Law Commons^™

Bodily Evidence And Rule 312, M.R.E., David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

n addressing the issues of obtaining bodily evidence, such as bodily fluids, from a suspect, Rule 312 of the Military Rules of Evidence must be considered in conjunction with the issues of self-incrimination, due process, and the Fourth Amendment. The Rule describes the procedures for collection of bodily evidence of service members. For example, a service member may not invoke the right against self-incrimination for external bodily evidence, but may when bodily fluids or cavity searches are requested. Any nonconsensual search may be conducted if it is both reasonable and performed under one of the authorized procedures of Rule 312. …

The Court-Martial: A Historical Survey, David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

In this article, Captain (P) Schlueter describes the development of the legal tribunal known as the court-martial. Beginning with the use of this form of trial in the armies of imperial Rome two thousand years ago, the author traces its evolution through the Middle Ages, to Britain from the Renaissance to the American Revolution. The focus then shifts to the United States, and the focus then shifts to the present day.

Tempia, Turner, Mcomber And The Military Rules Of Evidence: A Right To Counsel Trio With The New Look, David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

The potential for litigating right to counsel issues is ripe, and the new Military Rules of Evidence and recent case law ensure ample opportunity for litigation. Several significant developments in the law of military interrogations warrant an examination of a military suspect’s right to counsel. A series of Court of Military Appeals decisions have either clarified or expanded military case law on military interrogations. The pending new Military Rules of Evidence will implement a large amount of military case law, in some instances alter existing law, and more closely align military interrogation practices with prevailing civilian rules. Counsel should focus …

Pos-Graduacao Em Direito: Questoes Correlatas (Post-Graduation In Law: Related Questions), Roberto Rosas

Faculty Articles

No abstract provided.

1979-1980 School Year, St. Mary's University School Of Law

The Witan

No abstract provided.

Tutela Processual Do Menor (Procedural Guardianship Of The Minor), Roberto Rosas

Faculty Articles

SUMMARY: I. ACTIVE AND PASSIVE CAPACITY OF THE SMALLEST. II. DEFENSE OF THE SMALLEST. III. THE INTEGRATION OF THE MINOR IN THE SOCIETY: ADOPTION AND LEGITIMATION OF ADOPTION.

The Younger Abstention: Primary State Jurisdiction Over Law Enforcement, David A. Dittfurth

Faculty Articles

The abstention doctrines have received much attention by the United States Supreme Court over the last decade. These doctrines are represented by judicial rules that require federal trial courts, in appropriate circumstances, to abstain from exercising subject matter jurisdiction although they clearly have the power to do so. As a result, the particular case is shunted back into a state judicial system for determination.

The most confusing of these doctrines is the one arising in major part from Younger v. Harris. In short, this case stands for the rule that, once a state criminal prosecution has been initiated, a federal …

Personal Jurisdiction Under Article 2, Ucmj Whither Russo, Catlow, And Brown?, David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

The question of personal jurisdiction for military courts in cases of invalid enlistment creates several legal issues. Invalid enlistment cases exist in a legal gray area due to the uncertainty of whether the cases should be tried by civilian or military courts. The age and competence of the enlistee are material to determining jurisdiction. The conduct of the recruiter directly affects whether the enlistee was competent. Congress amended Article 2 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice in order to address these problems. The amendment resolves many of the lingering jurisdictional issues created by Russo and Brown, but fails to …

Wagner, Valadez And Harrison: A Definitive Enlistment Trilogy, David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

One area where enlistment law has received keen scrutiny is the subject of enlistment contracts vis a vis the question of personal jurisdiction. The Court of Military Appeals’s decision in United States v. Wagner served as the keystone for the Valadez and Harrison decisions. The Court in Wagner established the concept of constructive enlistment, which it subsequently relied on in Valadez and Harrison.

In Wagner, the court addressed whether a regulatory disqualification in and of itself voids the original enlistment contract for purposes of court-martial jurisdiction. The Court stated the regulation in question was not sufficient to void Wagner’s enlistment …

1978-1979 School Year, St. Mary's University School Of Law

The Witan

No abstract provided.

