Law Commons^™

Revocation Of Wills By Subsequent Change In The Condition Or Circumstances Of The Testator, Elizabeth Durfee

Michigan Law Review

Among the oldest rules in the law of wills are those by which a will is held to be revoked by implication by certain changes in the circumstances of the testator. The purpose of this paper is to investigate these rules. Special reference will be made to statutes, both those which deal generally with the subject and those which provide specifically for the effect of particular events, such as marriage; no attempt will be made, however to analyze the latter type of statute exhaustively. By way of introduction, a brief historical survey of the doctrine should be made.

Annuities - Satisfaction Of Prior Deficiencies From Income Surplusages Of Subsequent Years, Edward H. Adams

Michigan Law Review

Testatrix left her estate in trust for the purpose of paying certain sums of money annually to named beneficiaries. In a codicil to her will, she provided that in case there was insufficient income to meet expenses and pay all annuities stated, certain of the beneficiaries were to be preferred. Deficiencies occurred so that all sums were not paid, but subsequently there was surplus income which the trustees desired to apply to the prior deficiencies. Held, one justice dissenting, that the surplus after paying the annuities for the present year could be applied to the deficiencies which had occurred …

Wills - Provisions For Construction Of The Will By Umpire Named By Testator, Alfred I. Rothman

Michigan Law Review

Testatrix created a trust and bequeathed one-fifth of the income to her son W and to S, his wife, with a proviso that if S survived her husband such income should not be paid to her in case she remarried. S divorced Wand remarried. Under a clause in the will giving them the power to determine with finality any question as to the construction or administration of the will, the executors and trustees construed the will to mean that S was not to receive any further share of the income, that testatrix would consider the divorce and remarriage during …

Adoption -Trusts-Wills- Adopted Child's Right To Take Under A Trust For "Issue", Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

The settlor established a trust with himself, his wife, and his four children as beneficiaries. Under the trust deed the property was to vest in the "lawful issue" of the settlor's children on the death of his last surviving child. Held, that the term "lawful issue" included the plaintiff (an adopted child of settlor's daughter). Walker v. Obrien, (C. C. A. 9th, 1940) 115 F. (2d) 956, cert. den. (U.S. 1941) 61 S. Ct. 829.

Wills - Construction - Limitation Of Defeasance Clause, Herbert R. Whiting

Michigan Law Review

Testatrix died leaving as her only heirs at law and next of kin a son, Thomas, and a grandaughter, Malinda, to whom she devised her estate in approximately equal shares. At the time she executed her will Thomas was twenty-two years of age and unmarried and Malinda was eleven. The principal case turns on the construction of a clause in her will, devising a parcel of land to Malinda, which reads as follows: "I give and bequeath ... the same to the said Malinda McK. Young and her children but if the said Malinda McK. Young shall die before she …

Trusts - Power Of Settlor-Beneficiary To Terminate Spendthrift Trust, Roy L. Rogers

Michigan Law Review

The plaintiff established a trust fund, the income from which was to be paid to herself for life, remainder as she should appoint by will or in default of appointment to her next of kin. The trust instrument contained spendthrift provisions, and an express provision against revocation. Subsequently the value of the corpus declined, income dwindled to practically nothing, and plaintiff became practically destitute. Held, the trust, failing to accomplish its purpose, may be terminated. Rehr v. Fidelity-Philadelphia Trust Co., 37 Pa. D. & C. 324 (1939).

Trusts-Liability Of Life Tenant And Remainderman For Carrying Charges On Unproductive Property, James D. Ritchie

Michigan Law Review

Testator put certain property, highly productive at the time of his death, in trust, income to his grandaughter for life, remainder over. Subsequently part of the property became unproductive, so that if the income from the rest should have fallen below three per cent and taxes were paid from income, the life tenant would have received nothing. The will authorized the trustee to sell when expedient; although using due diligence, the trustee had not yet sold. In a contest between the life tenant and remainderman, held, taxes accrued since the property became unproductive are payable from principal, not income. …

Joint Tenancy - Right To Transfer By One Party - Right Of Survivorship, John H. Pickering

