Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Articles 1 - 1 of 1
Full-Text Articles in Human Resources Management
The Ideal Review Process Is A Three-Way Street, Andrea D. Ellinger, Patrik Johnson, Karen Chapman, Alexander E. Ellinger
The Ideal Review Process Is A Three-Way Street, Andrea D. Ellinger, Patrik Johnson, Karen Chapman, Alexander E. Ellinger
Human Resource Development Faculty Publications and Presentations
In response to the increasing difficulty of obtaining high quality peer reviews, our invited paper describes the concept of review avoidance and why this phenomenon occurs. In reaffirming the professional responsibilities and potential benefits of reviewing, we also emphasize the interdependent nature of the ideal peer review process. We suggest that the review process is a three-way street where the respective roles and responsibilities of authors, editors and editorial teams, and reviewers are inextricably linked. We present thematic illustrations of undesirable reviewer comments, and a brief synthesis of broad themes in the literature on high-quality reviewing. The synthesis is complemented …