Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Litigation (16)
- Civil Procedure (15)
- Courts (4)
- Legal History (4)
- Law and Economics (3)
-
- State and Local Government Law (3)
- Torts (3)
- Civil Law (2)
- Criminal Procedure (2)
- Dispute Resolution and Arbitration (2)
- American Politics (1)
- Arts and Humanities (1)
- History (1)
- Jurisprudence (1)
- Legal (1)
- Legal Biography (1)
- Legal Remedies (1)
- Political Science (1)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (1)
- United States History (1)
- Keyword
-
- Civil procedure (13)
- Courts (12)
- Class actions (9)
- Practice and Procedure (9)
- Complex litigation (7)
-
- Dispute Resolution (6)
- Law and Economics (5)
- Jurisdiction (4)
- Litigation (4)
- Procedure (4)
- Remedies (4)
- Complex civil litigation (3)
- Adversary system (2)
- Aggregate litigation (2)
- Attorneys’ fees (2)
- Bersch (2)
- Class Action (2)
- Class Actions (2)
- Class membership (2)
- Conflict of Laws (2)
- Cy pres (2)
- Foreign Citizens (2)
- International Enforcement (2)
- International Law (2)
- Process theory (2)
- Torts (2)
- Adequacy (1)
- Adequate representation (1)
- Aggregate Litigation (1)
- Alfred North Whitehead (1)
- File Type
Articles 1 - 30 of 41
Full-Text Articles in Law
The Future Of Oral Arguments, Jay Tidmarsh
The Future Of Oral Arguments, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
The civil-justice literature is replete with discussions of two phenomena: case management and the vanishing trial. These two phenomena are not unrelated. One commonly state goal of case management is to find ways, other than trial, to resolve civil disputes that find their way into court. Some observers find the movements toward case management and away from trial to be salutary; others find them disquieting. Regardless of the merits of this debate, the delivery of civil justice is undeniably evolving.
This evolution affects and changes many of the traditional attributes of American-style civil justice. The Essay examines one of these …
The Litigation Budget, Jay Tidmarsh
The Litigation Budget, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Because of fears that litigation is too costly, reduction of litigation expenses has been the touchstone of procedural reform for the past thirty years. In certain circumstances, however, the parties have incentives—both rational and irrational—to spend more on a lawsuit than the social benefits that the case provides. Present and proposed reform efforts do not adequately address these incentives, and, in some instances, exacerbate the parties’ incentives to overspend. The best way to ensure that the cost of a lawsuit does not exceed the benefits that it provides to the parties and society is to control spending directly: to require …
Auctioning Class Settlements, Jay Tidmarsh
Auctioning Class Settlements, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Although they promise better deterrence at a lower cost, class actions are infected with problems that can keep them from delivering on this promise. One of these problems occurs when the agents for the class (the class representative and class counsel) advance their own interests at the expense of the class. Controlling agency cost, which often manifests itself at the time of settlement, has been the impetus behind a number of class-action reform proposals. This Article develops a proposal that, in conjunction with reforms in fee structure and opt-out rights, controls agency costs at the time of settlement. The idea …
Foreign Citizens In Transnational Class Actions, Jay Tidmarsh, Linda Sandstrom Simard
Foreign Citizens In Transnational Class Actions, Jay Tidmarsh, Linda Sandstrom Simard
Jay Tidmarsh
This Article addresses an increasingly important question: When, if ever, should foreign citizens be included as members of an American class action? The existing consensus holds that courts should exclude from class membership those foreign citizens whose country does not recognize an American class judgment. Our analysis begins by establishing that this consensus is flawed. Rather, to minimize the costs associated with relitigation in a foreign forum, we must distinguish between foreign claimants who are likely to commence a subsequent foreign proceeding from those who are unlikely to do so; distinguishing between those who come from recognizing and nonrecognizing countries …
Superiority As Unity, Jay Tidmarsh
Superiority As Unity, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
One of Professor Redish’s many important contributions to legal scholarship is his recent work on class actions. Grounding his argument in the theory of democratic accountability that has been at the centerpiece of all his work, Professor Redish suggests that, in nearly all instances, class actions violate the individual autonomy of litigants and should not be used by courts. This Essay, prepared for a festschrift in honor of Professor Redish, begins from the opposite premise: that class actions should be grounded in the notion of social utility rather than autonomy so that class actions should be used whenever they achieve …
A Process Theory Of Torts, Jay Tidmarsh
Optimal Class Size, Opt-Out Rights, And "Indivisible" Remedies, Jay Tidmarsh, David Betson
Optimal Class Size, Opt-Out Rights, And "Indivisible" Remedies, Jay Tidmarsh, David Betson
Jay Tidmarsh
Prepared for a Symposium on the ALI’s Aggregate Litigation Project, this paper examines the ALI’s proposal to permit opt-out rights when remedies and “divisible,” but not to permit them when remedies are “indivisible.” Starting from the ground up, the paper employs economic analysis to determine what the optimal size of a class action should be. We demonstrate that, in some circumstances, the optimal size of a class is a class composed of all victims, while in other cases, the optimal size is smaller. We further argue that courts should consider optimal class size in determining whether to certify a class, …
Resolving Cases On The Merits, Jay Tidmarsh
Resolving Cases On The Merits, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Prepared for a Symposium on Civil Justice Reform, this essay examines the role of the “on the merits” principle in modern American procedure. After surveying the possible meanings of the phrase, the essay critiques its most common understanding due to its economic inefficiency and its lack of strong philosophical support. Relying on the recent work of Amartya Sen, the essay proposes that the principle be replaced with a “fair outcome” principle that melds both “procedural” and “substantive” concerns.