Michigan Law Review

In two recent cases the Supreme Court of Michigan has had occasion to pass upon the doctrine of survivorship in joint tenancies. In one case the deed ran to father and son as joint tenants and contained a covenant that neither would sell without the written consent of the other. The father conveyed his interest without the son's consent and died. The court held that the deed created a joint tenancy, that since the restrictive covenant was void as a restraint on alienation and repugnant to the grant, the joint tenancy was severed by the father's conveyance, and therefore the …

Wills- Partial Intestacy-Effect Of Attempt To Disinherit An Heir Or To Limit His Share, James D. Ritchie

Michigan Law Review

Where testator bequeathed to one of his brothers "the sum of five dollars, this amount to be in full for any and all bequests I would leave him as a brother or heir," and certain property passed by intestate succession because of a void residuary clause, held, the share of the brother, an heir, was restricted to five dollars. LaMere v. Jackson, 288 Mich. 99, 284 N. W. 659 (1939).

Executors And Administrators - Effect Of Testamentary Provisions On Executors' Fees, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

At the early English law an executor was entitled to the surplus of the personal estate after the payment of debts and legacies, but this practice nowhere prevails today. At common law the office of executor was regarded as honorary, to be performed without compensation unless the will expressly provided for compensation. It is doubtful if the common-law rule ever obtained in this country, where from a very early time it has been universally considered that executors are normally entitled to reasonable compensation not only to reward them for their time, labor and trouble, but also for the responsibility incurred …

Appeal And Error - The Administrator As A Party Aggrieved By Probate Of Will, John H. Uhl

Michigan Law Review

In an action to prove the existence of a lost will executed by the deceased, judgment was rendered setting up the lost will and revoking the letters of administration which had been issued. The administrator appealed from this order, and the appellee moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the administrator had no such interest as entitled him to review. The governing statute permitted appeal by "any party aggrieved by any final order, judgment, or decree." Held, that the administrator who has qualified as such was entitled to appeal under the statute, as the party aggrieved by …

Wills - Construction - Meaning Of "Issue" In Testamentary Gifts, Daniel Hodgman

Michigan Law Review

Two recent cases illustrate a trend in the judicial construction of the word "issue" in wills which seems to be divergent from the view expressed in the older cases.

In Re Thompson's Estate there was a bequest to A and B for their lives and at the death of the survivor "one half thereof to the living issue of each daughter, if there then be such issue of each, whether of the first or succeeding generations." At the death of the survivor there were six children of A and two grandchildren, issue of living children, and there were two children …

Banks And Banking - Trusts - Special Deposits - Agreement Between Depositor And Bank, Robert E. Sipes

Michigan Law Review

During a period of widespread bank failures, plaintiff corporation ceased depositing its funds with the defendant bank. To maintain the public's impression that the plaintiff was a regular customer of the bank, an agreement was entered into by the bank and the plaintiff whereby the bank was appointed "agent" of the plaintiff to collect and remit promptly money due plaintiff. Branch offices of the plaintiff deposited money under this agreement to be transmitted to the plaintiff. When the bank failed with some of this money still in its hands, plaintiff sought to be allowed a preferred claim. Held, the …

The Widow's Right Of Election In The Estate Of Her Husband, Elbridge D. Phelps

Michigan Law Review

Before launching into the discussion proper, and in order to avoid confusion and misunderstanding later on, it is deemed wise at once to mark out boundaries within which it is proposed to confine the treatment of the subject here involved. Accordingly, in that which follows, attention will be centered largely on the necessity for election by a widow under modern statutes which allow her to take against her husband's will, and on the effects of her election or non-election upon her interest in her husband's estate. In so far as a surviving husband has identical rights, they will be adverted …

Powers - Rule Against Perpetuities - Disposition Of Property Where Appointment Is Invalid - Enforcement Of Contract To Appoint, James H. Kilbourne

Michigan Law Review

The donor of the power bequeathed a fund to trustees to pay the income to the donee for the donee's life, and then to convey to such persons as the donee appointed by will. The donee appointed by will to trustees to pay the income to the donee's daughter for life; and then to convey the remainder to the daughter's surviving children and the surviving lawful descendants of any deceased child of the daughter, upon the death of the last surviving child or twenty-one years after the death of the last surviving child living at the donee's death, whichever event …

Conditional Wills, Alvin E. Evans

Michigan Law Review

The discovery of what the language of a testator means is a constant duty of the courts. The task in the case of wills conditional in form frequently is to inquire whether the conditional language is merely formal and used by way of inducement or is intended to be taken literally. Clear cut and uniformly dependable tests as guides to such inquiry do not exist.

