Law and Society Commons^™

Latina Multidimensionality And Latcrit Possibilities: Culture, Gender, And Sex©, Berta E. Hernández-Truyol

UF Law Faculty Publications

This essay explores the multiple margins that Latinas inhabit both within majority society and their comunidad Latina because of their compounded outsider status in all their possible communities. Exploring the concept and theme of "Between/Beyond Colors: Outsiders Within Latina/o Communities" elucidates both the challenges and the possibilities the young LatCrit movement presents for Latinas.

From its inception, LatCrit has broadened and sought to reconstruct the race discourse beyond the normalized binary black/white paradigm -- an underinclusive model that effects the erasure of the Latina/o, Native, and Asian experiences as well as the realities of other racial and ethnic groups in …

The Future Of Governmental Ethics: Law And Morality, Jon L. Mills

UF Law Faculty Publications

Based on a speech presented at the 16th International Symposium on Economic Crime, Cambridge University, England September 13-19, 1998.

Juvenile Crime And Punishment: An Analysis Of The "Get Tough" Approach, Shannon F. Mclatchey

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

The purpose of this note is to explore the current state of the juvenile justice system and its “get tough on juvenile crime” approach, as well as some alternatives to the current system. Part II examines the history of the juvenile court, the philosophy behind the creation of a separate system for juvenile offenders, and two U.S. Supreme Court cases that altered the nature of the juvenile court. Part III utilizes recent cases to illustrate the methods by which juveniles are transferred to adult court. Part IV discusses the problems and controversies surrounding transfer of juveniles to adult court. Part …

Ignoring The Sexualization Of Race: Heteronormativity, Critical Race Theory And Anti-Racist Politics, Darren Lenard Hutchinson

UF Law Faculty Publications

This Article, a third in a series of related works, explores the representation of sexual identity within Critical Race Theory and other forms of anti-racist discourse. I argue, after examining representative texts, that anti-racist discourse is often "heteronormative" -- or centered around heterosexual experiences. Most commonly, anti-racist heteronormativity occurs when scholars and activists in the field fail to analyze the homophobic dimensions of acts or conditions of racial inequality and when they dismiss, either implicitly or explicitly, the "morality" of gay and lesbian equality claims. This Article recommends that scholars in Critical Race Theory and related fields adopt a more …

A Socio-Legal History Of Florida's Juvenile Transfer Reforms, Henry George White, Charles E. Frazier, Lonn Lanza-Kaduce

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article is intended to provide a socio-legal history of the transfer laws in Florida, not only the recent reforms but also transfer provisions dating back nearly fifty years. Multiple changes involving a mix of instrumental expressive, and systems or institutional factors have occurred during this time. The goals of our analysis are to explore the underlying reasons for Florida’s transfer reforms in particular and to improve our understanding of the dynamics of legal reform in general.

Juvenile Transfers In Florida: The Worst Of The Worst?, Lonn Lanza-Kaduce, Charles E. Frazier, Donna M. Bishop

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

The purpose of this article is to examine what is needed to assess the issues of fairness and effectiveness, which are central to the rationales underpinning transfer policies. We start by considering the adequacy of the data that most often used to learn about transfer. We then report the findings from an in-depth study of local records. This field research illustrates how complex information gathering is on matters relevant to transfer. We then use the more detailed processing information gained from our study of local records to profile transfer cases and assess the comparability between criminal court transfers and their …

Using Violence As Social Control: Applying A Theory Of Conflict Management To Juvenile Disputes, Marian J. Borg

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article seeks to contribute both to the empirical evaluations of Black’s theory and to the literature on adolescent violence. It bridges these two area by examining the utility of Black’s theory of conflict management for explaining the use of violence in conflict situations between juveniles, an area in which Black’s propositions have not yet been systematically evaluated. The analysis focuses only on violence used to further a robbery, theft, or other predatory crime. Black’s theory is used as a basis for identifying social variables that increase the likelihood of using violence as a conflict management technique. A 1995 data …

Analyzing Juvenile Justice Policy: A Critical Review, Tonya Aultman-Bettridge

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article reviews a variety of perspectives that have been applied to the study of the juvenile justice system in more recent years. While not meant as an exhaustive summary of the literature on juvenile justice, this article outlines a number of different frames of reference that have been used in the analysis of policies aimed at chronic, serious and/or violent juveniles offenders, with a particular emphasis on framing the nature of the current controversy and debate. Starting with the social science of 1970s, which supported the “nothing works” doctrine of juvenile offender treatment, this work review and summarizes existing …

A House Divided: The Social And Economic Underdevelopment Of America's Inner Cities, Dash T. Douglas

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article attempts to demonstrate the urgent need to reconsider our current social policies and to revitalize government concern over our urban ghettos. Part II provides a historical background on how urban ghettos were formed in the United States. Part III discusses the Kerner Commission’s findings and the recommendations it made to President Lyndon Johnson and the American people. Part IV analyzes the social and economic regression experienced by inner-city communities during the past thirty years. Part V discusses the findings of the Eisenhower Foundation and describes the programs it espouses.

