Law Commons^™

The Partially Prudential Doctrine Of Mootness, Matthew I. Hall

Matthew I Hall

The conventional understanding of mootness doctrine is that it operates as a mandatory bar to federal court jurisdiction, derived from the “cases or controversies” clause of the United States Constitution, Article III. In two crucial respects, however, this Constitutional model—which was first adopted by the Supreme Court less than 45 years ago—fails to account for the manner in which courts actually address contentions of mootness. First, the commonly-applied exceptions to the mootness bar are not derived from the “cases or controversies” clause and cannot be reconciled with the Constitutional account of mootness. Second, courts regularly consider and resolve mootness issues …

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

Redefining Harm, Reimagining Remedies And Reclaiming Domestic Violence Law, Margaret Johnson

Margaret E Johnson

Women subjected to domestic violence are disserved by the civil domestic violence laws that should effectively address and redress their harms. The Civil Protective Order [CPO] laws should remedy all domestic abuse and not solely physical violence or criminal acts. All forms of abuse, including psychological, emotional, economic and physical abuse, cause severe emotional distress, physical harm, isolation, sustained fear, intimidation, poverty, degradation, humiliation, and coerced loss of autonomy. Moreover, all abuse is interrelated, because, as researchers have demonstrated, most domestic violence is the fundamental operation of systemic oppression through the exertion of power and control. Given the effectiveness of …

Recognizing Marriage, William J. Rich

William Rich

Recognizing Marriage Abstract Two adults living in the United States already have the right to form enduring relationships, to cohabit, and to identify themselves as married. The path towards full social and legal recognition of marriage for individuals of the same sex, however, must still be developed and will involve multiple steps requiring careful navigation. That path begins with broadening social acceptance, including extension of employment benefits, acceptance within progressive social and religious organizations, and support for children living with same sex couples. Legal acceptance will inevitably follow these changes in society, but in a majority of states, significant road …

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

(How) Does Unconscious Bias Matter?: Law, Politics, And Racial Inequality, Richard Banks, Richard Thompson Ford

R. Banks

During the past several years, psychological research on unconscious racial bias has grabbed headlines, as well as the attention of legal scholars. The most well-known test of unconscious bias is the Implicit Association Test (IAT), a sophisticated and methodologically rigorous computer-administered measure that has been taken by millions of people, and featured in major print and broadcast media. Its proponents contend that the IAT reveals widespread unconscious bias against African-Americans, even among individuals who believe themselves to be free of racial bias.

In fact, however, the findings of the IAT are ambiguous. The test could just as plausibly be thought …

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

It's Not Just Shopping, Urban Lofts, And The Lesbian Gay-By Boom: How Sexual Orientation Demographics Can Inform Family Courts, Todd Brower

todd brower

Courts today are deeply involved in matters involving lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered persons. Same-sex marriage, custody disputes, conflict with religious claims and other, more routine family law cases all bring sexual orientation minorities into the judicial system as parties, witnesses, lawyers, or jurors. Like sexuality, gender and gender roles have traditionally and significantly influenced these issues. Nevertheless, judges and the legal system often have little factual information about the lesbians and gay men who appear in their courtrooms, instead relying on stereotypes of gay persons. Such reliance fails to see the real people currently present in family courts and …

Social Cognition 'At Work:' Schema Theory And Lesbian And Gay Identity In Title Vii, Todd Brower

todd brower

Lesbians and gay men are frequent subjects for modern news, politics, and court opinions. From marriage for same-sex couples to Congressional hearings on the military’s “Don’t ask, don’t tell” regulation, decision-makers are setting policy based on their ideas about how gay people are and how they fit into society. But what are those perceptions and how do they interact with law? We ordinarily think of lesbians and gay men as predominantly childless, urban residents of cities like San Francisco, New York, Chicago, or Los Angeles or as inhabitants of the Northeastern or Pacific Coast states. However, data from the 2000 …

An Empirical Examination Of The Impact At The Polls Of Indiana's Voter Identification Law, Michael J. Pitts

Michael J. Pitts

No abstract provided.

