Tax Law Commons^™

Books Received, Journal Staff

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

Books Received

Utilization of Outer Space and International Law

Gijsbertha C.M. Reijnen.

Amsterdam and New York: Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, 1981. Pp. 179, $69.75.

=====================

International Estate Planning

William H. Newton, III.

Colorado Springs: Shepard's/McGraw-Hill Company, 1981. Pp. 614.

=====================

International Tax Avoidance and Evasion, Colloquy of the Council of Europe, Strasbourg, 1980

Publication 31, Publications of the International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation Amsterdam: International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation, 1981. Pp.184, Dfl. 65.00.

=============

Fiscal Reform in Bolivia: Final Report on the Bolivian Mission on Tax Reform Richard A. Musgrave

Cambridge: Harvard Law School International Tax Program, 1981. Pp. 593, …

Tax Havens, Charles R. Irish

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

Opinions about tax havens cover a wide spectrum. Some suggest tax havens present an unacceptable face of capitalism and inflict considerable damage on the economies of nonhaven countries. Others argue that havens offer relief from oppressive taxes and other regulations which inhibit the free and efficient flow of capital; and still others hold the view that tax haven status may act as a catalyst for economic development. Obviously, the opinions vary according to whether a person is a tax collector in a non-haven country, a taxpayer engaged in international business activities, or a government policymaker in a haven country.

The …

The Uniform Gifts To Minors Act:A Patent Ambiguity, Margaret M. Mahoney

Vanderbilt Law Review

The current treatment of uniform gifts as creating interests in only one person for gift tax purposes, and as creating interests in others as well for income and estate tax purposes, is inappropriate. Resolution of the underlying ambiguity within the Uniform Gifts to Minors Act would produce a more uniform tax treatment. If section 4(b) were modified to state clearly that the custodian is not empowered to use the fund to discharge parental support duties,no change would occur in the gift tax treatment. Income tax liability would be incurred by only the minor donee, the result presumably desired by most …

Motor Carrier Act Of 1980: Toward Compensating Trucking Companies For The Loss Of The Monopolistic Value Of Their Operating Rights, Mary H. Leech

Vanderbilt Law Review

This Note examines the historical background and nature of the operating rights acquired by the trucking companies, with emphasis on those rights issued to a common carrier by the ICC and represented by a certificate of public convenience and necessity(certificate). The Note then examines and analyzes the tax law and the judicial response to attempts by taxpayers to deduct from gross income the loss of a monopolistic right. Finally, the Note explores alternate theories for compensating trucking companies for their losses and concludes with a recommendation of the most equitable method of compensation.

Case Digest, Journal Staff

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

Carrier Who Employs Stevedore under a Long-Term Contract is Vicariously Liable to Cargo Owner for Stevedore's Mishandling of Cargo even after Unloading and Storage

Vessel Owner Denied Duty Remission because of Procedural Failure in Filings with Customs Service

Wife of Harbor Worker Injured Nonfatally in State Territorial Waters May Maintain Action for Loss of Husband's Society

Corporation may Qualify for Tax Treatment as a Western Hemisphere Trade Corporation even though Incidental Purchases are Made Outside the Hemisphere

Importation or Receipt of Goods from the United States Confirmed by Telex to Plaintiff in United States Insufficient Contacts to Establish Personal Jurisdiction …

Books Received, Journal Staff

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

THE MIDDLE EASTERN STATES AND THE LAW OF THE SEA

By Ali A.El-Hakim

Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 1979. Pp. 293.Tables, maps, and international agreements.

-------------------------------------

COMPLIANCE AND PUBLIC AUTHORITY: A THEORY WITH INTERNATIONAL APPLICATIONS

By Oran R. Young

Baltimore: Resources for the Future, 1979. Pp. 161.

----------------------------

DOING BUSINESS WITH THE Russians

Under license from Westshore, Inc. New York: Praeger Publishers, 1978. Pp. 166.

---------------------------

TAX LAW AND POLICY IN THE E.E.C.

By Alexander James Easson

London: Oceana Publications, 1980. Pp. 269. Tables of treaty provisions, secondary legislation, cases, and statistics.

----------------------------------

THE COLLAPSE OF WELFARE REFORM: POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS, POLICY …

Book Reviews, Edward C. Brewer, Iii., W. Paul Gormley, Allaire U. Karzon.

