Law Commons^™

Richmond Law Magazine: Autumn 2024

Richmond Law Magazine

Conviction is not the end

Law's newest laboratory

Take good care

The Framework Is The Message: Legal And Ethical Implications Of Chatgpt, Amanda Turnbull

Canadian Journal of Law and Technology

The rapid rise of generative AI represents a palpable paradigm shift: models like GPT-3 (and its subsequent iterations), DALL-E, and AlphaCode are becoming foundation models for many other AI-based applications. Foundation models may be used for many different tasks with minimal modification and are positioned to replace task-specific models of AI. This holds tremendous promise in society such as advancing scientific research, rethinking education and training, and creating new types of art and expression. At the same time, however, generative AI has its dark side such as accuracy risk, the threat of large-scale unemployment, potential security vulnerabilities, and AI misbehaviour …

Towards Green Crypto Mining: Regulating Sustainability In Canada And Iceland — A Dual Approach With Lessons From Bitcoin And Copper Industries, Gulnoza Abdurakhmonova

Canadian Journal of Law and Technology

Cryptocurrency mining has emerged as a significant sector within the digital economy, characterised by its substantial energy consumption and its impact on environmental sustainability. The article undertakes a comparative analysis of the regulatory frameworks governing cryptocurrency mining in Canada and Iceland, with a particular emphasis on addressing energy consumption and environmental concerns. The article aims to provide valuable insights into crafting effective regulatory strategies that balance the growth of the crypto mining industry with sustainable energy practices. It will highlight the growing importance of regulating this industry to address these challenges effectively.

L’extraction de crypto-monnaie est devenue un secteur important …

The Privacy Fallacy: Harm And Power In The Information Economy By Ignacio Cofone, Christopher D'Souza

Canadian Journal of Law and Technology

‘‘Our privacy is besieged by tech companies,”1 laments Ignacio Cofone, Law Professor and privacy aficionado, in The Privacy Fallacy: Harm and Power in the Information Economy. In an enlightening yet harrowing discourse, Cofone draws on insights from behavioural science, sociology, and economics2 to argue that the widespread consent-based model of privacy is not only outdated, but untenable given modern data practices.3 Further, Cofone acknowledges the increasing use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in data processing, leading to novel challenges for the safeguarding of personal information.4 Thus, The Privacy Fallacy is more than just about privacy law’s shortcomings; it also raises questions …

R. V. Bykovets: An Affirmation Of Canadians’ Right To Informational Privacy, Bertina Lou

Canadian Journal of Law and Technology

The R. v. Bykovets decision illustrates how new technological realities can reconfigure societal norms and values in ways that demand recognition in the eyes of the law. This case commentary summarizes the Supreme Court’s 2024 Bykovets decision and situates it in jurisprudence on Section 8 of the Canadian Charter in relation to informational privacy. It also demonstrates how the normative approach applied by the SCC in Bykovets, which reflects increased accountability for third parties to safeguard individuals’ privacy, appropriately reconciles divergences in jurisprudence over time.

La décision R c. Bykovets illustre comment les nouvelles réalités technologiques peuvent reconfigurer les …

Learning In Lockdown: Assessing The Impact Of Online Legal Education On The Development Of Professional Competencies And Identity, Adrien Habermacher, Sulaimon Giwa

Dalhousie Law Journal

We administered a survey to law students at three Canadian law schools in the Atlantic region at the end of the Fall 2020 term. The survey asked students to compare their learning of each of the Federation of Law Societies of Canada (FLSC)-mandated competencies, as well as several others taken from the Law Society of New Brunswick (LSNB) competency profile, in the Fall 2020 (online) term versus previous terms of study. The survey also solicited testimonies on students’ socialization into the legal community during their unexpected online law school experience. Our data sheds lights on which competencies, among those deemed …

New Ways Of Teaching Adat (Customary) Law At Indonesian Law Schools, Tody S.J. Utama, Rikardo Simarmata, Jacqueline A.C. Vel, Adriaan W. Bedner

The Indonesian Journal of Socio-Legal Studies

While customary law typically is not the sole legal system regulating people's daily lives, it still plays a big role in shaping the behavior of countless individuals worldwide. For this reason, law schools in many countries teach customary law courses, but these courses often present customary law as a sterile set of principles and norms detached from studying social reality. This approach associates customary law with traditional communities whose members live in relative isolation from the world, ignoring the fact that customary law operates in a legally pluralistic universe, interacting with religious and state law systems, and that it adapts …

التفريد القضائي للعقوبة في القانون الجزائي الاماراتي, Hamad Abdulla Alebri

Theses

/="/">

Judicial Individualization of Punishment in UAE Criminal Law

This study addresses the topic of judicial individualization of punishment in UAE criminal legislation through a descriptive-analytical approach. In the preliminary section, the study defines punishment, which is imposed as a consequence of a crime that has already occurred, and precautionary measures aimed at confronting criminal danger to prevent future harm that could affect society. The characteristics and purposes of both punishment and precautionary measures are detailed, as they cannot be applied unless those implementing them understand their goals and intended outcomes.
/="/">
/="/">The study examines, in the first chapter, …