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

Good Ole' Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

Good Ole' Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

Good Ole’ Boys Apply Only: How The Ncaa Discriminates Against Minorities & Women In Collegiate Coaching, Nathan Berkeley

Nathan Berkeley

This note discusses the early-2008 NCAA Rule mandating that every NCAA Division I football team interview at least one minority head coach candidate when a vacancy evolves. I explore the possible reasons for the racial inequities and the unique circumstances in trying to implement an affirmative action program for unique high level positions. I argue that the NCAA Rule, as it stands now, is ineffective because there is currently no enforcement mechanism and that the Rule should be expanded to include other sports and women.

State Actors Beating Children: A Call For Judicial Relief, Deana Ann Pollard Sacks

Deana A Pollard

Controversy over public school corporal punishment is at an all-time high. On August 20, 2008, the Human Rights Watch/ACLU brought public attention to the issue by releasing its report on corporal punishment of children in American public schools. Lawsuits challenging this state action on constitutional grounds continue to be filed, as advocates seeking to ban school paddling refuse to accept that beating students is constitutionally permissible, despite their repeated losses in the federal courts, and the Supreme Court’s refusal to consider the issue again on June 23, 2008. Ignoring the uproar, nearly half of the United States continue to employ …

The Coercion Test: On Prayer, Offense, And Doctrinal Inculcation, Mark Strasser

Mark Strasser

Several different tests have been proposed to determine whether a state practice violates the Establishment Clause, including the Lemon test, the Endorsement test, and the Coercion test. While no test yet commands the consistent support of members of the Court, it is clear that several members of the Court favor some version of the Coercion test. Interpretation and evaluation of that test are rather difficult, however, because Court members differ greatly both about what kind of coercion triggers the relevant protections and about what the test is designed to prevent. The great disparity in views both about the reach and …

What Will The Life Of Riley V. Kennedy Mean For Section 5 Of The Voting Rights Act?, Michael J. Pitts

Michael J. Pitts

No abstract provided.

Is Arbitration Under Attack? Exploring The Recent Judicial Skepticism Of The Class Arbitration Waiver And Innovative Solutions To The Unsettled Legal Landscape, Ramona L. Lampley

Ramona L. Lampley

This article explores the hotly debated field of enforcing arbitration clauses with binding class-action waivers. While the enforcement of arbitration clauses generally, and those with class-action waivers specifically, has undergone much debate in the past three years in both the academic and judicial fora; this article casts a new look on the analysis. Instead of advocating simply for or against the enforcement of the class-action waiver, this article analyzes the dialogue between the consumer products industry and the consuming public, via the court system. This dialogue has resulted in a “new wave” of consumer products arbitration agreements: agreements that are …

Exporting Harshness: How The War On Crime Has Made The War On Terror Possible, James Forman

James Forman Jr.

This Essay responds to a consensus that has formed among many opponents of the Bush administration’s prosecution of the war on terror. The consensus narrative goes like this: America has a long-standing commitment to human rights and due process, reflected in its domestic criminal justice system’s expansive protections. Since September 11, 2001, President Bush, Vice President Cheney, former Defense Secretary Rumsfeld, and their allies have dishonored this tradition.

It is too simple, I suggest, to assert that the Bush administration remade our justice system and betrayed American values. This Essay explores the ways in which our approach to the war …

The Congressional Chaplaincies, Christopher C. Lund

Christopher C Lund

Twenty five years ago, in Marsh v. Chambers, the Supreme Court considered the congressional chaplaincies, and concluded that they were not “an ‘establishment’ of religion or a step toward establishment,” but instead were “simply a tolerable acknowledgment of beliefs widely held among the people of this country.” That latter phrase has been repeated hundreds of times in cases and law review articles; it suggests that the chaplaincies are uninteresting and uncontroversial and that they have been so throughout our history.

