No abstract provided.

Vol. 66, No. 04 (February 5, 2024)

Indiana Law Annotated

No abstract provided.

The Federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act: Statutory Requirements, Regulations, And Need (Especially In Post-Dobbs America), Deborah Widiss

Articles by Maurer Faculty

The federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, enacted in December 2022, is landmark legislation that will help ensure workers can stay healthy through a pregnancy. It responds to the reality that pregnant workers may need small changes at work, such as permission to sit periodically, carry a water bottle, relief from heavy lifting, or reduced exposure to potentially dangerous chemicals. Workers may also need schedule modifications or leave for prenatal appointments, childbirth, or post-partum recovery, or accommodations to address medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.

Previously, federal sex discrimination law and federal disability law sometimes required employers to provide such …

Conjuring The Flag: The Problem Of Implied Government Endorsements, Michael Mattioli

Articles by Maurer Faculty

This Article exposes a harmful form of advertising that exploits government actions like patent issuances, FDA authorizations, and trademark registrations. By calling upon the symbolic power of such regulatory approvals—i.e., “conjuring the flag”—marketers deceive consumers, distort competition, and undermine administrative agencies. Using machine-learning techniques to analyze hundreds of ads across multiple media formats, this Article offers the first comprehensive analysis of this pervasive practice. The study reveals that it is especially prevalent in industry settings where consumers are likely to seek reassurance that a product is safe and effective. Specifically, the examples examined show that patents are mentioned frequently in …

Selling Surveillance, Asaf Lubin

Articles by Maurer Faculty

Almost everything we do on the Internet is achieved through Internet-connected devices, such as smartphones and laptops. This reality has produced a new sprawling industry of commercial spyware corporations: a vast network of companies specializing in selling security vulnerabilities in the very devices we all use. These companies provide clients with tools and services for unauthorized access and surveillance. Investigative reporting has unearthed the scope and nature of the systematic abuses produced by these technologies. Around the world, government actors rely on spyware to target human rights activists, journalists, and dissidents with almost no accountability.

Spyware companies have long defended …

What Fischer V. United States Gets Wrong About Prosecutorial Discretion, Cindy J. Cho

Articles by Maurer Faculty

Conservative Supreme Court Justices have recently expressed heightened concerns about prosecutorial power in cases involving former President Donald Trump and the Capitol siege on January 6, 2021.  Making good on those worries, the conservative majority in Fischer v. United States, rested its decision in part on theoretical concerns about government overreach. The Department of Justice has pushed back on those concerns, but to this point, the debate has been mostly rhetorical and hypothetical.

This article attempts to fill that rhetorical void—and concretely answer the concerns animating Fischer—with evidence from actual cases.  A survey of ten January 6 cases …

The D.C. Circuit As A Conseil D'Etat, Andrew Hammond

Articles by Maurer Faculty

A storm is brewing in American administrative law. More and more federal judges, including a majority of the Justices of the Supreme Court, openly question longstanding doctrine. A throng of academics profess skepticism of the same. This formalist turn among judges, lawyers, and academics challenges the very legitimacy of the administrative state. But what does this tempest portend for the D.C. Circuit?

The D.C. Circuit is often described as the nation’s second highest court, but its precise role in the federal judiciary is only fifty years old. As a member of that appellate court, now-Chief Justice John Roberts once admitted …

Love, Liberalism, Substituted Judgment, James Toomey

Indiana Law Journal

Under the doctrine of substituted judgment, decision-makers for adults without legal capacity are to make the decision the person in their care would have made. In cases involving irreversible cognitive decline—where substituted judgment is most frequently applied—scholars have struggled to explain it, resorting to mysterious metaphysical claims. These philosophical acrobatics seem necessary because the person for whom the decision is made cannot appreciate it, and, philosophically, they may not be the same person they had been.

This Article offers a novel account of substituted judgment that circumvents these challenges. I argue first that the doctrine is straightforwardly justified in cases …

Helping Students To Organize Their Thoughts About The Erie Doctrine, William Casto

Indiana Law Journal

This little Essay presents a framework for teaching the Erie Doctrine. It is not a grand analysis of the federal courts’ puzzle. It does not even offer a wondrously insightful vision of one of the puzzle’s colorful pieces. Rather, the purpose is quite modest. The essay simply aims to help students to organize their thoughts about whether a particular legal issue is governed by state or federal law. Given the Essay’s limited and wholly heuristic purpose, the usual endless parade of all possible cases and the careful rehearsal of exquisite and finely-tuned factors and considerations are eschewed.

Banned Books & Banned Identities: Maintaining Secularism And The Ability To Read In Public Education For The Well-Being Of America's Youth, Megan M. Tylenda

Indiana Journal of Law and Social Equality

Books containing LGBTQ+ themes and characters are being removed from public school libraries at a rapid rate across the United States. While a book challenge has made it to the Supreme Court once before, the resulting singular plurality opinion left courts without a clear test to apply, ultimately leaving students’ First Amendment rights in the air. Additionally, the increasingly relaxed view of courts towards religious influence in public schools indicates that if a modern case were to reach the Supreme Court, religious challenges may be accepted, which would leave LGBTQ+ students who seek to see themselves represented in literature without …

Countering Jihadi Cool And The Case Of Raza V. City Of New York, Caroline Joan S. Picart

Indiana Journal of Law and Social Equality

This Article begins with an explanation of the rhetoric, aesthetics, and culture of jihadi cool/chic, which is a crucial factor in the formation of self-radicalizing individuals. It then analyzes the jurisprudence, and legal and cultural ramifications of Raza v. City of New York, in which the New York Police Department had initiated an intense covert surveillance operation that focused on Muslims in New York and beyond without probable cause. This led to a lawsuit that claimed that the New York Police Department’s Muslim Surveillance Program violated the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, the First Amendment’s Free Exercise and Establishment Clauses, …

A Taxonomy Of Impeachment Methods Used Worldwide, Lucas Brown

Indiana Journal of Constitutional Design

Impeachment is a charge of misconduct against a government official who, if convicted, is removed from office before the term is set to end. A country can impeach any number of elected or appointed officials but is most frequently discussed in its use against the president of a particular country. This paper explores impeachment by looking at the impeachment methods used world-wide, attempting to draw a correlation between the method of impeachment used and the frequency of impeachment. The analysis shows that a correlation exists between the frequency of impeachment and the impeachment method used. It will also demonstrate how …

Alternative Routes For Military Grievance, Courtney Kintz

Indiana Journal of Constitutional Design

Once a country experiences a coup, that country is likely to experience another coup within six years and, since 1950, there have been at least 240 military coups. On average, about half of all coup attempts involve fatalities, with most resulting in governmental and civilian deaths. So, once a country experiences a coup, it is statistically likely that another coup will expose citizens to more uncertainty about their safety. For a citizen whose country has experienced a recent coup, this data is alarming as an incident of one coup starts the stopwatch for another coup occurring within a few years. …