Bankruptcy Law Commons^™

The Permissibility Of Chapter 11 Non-Debtor Release Provisions, Ashraf Mokbel

Bankruptcy Research Library

(Excerpt)

Generally speaking, bankruptcy proceedings do not impact non-debtor third parties liabilities. However, bankruptcy courts are courts of equity. This raises the issue of what provisions may be included in a confirmable plan. Specifically, there is the issue of whether a bankruptcy court can confirm a plan if it contains a non-debtor release provision which impacts non-debtor third party liabilities.

A non-debtor release provision shields third parties who share an identity of interest with the debtor, usually corporate officers and directors in a Chapter 11 proceeding, from any claim, obligation, cause of action, or liability to any party in interest …

Fraud And Defalcation By A Fiduciary: The Amorphous Exception To Bankruptcy Discharge, H.C. Jones Iii

University of Baltimore Law Review

No abstract provided.

Student Loans Can Be Discharged (At Least Partially) In Bankruptcy After All, Carmella Gubbiotti

Bankruptcy Research Library

(Excerpt)

Section 523 of the Bankruptcy Code sets forth debts that are not dischargeable. Among the non-dischargeable debts, which a debtor will still owe after they receive a bankruptcy discharge, are debts from educational loans. As such, these student loan debts may prevent many debtors from receiving a truly fresh start following bankruptcy. Courts historically have approached the undue hardship exception to this rule narrowly, applying it only where the debtor, under the circumstances, could not reap the benefit of her education.

This Article will discuss the various tests courts use to determine whether an educational debt is dischargeable. Part …

Survey 2014: Bankruptcy + Student Loan Debt Crisis, Brenda Beauchamp, Jason R. Cooper

Touro Law Review

No abstract provided.

Fairness Over Deference: The Shifting Landscape Of Creditors Rights To Claims And Debtor Protection Regarding The Issuance Of Form 1099-C, Patrick Christensen

Bankruptcy Research Library

(Excerpt)

Issues surrounding the discharge of indebtedness with regard to Form 1099-C filings have recently become a difficult issue for bankruptcy courts. When a debtor cannot afford to pay a creditor an outstanding debt, a Form 1099-C is utilized to “discharge the debt.” The resulting cancellation is then reportable for tax purposes for both the debtor (as cancellation-of-debt income – “COD income”) and the creditor (as a deduction). Form 1099-C filings are made by creditors and issued to each “debtor for whom . . . $600 or more of a debt owed” had been cancelled.

Courts have had to consider …

Discharging Non-Filing Co-Debtor Debt Under Chapter 13, Carly Krupnick

Bankruptcy Research Library

(Excerpt)

During chapter 13 proceedings, both the debtor and the non-filing co-debtor are protected from their creditors by a stay. Once a bankruptcy petition is filed, section 362(a) of the Bankruptcy Code creates an “automatic stay” that operates by halting almost all actions by creditors against the debtor and his property to collect a prepetition debt. In a chapter 13 bankruptcy case, section 1301(a) provides that the filing of the petition also automatically creates a co-debtor stay that generally prevents a creditor from taking any “act[ion], or commenc[ing] or continu[ing] any civil action, to collect all or any part of …

Undo Undue Hardship: An Objective Approach To Discharging Federal Students Loans In Bankruptcy, Aaron N. Taylor

All Faculty Scholarship

A debtor seeking to discharge student loans in bankruptcy must prove that paying the debt would cause an undue hardship upon him and his dependents. Undue hardship, however, is an undefined concept, flummoxing debtors, creditors and judges alike. The result of this ambiguity is rampant inconsistency in the manners in which similarly-situated debtors (and creditors) are treated by the courts. This article argues that the undue hardship standard should be replaced by a framework that uses debt service thresholds to determine the propriety of federal student loan bankruptcy discharges. Eligibility for discharge would depend on outstanding loan amounts, debtor income …

Intentional Conduct May Be Required To Prove Defalcation Under Section 523(A)(4) In Certain Circuits, Elizabeth Vanderlinde

Bankruptcy Research Library

(Excerpt)

In the average bankruptcy case, individual debtors seek to discharge some, all, or most of their debts. The Bankruptcy Code (the “Code”) sets certain limits on the dischargeability of obligations. For example, section 523 of the Code provides circumstances in which certain debts are not dischargeable. Specifically, section 523(a)(4) provides that an individual debtor will not be discharged from any debt “for fraud or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity.” In the bankruptcy context, defalcation means “the failure to meet an obligation.” However, the Code is silent as to the level of culpability required to prove defalcation. The …

Discharge Under The Code For Erisa "Fiduciaries", Devin Sullivan

Bankruptcy Research Library

(Excerpt)

The Bankruptcy Code (“Code”) provides debtors with relief from many of their outstanding debts. However, even under the broad protection of the Code, some debts cannot be erased. Pursuant to section 523(a)(4) of the Code, an individual debtor may not discharge any debt for fraud or defalcation (unauthorized appropriation of money) while acting in a fiduciary capacity. 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(4). The federal courts are currently split on the issue of whether a debtor who qualifies as a “fiduciary” under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, 29 U.S.C. § 1132 et seq, (“ERISA”) will also qualify as …

Illness And Inability To Repay: The Role Of Debtor Health In The Discharge Of Educational Debt, Rafael I. Pardo

