Dispute Resolution and Arbitration Commons^™

International Advocate For Peace Award Acceptance Speech, James Paul Mccartney

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

On May 28, 2019, the Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution presented the Nineteenth Annual International Advocate for Peace Award to Sir James Paul McCartney at Cardozo Law School's forty-first Commencement Ceremony. What follows is a transcription of the award ceremony, including Sir McCartney's acceptance speech.

The Singapore Convention And The Metamorphosis Of Contractual Litigation, Jean-Christophe Boulet

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This article addresses the grounds provided for in Article 5 of the Singapore Convention for the refusal of enforcement of a settlement agreement or for the refusal of a settlement agreement as evidence that the dispute has been resolved. It is divided into three sections. The first section briefly places these grounds in the context of the Singapore Convention as a whole as well as the 1958 New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. The second section is devoted to a more detailed examination of the various grounds listed in Article 5 of the Convention, …

Author Biographies

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

Attorney-Client Privilege & International Arbitration, Ibrahim Shehata

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This article attempts to offer a new perspective to the existing debate concerning the applicable standard of attorney-client privilege in international commercial and investment arbitration. This article starts by analyzing the main convergences and divergences in the concept of attorney-client privilege across four national jurisdictions. In this regard, this article sheds light upon the divergence of opinions between international arbitration scholars in the literature and how international arbitration operates in practice. For instance, the standard of the "most-protective law," which most arbitration scholars vouch should be the right answer, is not actually the most featured standard in the published arbitral …

Singapore Symposium Program

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This program outlines the proceedings of The Singapore Mediation Convention: Compliance with Cross-Border Mediated Settlement Agreements symposium, held on March 18, 2019, at the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law in collaboration with Touro College. Hosted by the Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution, the symposium brought together legal scholars, practitioners, and international delegates to discuss the significance, development, and practical implications of the Singapore Mediation Convention. Panels explored the Convention’s legal framework, empirical data on its necessity, enforceability mechanisms, and its interactions with other international instruments, providing a comprehensive analysis of its potential to transform international dispute resolution through mediation.

Evaluating The Singapore Convention Through A U.S.-Centric Litigation Lens: Lessons Learned From Nearly Two Decades Of Mediation Disputes In American Federal And State Courts, James R. Coben

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This chapter assesses the likely efficaciousness of the Singapore Mediation Convention based on nearly two decades experience of systematically tracking and studying mediation litigation in the U.S. federal and state courts.

The Life Of Arbitration Law Has Been Experience, Not Logic: Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, And The Federal Arbitration Act, William F. Fox, Ylli Dautaj

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Over the past 50 years, the international business community has settled on the device of international commercial arbitration to resolve the overwhelming number of disputes that arise in their commercial agreements. One reason is that many business people are suspicious of the domestic courts of many host countries and have always sought the comfort of a neutral forum. Arbitration is neutral (i.e., not tied directly to any particular domestic legal system), efficient and confidential. Much of this evolution has been triggered by events in the United States-in particular a long series of United States Supreme Court decisions that ended the …

Novel Adaptation To Stage And Screen: Rethinking The Contractual And Creative Process, Jennifer Rainville Mccabe

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

The Universal Periodic Review As A Form Of Alternative Dispute Resolution: Strengths & Shortcomings, Sara Alvarez

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

2018 Camp Courthouse Colloquy, United States Court Of Appeals For The Second Circuit: The Art Of Mediating Intractable Disputes, George J. Mitchell

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

In 1974, the Civil Appeals Mediation Program ("CAMP") was established in the Second Circuit of the United States Court of Appeals as a pioneering initiative. CAMP is an integral part of the court's appellate process and provides mediation in suitable, counseled civil appeals that are eligible under Local Rule 33.1. In 2017, CAMP inaugurated the Courthouse Mediation Colloquy series to gather members of the judiciary, members of the bar, mediators, academics, and students in an informal, educational setting. The Colloquy features a distinguished guest engaging in a conversation with a representative of the court about aspects of mediation that are …

Using Restorative Dialogue As An Assimilation Technique For Unaccompanied Children Escaping Gang Violence, Naomi Jawahar

