Environmental Law Commons^™

Rethinking Law To Reach A Collective Consensus-Based Approach - The Case For Prinicples In The African Union, Willem Daniel Lubbe

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

The global environment (including humans) faces critical threats brought on by, among others, rapid decline of biodiversity and climate change. These threats are not just the concerns of nation-states but indeed the common concerns of the global world.

Environmental protection manifests at three different levels. These are international (or global), regional (including sub-regional) and national. It may be argued that these levels should inform each other culminating in harmonized national legal systems effecting the ideals contained at supra-national levels. Unfortunately, this is not the case in the African Union. Various aspects unique to the region hamper the efforts to reach …

Strengthening Regional Ocean Governance To Protect The Marine Environment: A Case Study Of The Yellow Sea Large Marine Ecosystem Project, Yu Ming

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

The UNDP/GEF Yellow Sea Large Marine Ecosystem (YSLME) project, with two participating countries of the People’s Republic of China and the Republic of Korea, is a very successful attempt to strengthen regional ocean governance to protect the marine environment in the Yellow Sea region. The project’s structure of regional ocean governance is characterized by an ecosystem-based approach, an effective and efficient institutional framework, and wide participation of stakeholders. This structure promised a fruitful result after more than five years of implementation. It developed a practical Strategic Action Programme (SAP) with tangible targets and appropriate management actions, made considerable progress in …

The Unep Regional Seas Programme: Bridging The Governance Gap, Nilufer Oral

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

One of the important outcomes of the historic 1972 United Nations Conference on the Human Environment (UNCHE) forty years ago was the establishment of the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) and the UNEP Regional Seas Programme. Today the UNEP Regional Seas Programmes, with eighteen regional seas programmes under its auspices, has created an institutional and governance framework for the protection and preservation of the marine environment based on state co-operation at the regional level. Ideally, under the centralized and coordinated administration of UNEP each regional sea programme should have a standardized regional framework of governance based on the best available …

The Contribution Of Local Conventions To The Effectiveness Of Environmental Law In Burkina Faso, Habib Ahmed Djiga

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

Burkina Faso, a small country in West Africa, is hard struck by desertification, drought, rainfall irregular, land degradation, competitions related to access and management of natural resources. These environmental challenges have provoked food insecurity and increasing poverty. These difficulties exacerbate the harsh living conditions of communities, accentuate their vulnerability to climate change and increase conflicts over natural resource use.

Facing to this context, the Burkinabe State authorities have taken action to protect the environment that led to the development of environmental law. They have indeed adopted rule of laws, established strategies, programs and action plans, and ratified international treaties related …

Gender And The Rio Conventions: Is The Road Getting Less Bumpy?, Nicky Broeckhoven

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

Desertification, biodiversity loss and climate change pose unrivalled global problems affecting everyone on the planet. However, the impacts thereof are not gender-neutral. Different needs and concerns of men and women and existing gender inequalities mean that women are more likely to lose out than men in the face of these global problems. Over the last two decades, this gender dimension has steadily been recognized in several international legal and policy documents (E.g. Agenda 21, Rio declaration, Beijing Platform for Action). The need to address gender issues with regard to desertification and biodiversity loss has been recognized since the UN Conference …

What's The Fracking Problem?, Joel S. Sonnenberg

In the Balance

No abstract provided.

Federal Constraints: Possible Constitutional Hurdles To Cross-Border Cap-And-Trade,, Shelley Welton

Faculty Publications

No abstract provided.

Summer 2012 Utton Center Newsletter, Utton Center, University Of New Mexico - School Of Law

Publications

No abstract provided.

Evaluating Citizen Petition Procedures: Lessons From An Analysis Of The Nafta Environmental Commission, David L. Markell, John H. Knox

Scholarly Publications

The NAFTA Environmental Commission’s citizen petition process is an important experiment in “new governance” because of its emphasis on citizen participation, accountability, and transparency as strategies to enhance government legitimacy and improve government performance. Its focus on promoting compliance and enforcement adds to its importance for those interested in those central aspects of the regulatory process. The procedure has had a rocky start in many respects, although there are signs that in some cases it has had a positive impact.

