Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Law Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Church and State

Discipline
Institution
Publication Year
Publication
Publication Type
File Type

Articles 1 - 30 of 165

Full-Text Articles in Law

Establishment Clause Mythology, Peter J. Smith, Robert W. Tuttle Jan 2023

Establishment Clause Mythology, Peter J. Smith, Robert W. Tuttle

GW Law Faculty Publications & Other Works

For 75 years, the Supreme Court’s opinions have reflected stark conflict between two competing narratives about the Establishment Clause’s meaning and legal foundation. One view holds that the Constitution requires a separation between church and state. The other view asserts that the government may promote religion. The former view—which we call separationism—is based on the framers’ understanding of the nature of civil government, and on a political theory of liberal pluralism. The latter view—which we call religionism—is usually grounded in tradition, and principally has its roots in the Second Great Awakening of the nineteenth century and its urge to transform …


No Aid, No Agency, Steven K. Green Jul 2021

No Aid, No Agency, Steven K. Green

William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal

Over the past three decades, members of the Supreme Court have demonstrated increasing hostility to the Establishment Clause’s rule against funding religion, first enunciated in 1947. Over the years, the Court has not only narrowed the rule to allow for government aid to flow to religious schools and faith-based charities, it has more recently declared that to enforce that rule may amount to discrimination against religion. This Article argues that a key reason for the decline in the no-aid principle rests on the weakness of the rationale underlying that rule: that funding of religion coerces the conscience of taxpayers. The …


The Supreme Court And Private Schools: An Update, Neal Devins Sep 2019

The Supreme Court And Private Schools: An Update, Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Social Meaning And School Vouchers, Neal Devins Sep 2019

Social Meaning And School Vouchers, Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Religious Symbols And The Establishment Clause, Neal Devins Sep 2019

Religious Symbols And The Establishment Clause, Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Coercion And Choice Under The Establishment Clause, Cynthia V. Ward Sep 2019

Coercion And Choice Under The Establishment Clause, Cynthia V. Ward

Cynthia V. Ward

In recent Establishment Clause cases the Supreme Court has found nondenominational, state-sponsored prayers unconstitutionally "coercive" -although attendance at the events featuring the prayer was not required by the state; religious dissenters were free to choose not to say the challenged prayers; and dissenters who so chose, or who chose not to attend the events, suffered no state-enforced sanction. Part I of this Article lays out the historical background that gave rise to the coercion test, traces the development of that test in the Court's case law, and isolates the core elements in the vision of coercion that animates the test. …


Religious Tests And The British Monarchy, Nathan B. Oman Sep 2019

Religious Tests And The British Monarchy, Nathan B. Oman

Nathan B. Oman

No abstract provided.


The Story Of A Forgotten Battle, Nathan B. Oman Sep 2019

The Story Of A Forgotten Battle, Nathan B. Oman

Nathan B. Oman

No abstract provided.


The Need For A Law Of Church And Market, Nathan B. Oman Sep 2019

The Need For A Law Of Church And Market, Nathan B. Oman

Nathan B. Oman

This Essay uses Helfand and Richman’s fine article to raise the question of the law of church and market. In Part I, I argue that the question of religion’s proper relationship to the market is more than simply another aspect of the church-state debates. Rather, it is a topic deserving explicit reflection in its own right. In Part II, I argue that Helfand and Richman demonstrate the danger of creating the law of church and market by accident. Courts and legislators do this when they resolve questions religious commerce poses by applying legal theories developed without any thought for the …


Judicial Review And Nongeneralizable Cases, Neal Devins, Alan J. Meese Sep 2019

Judicial Review And Nongeneralizable Cases, Neal Devins, Alan J. Meese

Alan J. Meese

No abstract provided.


Zelman V. Simmons-Harris, Neal Devins Sep 2019

Zelman V. Simmons-Harris, Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Inconsistent Standards Of Review In Last Term's Establishment Clause Cases, Neal Devins Sep 2019

Inconsistent Standards Of Review In Last Term's Establishment Clause Cases, Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Fundamentalist Schools And The Law, Neal Devins Sep 2019

Fundamentalist Schools And The Law, Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Fundamentalist Christian Educators V. State: An Inevitable Compromise, Neal Devins Sep 2019

Fundamentalist Christian Educators V. State: An Inevitable Compromise, Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


School Vouchers: Inviting The Public Into The Religious Square, James G. Dwyer Sep 2019

School Vouchers: Inviting The Public Into The Religious Square, James G. Dwyer

James G. Dwyer

No abstract provided.


Funding Religion In A Post-Zelman World, James G. Dwyer Sep 2019

Funding Religion In A Post-Zelman World, James G. Dwyer

James G. Dwyer

No abstract provided.


Symposium Introduction: The Religion Clauses In The 21st Century, William P. Marshall, Vivian E. Hamilton, John E. Taylor Sep 2019

Symposium Introduction: The Religion Clauses In The 21st Century, William P. Marshall, Vivian E. Hamilton, John E. Taylor

Vivian E. Hamilton

No abstract provided.