Introduction, Bernard D. Reams Jr.

Faculty Articles

Volume Two of Immigration and Nationality Law Review continues to represent a centralized annual forum for the paramount articles concerning American immigration laws. In addition to the law review articles selected by the editor for inclusion in this second volume, two original essays by practitioners in immigration law are featured. Mark Mancini examines excludability for lack of a valid labor certification as a species of fraud, and Dan P. Danilov reviews and discusses recent changes regarding nonimmigrant and immigrant visas for workers, businessmen, managers and investors. The Review’s goal remains that of providing the practicing lawyer and legal researcher with …

1977-1978 School Year, St. Mary's University School Of Law

The Witan

No abstract provided.

The Enlistment Contract: A Uniform Approach, David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

The author explores the history of various jurisdictional and administrative issues that arise under consideration of a service member’s enlistment contract. He proposes a change to the Uniform Code of Military Justice to codify the constructive enlistment doctrine for establishing personal court-martial jurisdiction over service members whose enlistment contracts and entry onto active duty were facilitated by recruiter misconduct. The proposal later became part of amendment to Art. 2, U.C.M.J..

Constructive Enlistments: Alive And Well, David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

Despite the predicted demise of the doctrine of constructive enlistments, recent case law from the Courts of Military Appeals has extended its existence. The constructive enlistment is recognized as a means of changing one’s status from civilian to servicemember where some deficiencies exist in the formal enlistment process.

In a trio of cases, United States v. Brown, United States v. Catlow, and United States v. Russo, the Court of Military Appeals laid a firm foundation for estopping the government from relying upon constructive enlistments in order to establish in personam court-martial jurisdiction. This trio of cases raised more questions than …

Unequal Justice: Lawyers And Social Change In Modern America, By Jerold S. Auerbach (Book Review), David A. Dittfurth

Faculty Articles

In Unequal Justice, Jerold S. Auerbach attempts to prove that the legal profession has failed to adequately pursue equality of justice. He finds little evidence that the legal profession or its dominant factions have made an adequate effort to assure the provision of legal services according to need. On the contrary, most of the historical evidence presented in this book leads one to believe that the legal profession has accepted profit as its real goal.

The author contends that, because the legal profession is responsible for formulating and applying law in a very legalistic society, it serves a very important …

1976-1977 School Year, St. Mary's University School Of Law

The Witan

No abstract provided.

Introduction, Bernard D. Reams Jr.

Faculty Articles

The law of immigration and nationality is becoming an increasingly important topic in legal literature. This introductory volume of Immigration and Nationality Law Review represents an attempt to provide a centralized annual forum for the leading articles in this area of American law. Normally, leading legal periodical articles on the subjects of immigration, nationality, and alienage, are spread throughout various law journals. At best, materials germane to this subject have occasionally appeared in special law review issues or symposium volumes published by various American law schools. However, considering the growing relevance and concerns of immigration and nationality in the United …

Charter Air Travel: Paper Airplanes In A Dogfight (Comment), Gerald S. Reamey

Faculty Articles

Air transportation has traditionally been considered the most expensive form of travel. In that price context, the charter is an anomaly. Supplemental air carriers have built multi-million dollar businesses exclusively from the charter trade, and millions of passengers have flown by charter.

An anomaly, however, is inherently suspect and becomes proportionally more suspect as it infringes upon the status quo. Resolution of questions concerning the viability of the charter concept lies in a full understanding of the different charter forms available, the possible alternatives to these forms, the advantages and disadvantages of each, and the best way to accomplish the …

Allegheny Airlines, Inc. V. United States (Case Note), Gerald S. Reamey

Faculty Articles

On September 9, 1969, Robert W. Carey, a student pilot flying a solo cross-country flight in a plane owned by the operator of the flight school in which he was enrolled, collided with an Allegheny Airlines plane near Fairland, Indiana, destroying both aircraft and killing Carey, the crew of the Allegheny aircraft, and all 78 passengers. Allegheny Airlines, Inc. and G.E.C.C. Leasing Corporation brought suit-seeking recovery of damages sustained by their aircraft and engine, and named Forth Corporation, owner of the airplane and operator of the flying school, as a defendant. The trial court, in holding for the defendants, determined …