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

DIRECT INVESTMENT AND DEVELOPMENT IN THE U.S.: A GUIDE TO INCENTIVE PROGRAMS, LAWS AND RESTRICTIONS 1980-1981

Raymond Waldmann

Washington D.C.: Transnational Investments, Ltd.; London: Kluwer Publishing, 1980. Pp. viii, 443. $75.00, London £45 plus £1 surface mail.

Reviewed by Edward C. Brewer, III.

-----------------------

NUCLEAR ENERGY AND NUCLEAR WEAPON PROLIFERATION

Frank Barnaby, Jozef Goldblat, Bhupendra Jasani, and Joseph Rotblat,eds. Published for the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute. London: Taylor & Francis, 1979. Pp. xxiv, 462.

Reviewed by W. Paul Gormley

--------------------------------------

INTERNATIONAL ASPECTS OF U.S. INCOME TAXATION Vois. I and III

Elisabeth Owens Boston, Mass.: Harvard Law School, 1980. Pp.305. …

Recent Decisions, Kevin P. Hishta, J. Clifton Cox, Shari D. Olenick, Stephen B. Hatcher, Ann M. Bell

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

ALIENS--Executive Suspension of Alien's Deportable Status Final as Congressional Veto Mechanism violates Constitutional Doctrine of Separation of Powers

Kevin P. Hishta

--------------------------- Sovereign Immunity--Iranian Immunity from Pre-Judgment Attachments Terminated under International Emergency Economic Powers Act

J. Clifton Cox

---------------------------

Sovereign Immunity--Government Shipping Company of the People's Republic of China is an "Agency or Instrumentality" for the Purposes of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976

Shari D. Olenick

----------------------------

State Corporate Income Tax--Foreign Source Dividends Included in State Taxation Base Under Unitary Business Enterprise Test

Stephen B. Hatcher

-----------------------------

Trade Regulation--Use of Registered Mail by Federal Trade Commission to Subpoena …

Domestic International Sales Corporations (Discs): How They Provide A Tax Incentive For Exports, Garrison R. Cox

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

This Note examines the logical and empirical validity of the reasons for the passage of the DISC legislation. Basically, the DISC legislation was prompted by the negative trade balance in 1971, a novel phenomenon in post-World War II United States. Providing a tax break on producers' export income was viewed as a way of reducing trade deficits by stimulating exports. On its surface, using "tax expenditures" to reach this goal seems logical, or at least benign. But when one considers that the primary thrust of the legislation was to encourage small producers to enter the export market, the logic of …

Corporate Borrowing For Investment In Equity Securities: Tax Advantages Via The Interest Deduction And Dividends Received Deduction, Thomas D. Moore, Jr.

Vanderbilt Law Review

By borrowing money and purchasing preferred stocks with an average yield greater than 58% of the interest rate on the debt, a corporation at the maximum marginal tax rate can reduce its federal income tax liability. In evaluating the potential benefit of this practice, the corporation must consider transactions costs and its ability either to tie the debt to the equities or to have a sufficiently distant maturity on the debt to weather interest rate cycles that depress preferred stock prices. A small to medium-sized corporation probably is in a better position to obtain appropriate debt and to purchase enough …

Nonmutual Collateral Estoppel In Federal Tax Litigation, Samuel E. Long, Jr.

Vanderbilt Law Review

First, the Note briefly traces the demise of the mutuality rule in nontax cases. Second, the Note discusses the cases examining the rule in tax disputes and argues that courts should not require mutuality as an absolute rule before collateral estoppel can apply.Finally, the Note proposes a framework within which courts should analyze nonmutual estoppel claims in federal tax cases...

This Note has argued that the Supreme Court's decision in Parklane Hosiery and the Ninth Circuit's decision in Starker v. United States have sounded the death knell for the mutuality rule in its final stronghold-federal tax litigation. Courts can apply …

Open Space Taxation And State Constitutions, David A. Myers

Vanderbilt Law Review

this Article will first examine the theoretical function and form of state constitutions. This analysis can in turn be used to develop criteria for evaluating the content of these open space amendments. These criteria can then be used to suggest alternative methods of constitutional change that will allow state governments to respond most effectively to contemporary problems in the taxation of real property.