Religious V. Secular Ideologies And Sex Education: A Response To Professors Cahn And Carbone, Vivian E. Hamilton Sep 2019

Religious V. Secular Ideologies And Sex Education: A Response To Professors Cahn And Carbone, Vivian E. Hamilton

Vivian E. Hamilton

No abstract provided.


Introduction: Perspectives On Religious Fundamentalism And Families In The U.S., Vivian E. Hamilton Sep 2019

Introduction: Perspectives On Religious Fundamentalism And Families In The U.S., Vivian E. Hamilton

Vivian E. Hamilton

No abstract provided.


Bob Jones University V. United States 461 U.S. 574 (1983), Neal Devins Sep 2019

Bob Jones University V. United States 461 U.S. 574 (1983), Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Bob Jones University V. United States 461 U.S. 574 (1983), Neal Devins Sep 2019

Bob Jones University V. United States 461 U.S. 574 (1983), Neal Devins

Neal E. Devins

No abstract provided.


Religion In The Public Square, Davison M. Douglas Sep 2019

Religion In The Public Square, Davison M. Douglas

Davison M. Douglas

No abstract provided.


Book Review, Richard Garnett Jan 2019

Book Review, Richard Garnett

Journal Articles

Richard Garnett reviews Ellis M. West's The Free Exercise of Religion in America: Its Original Constitutional Meaning

This is a review of Professor Ellis M. West's 2019 study of the original meaning of "free exercise of religion."


An Illiberal Union, Sonu Bedi May 2018

An Illiberal Union, Sonu Bedi

William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal

This Article breaks new ground by applying the philosophical framework of liberal neutrality (most famously articulated by John Rawls) to the United States Supreme Court’s jurisprudence on marriage. At first blush, the Court’s decision in Obergefell v. Hodges—the culmination of marriage rights—seems to affirm a central principle of liberalism, namely equal access to marriage regardless of sexual orientation. Gays and lesbians can finally take part in an institution that celebrates the union of two committed individuals. But perversely, in its attempt to expand access to marriage, the Court has simultaneously entrenched values that are antithetical to the basic tenants …


Not Today, Satan: Re-Examining Viewpoint Discrimination In The Limited Public Forum, Daniel Cutler May 2018

Not Today, Satan: Re-Examining Viewpoint Discrimination In The Limited Public Forum, Daniel Cutler

William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal

No abstract provided.


The Schofield/Gunner Decisions And Episcopal Church Property-Splitting Litigation: Considering Proposed Improvements To The Litigation Process And The Neutral Principles Of Law Doctrine, Ten Years On, Timothy D. Watson Apr 2018

The Schofield/Gunner Decisions And Episcopal Church Property-Splitting Litigation: Considering Proposed Improvements To The Litigation Process And The Neutral Principles Of Law Doctrine, Ten Years On, Timothy D. Watson

William & Mary Business Law Review

In recent years, the Episcopal Church in the United States has seen a spate of parishes leaving the Church. Many of these departing parishes have attempted to take property with them as they leave and continue to operate independently or realign themselves with a different denomination. The Episcopal Church maintains that this property is held by the parishes on behalf of the national Church, and has generally been successful in obtaining a return of the property through legal action. In deciding these suits, state courts have skirted carefully around the contours of ecclesiastical questions; many state courts, following the Supreme …


The Light Of Nature: John Locke, Natural Rights, And The Origins Of American Religious Liberty, Steven J. Heyman Mar 2018

The Light Of Nature: John Locke, Natural Rights, And The Origins Of American Religious Liberty, Steven J. Heyman

Marquette Law Review

This Article explores John Locke’s theory of religious liberty, which deeply influenced the adoption of the First Amendment and the first state bills of rights. Locke sharply criticized the religious and political order of Restoration England—a regime in which the king claimed to hold absolute power by divine right and in which individuals were required by law to conform to the established church.

In opposition to this regime, Locke developed a powerful theory of human beings as rational creatures who were entitled to think for themselves, to direct their own actions, and to pursue their own happiness within the bounds …


Why Justice Breyer Was Wrong In Van Orden V. Perry, Erwin Chemerinsky Jun 2017

Why Justice Breyer Was Wrong In Van Orden V. Perry, Erwin Chemerinsky

Erwin Chemerinsky

No abstract provided.


Why Church And State Should Be Separate, Erwin Chemerinsky Jun 2017

Why Church And State Should Be Separate, Erwin Chemerinsky

Erwin Chemerinsky

No abstract provided.


Should ‘Public Reason’ Developed Under Us Establishment Clause Jurisprudence Apply To Australia?, Anthony K. Thompson Dec 2015

Should ‘Public Reason’ Developed Under Us Establishment Clause Jurisprudence Apply To Australia?, Anthony K. Thompson

The University of Notre Dame Australia Law Review

John Rawls’ idea of public reason holds that comprehensive doctrines including religion should not be allowed a voice in the public square. Such ideas prevent society achieving that ‘overlapping consensus’ which is said to be a requirement for enduring peace and progress. However, the suggestion that some ideas should be excluded from public debate is anti-democratic. This article reviews Rawls’ idea of public reason’ against its US legal context and suggests it was a response to US Supreme Court decisions concerning their First Amendment. Though our framers copied most of that clause into the Australian Constitution, the High Court has …