Allegheny Airlines, Inc. V. United States (Case Note), Gerald S. Reamey

Faculty Articles

Under Allegheny Airlines, the United States Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit held that a flying school/aircraft owner is engaged in a joint enterprise with its student pilots and is vicariously liable for the student’s negligent acts. This Court and others have developed the principle that the vicarious liability of an aircraft owner for the actions of the pilot is dependent upon the existence of a principal/agent relationship between the owner and pilot. Courts developed this legal fiction to enable recovery by injured parties against the financially responsible principal, rather than effectively denying recovery by forcing personal judgments against …

1975-1976 School Year, St. Mary's University School Of Law

The Witan

No abstract provided.

Judicial Reasoning And Social Change, David A. Dittfurth

Faculty Articles

Some have begun to doubt whether courts adequately respond to recent social problems. Formulated rules, principles, and statutes govern a case in court, and these commanding communications addressed to judges theoretically guide and control the decision-making process. Rules, although often imprecise, are subjected to the scrutiny of the legal profession, which is trained to interpret their meaning and possible application in different fact situations. This, in turn, promotes a high degree of social and political stability since there is less ambiguity as to what constitutes permissible or required behavior.

Attitudes, social institutions, language, and critical decision making are all factors …

Sec And Frb Treatment Of Options: An Experiment In Market Regulation (Comment), George Lee Flint Jr

Faculty Articles

The Chicago Board Options Exchange (“CBOE”) provided the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) with an opportunity to exercise regulatory rules to protect the public and economy. The options market was an appropriate testing ground, as options presented complex and untested risks in the broader securities market. Before the CBOE attempted to add security and balance, options existed in an unorganized and underfinanced market. The market needed to expand. However, the SEC was faced with a few problems of its own making. Rule 9b-1 undermined the SEC’s regulatory intent by providing loopholes that would leave it powerless to intervene in any …

1974-1975 School Year, St. Mary's University School Of Law

The Witan

No abstract provided.

Captain’S Advisory Council Notes, David A. Schlueter

Faculty Articles

On 24 and 25 June 1974, the Captain’s Advisory Council, with the cooperation of the Fort Meade JAG shop, sponsored a Regional Continuing Legal Education Conference at Fort Meade. The purpose of the conference was to provide a medium for presenting a continuing legal education program which would complement existing programs as well as allow junior officers of the JAG Corps to meet in a relaxed, yet productive, atmosphere. After a Council subcommittee outlined a tentative agenda, council members representing various fields of military law planned and implemented general presentations to the conference as a whole, as well as seminars …

Election Inspectors Have Judicially Reviewable Discretionary Authority To Determine The Validity Of Proxies (Casenote), George Lee Flint Jr

Faculty Articles

The Salgo court held that an election inspector, in a corporate proxy vote, was empowered with discretion to determine the validity of votes through a review of the transfer books. This decision marked a change from the standard course of American cases, which previously confined the inspector’s ability to a strict ministerial duty. An inspector’s discretion to review votes was limited under this interpretation. By limiting his inquiry to the transfer books, Salgo allowed the inspector to determine the validity of votes, but not who could vote.

Although the court did not apply the broader view of granting the inspector …

Vicarious Liability Of An Employer For An Assault By His Servant: A Survey Of Texas Cases Reexamining The “Rule Of Force”, Charles E. Cantú

Faculty Articles

The doctrine of respondeat superior has long been entrenched in Anglo-American jurisprudence. It is under this doctrine that principles, masters, and employers have been held liable for the wrongs of individuals working under them and acting within the scope of their employment. This doctrine has been applied to all injury producing acts of the employee, whether negligent or intentional.

Presently, there is considerable conflict in Texas concerning an employer’s liability for the intentional torts of his employee. Analysis of several Texas cases regarding the doctrine of respondeat superior points out that Texas courts have applied two conflicting tests in determining …