Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Medical Jurisprudence Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Articles 1 - 15 of 15

Full-Text Articles in Medical Jurisprudence

Equal Protection Challenges To Legislative Abrogation Of The Collateral Source Rule Sep 1987

Equal Protection Challenges To Legislative Abrogation Of The Collateral Source Rule

Washington and Lee Law Review

No abstract provided.


Equal Protection Challenges To Legislative Abrogation Of The Collateral Source Rule Sep 1987

Equal Protection Challenges To Legislative Abrogation Of The Collateral Source Rule

Washington and Lee Law Review

No abstract provided.


Will Tort Reform Combat The Medical Malpractice Insurance Availability And Affordability Problems That Virginia's Physicians Are Facing? Sep 1987

Will Tort Reform Combat The Medical Malpractice Insurance Availability And Affordability Problems That Virginia's Physicians Are Facing?

Washington and Lee Law Review

No abstract provided.


A Proposal To Cap Tort Liability: Avoiding The Pitfalls Of Heightened Rationality, Richard S. Kuhl Jun 1987

A Proposal To Cap Tort Liability: Avoiding The Pitfalls Of Heightened Rationality, Richard S. Kuhl

University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform

This Note sets forth a model statute that limits high damage awards, yet will withstand the rigors of judicial scrutiny. After presenting a brief background of the medical malpractice crisis in Part I, Part II outlines the standards of equal protection review that the courts are presently using. The Note then focuses on the constitutional challenges to caps on medical malpractice liability in Part III. Part IV discusses the values and interests that were found to be dispositive in the courts' decisions. Finally, after analyzing the criteria that must be met to ensure that a legislative limitation will survive judicial …


Medical Maloccurrence Insurance: A First Party No-Fault Insurance Proposal For Resolving The Medical Malpractice Insurance Controversy, Larry M. Pollack Jun 1987

Medical Maloccurrence Insurance: A First Party No-Fault Insurance Proposal For Resolving The Medical Malpractice Insurance Controversy, Larry M. Pollack

University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform

Part I of this Note examines the broad, underlying themes of tort theory and argues that, in general, the tort system's primary responsibility should be compensation, rather than deterrence of risk taking. In so far as the production of goods and services causes injury, such losses should be shared and spread as widely and proportionately as possible. Part II discusses the history and nature of the medical malpractice insurance crisis. Part III evaluates the numerous systemic solutions suggested by various commentators. Finally, Part IV proposes a new solution: first party, no-fault medical maloccurrence insurance (MMI).


Casenotes: Statute Of Limitations — Medical Malpractice — Constitutional Law — Five Year Statute Of Repose On Medical Malpractice Claims That Commences When An Injury Occurs Is Constitutional. Hill V. Fitzgerald, 304 Md. 689, 501 A.2d 27 (1985), Nancy E. Leibowitz Jan 1987

Casenotes: Statute Of Limitations — Medical Malpractice — Constitutional Law — Five Year Statute Of Repose On Medical Malpractice Claims That Commences When An Injury Occurs Is Constitutional. Hill V. Fitzgerald, 304 Md. 689, 501 A.2d 27 (1985), Nancy E. Leibowitz

University of Baltimore Law Review

No abstract provided.


Comments: Blasting The Cap: Constitutional Issues Arising From Maryland's Limitation Of Noneconomic Damages In Personal Injury Claims, James R. Andersen Jan 1987

Comments: Blasting The Cap: Constitutional Issues Arising From Maryland's Limitation Of Noneconomic Damages In Personal Injury Claims, James R. Andersen

University of Baltimore Law Review

A topic of fervent debate in recent years has been the growing crisis in personal injury liability insurance, particularly in the area of medical malpractice. Insurers, doctors, and lawyers have presented differing theories as to the cause and solution of the problem. In 1986, the Maryland General Assembly sought to resolve the crisis by limiting the amount recoverable for noneconomic damages in a personal injury action to $350,000. Similar provisions in other states have been struck down as unconstitutional. This comment examines the constitutionality of Maryland's noneconomic damages limitation and argues that the damage limitation violates both the state and …


The Constitutional Attack On Virginia's Medical Malpractice Cap: Equal Protection And The Right To Jury Trial, M. Margaret Branham Kimmel Jan 1987

The Constitutional Attack On Virginia's Medical Malpractice Cap: Equal Protection And The Right To Jury Trial, M. Margaret Branham Kimmel

University of Richmond Law Review

Since its enactment, Virginia's statute limiting medical malpractice awards has spawned questions concerning its constitutionality. In response to the alleged insurance crisis of the 1970's, many state legislatures passed statutes designed to slow the rising costs of liability insurance. With such statutes already enacted in many jurisdictions, the insurance and health care industries claim that another malpractice insurance crisis exists today. While that may be true in some parts of the country and within some medical specialties, the problem originally was not as severe in the state of Virginia. Today, it is still not as severe in Virginia as it …


Substituted Judgment And The Right To Refuse Shock Treatment In Washington: In Re Schuoler, Gregory S. Marshall Jan 1987

Substituted Judgment And The Right To Refuse Shock Treatment In Washington: In Re Schuoler, Gregory S. Marshall

Seattle University Law Review

This Note will first analyze and evaluate two competing decision-making models established in other jurisdictions. The Note will then apply that analysis to Schuoler and critically evaluate that decision. The Note will conclude that while the Washington court follows the more appropriate judicial substituted judgment model, its poor articulation of that model may defeat the purpose of the decision: to protect a mental patient's right to refuse ECT.


The Frustaci Septuplets: Miracle Or Malpractice, Susan Ferguson Slabaugh Jan 1987

The Frustaci Septuplets: Miracle Or Malpractice, Susan Ferguson Slabaugh

Journal of Law and Health

The possibility of imposing such liability has tremendous implications not only for the physician and clinic directly involved, but also for other health care practitioners, health care consumers, and the legal profession, as well. This Note will focus on those implications and proposes a solution to the issues raised by this type of litigation.


Medical Staff Decisions In Private Hospitals: The Role Of Due Process, Thaddeus J. Nodzenski Jan 1987

Medical Staff Decisions In Private Hospitals: The Role Of Due Process, Thaddeus J. Nodzenski

Loyola University Chicago Law Journal

No abstract provided.


Monopsony Power In Health Care Markets: Must The Big Buyer Beware Hard Bargaining?, Jack A. Rovner Jan 1987

Monopsony Power In Health Care Markets: Must The Big Buyer Beware Hard Bargaining?, Jack A. Rovner

Loyola University Chicago Law Journal

No abstract provided.


Baumgartner V. First Church Of Christ, Scientist: Religious Healers' Exemption From Liability, Rebecca Carlins Jan 1987

Baumgartner V. First Church Of Christ, Scientist: Religious Healers' Exemption From Liability, Rebecca Carlins

Loyola University Chicago Law Journal

No abstract provided.


Medicaid's Unhealthy Side Effect: The Financial Burdens On At-Home Spouses Of Institutionalized Recipients, Paul Drizner Jan 1987

Medicaid's Unhealthy Side Effect: The Financial Burdens On At-Home Spouses Of Institutionalized Recipients, Paul Drizner

Loyola University Chicago Law Journal

No abstract provided.


The Constitutionality Of Medical Malpractice Legislative Reform: A National Survey, Larry Stephen Milner M.D., J.D. Jan 1987

The Constitutionality Of Medical Malpractice Legislative Reform: A National Survey, Larry Stephen Milner M.D., J.D.

Loyola University Chicago Law Journal

No abstract provided.