This Article sets forth what we perceive to be the promise of the process, the pitfalls that have undermined its …

Anaerobic Digestion Technology: How Agricultural Producers And The Environment Might Profit From Nuisance Lawsuits, Catherine M. H. Keske

Natural Resources Journal

No abstract provided.

The Human Right To Water: Will Its Fulfillment Contribute To Environmental Degradation?, Alezah Trigueros

Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies

Human rights and environmental protection are two often overlapping bodies of law, each of which by their nature seeks to take priority over other applicable law. For this reason, these two bodies of law often find themselves in tension with one another. This Note aims to illustrate the tension between human rights and environmental protection in the context of the recent push for a codified human right to water. My thesis is that ideally these two bodies of law should balance each other out-a human right to water would be subject to environmental safeguards, and, likewise, conservation efforts would be …

Playing Without Aces: Offset And The Limits Of Flexibility Under Clean Air Act Climate Policy, Nathan D. Richardson

Faculty Publications

The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) continues to move ahead with regulation of greenhouse gas emissions under the Clean Air Act (CAA). Previous work has indicated that basic forms of compliance flexibility—trading—appear to be legally permissible under section III of the CAA. This Article takes a close look at more expansive and ambitious types of flexibility: trading between different kinds of sources, biomass co-firing, and above all, offsets. It concludes that most types of such extended flexibility are either legally incompatible with the CAA, or so legally problematic that EPA is unlikely to adopt them. This has important implications …

Legal Lock-Picking: An Analysis Of Anti-Circumvention Law In The United States And Brazil, Skyler Sourifman

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note examines the contrasting approaches of the U.S. and Brazil in their anticircumvention laws under copyright regimes. It highlights how the U.S. DMCA strictly prohibits circumvention, while Brazil's proposal allows exceptions for fair use, interoperability, and public domain access. The analysis critiques the DMCA for its broad provisions that have led to inconsistent court rulings, such as in RealNetworks v. Streambox and Universal City Studios v. Corley, which have stifled competition and free expression. Conversely, Brazil's approach aligns with the Access to Knowledge movement, emphasizing a balanced copyright system. The note suggests that recent U.S. exemptions, like those …

Curb Your E-Waste: Why The United States Should Control Its Electronic Waste Exports, Louisa Olds

Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law

The note addresses the urgent issue of electronic waste (e-waste) management, emphasizing the need for comprehensive national legislation in the United States to regulate e-waste exports, collection, and recycling. Drawing lessons from the European Union's WEEE and RoHS Directives, the analysis advocates for uniform standards, producer responsibility, and strict enforcement to prevent illegal exports and ensure environmentally sound practices. The proposed framework aims to reduce the environmental and health impacts of improper recycling, particularly in developing countries, while promoting sustainable practices and resource conservation.

Environmental Damages After The Federal Environmental Enforcement Act: Bringing Ecosystem Services To Canadian Environmental Law?, Martin Z. P. Olsynski

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

The Canadian Environmental Enforcement Act [EEA] directs judges to consider actual environmental damage, or risk thereof, when setting fines for environmental offences. The EEA defi nes damage as including the loss of use and non-use values. While these terms are not unprecedented in Canadian environmental law, their use in environmental damage assessment is. Bearing in mind recent developments in environmental valuation in the United States and internationally, and considering the emergence of the “ecosystem services” paradigm in particular, this article explores the opportunities and challenges for ecosystem services based environmental damages assessment in the Canadian environmental sentencing context. The ecosystem …

Alternative Policies To Increase Recycling Of Plastic Water Bottles In The United States, W. Kip Viscusi, Joel Huber, Jason Bell

Vanderbilt Law School Faculty Publications

Using an original, nationally representative sample of plastic water bottle users, this article examines the efficacy of various policy mechanisms to increase recycling. We evaluate the impact of bottle deposits and the stringency of a state’s recycling laws on the provision of recycling opportunities and on recycling rates. Using household-level data and controlling for the type of recycling legal regime as well as the bottle deposit policies in each state, we find that mandated separation of recyclables, the availability of a recycling center in the community, and the provision of curbside pickup at houses or recycling locations at apartments increase …

American Bar Association Section Of Environment, Energy, And Resources Symposium: Selected Addresses [Comments], Eileen Gauna

Faculty Scholarship

Opening remarks for Environmental Justice conference that reviews the growth and efforts made for environmental justice.