Tactical Restructurings, Diane Lourdes Dick

Fordham Law Review

The traditional legal account of a corporate debtor’s journey into and through bankruptcy reorganization naturally focuses on legal rights and entitlements, such as obligations arising under the debtor’s existing agreements and rights articulated in the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. But the traditional legal account does little to probe why these prior agreements and transactions were entered into in the first place, and how they interact with the bankruptcy system to generate predictable outcomes. Rather, the traditional legal account applies a presumption that the debtor’s financial characteristics, qualities, and features (what this Article calls “restructuring attributes”) are not premeditated, at least insofar …

Ethical Guardrails To Unbounded Procedure, Seth Katsuya Endo

Fordham Law Review

Civil lawsuits in federal courts—especially class actions and multidistrict litigation (MDL)—can be messy and complicated, calling for pragmatic interventions that lie beyond what is explicitly addressed by the existing rules. And flexibility is part of the genius of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. On the other hand, unbounded discretion and innovation in procedure can lead to illegitimate exercises of power, bias, democratic nonaccountability, and other serious harms. But the choice is not between providing individual courts with nearly limitless authority to experiment with procedure or having a set of rigid rules. Instead, there is a third path: district judges …

The Contemporary Case For Consumer Expectations: Reevaluating The Evolution Of The Original Defect Standard And Its Place In Modern Products Litigation, Alyssa Clune

Fordham Law Review

The consumer expectations standard for design defect has been the subject of fierce debate since its inception. Though many see it as the test that best reflects the plaintiff-friendly goals of products liability, others critique it as vague, outdated, and ripe for jury misuse. Once the primary test for design defect under the Restatement (Second) of Torts, the consumer expectations test has since been rejected by the Restatement (Third) of Torts, and its use has been eliminated or restricted in approximately half of all states in favor of the risk-utility test. Much of the reasoning behind this growing rejection revolves …

Section 1983 And Voting Rights: A Case Study On The Materiality Provision And The Future Of Private Enforcement, Paul Feingold

Fordham Law Review

A recent ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit stating that § 2 of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 is not enforceable by private litigants under an implied private right of action has many voting rights advocates rightfully concerned about the future of federal voting rights protections. Indeed, that ruling appears partly motivated by signals from the U.S. Supreme Court. However, not all hope is lost. In Health and Hospital Corp. of Marion County v. Talevski, the Supreme Court recently reaffirmed its Gonzaga University v. Doe test for enforcing a statute under § 1983. …

Surviving Lender Violence: The Case For Resuscitating Contractual Good Faith In New York, Zachary T. Hanusek

Fordham Law Review

In recent years, lender violence has become the preferred term for a rapidly developing restructuring market centered on the premise that a subset of lenders in a syndicate can increase their own recovery prospects at the expense of the remaining lenders in their group by engaging in a so-called “liability-management transaction.” This term evokes images of rival factions of corporate lenders engaging in physical combat. Although these hyper-technical restructurings certainly fall short of the barbarity the label suggests, the reality is that lenders participating in the so-called violence can siphon hundreds of millions of dollars away from nonparticipating lenders and …

Surviving The Rule Of Reason: An Antitrust Analysis Of Employment Noncompetes, Erin Lee

Fordham Law Review

When the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issued a rule banning noncompete agreements as unfair methods of competition, it reinvigorated debates regarding the purpose of federal antitrust law. At its core, federal antitrust law seeks to preserve a competitive economy and promote new entry into the marketplace, primarily to protect consumer interest. Under President Biden’s administration, the FTC has increased its efforts to expand the scope of antitrust protection beyond consumer welfare by applying it to other public policy concerns, such as employee mobility. The FTC points to noncompete agreements as detrimental constraints to employees’ economic freedoms. In practice, employment noncompetes …

Make America Fake Again?: Banning Deepfakes Of Federal Candidates In Political Advertisements Under The First Amendment, Sophie Loewenstein

Fordham Law Review

In recent years, artificial intelligence (AI) technology has developed rapidly. Accompanying this advancement in sophistication and accessibility are various societal benefits and risks. For example, political campaigns and political action committees have begun to use AI in advertisements to generate deepfakes of opposing candidates to influence voters. Deepfakes of political candidates interfere with voters’ ability to discern falsity from reality and make informed decisions at the ballot box. As a result, these deepfakes pose a threat to the integrity of elections and the existence of democracy. Despite the dangers of deepfakes, regulating false political speech raises significant First Amendment questions. …

(Synthetic) Stump Speech: Crafting Generative Ai Disclosure Regulations For Political Advertisements, Alex Paget

Fordham Law Review

Synthetic media, or content generated using artificial intelligence, has begun to infect political advertising. Federal legislation has spent most of its time stalled in committees, but states and online platforms have rapidly implemented regulations. Although synthetic media may pose harms through voter manipulation and democratic distortion, it also can lower campaign costs and more vividly illustrate conceptions of a political choice’s consequences. Some governments and commentators have sought to prohibit the most harmful forms, while others have focused more on transparent approaches to regulation. In the face of yet another contentious election cycle, the question of how to ensure choices …

Masthead, Volume 46 (2024-2025)

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Table Of Contents - Cardozo Law Review, Volume 46, Issue 1

Cardozo Law Review

No abstract provided.