The Court in Marsh looked only briefly at the history of the chaplaincies. But a deeper look at that history …

Gendercide And The Cultural Context Of Sex Trafficking In China, Susan W. Tiefenbrun, Susan W. Tiefenbrun

Susan W Tiefenbrun

Abstract:Gendercide and the Cultural Context of Sex Trafficking in China

By Susan Tiefenbrun and Christie Edwards

Women in China are bought and sold, murdered and made to disappear in order to comply with a strict government One Child Policy that coincides with the cultural tradition of male-child preference and discrimination against women. Everyday “500 female suicides” occur in China because of “violence against women and girls, discrimination [against women] in education and employment, the traditional preference for male children, the country’s birth limitation policies, and other societal factors…” As a result of a widespread and arguably systematic disappearance and death …

Reconceptualizing Competence: An Appeal, Mae C. Quinn

Mae C. Quinn

This article builds on contemporary critiques of the justice system’s treatment of the mentally impaired, examining an important issue that until now has gone wholly unaddressed -- the effect of defendant impairment on the criminal appeals process. It argues that conventional wisdom stressing the importance of defendant competence during criminal trials but ignoring the incompetence of defendants during direct appeals makes little sense. Such an approach to defendant capacity not only fails to account for the realities of criminal practice, but works to undermine the fairness and efficacy of the American appellate process. Thus this paper calls for reconceptualization of …

Some Penetrating Observations On The Fifth Anniversary Of Lawrence V. Texas: Privacy, Dominance, And Substantive Equality Theory, Shannon Gilreath

Shannon Gilreath

This article, “Some Penetrating Observations on the Fifth Anniversary of Lawrence v. Texas: Privacy, Dominance, and Substantive Equality Theory,” asks the reader to look at the equality claims of minority groups at a new conceptual level. With the Lawrence decision as its critical paradigm, the essay proceeds through several observations on the failure of privacy/substantive due process grounded opinions to deliver rights to minorities. This discussion feeds an ultimate criticism of the equality analysis (or lack thereof) of many of the Court’s principal minority rights opinions. Particularly, I am critical of the longstanding notion that equal protection of the laws …

Bloodstains On A "Code Of Honor", Kenneth Lasson

Kenneth Lasson

Abstract In the real world of the Twenty-first Century, deep biases against women are prevalent in much of Muslim society. Although there is no explicit approval of honor killing in Islamic law (Sharia), its culture remains fundamentally patriarchal. As unfathomable as it is to Western minds, “honor killing” is a facet of traditional patriarchy, and its condonation can be traced largely to ancient tribal practices. Justifications for it can be found in the codes of Hammurabi and in the family law of the Roman Empire. Unfortunately, honor killings in the Twenty-first Century are not isolated incidents, nor can they be …

The Tort Of Negligence Or The State-Created Danger: Two Avenues For School Liability In The Case Of The Injured Student Informant, Michele H. Berger

Michele H Berger

Schools use students as the watchdogs of the school to report to authorities about drugs and weapons possession. There is a lack of liability assigned to schools for placing students in this inherently dangerous situation. If it is absolutely necessary for high schools to use students as informants, courts should charge schools with an affirmative duty to protect student informants.

Where there is a duty, there is the potential to breach that duty, thus exposing the school to liability for negligence. So long as that breach of a duty causes an injury to the plaintiff through cause in fact, proximate …

The Second Amendment: Scope And Criminological Considerations, Clayton E. Cramer

Clayton E Cramer

The recent decision D.C. v. Heller (2008) has opened up the question of what the Second Amendment protects. What “arms” are protected? What classes of persons may be properly prohibited from being armed?

Belonging And Empowerment: A New "Civil Rights" Paradigm Based On Lessons Of The Past, Rebecca E. Zietlow

Rebecca E Zietlow

ABSTRACT: Despite the advances that African Americans have made in our country as a result of the Civil Rights movement of the 1960s, poverty stubbornly persists in communities of color throughout our country. Our current civil rights paradigm, which is rooted in the Equal Protection Clause, and prohibits intentional state discrimination on the basis of immutable characteristics, simply is not working. This article suggests an alternative approach, one based not solely in equality norms but in facilitating the belonging of outsiders in our society. The subordination of people of color in our society has never been just about race. Rather, …