Physical Sciences and Mathematics Commons^™

Mccolm’S Conjecture, Yuri Gurevich, Neil Immerman, Saharon Shelah

Neil Immerman

Gregory McColm conjectured that positive elementary inductions are bounded in a class K of finite structures if every (FO + LFP) formula is equivalent to a first-order formula in K. Here (FO + LFP) is the extension of first-order logic with the least fixed point operator. We disprove the conjecture. Our main results are two model-theoretic constructions, one deterministic and the other randomized, each of which refutes McColm’s conjecture.