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Note will first give background on the Northern Triangle area and background on the asylum process in Part I. Part II of the Note will discuss the negative government response in Section A. Section B will delve into the influence of gangs, Section C will discuss the relation between juvenile stigmatization and crime, and Section D will discuss the current resettlement process for UACs that is in place. Finally, Section E, of Part II, will discuss how ADR will help with the resettlement process. Part IH will offer a solution, with Section A showing how restorative dialogue specifically can …

The Role Of Transformative Mediation In Family Business Disputes, Jacob Lebovics

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

In Part II, this note will attempt to lay out the benefits and detriments of approaching family business disputes through litigation, alternative dispute resolution, and various methods of mediation, with a goal of explaining how transformative mediation relates to other approaches of resolving conflict. Part IHl will discuss the unique issues that apply to family business conflicts and how concepts from other disciplines of study can be utilized to help best achieve the goals of a family business. Part IV will propose how transformative mediation is well suited to address these conflicts and what form of transformative mediation would reach …

When The Rich Regret: The Case Of Non-Payment In Art Auction Sales, Allison Trupp

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Part I is a brief introduction to this Note. Part II of the Note will examine the history of auction and the shift that has occurred in the market that has led to the non-payment problem that has become rampant. It also looks at the issue abroad and differences in buying culture in countries such as China. This Note will then delve into many of the recent cases that have arisen due to nonpayment problems. Part III will discuss the problem in more detail and look at the status of the art auction processes, what is already in place, and …

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Journal Of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 20, Iss. 3

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

A New Generation Of Peace Missions?: Exploring The Colombian Case, Rut Diamint, Laura Tedesco

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

he UN Security Council approved the establishment of a political mission in Colombia. The UN Verification Mission in Colombia to monitor the reintegration of FARC-EP has two precise objectives: to verify the bilateral cessation of fire and hostilities, and to accompany the process of laying down the FARC-EP’s arms. This article analyzes this UN mission in Colombia to ascertain if it can be considered one of a new generation of peacekeeping missions. The final statement considers if the model of the Colombian mission could be implemented in other conflicts around the world.

Careful Training Does Eliminate Gender-Based Negotiation Differences, Charles B. Craver

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

Judicial Conflict Resolution In Plea Bargaining As The Golden Mean Between The Adversarial And Inquisitorial Legal Systems, Golan Luzon

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This article seeks to develop a better understanding of plea bargaining as a mechanism of judicial conflict resolution in criminal law. Plea bargaining plays a significant role in both the adversarial and inquisitorial legal systems. The article examines how the plea-bargaining model is designed in both legal systems by comparing two civil law countries (Italy and Germany) with two common law countries (England and Wales and the U.S.). I argue that two developments-a mechanism similar to plea bargaining in inquisitorial systems and judges' participation in the criminal plea bargaining negotiations in adversarial legal systems-are part of the same phenomenon seeking …

Remodifying Colombian Peace Process: A Critical Perspective And A Demand For Justice, Armando Martinez

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

Part II of this Note will give a background of the FARC, the FARC's impact throughout Colombia., and the Role of the ICC in the Colombian Peace Process. Part III of this Note will discuss the legal status of the peace deal between the FARC and the Colombian Government, as well as whether the ICC should intervene in the peace deal's implementation process. Lastly, Part IV discusses that the future Colombian presidential administration should consider modifying the current peace deal using interest-based facilitative mediation

Mediation As An Alternative To Litigation For Child Custody Disputes For Incarcerated Parents, Maria Abbruzzese

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Note will discuss the background of family law and mediation in America, including the "best interests of the child," how its vague application limits incarcerated parents' rights, and how litigation can lead to an arrangement that is not in the child's best interests. This Note will introduce the Family Dispute Resolution Act, which is legislation enacted in New Zealand that designed a framework for mediation for incarcerated parents. This Note will introduce the problems that incarcerated parents and children of incarcerated parents face in the United States and New Zealand. In the Discussion section, this Note will discuss why …

Arbitration As The Ideal Method Of Labor Law Dispute Resolution: A Case Study Using 14 Penn Plaza Llc, Et Al. V. Steven Pyett, Et Al., Douglas Shribman

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

Sponsors

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

We sincerely thank all the sponsors for their generous support.