Environmental Protection Versus Energy Supply Security - The Shale Gas Case And Its Impact On Ecosystem Services, Leonie Reins

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

The complexity, interrelation and competition between environmental protection and energy supply security is an emerging problem. Often, State environmental protection concerns and standards are outweighed by a competing interest, such as ensuring energy supply security. This paper discusses the benefits and risks of an ecosystem service approach in connection with shale gas extraction in the United States and the European Union. The shale gas example demonstrates that even in advanced jurisdictions with high standards of environmental protection, ecosystem services are compromised for energy generation purposes. In addition, it explains the impacts of shale gas extraction on the individual elements of …

Ecosystem Services And Sustainable Development: Creating An Integrated Governance Approach: Critical Reflections On The New European Strategy On Biodiversity, Nathalie Herve-Fournereau

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

“Biodiversity is also our natural capital, delivering ecosystem services that underpin our economy.” According to the European Strategy on Biodiversity, EU commits to halt the loss of biodiversity and the degradation of ecosystem service by 2020 in the light of the transition towards a resource efficient and green and sustainable economy. As defined in Directive 2004/35/EC on environmental liability, the concept of ecosystem service (« functions provided by a natural resource for another natural resource or for the public») enjoys a broad conception that differs from the definition used by the Millenium ecosystem assessment report (« the benefits that …

The Emerging Institutional Risks From Widespread Adoption Of An Ecosystem Services Market Approach To Environmental Governance, Paul Martin, Jacqueline Williams, Amanda Kennedy

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

Best practice commercial management involves two distinct mindsets, harnessed for separate purposes. The innovative mindset is concerned with the creative side of enterprise – entrepreneurship, innovation, strategising and commercialisation). However this is also married to a more pessimistic mindset focused on the identification and avoidance of what might go wrong- (risk management).

The modernist paradigm for environmental governance stresses scientific model-based estimation to determine resource use-limits, legally specified property rights to fractions of the environment, market or market like mechanisms for allocation of interests, and scientific methods of performance of the strategies. These elements exist in varying forms regardless of …

Law, Ecosystem Valuation And Risk Allocation, David Hodas

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

Assigning a precise economic value to a non-market ecosystem service or environmental externality that damages an ecosystem or human health and welfare is challenging. However, if we tie fairness and equity to getting the “prices” exactly right, the best will become the enemy of the good and we will sacrifice ecosystem services on the alter of excessive exactness. In terms of equity and ecosystem services, the precision of any particular monetized value is less important than that there be a value, and that the value is incorporated into legal and policy decisions. Existing legal models and institutional frameworks were not …

Forests, Protected Areas And The Payment For Ecosystem Services: Reserva Do Juma (State Of Amazonas- Brazil), Solange Teles Da Silva, Danielle De Ouro Mamed

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

In the State of Amazonas, the Climate Change, Environmental Conservation and Sustainable Development Policy Act adopted by State Law n. º 3.135/2007 has created a Program called “Bolsa Floresta”. In a pioneering way, this program was established with the aim of starting the payment for environmental services and products to traditional communities for the sustainable use of natural resources, conservation, environmental protection and encouragement of voluntary policies to reduce deforestation. This Program of “compensation” - “Bolsa Floresta” - is divided into four types: a) “Bolsa Floresta” Family b) “Bolsa Floresta” Association c) “Bolsa Floresta” Social and, d) “Bolsa Floresta” Income. …

Payment For Ecosystems Services: A Pathway For Environmental Conservation In Uganda, Emmanuel Kasimbazi