... This Article has been concerned with the various justifications for putting open space taxation provisions in state constitutions. It should be noted, however, that these amendments can have important negative effects on state constitutional law. Because …

Let Them Be Judged: The Judicial Integration Of The Deep South / Federal Taxation Of Trusts, Grantors And Beneficiaries/, Steven F. Lawson, John H. Martin

Vanderbilt Law Review

Let Them be Judged: The Judicial Integration of the Deep South Frank T. Read and Lucy S. McGough

The manner in which federal judges in the South both retarded and promoted first-class citizenship rights for Black Americans is the topic of Frank Read's and Lucy McGough's 1978 work Let Them Be Judged: The Judicial Integration of the Deep South. The authors, law professors at the University of Tulsa and Emory University respectively, review in great detail the operation of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in adjudicating the rapidly increasing volume of civil rights litigation after …

Income And Gift Tax Treatment Of A Waiver Of Rights To Future, Undeclared Dividends By A Corporate Shareholder, Cornelia H. Boozman

Vanderbilt Law Review

This Note will attempt to set forth and analyze the present state of the law concerning dividend waivers.After determining that this law gives taxpayers few standards for determining the proper tax characterization of a dividend waiver, the Note concludes that analogous areas of tax law must be examined for guidance. Finally, the Note identifies and discusses several analogies that might be helpful to a taxpayer faced with a dividend waiver problem.

Taxation Of Sale And Leaseback Transactions - A General Review, Kenneth L. Stewart

Vanderbilt Law Review

This Note first discusses in detail the operation of a sale and leaseback transaction and delineates its various uses. The Note next points out the tax and financial advantages and disadvantages of the sale and leaseback, sets forth the possible avenues of attack on the transaction by the Internal Revenue Service (Service), and describes the consequences of a successful attack by the Service. The final section of the Note analyzes the judicial treatment of sale and leaseback transactions for tax purposes, focusing both on the traditional tests used by the courts and on changes in the law brought about by …

The Negative Commerce Clause And State Environmental Legislation-Externalities Suggest Application Of The Tax Standard To Environmental Regulations, Douglas K. Stewart

Vanderbilt Law Review

This Note advocates judicial application of this tax analysis not only to tax environmental legislation, but also to regulatory environmental legislation. The theoretical justification for this thesis is provided by the economic concept of externalities. Externalities are elements used in the production of a marketed item without cost to the producer, but at a cost to others. The term "externality"stems from the fact that the use of the element of production is not included in the market price of the item. Undesirable environmental impact has been recognized as an externality -- a cost to those people adversely affected by it …

The Changing Meaning Of "Gift": An Analysis Of The Tax Court's Decision In Carson V. Commissioner, Jeffrey Schoenblum

Vanderbilt Law Review

This Article will focus on the Carson case in an effort to identify the emerging meaning, if any, of gift. Following a consideration of the factual background of the case in Part II, Part HI will analyze critically and in-depth each of the five Carson opinions in an effort to decipher the various currents at play and any common ground that may still be shared by a majority of the court. Finally, Part IV will consider the decision's likely consequences and the long-term prospects for a settled meaning for gift, one that is not only workable, as is the case …

From De Facto To Statutory Exemption: An Analysis Of The Evolution Of Legislative Policy Regarding The Federal Taxation Of Campaign Finance, Jeffrey Schoenblum

Vanderbilt Law School Faculty Publications

This article first explores the development of the de facto system of tax exemption and identifies the tensions that led to its demise. The analysis then details the substitution of a statutory structure in place of the traditional informal arrangement and examines the potential present in that structure for substantial IRS interference in the political process.

The Changing Meaning Of "Gift": An Analysis Of The Tax Court's Decision In "Carson V. Commissioner", Jeffrey Schoenblum

Vanderbilt Law School Faculty Publications

The complexity of detail that characterizes the Internal Revenue Code (Code) has been the subject of intense criticism and only faint praise. Yet, one of the more striking anomalies of the Code is that its often suffocating detail coexists with the sparest definitions of many key terms. The term "gift" is a prime example. Although its meaning plays an instrumental role in income and gift taxation, the Code nowhere defines the term. As a result, the task of fleshing out its meaning has largely fallen on the Treasury, through the issuance of regulations and rulings, and on the courts, which …

Books Received, Journal Staff

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

THE HOST STATE AND THE TRANSNATIONAL CORPORATION: AN ANALYSIS OF LEGAL RELATIONSHIPS

By Juha Kuusi

Farnborough, England: Saxon House, 1979. Pp. 177. $25.25 (Distributed by Renouf USA, Brookfield, Vermont.)