Finally, part VI, outlines recommendations on how the United …

Constitutional Law: Decency Requirement In Art Funding Nea V. Finley, 118 S. Ct. 2168 (1998), Amy Petrick

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

No abstract provided.

Remember The Ingredient: The View From Outside The Tower, Michael A. Mogill

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

No abstract provided.

The Appeal Provision Of Florida's Criminal Punishment Code: Unwise And Unconstitutional, Robert Batey, Stephen M. Everhart

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article addresses whether this startling new appeal provision in Florida’s Criminal Punishment Code is constitutional: Can the state give itself the right to appeal downward departure sentences but deny the reciprocal right of the defendant to appeal upward departure sentences? Part II of this article sets the background for answering this question by briefly sketching the history of sentencing guidelines in Florida, and how the new appeal provision undermines the wise policy behind those guidelines. Part III then outlines the infirmities of the new appeal provision under the double jeopardy, right-to-appeal, due process, and proportionality provisions of both the …

In Order To Hire The Best Person For The Job, We Have To What?, Brian John Halliday

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This Article will examine the numerous claims of U.S. employers that they cannot fill professional-level job openings with home-grown U.S. workers, and the complaints of those who oppose the importation of foreign professional labor. By shedding some light on these broad questions, we should put into proper perspective the motivating elements behind our ever-changing United States immigration laws, separating the valid impetuses from the rhetoric. This should serve to paint a clearer picture of the actual state of affairs affecting our labor needs, and to suggest courses of action designed to stabilize and to correct the U.S. employment-based immigration system. …

Arbitration Law: Jurisprudence Of Uncertainty, Matthew L. Hicks

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

No abstract provided.

Perilous Potholes In The Path Toward Patent Law Harmonization, Kevin Cuenot

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This Note will address the public policy issues and the economics involved with changing the United States patent system to a first-to-file system.

Toward A More Utilitarian Juvenile Court System, Rod Smith

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

No abstract provided.

Privacy And The Internet: Welcome To The Orwellian World, Allegra Knopf

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This Note explores the current state of federal law applicable to computer communication privacy. Part I discusses the application of the Fourth Amendment to computer privacy concerns. Part II explores the federal wiretap statute and its limitations. Part III concludes with a discussion of how legislation may enhance computer privacy.

Global Rights, Local Wrongs, And Legal Fixes: An International Human Rights Critique Of Immigration And Welfare "Reform", Berta E. Hernández-Truyol, Kimberly A. Johns

UF Law Faculty Publications

The United States enjoys a lofty reputation worldwide as the land of opportunity and dreams, the welcoming home to all who want to be free, the brave new world that embraces huddled masses and offers them limitless possibilities to find freedom, liberty, and happiness. In marked juxtaposition to this welcomeness narrative is the counter-narrative of historic exclusion evidenced by the harsh description of these "huddled masses, yearning to breathe free" as "wretched refuse." Indeed, to describe some immigrants as "wretched refuse" manifests that Lady Liberty's welcome is, at best, highly selective and, at worst, patently discriminatory. The irony, of course, …

Introductory Remarks: Reflections On Privatization In Higher Education, John V. Lombardi

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

No abstract provided.

Gratis Dictum! The Limits Of Academic Free Speech On The Internet, Ray August

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article is about the right of university professors to exercise their academic freedom to speak out and to teach in a new forum: the Internet. Although the Internet is a new forum, this article will attempt to show that the same basic rights and duties that apply to professors in the classroom and in the academic media apply to professors speaking out on the Internet. Part I sets the stage with a very brief history of the Internet. Part II examines the principal cases dealing with academic free speech as they relate to the Internet. Most of these cases …

Private Publics, Public Privates: An Essay On Convergence In Higher Education, Richard A. Matasar

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

Once upon a time, not too long ago, we understood social organization. Parents ran their families. The principal governed the local school with an iron fist and a velvet glove; the school board controlled the principal. People turned to religious leaders for guidance and respected their views. We knew that the President had a private life, but did not find it necessary to read daily press speculations about that life. Greedy bosses exploited professional athletes, studios extracted life-time servitude from performers, and the three television networks controlled access to popular information and entertainment. Every social institution discriminated against women and …

Who Is An "Otherwise Qualified" Law Student? A Need For Law Schools To Develop Technical Standards, J. Patrick Shannon

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

An increasing number of prospective and current law students are seeking disability-related accommodations under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA). Various accommodation requests include: extended time on exams (time-and-a-half, double-time, quadruple-time, or no time limit), modification of exams from essay to short-answer, individual testing rooms, modification of all exam from closed-book to open-book, large print exams, the presence of service animals for the sight-impaired and for those with stress disorders, audio/visual recordings of lectures, notetakers, no deadlines for papers, no in-class exercises, not being called upon to respond in class, a stand-up desk on which to write, special …

