Internet Law Commons^™

Table Of Contents, Seattle University Law Review

Seattle University Law Review

Table of Contents

The Marijuana Insurgency: Federalism And Social Reframing In Policy Reform, Matthew P. Cavedon

Seattle University Law Review

After fifty years of federal prohibition, marijuana reform efforts have won political and legal success. These victories hold lessons for anyone seeking to resist federal law without being able to directly affect it.

Victory can come from reframing an issue. For marijuana reform, social reframing—not formal legal analysis or material factors—provides the best explanation for how advocates achieved change. Their unconventional political tactics, akin to those used by insurgents in wartime, undercut federal prohibition by winning hearts and minds.

This is an analysis of the sociology of legal change. It is also the story of how ordinary Americans retook personal …

Blacklisting Or Banning Technologies That Scare Us: Ai, Cryptocurrencies, And More, Nizan Geslevich Packin, Hadar Yoana Jabotinsky

American University Law Review

Policymakers often play a critical role in regulating the use and advancement of technology. Their decisions can have significant positive impacts on the development, adoption, and use of various technologies, but also negative ones if they decide to limit or even block a certain technology. Italy’s temporary banning of the Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) platform ChatGPT, much like New York City’s Department of Education, demonstrates administrations’ and policymakers’ reliance on blacklisting and banning.

Blacklisting and banning are often used interchangeably. Nevertheless, in the context of regulation, the terms are different and used for different purposes, and it is key to …

Innovation Misunderstood, Maurice E. Stucke, Ariel Ezrachi

American University Law Review

Innovation is transformative and key to future prosperity. It is therefore of no surprise that antitrust laws seek to promote it. What is surprising, however, is that despite the central role that innovation occupies in competition cases, its actual treatment by the courts is far from nuanced. In this paper, we reflect on the D.C. Circuit’s 2023 ruling in New York v. Meta to illustrate the prevailing monocular vision adopted by the court in its treatment of innovation. That vision, we argue, reflects simplistic assumptions as to innovation dynamics and mistaken beliefs about the digital economy. It is further compounded …

How Licenses Learn, Madiha Zahrah Choski, James Grimmelmann

Lewis & Clark Law Review

Open-source licenses are infrastructure that collaborative communities inhabit. These licenses don’t just define the legal terms under which members (and outsiders) can use and build on the contributions of others. They also reflect a community’s consensus on the reciprocal obligations that define it as a community. A license is a statement of values, in legally executable form, adapted for daily use. As such, a license must be designed, much as the software and hardware that open-source developers create. Sometimes an existing license is fit to purpose and can be adopted without extensive discussion. However, often the technical and social needs …

Ethics Of Innovation: A Framework For Responsible Innovation Governance, Nicole Morris

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

Over the past several years, startups that once seemed destined for greatness have failed or collapsed because of fraud committed by the founders. Most notable are the Theranos and FTX business collapses, which culminated in the convictions of two infamous entrepreneurs, Elizabeth Holmes and Sam Bankman-Fired, respectively. Startup innovators are not alone when it comes to morally dubious behavior. According to Retraction Watch, nearly 5000 papers published in science & engineering journals were retracted in 2022. Research misconduct allegations eventually led to the resignation of Stanford University President Marc Tessier-Lavigne in July 2023. The research scandal at Stanford received lots …

Solar Eclipses And The Law, Chad Marzen, Michael Conklin

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

This Article provides a comprehensive overview of the legal issues that appear with a solar eclipse. These include the sale of defective or fake eclipse glasses, vehicle accidents, liability claims for personal injuries against school districts, as well as questions involving the freedom of religion. Finally, this Article concludes by considering the juxtaposition between a perennial event such as a solar eclipse and the evolving nature of law.

Front Matter

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

No abstract provided.

Liability Rules For Automated Vehicles: Definitions And Details, William H. Widen, Philip Koopman

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

This paper explains how the law ought to assign liability for automated vehicle accidents by providing an example of a proposed statute. We advocate for the creation of the legal fiction of a “Computer Driver,” which can have negligence liability, anytime a court or jury determines that the Computer Driver’s behavior failed to imitate or exceed the level of care we would expect of an attentive and unimpaired Human Driver in similar circumstances. We then use this concept to explain how to determine contributory negligence and comparative fault when control of a vehicle is transferred from a Computer Driver to …

The Fall Of Z-Library: The “Burning Of The Library Of Alexandria” Or Protection For Authors Against Ai Companies, Lisa Silveira

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

The development and advancement of artificial intelligence (“AI”) is changing the way we use technology while creating an ongoing battle between media and technology companies. With AI companies gathering data from the internet to train programs like ChatGPT, authors have growing concerns about unpermitted use of their work when pirated copies of their books exist illegally online through shadow libraries. This article examines the popular shadow library known as Z-Library and the views of its proponents and opponents. In addition, this article will discuss the training process AI companies use and the data sets containing content from shadow libraries. While …

Algorithmic Adjudication And Constitutional Ai—The Promise Of A Better Ai Decision Making Future?, April G. Dawson

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

Algorithmic governance is when algorithms, often in the form of AI, make decisions, predict outcomes, and manage resources in various aspects of governance. This approach can be applied in areas like public administration, legal systems, policy-making, and urban planning. Algorithmic adjudication involves using AI to assist in or decide legal disputes. This often includes the analysis of legal documents, case precedents, and relevant laws to provide recommendations or even final decisions. The AI models typically used in these emerging decision-making systems use traditionally trained AI systems on large data sets so the system can render a decision or prediction based …

Front Matter

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

No abstract provided.