Powers - Execution By A Residuary Clause, Herman J. Bloom

Michigan Law Review

A testator devised all his property in trust; he instructed the trustees to purchase a residence for his wife and gave her the general power to appoint by will, both with respect to this proposed residence and with respect to a sum of money from the testator's estate, the aggregate amount being $20,000. The trustee purchased a 25-foot lot and the wife purchased 8 1/ 3 feet of an adjoining lot. At the request of the wife, the trustees erected a two family residence, the main part of the building being on the 25-foot lot, but the eaves and one …

Wills - Charitable Trusts - Doctrine Of Approximation - Accumulation, Malcolm L. Denise

Michigan Law Review

By his will of 1915 the testator, after providing for several legacies, left the residue of his estate to trustees, to expend the income therefrom in establishing and providing a home for the worthy aged poor of Waterbury, in the memory of his deceased wife. The income was not sufficient adequately to carry out this direction, the fund amounting to around $30,000 at the time of testator's death in 1920, and the trustees petitioned the court for instructions. Held, there being a general charitable intent, the fund should be administered cy pres by the court to relieve the aged …

Wills - Conveyance By Testator Of Land Devised As Implied Revocation

Michigan Law Review

Testator devised "all the property, real, personal or mixed of which I die seised" to defendant. Subsequently, he and his wife conveyed a portion of the land he then owned to the defendant. Defendant later reconveyed to the testator. Testator never republished his will, nor altered it in any way. Plaintiffs are his heirs at law and insist that as to these lands the will was revoked and the testator died intestate. Held, there was no revocation here. The land in question passed under the devise to the defendant as after-acquired property, the language of the general devise being …

Powers-Exercise Of Power By Residuary Clause In Will-Admissibility Of Evidence To Show Donee's Intent

Michigan Law Review

Testator was the donee of general powers of appointment conferred upon him by his mother's deed and will. By the ninth clause of this will he gave to two named persons "all the rest and residue of my personal property . . . to be divided equitably among the members of said two families as they may in their uncontrolled discretion decide." Held, this did not exercise the powers of appointment. Evidence was admitted to show the testator's knowledge of the nature and scope of his property and of the fact that his estate was being diminished by the …

Executors And Administrators-Executor's ''Right Of Retainer" Of Distributive Share Of Estate Where Distributee Is Indebted To Decedent

Michigan Law Review

A question little noticed by legal writers, but of utmost importance in the administration and distribution of decedents' estates, is the universally recognized right of executors and administrators of the estates to retain a distributive share as satisfaction in whole or in part for a debt due from the distributee to the estate of the decedent. It should be remarked at the outset that the term "retainer" as here used is itself a misnomer; properly speaking, that term refers to the right of an executor, who is himself a creditor of the estate, to retain from its funds in his …

Wills - Precatory Gifts

Michigan Law Review

In the second item of the will testator gave to his wife all of his property "as her absolute property." In the third item the testator provided: "it is hereby directed that my sister [plaintiff in this case] . . . be given one hundred fifty and no/loo dollars monthly during her natural life and one hundred dollars monthly to my brother-in-law Charles E. McCarle . . . in the event that he survives his wife above mentioned." The fourth item provided that in case the testator's wife predeceased him, one hundred dollars monthly should be paid to each of …

Wills - Gift's - Construction Of Instrument

Michigan Law Review

Decedent had lived with plaintiff and her parents. In 1932, after telling plaintiff's parents that he had some money in the bank, decedent said, "I got a will here . . . I understand I have got to have two signatures." Both parents, at his request, signed the instrument below.