----------------------------------------------------

THE INDIRECT CREDIT Vol. II

By Gerald Ball and Elizabeth A.Owens

Cambridge, Mass.: The International Tax Program, Harvard Law School, 1979. Pp. 406. $40.00.

----------------------------------------------------

JURIDICA: ANUARIO DEL DEPARTAMENTO DEL DERECHO DE LA UNIVERSIDAD IBEROAMERICANA

Edited by Enrique Portilla Osio Mexico City: Universidad Iberoamericano. 1978. Pp. 595.

---------------------------------------------------

LES SANCTIONS PRIVATES DE DROITS Ou DE QUALITE DANS LES ORGANISATIONS INTERNATIONALES SPECIALISEES

By Charles Leben Brussels: Emile Bruylant. 1979. Pp. 410. …

Recent Decisions, Jamie S. Martin, Margaret H. Fiorillo, J. Andrew Hoyal, Ii

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW--COMMERCE CLAUSE--STATE TAX ON INSTRUMENTALITIES OF FOREIGN COMMERCE INVALID WHEN TAX RESULTS IN MULTIPLE TAXATION AND IMPAIRS FEDERAL UNIFORMITY IN REGULATION OF FOREIGN TRADE

Jamie S. Martin

-----------------------------

IMMIGRATION--LAWFUL UNRELINQUISHED DOMICILE--DEPORTABLE RESIDENT ALIEN MUST ACCUMULATE SEVEN YEARS OFLAWFUL DOMICILE SUBSEQUENT TO ADMISSION FOR PERMANENT RESIDENCE TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR DISCRETIONARY RELIEF

Margaret H. Fiorillo

----------------------------------

LONGSHOREMEN'S AND HARBOR WORKERS' COMPENSATION ACT--MANUFACTURER MAY SUE STEVEDORE FOR INDEMNIFICATION FROM LIABILITY ARISING OUT OF LONGSHOREMEN'S INJURIES--THEORY OF EQUITABLE CREDIT DOES NOT APPLY TO THE LHWCA

J. Andrew Hoyal, II

Proposed Legislative Solutions To Tax Shelter Partnership Abuses - The End Of The Aggregate Concept?, Thomas E. Settles

Vanderbilt Law Review

This Note first will set forth the Treasury Department's perception of the present abuses of tax shelter partnerships and will analyze existing procedural rules, the Treasury Department's proposed amendments, and the House of Representatives' proposed amendments in light of these abuses. Next, the Note will examine the substantive law of Subchapter K and will attempt to point out the probable effects of the proposed amendments on the aggregate concept of partnerships, on substantive partnership tax law, and on the viability of the partnership form of business. Finally, this Note will propose a solution to the problem of tax shelter partnership …

Section 243 And Bootstrap Sales: The Dilemma Of The Corporate Shareholder, Don B. Cannada

Vanderbilt Law Review

The differences in the tax treatment of dividends and redemptions, the tax goals of individual and corporate shareholders, and the characterizations given corporate distributions by the Internal Revenue Service and the courts have combined to create over-whelming confusion for corporate bootstrap sales. The purpose of this Note is to formulate a rational, consistent approach to the tax treatment of corporate bootstrap sales. Accordingly, this Note initially will discuss various lines of cases governing the possible tax treatment of the seller in a bootstrap acquisition. Special emphasis will be placed on the recent line of cases that deny section 243 intercorporate …

Recent Cases, Alan W. Duncan, Elton G. Snowden, William A. Holby, Joseph W. Gibbs

Vanderbilt Law Review

Constitutional Law -- Newsperson's Privilege - The First Amendment Guarantee of a Free Press Protects Against Compelled Disclosure of a Journalist's Exercise of Editorial Control and Judgment

Plaintiff, a former army officer who had achieved national prominence by claiming that his superiors ignored his reports of atrocities by American forces in Vietnam,' brought a libel suit against defendant television producer, reporter, and network for broadcasting a program that cast doubt upon plaintiff's allegations. Contending that defendant did not present available information corroborating plaintiff's claims, plaintiff sought discovery of the producer's beliefs, opinions, intent, and conclusions in preparing the program.