The primary financial sponsors were the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law and Touro College Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center.

Other valuable financial sponsors were the International Academy of Mediators (IAM), the Federal Bar Association Federal Litigation Section, and the Federal Bar Association Alternative Dispute Resolution Section.

The Singapore Convention Is Live, And Multilateralism, Alive!, Natalie Y. Morris-Sharma

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.

The United Nations Commission On International Trade Law (Uncitral) And The Significance Of The Singapore Convention On Mediation, Corinne Montineri

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This paper outlines how the UNCITRAL drafting process that produced the Singapore Convention on Mediation functions within the United Nations and explains the significance of the Singapore Convention for the United Nations and for promoting cross-border trade and investment.

The Role Of Empirical Research And Dispute System Design In Proposing And Developing International Treaties: A Case Study Of The Singapore Convention On Mediation, S. I. Strong

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This Article seeks to provide insights into the "black box" of early treaty-making processes by undertaking a case study of the development of the United Nations Convention on International Settlement Agreements Resulting from Mediation, known colloquially as the Singapore Convention on Mediation (Singapore Convention). The discussion focuses on several issues that have seldom been addressed in the legal literature, including the way in which a proposal for an international treaty makes its way to the relevant decision-makers and how those decision-makers determine which of the various alternatives to pursue. The analysis also considers how interested individuals can assist the treaty-proposing …

Report On Empirical Study Of Business Users Regarding International Mediation And Enforcement Mechanisms, David S. Weiss, Michael R. Griffith

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This report will proceed as follows. Part II describes the methodology of the IMI and NJCU IDR study in conjunction with analyzing the GPC Survey. Part III provides basic information of the demographics of the users, their sectors of business, and other pertinent data that can be useful for further academic scholarly review. Part IV analyzes the user's response to the surveys. Part V will analyze pertinent questions from the GPC Survey. Finally, Part VI provides concluding thoughts on the results of this report.

The responses to the survey questions will be provided if requested with personal identifying information removed …

What's In A Name? The Terms "Commercial" And "Mediation" In The Singapore Convention On Mediation, Ellen E. Deason

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

One could interpret Shakespeare's famous quote as standing for the proposition that labels do not alter the essence of the thing named. In this article I draw inspiration from the quote to provide a foil for examining the use of the terms "commercial" and "mediation" in the Singapore Convention and Mediation Model Law. I will consider how the terms are framed and defined, the extent to which the names and their associated meanings introduce new ideas, and how their use might matter for the interpretation of important concepts in these instruments. Part I of the article discusses the term "commercial" …

The Singapore Convention: When Has A Mediation Taken Place (Article 4)?, Allan J. Stitt

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

As delegates to UNCITRAL Working Group II, our task was to come up with a Convention that would facilitate enforcement of mediated settlements by assisting the parties who are seeking enforcement while making it harder for those who try to renege on their commitments. This is an important lens through which to view and understand the Convention drafted by the Working Group.

Singapore Convention Defences Based On Mediator's Misconduct: Articles 5.1(E) & (F), Michel Kallipetis

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

At the February 2019 ICC Mediation Competition in Paris, Damien Cote from Canada and David Lewis from New York moderated a "debate" on the Singapore Convention. One of the panellists launched into a full-scale attack on the Convention, in which he dismissed it on the basis that the "whole document resembled the New York Convention and was redolent of arbitration rather than mediation." The speaker focused on Article 5 and the Grounds for Refusing Relief, and he was particularly critical of Articles 5.1(e) and (f). He expressed his view that these articles were apposite to the setting aside of an …

Grounds To Refuse The Enforcement Of Settlement Agreements Under The Singapore Convention On Mediation: Purpose, Scope, And Their Importance For The Success Of The Convention, Héctor Flores Sentíes

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

This article will attempt to: (i) explain the purpose behind the drafting of the grounds to refuse enforcement; (ii) describe the scope of these defenses, based on the deliberations of the Working Group that drafted the Singapore Convention; and finally, (iii) briefly comment on the relationship between the scope of the defenses and the likelihood of the success of the Singapore Convention.

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Journal Of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 20, Iss. 2

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution

No abstract provided.