"Dear Carlotta

"I give to you my money in Live Stock Bank.

"Hans Larsen

"April 16, 1932

"Witness: Michael C. Kelley

"Mamie V. Kelley."

Decedent put the instrument in his bank book and took it into the other room where plaintiff was sitting. He said, "Carlotta, I will give you …

Trusts - Cy Pres Doctrine -Application To Charitable Trusts - Accumulations

Michigan Law Review

A bequeathed the residue of her estate to the Trustees of Bowdoin College in trust to apply two-thirds of the annual income to the purposes of the Medical School of Maine and to accumulate the other one-third with another fund left by A for the same purpose until the whole should reach $50,000, when all should be applied for the purposes of the Medical School of Maine. The Medical School ceased to function, and the trustees applied to the court for instructions. Held, that there was a general charitable intent, indicated by the use of the word "purposes," and …

Deeds-Instrument In Form Of Contract For Sale Of Land As Gift

Michigan Law Review

Decedent executed and delivered to his sister, the petitioner, in a sealed envelope an instrument in the form of an executory contract for the sale of land by the terms of which the decedent promised to convey to the petitioner his undivided two-thirds interest in a certain building and lot. The execution of the instrument was not the result of any agreement and no consideration was paid, although receipt of payment in full was endorsed on the back of the instrument. After decedent's death the envelope was produced and the probate court under a statutory authority ordered a conveyance to …

Wills - Revocation By Change Of Circumstances

Michigan Law Review

The testator executed his will providing that a termination of the marriage relation would make the provisions for his wife null and void. Subsequently, they separated, and, in anticipation of a divorce they agreed upon and carried into effect a property settlement providing that the wife should receive certain real estate, stock, and money in consideration of her surrender of all her rights of dower, alimony, and claims of support. A short time thereafter the wife sued for a divorce, but the action was discontinued when, in accordance with the testator's wishes, she went to live with him until his …

Future Interests - Rule Against Perpetuities Applibd To A Charitable Trust

Michigan Law Review

The testator devised property to a trustee to accumulate the income for the period of a life in being and twenty-one years. Then a corporation was to be organized to receive the fund as trustee in order to apply it to a named charitable purpose. Held, that the gift does not contravene the rule against perpetuities on the grounds that the gift takes effect in possession the instant the prior period ends, that beneficially the gift vests in charity at the death of the testator, and that the rule does not apply to charitable gifts. First Camden National Bank …

The Meaning Of "Heirs" In Willsa Suggestion In Legal Method, Lewis M. Simes, Lorentz B. Knouff, George E. Leonard Jr.:

Michigan Law Review

A major task of the lawyer is the prediction of judicial action. No less than a quarter of a century ago Justice Holmes referred to the law as a body of "systematized prediction." Today legal scholars are not content to base their predictions solely upon the body of rules announced in judicial opinions. By means of elaborate fact studies they have sought to ascertain how rules of law actually function in society. Not only have these studies dealt with problems of procedure and the administration of courts, they have also invaded the fields of commercial and property law. Among such …

Trusts - Compromise Agreement As Means Of Terminating Testamentary Spendthrift Trust

Michigan Law Review

In Rose v. Southern Michigan National Bank, the Michigan Supreme Court refused to terminate a spendthrift trust composed of both real and personal property, although to end litigation upon the will all the parties in interest had signed a compromise agreement to terminate the trust according to the Michigan statute. There was no objection as to the fairness of the agreement, upon which ground the court might have refused to sanction the compromise under the statute. The decision seems to have been based upon the theory that to give effect to the compromise agreement would defeat the purpose of …

Wills - Pretermitted Heirs

Michigan Law Review

In an action based on section 1550 of the Compiled Laws of 1929 providing that a child omitted from the will of a parent shall share as in intestate succession unless it appears that such omission was intentional, the question arose as to whether this intent could be shown by extrinsic evidence. Held, such evidence is admissible. O'Neall v. Her, 254 Mich. 631, 236 N. W. 890 (1931).