International Law Commons^™

Professor Valentine Korah: A Biographical Note, Joseph C. Sweeney

Fordham International Law Journal

This is a biographical tribute to Professor Korah. All scholars researching in the area of European Union competition law have benefited greatly by her clear analyses of complex business problems.

Article 82: Remedies In Search Of Theories?, Ian S. Forrester

Fordham International Law Journal

I submit that over the last two or three years, we may observe troubling signs that Article 82 of the EC Treaty is being used more as an adjunct to industrial policy than as a pure competition law tool. This is especially evident in refusal to deal cases. The intervention of antitrust in a situation of refusal to deal is a critical pointer of how an antitrust enforcer perceives itself and of what kind of competition law is in force. At a time when ten new agencies have joined the family, it is especially desirable to approach controversies in a …

The Treaty Establishing A Constitution For Europe, Jeremy Lever

Fordham International Law Journal

This Article contains some reflections concerning the Draft Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe (“the Draft Treaty”), which was approved by the European Council on September 28, 2004 and formally signed in Rome on October 29, 2004. At the time of writing in early 2005, it is presently in the process of ratification by the twenty-five Member States of the European Union (“EU”). The Article is primarily concerned with the extent to which the Treaty is a constitution, and its merits and demerits as such. It does not go in any depth into the political desirability of some of the …

The Logic & Limits Of The "Exceptional Circumstances Test" In Magill And Ims Health, Christian Ahlborn, David S. Evans, A. Jorge Padilla

Fordham International Law Journal

In this Article, we show that, in contrast to the Commission's balancing approach in Microsoft, the ECJ's narrow construction of the obligation to license IP under Article 82 of the EC Treaty is based on sound economics and constitutes appropriate public policy. The set of “exceptional circumstances” listed in Magill and IMS Health constitutes a reasonable implementation of the optimal legal standard for the assessment of refusals to licence IP: modified per se legality. In the IP context, an obligation to make property available is a requirement for compulsory licensing. The ECJ test limits compulsory licensing to those situations in …

Article 82: The Last Frontier – Fighting Fire With Fire?, James S. Venit

Fordham International Law Journal

Since the entry into force of the European Union (“EU”) merger regulation in September 1990, there has been progress toward the acceptance of the need for rigorous economic analysis as the basis for the application of Community competition law. Although the path toward sound economic analysis has been uneven and recognition of the principle has sometimes exceeded its correct application, the increased willingness to acknowledge economic analysis as the basis for rational enforcement action should not be underestimated. The most noticeable and obvious success has been in the field of merger control. But even a statute as venerable as Article …

The Impact Of Consumer Protection On Banking Legislation In The European Community And The Effect Of The Recent Consumer Protection Proposals, Thomas F. Taylor

Fordham International Law Journal

In this article, I will examine the means by which European Community institutions have used consumer protection, and their impact. I will also examine the new proposals concerning consumer protection, and their impact. Finally, I will look at what the likely outcome of these proposals may be, if implemented.

The Impact Of Monetary Union And The Euro On European Capital Markets: What May Be Achieved In Capital Market Integration, Rosa Giovanna Barresi

Fordham International Law Journal

Up to now, the Euro has been successful in replacing the traditional European currencies and in altering the landscape of European Capital Markets. Domestic users of the Euro are almost the same in number as the population of the United STates, although the Gross Domestic Products of the two economies are clearly not comparable. Still, if the Member States within the Euro-area truly want to be recognized as an integrated capital market, some work must be done. This Article will estimate, from current economic thought, what remains to be done and what can be achieved in the short term. Some …

End Of Exile: Practical Solutions To The Palestinian Refugee Question, Arthur C. Helton

Fordham International Law Journal

The objective of this Essay is to add new information and analytical insights to the debate, namely, research about how refugee and compensation solutions have been implemented in other situations. Practical implementation options are examined from a variety of comparative experiences. Examining these options could help soften the political absolutism that characterizes the current impasse on the refugee issue. But there is value in any event in understanding the international system context, and mapping realistic scenarios for such matters as an institutional framework to implement a settlement, the criteria and procedures for relocating refugees, and techniques and methods to award …

Refugees, Internally Displaced Persons, And International Humanitarian Law, Francois Bugnion

Fordham International Law Journal

The fact that war is the primary cause of people being uprooted prompts us to ask what protection the law of armed conflict affords refugees and displaced persons. How does humanitarian law protect groups of civilians from being forced to flee? What protection does it offer those who have nevertheless been uprooted, and how does that protection interrelate with refugee law? How can the Red Cross and Red Crescent organizations, in particular the International Committee of the Red Cross (“ICRC”), come to the aid of refugees and displaced persons? These are the questions this Article aims to answer. First, however, …

The Judiciary, The State, And The Refugee: The Evolution Of Judicial Protection In Asylum – A U.K. Perspective, Geoffrey Care

Fordham International Law Journal

I will look at how the United Kingdom has attempted to handle its own obligations under the Refugee Convention of 1951 - and the European Convention on Human Rights - under the pressures of the increased numbers of those arriving in the country and claiming protection. I propose to survey the development of the system over the years, and in what seems to be a crisis management manner, the role played by the judiciary, and the overall effect on the refugee and how he or she establishes the claim. I will draw attention to some of the cases, particularly in …