Cy Pres And The Optimal Class Action, Jay Tidmarsh
Cy Pres And The Optimal Class Action, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
This Article, prepared for a symposium on class actions, examines the problem of cy pres relief through the lens of ensuring that class actions have an optimal claim structure and class membership. It finds that the present cy pres doctrine does little to advance the creation of optimal class actions, and may do some harm to achieving that goal. The Article then proposes an alternative “nudge” to induce putative class counsel to structure class actions in an optimal way: set attorneys’ fees so that counsel is compensated through a combination of an hourly market rate and a percentage of the …
Rethinking Adequacy Of Representation, Jay Tidmarsh
Rethinking Adequacy Of Representation, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
This article questions the usefulness of traditional tests for adequacy of representation in class action proceedings. When determining whether to certify a class, courts have sought to avoid endorsing those classes marred by conflicting interests or the possibility of collusion. Yet, such conflicts of interest are an intrinsic characteristic of class actions, stemming from the very policy rationales that have prompted the judiciary to allow litigation by classes. As a result, the current doctrine of adequate representation has left the courts without a bright-line rule; instead, the courts' inquiries into adequacy of representation must focus primarily on the degree of …
Resurrecting Trial By Statistics, Jay Tidmarsh
Resurrecting Trial By Statistics, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
“Trial by statistics” was a means by which a court could resolve a large number of aggregated claims: a court could try a random sample of claim, and extrapolate the average result to the remainder. In Wal-Mart, Inc. v. Dukes, the Supreme Court seemingly ended the practice at the federal level, thus removing from judges a tool that made mass aggregation more feasible. After examining the benefits and drawbacks of trial by statistics, this Article suggests an alternative that harnesses many of the positive features of the technique while avoiding its major difficulties. The technique is the “presumptive judgment”: a …
Complex Litigation And The Adversary System, Jay Tidmarsh, Roger Trangsrud
Complex Litigation And The Adversary System, Jay Tidmarsh, Roger Trangsrud
Jay Tidmarsh
A law school level coursebook on complex litigation and the adversary system. The book examines the four ways in which cases can be complex: joinder issues, pretrial issues, trial issues, and remedial issues. The book challenges the reader to consider whether the prevailing doctrines in these areas are consistent with modern adversarial theory, with the aspirations of our system of justice, and with a democratic system’s constraints on judicial power. One volume.
Modern Complex Litigation, Jay Tidmarsh, Roger Trangsrud
Modern Complex Litigation, Jay Tidmarsh, Roger Trangsrud
Jay Tidmarsh
Modern Complex Litigation is the successor to Complex Litigation and the Adversary System, which was published in 1998. Due to the many developments in this field, the authors have reorganized and completely rewritten the text. Most of the principal cases used in the new edition have been decided since 1998, and many of the notes discuss cases, literature, and developments that have arisen in the past decade. In the interest of creating an accessible, student-friendly text, the book has been substantially shortened through the careful editing of cases and the use of short, informative notes. At the same time, the …
Complex Litigation: Problems In Advanced Civil Procedure, Jay Tidmarsh, Roger Trangsrud.