Alan …

Recent Decisions, Lloyd F. Leroy, Shelley B. O'Neill, Thomas E. Settles

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

Commodity Futures Trading Commission Act of 1974--Commodity Futures Trading Commission Regulating that Restrict Dealers in Foreign Options More Severely than Dealers in Futures Contracts are not Arbitrary or Capricious

Lloyd F. LeRoy

==================

Customs--Countervailing Duties--Rebates of Nonexcessive Excise Taxes Do Not Constitute a Bounty Subject to Countervailing Duties

Shelley B. O'Neill

==================

Jurisdiction--Exercise of in REM and Quasi in Rem Jurisdiction Justified only Where International Shoe Minimum Contacts Standard is Satisfied

Thomas E. Settles

==============================

SECURITIES REGULATION--Extraterritorial Application of the Anti-fraud Provisions--Federal Securities Laws Grant Jurisdiction When There is Some Activity in Furtherance of a Fraudulent Scheme Committed Within the …

Current Problems Facing The Executor Taking The Section 2053 Estate Tax Deduction, Jay D. Christiansen

Vanderbilt Law Review

Section 2053 of the Internal Revenue Code allows the executor to deduct from the gross estate amounts attributable to expenses, indebtedness, and taxes. This Note will examine problems currently confronting an executor who is attempting to utilize the 2053 deduction. The first problem examined in this Note is the conflict in the federal courts of appeals regarding the deductibility of expenses incurred as a result of a sale of decedent's property. The statute,cases, and regulations in this area will be examined, and a suggested approach for the executor encountering this problem will be provided. The second problem considered is the …

Recent Cases, Sara P. Walsh, Don B. Cannada, Frances L. Adams, William T. Luedke, Iv

Vanderbilt Law Review

Civil Procedure - Appellate Jurisdiction - Orders Denying Disqualification of Counsel on Ethical Grounds Are Not Final Decisions Subject to Immediate Review Under 28 U.S.C. § 1291

Sara Porter Walsh

Petitioner,' an applicant for a Federal Communications Commission (FCC) broadcasting license, sought interlocutory review of a Commission order' denying a motion to disqualify the law firm that had represented competitor RKO for thirty years. Petitioner alleged that participation by the firm, which included an attorney who was chairman of the FCC while RKO's application was under consideration, constituted a violation of Canons Five and Nine' of the ABA Code of …

Foreign Accumulation Trusts And The Tax Reform Act Of 1976, David H. Simmons

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

If the foreign trust is not a grantor trust under the Grantor Trust Provisions (sections 671-679), then the new Act creates several new disparities in the tax treatment between it and a corresponding domestic accumulation trust. Domestic accumulation trusts are no longer subjected to a capital gains throw back, while capital gains of foreign trusts are included in DNI, subject to throw back, and then taxed as ordinary income to the beneficiary because of the abolition of the character rules upon accumulation distribution. Foreign trusts are subjected to throw back of accumulation distributions even though the accumulation was during the …

Recent Decisions, William W. Allen, Alexander A. Hassani, Peter A. Schuller

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

INCOME TAX--LIQUIDATION OF FOREIGN CORPORATIONS--SHAREHOLDERS IN A LIQUIDATING FOREIGN CORPORATION MUST INCLUDE IN THE CORPORATION'S EARNINGS AND PROFITS ACCOUNT THE AMOUNT OF RECAPTURED EXCESS DEPRECIATION REALIZED UPON THE SALE OF ITS ASSETS

William W. Allen

CUSTOMS DUTIES--ANTIDUMPING ACT OF 1921--THE SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY HAS No AUTHORITY TO TERMINATE A WITH-HOLDING OF APPRAISEMENT PRIOR TO THE PUBLICATION OF A DUMPING FINDING BASED ON A LIKELIHOOD OF INJURY DETERMINATION BY THE INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION

Alexander A. Hassani

INTERNATIONAL BANKING--BANKRUPTCY-FOREIGN BANKS NEITHER REGULATED BY NOR LICENSED To Do BUSINESS IN THE UNITED STATES MAY FILE FOR VOLUNTARY BANKRUPTCY UNDER THE NATIONAL BANKRUPTCY …

Books Received, Journal Staff

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

A Practical Guide to U.S. Taxation of Overseas Americans

By Thomas E. Johnson

London: Raftwain Ltd., 1977. Pp. 311. $25.00.

======================

The Impact of International Organizations on Legal and Institutional Changes in the Developing Countries

New York: International Legal Center, 1977. Pp. 275.

=======================

U.S. Customs Tariffs and Trade

By Eugene T. Rossides

Washington, D.C.: The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc., 1977. Pp. 826. $45.00.