Neither Here Nor There: Redefining “Presence” For A Virtual Criminal Justice System, Brandon M. Draper

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

The coronavirus (“COVID-19”) pandemic dramatically altered how the criminal justice system operated by adding virtual options to traditionally in-person proceedings. The impact of the criminal justice system’s failure to include virtual jury trials among these options was shocking, but not surprising: jury trial rates across the country dropped close to zero percent and several in-custody defendants died from COVID-19 before a jury could determine their guilt or innocence. After the pandemic, criminal courts across the country made many of these virtual options permanent, but only for non-evidentiary proceedings and other non-jury trial settings. The failure to include criminal jury trials …

Computers, Credit, And Human Dignity, Jonathan Weinberg

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

Credit scores determine a person’s life chances. The credit scores we’re all used to, calculated by Equifax, Experian, or TransUnion, take as inputs a person’s payment history, loans, current debt, and similar financial information. But that world is changing. Modern alternative data models for credit scoring can go so far as to include an individual’s educational record, criminal history, shopping behavior, or telephone patterns. Activists, regulators, and scholars have expressed serious concerns about these new credit systems. Do they classify applicants on unfair or arbitrary grounds? Do they perpetuate, or even amplify, bias and pre-existing inequality?

Participants in this conversation …

Generative Ai In The Attorney-Client Relationship: An Exercise In Critical Revision And Client Management, Michael L. Smith

SMU Science and Technology Law Review

Discussions of generative AI in legal practice and education often assert that this technology will lead to a sea change in legal writing, research, and revision. While some of the more breathless proclamations deserve skepticism, there’s little doubt that this technology may generate new forms of headaches for those in the legal field—particularly once it’s in the hands of clients or opposing counsel who wish to use this technology to save the time, money, and effort required for complex legal tasks.

This essay proposes an exercise template for law students that illustrates how generative AI technology may be misused or …

Trademarks On The Blockchain: Nft Domains And Collisions, Jelena Laketić

Michigan Technology Law Review

Blockchain technology supporting cryptocurrency transactions is one of the most critical innovations of this decade. Establishing a legal identity on blockchain, however, is fraught with uncertainty. In the 1990s, the internet faced a similar set of issues, which were resolved through the ICANN dispute resolution system. This Article asserts that blockchain technology urgently needs a similar cohesive approach to NFT domains.

This Article will explore trademark issues with non-fungible tokens (NFTs), specifically NFT domains. It begins by exploring the fundamental structure of NFTs by demystifying the technology and showing how NFTs contrast with other currency regimes. Increased usage of NFTs …

How To Get The Property Out Of Privacy Law, Jane R. Bambauer

UF Law Faculty Publications

For the last ten years, American rhetoric and state lawmaking has attempted to provide consumers with greater and stickier property interest in their personal information. But the impracticalities of the sticky property model are becoming evident, and will be impossible to ignore as AI becomes more prevalent and useful. This Article critiques the property framework in privacy law, and explains how a risk-based approach can be modernized and implemented instead. An enduring system of privacy laws will manage risks rather than bestowing rights to control and delete information. To do this, data practices should be categorized into safe harbor practices …

The Twenty-Six Words That Created The Internet… And Then Maybe, Kind Of, Destroyed Society: Understanding And Reforming Section 230 Of The Communications Decency Act, Nandor F. R. Kiss

Michigan Technology Law Review

In 1996, Congress passed Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, a twenty-six-word law that immunized early internet companies from civil immunity arising from hosted, third-party content. At the time, the law was necessary to allow fledging companies to innovate without fear of bankruptcy-inducing lawsuits and ultimately helped to create the internet as we know it. To the extent this civil immunity has contributed to the vast technological advances over the past three decades, it should be lauded. However, the internet has dramatically changed in the past thirty years, and the law has been relied upon to protect companies in …

The Jawboning Cases End With A Bang Disguised By A Whimper, Derek E. Bambauer

UF Law Faculty Publications

Jawboning is government enforcement through informal channels, where the underlying authority is in doubt. Government actors at all levels have increasingly deployed this tactic to pressure Internet platforms to suppress disfavored speech. Internet jawboning debuted at the Supreme Court in two cases (National Rifle Association of America v. Vullo and Murthy v. Missouri) in 2023. Although the Court disposed of both cases on procedural and standing grounds, rather than offering a new methodology for evaluating jawboning, the opinions offer examples of what a successful jawboning claim looks like and what an unsuccessful claim lacks. Thus, jawboning as a …