The First Amendment Threat To Academic Tenure, Daniel E. Hall

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

Many people have questioned the need for academic tenure. Both higher education literature and the popular press are filled with articles concerning the subject. The article addresses whether tenure continues to be needed as we move into the new millennium. Specifically, the argument that contemporary First Amendment protections make tenure superfluous is examined. Part I describes the history of tenure. The purpose of tenure is examined in part II. Part III examines the law of tenure. Part IV identifies the First Amendment argument in opposition to tenure. In part V the reasons the First Amendment does not obviate the need …

The Decline And Fall Of The Wall Of Separation Between Church And State And Its Consequences For The Funding Of Public And Private Institutions Of Higher Education, F. King Alexander

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article summarizes the evolution of judicial thought concerning the funding of higher education as it pertains to the constitutional concept of separation between church and state. The fiscal consequences of the decline and fall of this wall of separation, as government has increasingly aided private higher education with public resources, are explored. The article notes the ineffectiveness of government student aid policies in providing lower-income students with meaningful choice in pursuing higher education opportunities. The findings presented in this article are not important to higher education alone, but also indicate the probable effects of government funding schemes that aid …

Juvenile Justice Under Attack: An Analysis Of The Causes And Impact Of Recent Reforms, Donna M. Bishop, Lonn Lanza-Kaduce, Charles E. Frazier

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

The juvenile justice system is currently under attack on two broad fronts. First, legal experts and commentators are providing stinging critiques of the system’s failure to protect the liberty and due process interests of juveniles. Second, legislators throughout the country are supporting more and more legislation designed to “get tough” on juvenile crime. In combination, these criticisms and reforms advance the “recriminalization” of juvenile offenders. Juvenile offenders are increasingly subject to adult standards of culpability and punishment. Most of this change in the way we think about and officially respond to juvenile crime has proceeded without a discussion of the …

The Media In The New Millennium: Exploring Myths And Misconceptions Before Shooting The Messenger, Sandra F. Chance

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

The press has a crisis of credibility. May believe that the media increasingly violate basic standards of fairness, accuracy, objectivity, and respect for privacy in the rush to profit from sensationalizing sex, scandal, and violence. Criticism often turns into media bashing, as it has become almost derigueur to blame the media for all of society’s ills. Some of the bashing is deserved. Much of it is not. The entire industry is often blamed for the excesses of a few. And, there is a widespread temptation to shoot the messenger who brings the bad news.

Often, this underserved criticism flows from …

Union Dues And Politics: Workers Speak Out Against Unions Speaking For Them, R. Bradley Adams

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

The purpose of this note is to examine the current movement towards implementing legislation that would require unions to obtain workers’ consent prior to using their compulsory dues and fees for political purposes. Part II is devoted to framing the major developments in the law that have roughly defined the limits of unions’ use of compulsory dues for political purposes. Part III provides an analysis of relevant U.S. Supreme Court cases and emphasizes First Amendment questions surrounding union expenditures of compulsory union dues and fees. Part IV addresses the movement in some states to require unions to obtain affirmative consent …

Speaking Freely About Reducing Violence Against Women: A Harm Reduction Strategy From The Law And Social Science Of Pornography, Michelle Chernikoff Anderson

University of Florida Journal of Law & Public Policy

This article exposes legal scholars to the research essential to establishing support for an education policy that would inoculate our children against the potentially harmful effects of consuming media that promote violence against girls and women. It argues that Dworkin-MacKinnonites, concerned about pornography, and civil libertarians, concerned about free speech, should waste neither more time nor more ink debating this issue. Rather, it is time to dedicate our efforts to creating and implementing a harm reduction educational approach to protect our children against pornography.

Part II defines the terminology used throughout the article. Part III outlines the failures of current …

Law, Culture, And The Morality Of Judicial Choice, Kenneth B. Nunn

UF Law Faculty Publications

Remarks from Professor Kenneth B. Nunn at the Ray Rushton Distinguished Lecture Series at the Cumberland School of Law on April 24, 1998.

Building Bridges Iii - Personal Narratives, Incoherent Paradigms, And Plural Citizens, Berta E. Hernández-Truyol

UF Law Faculty Publications

This Essay, in three parts, explores bridge building among communities of color with the purposes of creating, maintaining, and developing alliances. The first part, Personal Narratives, shares with readers some cuentos (stories) as a method and path in which to position the lectors: to contextualize my frontiers and familiarize them with my daily travels through diverse and varied borderlands; the many communities with which I intersect and interact, and in which I live- all of them my communities; and in all of which I am both insider and outsider. Part II, Incoherent Paradigms, suggests that the prevailing race-based legal paradigms …