Complex Litigation: Problems In Advanced Civil Procedure, Jay Tidmarsh, Roger Trangsrud.
Jay Tidmarsh
Offers concepts of and insights into the forms and functions of complex litigation issues, including their implications. Helps students in such courses to review and study, as well as serves as a reference book for students once they are in practice.
Mass Tort Settlement Class Actions, Jay Tidmarsh
Out Of Court, Out Of Luck, Jay Tidmarsh
Out Of Court, Out Of Luck, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh op-ed article Out of Court, Out of Luck published in U.S. News on March 19.
Auctioning Class Settlements, Jay Tidmarsh
Auctioning Class Settlements, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Although they promise better deterrence at a lower cost, class actions are infected with problems that can keep them from delivering on this promise. One of these problems occurs when the agents for the class (the class representative and class counsel) advance their own interests at the expense of the class. Controlling agency cost, which often manifests itself at the time of settlement, has been the impetus behind a number of class-action reform proposals. This Article develops a proposal that, in conjunction with reforms in fee structure and opt-out rights, controls agency costs at the time of settlement. The idea …
Jay Tidmarsh Was Quoted In The Npr Marketplace Story ‘Consent Is A Fiction’ In Consumer Contracts On April 17, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh Was Quoted In The Npr Marketplace Story ‘Consent Is A Fiction’ In Consumer Contracts On April 17, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh was quoted in the NPR Marketplace story ‘Consent is a fiction’ in consumer contractson April 17. Listen to audio at 1:25 Jay is introduced.
Cy Pres And The Optimal Class Action, Jay Tidmarsh
Cy Pres And The Optimal Class Action, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Prepared for a symposium on class actions, this Article examines the problem of cy pres relief in class actions through the lens of optimal claim structure and class membership. It finds that the present cy pres doctrine does little to advance the creation of optimal class actions, and that it may do some harm to achieving that goal. The Article then proposes an alternative “nudge” to induce putative class counsel to structure class actions in an optimal way: setting attorneys’ fees so that counsel is compensated through a combination of an hourly market rate and a percentage of the net …
Exiting Litigation, Jay Tidmarsh
Professor Jay Tidmarsh Commencement Address, Jay Tidmarsh
Professor Jay Tidmarsh Commencement Address, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Professor Jay Tidmarsh, who had been selected as Law School Distinguished Teacher, addressed the graduates; his remarks follow.
Auctioning Class Settlements, Jay Tidmarsh
Auctioning Class Settlements, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
Although they promise better deterrence at a lower cost, class actions are infected with problems that can keep them from delivering on this promise. One of these problems is the issue of agency cost, in which the agents of the class (the class representative and class counsel) advance their own interests at the expense of the class. Controlling agency cost, which often manifests itself at the time of settlement, has been the impetus behind a number of class-action reform proposals.
This Essay develops an idea that, in conjunction with reforms in fee structure and opt-out rights, controls agency costs at …
Resurrecting Trial By Statistics, Jay Tidmarsh
Resurrecting Trial By Statistics, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
“Trial by statistics” was one means by which a court could resolve a large number of aggregated claims: a court could try a random sample of claim, and extrapolate the average result to the remainder. In Wal-Mart, Inc. v. Dukes, the Supreme Court seemingly ended the practice at the federal level, thus removing from judges a tool that made mass aggregation more feasible.
After examining the benefits and drawbacks of trial by statistics, this Article suggests an alternative that harnesses many of the positive features of the technique while avoiding its major difficulties. The technique is the “presumptive judgment”: …
Dialogic Defense Of Alden, Jay Tidmarsh
Tort Law: The Languages Of Duty, Jay Tidmarsh
States' Rights In The Twenty-First Century, Jay Tidmarsh, Mark Racicot, Robert Miller, Michael Greve
States' Rights In The Twenty-First Century, Jay Tidmarsh, Mark Racicot, Robert Miller, Michael Greve
Jay Tidmarsh
No abstract provided.
Pound's Century, And Ours, Jay Tidmarsh
A Process Theory Of Torts, Jay Tidmarsh
Civil Procedure: The Last Ten Years, Jay Tidmarsh
Whitehead's Metaphysics And The Law: A Dialogue, Jay Tidmarsh
Whitehead's Metaphysics And The Law: A Dialogue, Jay Tidmarsh
Jay Tidmarsh
No abstract provided.