Palestinian Refugees In Gaza, Susan Martin, John G. Warner, Patricia Fagen

Fordham International Law Journal

Events since Arthur Helton's death - including the change in leadership of the Palestinian Authority and the Israeli proposal for disengagement from Gaza make it even timelier to examine some "practical solutions." For improving Palestinian lives in the short term, much can be learned from the approaches taken in other refugee situations. This Article begins with background information on Palestinian refugees in Gaza. It then discusses Israeli plans for disengagement from Gaza. In the following section, the Article reviews options for addressing the problems faced by Palestinian refugees in Gaza, utilizing the broader literature devoted to the integration of refugees …

Return Seen From A European Perspective: An Impossible Dream, An Improbable Reality, Or An Obstruction To Refugee Policy?, Joanne Van Selm

Fordham International Law Journal

The central theme of this Essay is that both individuals in need of protection and governments obliged to grant protection to those in need generally hold the eventual return of citizens to their countries of origin to be the ideal scenario. However, this ideal cannot always come to fruition -- not only due to circumstances in the country of origin, but also as an unintended consequence of policy decisions taken by governments concerning the protection of refugees (or indeed internally displaced persons ("IDPs")) and the reactions of individuals to the outcomes of those policy decisions. Return, it will be suggested, …

Reason Without Borders: How Transnational Values Cannot Be Contained, Shane B. Kelbley

Fordham International Law Journal

Part I of this Note will review the influence of international law in early U.S. history as well as the current practice of the U.S. Supreme Court in citing international law, and will briefly explain how principles of international law are imported into U.S. courtrooms. Part II will examine competing legal theories on the proper role for international law in U.S. constitutional interpretation. Part III will argue that although it is proper for U.S. courts to reference international sources in their decisions, the U.S. Supreme Court's current articulation of how courts should do so is deeply flawed. Part III will …

The Dichotomy Between Judicial Economy And Equality Of Arms Within International And Internationalized Criminal Trials: A Defense Perspective, Geert-Jan Alexander Knoops

Fordham International Law Journal

This Article considers the trend to effectuate judicial economy within international criminal trials juxtaposed with the principle of equality of arms from the standpoint of the defense. It focuses on this juxtaposition as exemplified in contemporary case law of the ICTY. In addressing this issue, the analysis in this Article will build on the assumption that the interrelationship between these two notions must be interpreted in light of two cardinal parameters: first, the protection of the interests of the defense, and second, the principle of independence and non-political use of the notion of judicial economy.

Federal Courts, International Tribunals, And The Continuum Of Deference: A Postscript On Lawrence V. Texas, Roger P. Alford

Journal Articles

Last year, in the pages of this journal, I published an article addressing the role of international tribunal decisions in federal courts.1 In that article, it was suggested that federal courts should confer varying degrees of deference to international tribunal decisions depending on the circumstances presented. Such degrees of deference were plotted along a "continuum of deference." See: Federal Courts, International Tribunals, and the Continuum of Deference

The purpose of this brief Postscript is to reconsider the "no deference" model in light of the Supreme Court's decisions in Bowers and Lawrence. The Postscript elucidates why Lawrence relied on an international …

International Legal Developments In Review: 2003 [Foreign Law Review], Roger P. Alford

Journal Articles

Contents

• Introduction

Volume 38 Issues 2 (Summer) and 3 (Fall) are titled "International Legal Developments in Review: 2003." This Fall issue covers specific country laws. In previous volumes the Fall issue was titled "Foreign Law Year in Review..." and covered specific country laws.

International Legal Developments In Review: 2003, Roger P. Alford

Journal Articles

Contents

• Editor's Preface
• Introduction

Occupation Failures And The Legality Of Armed Conflict: The Case Of Iraqi Cultural Property, Mary Ellen O'Connell

Journal Articles

To wage war consistently with international law, a national leader must be able to answer at least three questions in the affirmative: Is there a right to resort to force? Is the use of force necessary? If it is necessary, can it be carried out in a way that the cost in terms of human lives, property, and damage to the natural environment will not outweigh the value of resorting to force? If the answer to any of these questions is no, the use of force is unlawful. International lawyers tend to focus on the first question, understandably. Why analyze …

Demos, Nomos And Globalization, Paolo G. Carozza

Book Chapters

It is a great privilege to comment on a paper that, like so much of Professor Weiler’s work, is brilliant not only in its intellectual scope but also in the underlying humanity of its vision. His basic thesis is indisputable. International law is indeed an exercise in governance that increasingly generates problems of legitimacy, especially because it governs without the ontological premises of democracy – it has no government and no demos. In the face of this problem, Weiler urges us to seek ‘alternative legitimating devices’. I would like to offer a modest comment on this thesis by making three …

On The Effectiveness Of The Restrictions Governing Life In A Common Interest Community: A Comparative Study Between American And Japanese Law, Wei Zhang

Research Collection Yong Pung How School Of Law

In this article, I made a comparative study on the laws regulating the restrictions established by developers or among property owners in common interest communities in the U.S. and Japan, as well as the cultural and social backgrounds against which they are created. It appears that similar rules exist in both countries to combat excessive restrictions on life in common interest communities, although the American law treats the ex ante restrictions somewhat differently from the ex post ones. Using a law and economics perspective, I argue that such disparate treatments make good sense given the feasibility of internalizing the effects …