Physical Sciences and Mathematics Commons^™

Confronting A Solar Irradiance Reconstruction With Solar And Stellar Data, Philip G. Judge, G. Wesley Lockwood, Richard R. Radick, Gregory W. Henry, Alexander I. Shapiro, Werner Schmutz, Charles Lindsey

Information Systems and Engineering Management Research Publications

Context. A recent paper by Shapiro and colleagues (2011, A&A, 529, A67) reconstructs spectral and total irradiance variations of the Sun during the holocene.

Aims. In this note, we comment on why their methodology leads to large (0.5%) variations in the solar TSI on century-long time scales, in stark contrast to other reconstructions which have ≲ 0.1% variations.

Methods. We examine the amplitude of the irradiance variations from the point of view of both solar and stellar data.

Results. Shapiro et al.’s large amplitudes arise from differences between the irradiances computed from models A and C of Fontenla and colleagues, …