Shareholder Primacy Versus Shareholder Accountability, William W. Bratton

Seattle University Law Review

When corporations inflict injuries in the course of business, shareholders wielding environmental, social, and governance (“ESG”) principles can, and now sometimes do, intervene to correct the matter. In the emerging fact pattern, corporate social accountability expands out of its historic collectivized frame to become an internal subject matter—a corporate governance topic. As a result, shareholder accountability surfaces as a policy question for the first time. The Big Three index fund managers, BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street, responded to the accountability question with ESG activism. In so doing, they defected against corporate legal theory’s central tenet, shareholder primacy. Shareholder primacy builds …

Content Moderation Regulation As Legal Role-Scripting, Sari Mazzurco

Indiana Law Journal

Lawmakers and scholars concerned with content moderation regulation typically appeal to “analogies” to justify or undermine different forms of regulation. The logic goes: law should afford individuals due process rights against speech platforms because speech platforms are “like” speech governors as a matter of objective reality. Other common analogies include common carriers, publishers, distributors, shopping malls, and bookstores.

Commentators attempt to invoke social roles to understand what the content moderation relationship is, what behaviors are “right” and “wrong” within it, and how law should police behavioral deviations. But they do so without relying on foundational sociology theory that explains what …

Verses Turned To Verdicts: Ysl Rico Case Sets A High-Watermark For The Legal Pseudo-Censorship Of Rap Music, Nabil Yousfi

Seattle University Law Review

Whichever way you spin the record, rap music and courtrooms don’t mix. On one side, rap records are well known for their unapologetic lyrical composition, often expressing a blatant disregard for legal institutions and authorities. On the other, court records reflect a Van Gogh’s ear for rap music, frequently allowing rap lyrics—but not similar lyrics from other genres—to be used as criminal evidence against the defendants who authored them. Over the last thirty years, this immiscibility has engendered a legal landscape where prosecutors wield rap lyrics as potent instruments for criminal prosecution. In such cases, color-blind courts neglect that rap …

A Framework For Applying Copyright Law To The Training Of Textual Generative Artificial Intelligence, Art Neill, James Thomas, Erika Lee

Faculty Scholarship

The rise in the popularity of consumer-facing generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has created considerable confusion and consternation among some copyright owners. The ability to automate the generation of original works based on user input is considered by some copyright holders to have been made possible by large-scale direct infringement by OpenAI, Microsoft, and other major GenAI developers. This article explores the application of copyright law to the training of OpenAI’s ChatGPT, specifically focusing on the legal issues surrounding the unauthorized use of copyrighted textual works in the GenAI training process.

The large language models (LLMs) that drive ChatGPT and similar …

Settlement Of Labor Dispute In Thailand: Establishing A Private Labor Dispute Settlement Organization, Nuthapach Worapichaiyut

Chulalongkorn University Theses and Dissertations (Chula ETD)

The settlement of labor dispute process is a process use to address the labor dispute between employers and employees. The interest-based labor dispute arises from the employer and employee on the demand to obtain an agreement relating to working conditions, including but not limited to wages, welfare, and on working days and hours. This type of labor dispute differs from right-based labor dispute, which includes issues such as unpaid wages, severance, or unfair dismissal. Both types of labor disputes require their own proper processes for resolution.The settlement of the interest-based labor dispute in Thailand has been prescribed in the Labor …

Balancing Interests: Ai, Business & Human Rights, And The Legal Landscape In An Era Of Disruption, Jena Martin, Ritu Narula

Faculty Articles

On October 30, 2023, the Biden Administration issued a sweeping executive order espousing a policy to advance the development and use of artificial intelligence ("Al") while also establishing safeguards across the federal government. The Executive Order marked the U.S. government's largest move forward related to the regulation of Al. The Order also represents the government's latest effort to advance equity, privacy, and national security in the use of AI systems. Moreover, the Order comes at a time when governments around the world are wrestling with the impact of AI and its disruptive effect, not just on markets, but on society …

Comparing Gdpr Against The United States’ Approach To Data Breach Notification By Examining Texas And California And The Feasibility Of A Universal Standard, Amrit Nagi

Cybaris®

No abstract provided.

Ai-Ip? Copyright In An Age Of Internet Propaganda With Artificial Intelligence, Sonya Saepoff

Cybaris®

No abstract provided.

Social Media, The Modern Public Forum: The State Action Doctrine And Resurrection Of Marsh, Erika L. Andersen

Mitchell Hamline Law Review

No abstract provided.

Virtual Justice: Criminalizing Avatar Sexual Assault In Metaverse Spaces, Olivia Bellini

Mitchell Hamline Law Review

No abstract provided.

We Shall Overcome: The Evolution Of Quotas In The Land Of The Free And The Home Of Samba, Stella Emery Santana

Seattle University Law Review

When were voices given to the voiceless? When will education be permitted to all? When will we need to protest no more? It’s the twenty-first century, and the fight for equity in higher education remains a challenge to peoples all over the world. While students in the United States must deal with the increase in loans, in Brazil, only around 20% of youth between the ages of twenty-five and thirty-four have a higher education degree.

The primary objective of this Article is to conduct an in-depth comparative analysis of the development, implementation, and legal adjudication of educational quota systems within …