Privacy Law’S Role In An Information Economy, Sari Mazzurco

Cardozo Law Review

What do we lose when we lose our privacy? A slew of recently enacted state laws suggest that the loss of privacy is merely a loss of individual choice in the market exchange of services for personal information. This Article argues that a loss of privacy risks something greater: the collapse of complex and fluid social identity. Without privacy, individuals cannot nurture their own senses of self because they are no longer free to try on different social roles across diverse relationships. Pervasive, private data collection threatens multifaceted selfhood by eliminating the boundaries that make social roles distinct and hindering …

The Forever Family’S Legal Loophole: A 50-State Survey On Adoption Dissolution, Kira Kilstein

Cardozo Law Review

Adoption is said to be “forever”—longing parents fulfill their dream of parenthood and children get a “forever family.” While the legal system intends for adoptive parent-child relationships to be permanent, a happily-ever-after ending is elusive when adoptions are enabled to fail. In the United States, each state can set its own standard for when courts may grant a request to dissolve an adoption, as well as time limits within which a parent may ask the court to vacate the adoption decree. This legal loophole, known as adoption dissolution, has been met with controversy about the permissibility of parents giving up …

Anyone You Are Related To Can Be Used Against You: Criminal Discovery Statutes And Investigative Genetic Genealogy, Caroline Levine

Cardozo Law Review

The use of investigative genetic genealogy (“IGG”) as a basis for arresting suspects in complex and dormant investigations is raising serious concerns about whether the due process rights of criminal defendants in these cases are being violated. This Note provides a comprehensive look at the role of this groundbreaking, yet little-understood technology in criminal prosecutions. Technological advances have historically necessitated that courts expand and reinterpret legal principles. As a novel derivative of traditional DNA testing, this Note argues IGG should similarly require that discovery statutes be amended or rewritten to adapt to this cutting-edge technique, which is so new that …

A Missed Opportunity: Clarifying Presidential Power Under The Procurement Act, Anthony Porcelli

Cardozo Law Review

In late 2021, President Biden relied on the Procurement Act to sign an Executive Order effectively requiring every employee of any private company that contracts with the federal government to be fully vaccinated for COVID-19. While the mandate was ultimately rescinded less than two years later, it produced four inconsistent federal circuit court opinions that together expose the problems with existing judicial frameworks for analyzing executive authority under the Procurement Act.

This Note explores the growth of the federal procurement industry, the evolution of executive orders under the Procurement Act, and the existing jurisprudence for executive power under the Act. …

Commentary In Support Of The Judgement Of The Provincial Administrative Court (Pac) In Warsaw Of 5 July 2023, File Reference: I Sa/Wa 2767/22 – Use Of The Polish Tourist Voucher In Good Faith And Undue Receipt Of Benefits, Dominik Borek

internetowy Kwartalnik Antymonopolowy i Regulacyjny (internet Quarterly on Antitrust and Regulation)

This article cites the facts described in the judgement of the Provincial Administrative Court (PAC) in Warsaw of 5 July 2023, fi le reference: I SA/Wa 2767/22. The commented ruling is of great importance for the future in the context of emerging ideas for the continuation of the Polish Tourist Voucher programme. The latter was originally launched in the context of the spreading of the COVID-19 epidemic, and was intended to enable children and young people to relax as part of the domestic tourism offer, while at the same time supporting tourism entrepreneurs in the difficult pandemic period. The period …

Fragmentation In Global Climate Governance: What Lessons From Covid-19?, Sivan Shlomo Agnon

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

No abstract provided.

The Scientific Border: Dna Testing For Family Reunification, Alexa Greco

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

No abstract provided.

"Asian" Principles For The Recognition And Enforcement Of Foreign Judgments? Singapore As A Case Study, Adeline Chong

Research Collection Yong Pung How School Of Law

This paper considers if there can be said to be an “Asian” body of principles for the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments. Tapping on the results of a research project which was conducted from 2016 to 2020, it is submitted that the answer to this query is in the negative. However, it is suggested that what marks out the “Asian” approach to private international law is the willingness of Asian countries to look outwards for reform and development and to balance the adoption of international norms against important local norms and objectives. Singapore’s approach to the recognition and enforcement …

Closing The Asylum Gender Gap: Why "Afghan Women" Is A Compelling Particular Social Group, Mackenzie Heinrichs

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

No abstract provided.

The International Copyright System And Development: The Role Of The World Intellectual Property Organization, Faith O. Majekolagbe

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

No abstract provided.

Cross-Border Cyber Operations: Targeting Healthcare As Unlawful Intervention In The Affairs Of States, Priya Urs

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

No abstract provided.

Ultra-Slow Responses To The Ultra-Fast Fashion Problem: Combatting Forced Labor In The Global Apparel Industry With Due Diligence And Customs Regulations, Cameron Watts

Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law

No abstract provided.