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

Ecosystem services are components of nature, directly enjoyed, consumed, or used to yield human well-being. They occur wherever plants, animals and people have interdependent relationships within the context of their physical environment. Payment for ecosystem services (PES) is a developing system which refers to payment for economic value of ecosystems. It is a scheme designed to provide incentives to individual landowners and local communities to conserve the environment. PES schemes seek to formulate a certain value to environmental services and establish appropriate pricing, institutional and redistribution systems that will lead to sustainable and socially optimal land use practices. These schemes …

The Relationship Of Ecosystem Services Valuation, Protection And Distribution With The Polluter-Pays Principle And The Provider-Gets Principle, Blaise-Pascal Ntirumenyerwa Mihigo, An Cliquet

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

This paper discusses the environmental, economic and social aspects of ecosystem services (ES) and their interactions with the polluter-pays principle and the provider-gets principle. The paper ends with observations concerning the theoretical and practical relationship of those principles with ES and Payment for Ecosystem Services (PES) programs.

ES have attracted increasing interest through PES as a mechanism which translates external, non-market values of the environment into real financial incentives for local actors to provide ES. The PES approach has inspired new incentives, innovative financing for ecosystem protection. The PES seeks to internalize what would otherwise be an externality. Here, we …

The Connection Between Natural Capital Productivity And Intergenerational Equity: Focus On Ecosystem Services, Laurel Pentelow

Global Environmental Law at a Crossroads

This paper will discuss measurement options and new policies that can contribute to the incorporation of ecosystem service values into economic measures, in particular productivity. Further, this work will highlight the linkage between such outcomes and the principle of intergenerational equity. A discussion of the challenges and ethical considerations which arise when dealing with valuing ecosystem services will also be included.

Despite an increasing trend towards considering and valuing ecosystem services in environmental policy decisions, there has been less movement towards including ecosystem service values within national measures of economic progress. Most discussion to date has focused on the inclusion …

What Hath Lynn White Wrought?, John Copeland Nagle

Journal Articles

Lynn White’s 1967 article on “The Historical Roots of Our Ecologic Crisis” famously blamed Christianity for modern environmental problems. White’s historical analysis viewed Christianity for cultivating a dismissive view toward nature and for embracing technology in a way that resulted in unchecked pollution and extinctions. Since White wrote his article, Christian scholars have accepted the challenge that White’s diagnosis presented. Other nations, perhaps most notably China, have experienced crippling environmental destruction even in the absence of a legacy of Christian thought. More positively, White’s thesis has encouraged a generation of scholars to explore the positive aspects of Christian thought for …

Agenda: A Low-Carbon Energy Blueprint For The American West, University Of Colorado Boulder. Natural Resources Law Center, University Of Colorado Boulder. Renewable And Sustainable Energy Institute, Western Resource Advocates, Rocky Mountain Research Station (Fort Collins, Colo.)

A Low-Carbon Energy Blueprint for the American West (Martz Summer Conference, June 6-8)

The future of the planet may depend upon our ability to increase energy supplies even as we reduce carbon emissions. This conference will address how a low-carbon energy program might evolve with a particular focus on the American West. It will focus on the future of energy in the West--on a “managed transition” to a different energy mix, on the need to nest this effort in a framework that acknowledges interconnections, and on identifying the most salient opportunities to consider the legal, political, financial, and technical challenges.

The Continuing Burden Of Short-Sighted Nuclear Waste Policy. Dominion Res., Inc. V. United States, Mark D. Godfrey

Journal of Environmental and Sustainability Law

No abstract provided.

A Case For Cooperation Between The Environmental Protection Agency And The United States Department Of Agriculture In Order To Achieve Federal Environmental Quality Goals. National Pork Producers' Council V. Epa, James D. Boresi

Journal of Environmental and Sustainability Law

No abstract provided.

Defogging The Future: The Effect Of American Electric Power On Future Lawsuits. American Electric Power Co. Inc. V. Connecticut, Marriam Lin

Journal of Environmental and Sustainability Law

No abstract provided.