Scholarship@WashULaw

For a debtor to obtain a discharge of student loans in bankruptcy, the debtor must establish that their repayment would impose an undue hardship. This Article presents the results of an empirical study of bankruptcy court doctrine over a ten-year period that involved undue hardship discharge proceedings where the court reported information on the debtor's health status, monthly household income, and monthly household expenses. The data show that a medical condition increased a debtor's odds of being granted a discharge by 140% but that household income and expense levels did not have a statistically significant association with legal outcome. These …

Hiding In Plain View: A Neglected Supreme Court Decision Resolves The Debate Over Non-Debtor Releases In Chapter 11 Reorganizations, Joshua M. Silverstein

Law Faculty Scholarship

This article presents a novel resolution of a long-standing circuit split on an issue of critical significance to bankruptcy and tort law: whether bankruptcy courts may extinguish liabilities of parties that have not filed for bankruptcy. Such "non-debtor releases" are similar in effect to a bankruptcy discharge and have become particularly common in both mass tort disputes and general insolvencies adjudicated through the bankruptcy process. In this article, I illustrate how an overlooked Supreme Court decision—United States v. Energy Resources, 495 U.S. 545 (1990)—offers crucial support for the pro-release position. Energy Resources demonstrates that the bankruptcy courts’ "general equitable power" …

Undue Hardship In The Bankruptcy Courts: An Empirical Assessment Of The Discharge Of Educational Debt, Rafael I. Pardo, Michelle R. Lacey

Scholarship@WashULaw

The discharge in bankruptcy embodies the policy that relief should be granted to an individual who has ceased to be economically productive by virtue of burdensome debt obligations (the fresh start policy). Once the debtor has been deemed eligible for discharge, forgiveness of debt is automatic, accomplished through legislative rule and its judicial enforcement. With regard to the discharge of educational debt, however, Congress has devolved the exercise of debt relief to courts. An obligation to repay such debt will be discharged if a debtor establishes that undue hardship would be suffered in the absence of its discharge. A court …

At The Intersection Of Bankruptcy And Divorce: Property Division Debts Under The Bankruptcy Reform Act Of 1994, Meredith J. Harbach

Law Faculty Publications

Bankruptcy has long had unique implications for divorce settlements and debts between ex-spouses. Historically, some marital debts owed from one ex-spouse to another were excepted from the traditional policy of "discharge. " Bankruptcy law distinguished between debts in the nature of alimony, maintenance, and support, which were protected from discharge, and property division debts, which were not. This distinction often had harsh consequences for creditor ex-spouses. Reeently, Congress enacted the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1994, in part to ameliorate this problem. The amended Bankruptcy Code providP..s better protection for some property division debts. In this Note, Ms. Johnson argues that …

Conversion Of Nonexempt Property To Exempt Property On The Eve Of Bankruptcy In Arkansas, J. Thomas Hardin

University of Arkansas at Little Rock Law Review

No abstract provided.

Title Iii Of The Bankruptcy Amendments Act Of 1984: The Substantive Changes, Lucinda Mcdaniel

University of Arkansas at Little Rock Law Review

No abstract provided.

The Dischargeability Of Debts In Bankruptcy, Paul J. Hartman

Vanderbilt Law Review

From the viewpoint of the bankrupt debtor, a discharge from his obligations is, no doubt, the most important facet of bankruptcy proceedings. The bankruptcy discharge is designed to relieve the honest debtor from his financial entanglements, and to give him an opportunity to reinstate himself in the business world. A debtor is now entitled to a discharge as a matter of right, unless he has been guilty of certain specified offenses against the Bankruptcy Act. For many generations the idea of a discharge from one's debts has been the relieving feature of bankruptcy. However, it has not always been so. …

Determination Of The Effect Of A Discharge In Bankruptcy, T. A. Smedley

Vanderbilt Law Review

This article examines the operation of the system under which the granting of the discharge is the function of the bankruptcy court but the construction of the effect of the discharge falls within the power of any court in which a creditor happens to bring suit to enforce an obligation of the bankrupt. The customary practice of leaving to the lower state courts the task of determining the dischargeability of specific debts is evaluated, and the bases for having this determination made in the bankruptcy court instead are explored.

Bankruptcy - Tenancy By The Entireties - Creditors's Right Against Entry Property After Discharge Of Husband In Bankruptcy, E. Roger Frisch

Michigan Law Review

The United States as assignee sought a joint judgment on four unsecured promissory notes signed by the defendants, who are husband and wife. The husband had filed in bankruptcy before the assignment of the notes to plaintiff and was discharged from all debts filed in the bankruptcy proceeding schedules (including the instant debt) prior to any action on these notes. His estate by the entireties, however, was not used to satisfy any listed debts. Held, plaintiff is entitled to proceed to judgment. A discharge in bankruptcy limits only the sources available for satisfaction. United States v. Fetter and Fetter …

Bankruptcy -Test Of Insolvency - Fair Valuation Of Debtor's Assets, William F. Hood

Michigan Law Review

An objecting creditor seeking to preserve his judgment lien appealed from an order adjudicating B a bankrupt. The alleged act of bankruptcy was that B, while insolvent, permitted the objecting creditor to obtain a lien on his property by judicial proceedings and failed to discharge it within thirty days. B's principal asset was his interest in a spendthrift trust fund, valued at more than a million dollars, set up in favor of B and his brother. Under the terms of the trust each beneficiary was to receive one-half the approximately $44,000 a year income until he reached the …