Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Law Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Articles 1 - 30 of 62

Full-Text Articles in Law

Mission Revival Jurisprudence: State Courts And Hispanic Water Law Since 1850, Peter L. Reich Oct 1994

Mission Revival Jurisprudence: State Courts And Hispanic Water Law Since 1850, Peter L. Reich

Washington Law Review

In this Article, the author argues that after the United States' annexation of the Southwest, state judges in California, New Mexico, and Texas knowingly distorted the communal nature of applicable Spanish and Mexican water law. While previous scholars have acknowledged that courts misinterpreted municipal and riparian water rights originating in the Southwest's Hispanic period, most historians have attributed the distortion to ignorance rather than design. Using archival sources, the author demonstrates that American judges created an historical fiction of "Spanish" absolute water control, and intentionally disregarded actual law and custom dictating water apportionment. The resulting doctrines of pueblo water rights …


In Re Marriage Of Mcdole: Modifying Child Custody By Ignoring Statutory Grounds, Virginia A. Petersen Oct 1994

In Re Marriage Of Mcdole: Modifying Child Custody By Ignoring Statutory Grounds, Virginia A. Petersen

Washington Law Review

In In re Marriage of McDole, the Washington Supreme Court upheld the modification of a parenting plan that changed the primary residential parent. By relying in part on the mother's interference with visitation, the court not only undermined the important policy underlying the modification statute of maximizing finality in custody determinations, but it also failed to read the modification statute as a whole. The court also inappropriately relied on the mother's move out of the state and continued conflict between the parents. The court further failed to explicitly explain the legal bases for its decision, providing little guidance for future …


Gilding The Iron Rice Bowl: The Illusion Of Shareholder Rights In China, Matthew D. Latimer Oct 1994

Gilding The Iron Rice Bowl: The Illusion Of Shareholder Rights In China, Matthew D. Latimer

Washington Law Review

In the late 1970s, the People's Republic of China (P.R.C.) embarked upon a program of economic reform that has resulted in the issuance of equity securities in previously state-owned enterprises. with the recent advent of national stockmarkets, national securities legislation is emerging to supplement and further define prior local-level regulation. Despite these new laws, however, private investors still lack many of the protections enjoyed by investors in Western financial markets. This Comment examines these disparities and suggests that non-state investors in China's nascent financial markets still lack an effective means of overseeing the policy decisions of State-owned corporations and face …


Causation And Injury In Corporate Control Transactions: Cede & Co. V. Technicolor, Inc., Jacqueline M. Veneziani Oct 1994

Causation And Injury In Corporate Control Transactions: Cede & Co. V. Technicolor, Inc., Jacqueline M. Veneziani

Washington Law Review

In Cede & Co. v. Technicolor, Inc., the Delaware Supreme Court held that shareholders are not required to prove injury from corporate directors' failure to exercise due care in approving a merger transaction. Tort principles, the court stated, have no role in a business judgment rule analysis. Therefore, once shareholders prove a violation of the directors' duty of care, the burden is shifted to the directors to prove the entire fairness of the transaction despite the absence of a breach of the duty of loyalty. This Note argues that the entire fairness review of a disinterested board transaction is unworkable. …


Corporate Versus Contractual Mutual Funds: An Evaluation Of Structure And Governance, Wallace Wen Yeu Wang Oct 1994

Corporate Versus Contractual Mutual Funds: An Evaluation Of Structure And Governance, Wallace Wen Yeu Wang

Washington Law Review

This Article develops an analytic framework to evaluate the comparative merits of the structure and governance of the two dominant types of mutual funds—the Corporate Fund (the U.S. model) and the Contractual Fund (the German, Japanese and British models). The former is characterized by centralized decision-making functions, while the latter employs a more decentralized structure. The semi-hierarchical structure of the Corporate Fund leads to significant transaction costs such as influence, intervention and collective decision-making costs. Specifically, the board of directors is not effective in negotiating performance-related terms (e.g., fees), and shareholder suits based on fiduciary duties do not adequately address …


The White Plague Returns: Law And The New Tuberculosis, Kollin K. Min Oct 1994

The White Plague Returns: Law And The New Tuberculosis, Kollin K. Min

Washington Law Review

Tuberculosis (TB) rates in the United States have increased dramatically over the past decade. The most disturbing aspect of the disease's resurgence is the rising prevalence of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB), which is frequently fatal and is far more difficult to treat than conventional TB. To combat the spread of the disease, state legislatures throughout the country are rewriting outdated tuberculosis control laws. Many public health officials have suggested that in order to control MDR-TB effectively, modem TB statutes must grant the state the ability to detain even non-infectious patients who may develop MDR-TB in the future. This Comment examines the …


Reentering The Golden Door: Waiving Good-Bye To Exclusion Grounds For Permanent Resident Aliens, William Mckay Bennett Oct 1994

Reentering The Golden Door: Waiving Good-Bye To Exclusion Grounds For Permanent Resident Aliens, William Mckay Bennett

Washington Law Review

Under the exclusion provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), an alien admitted to the United States for permanent residence can be prohibited from reentering the United States after a trip out of the country. Because exclusion grounds differ from deportation grounds, permanent resident aliens who are not deportable could leave the country and find themselves excluded at the border upon return. The INA provides relief in such cases by allowing permanent resident aliens who have lived in the United States for over seven years to apply for a discretionary waiver of exclusion grounds under INA § 212(c). In …


Simas V. Quaker Fabric Corp.: Erisa Preemption Of Statutory Tin Parachutes, Kristin D. Anger Oct 1994

Simas V. Quaker Fabric Corp.: Erisa Preemption Of Statutory Tin Parachutes, Kristin D. Anger

Washington Law Review

In Simas v. Quaker Fabric Corp., the First Circuit invalidated Massachusetts's innovative tin parachute statute, designed to assist workers displaced by corporate takeovers, by finding it preempted by ERISA. After examining the relationship between the tin parachute and ERISA and the analysis in Simas, this Note argues that preemption was mandated neither by ERISA itself nor by decisions interpreting its preemptive reach. In light of the state interest at stake, the Simas decision is unfortunate and suggests the need for a legislative solution.


For The Sake Of The Child: Moving Toward Uniformity In Adoption Law, Marja E. Selmann Jul 1994

For The Sake Of The Child: Moving Toward Uniformity In Adoption Law, Marja E. Selmann

Washington Law Review

Adoption is governed by state law, which varies dramatically among states, and thus encourages forum shopping and complicates interstate adoption. A new Uniform Adoption Act (UAA), likely to be completed and approved by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws in 1994, offers states the opportunity to move toward greater uniformity. The UAA balances all of the participants' interests while keeping the child's best interests foremost.


Keynote Address—The 21st Century Lawyer: Is There A Gap To Be Narrowed?, Robert Maccrate Jul 1994

Keynote Address—The 21st Century Lawyer: Is There A Gap To Be Narrowed?, Robert Maccrate

Washington Law Review

This law school symposium on the Twenty-First Century Lawyer reflects a fundamental shift in the focus of legal education within the academy—from law in the abstract toward the reality of law in the daily work of lawyers. While holding firm to their scholarly mission, law schools are giving increasing attention to the world of lawyer performance and the needs of their students to be prepared to participate effectively in the legal profession. The 1992 Report entitled Legal Education and Professional Development-An Educational Continuum, by a task force of the American Bar Association Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the …


The Washington State Parenting Act In The Courts: Reconciling Discretion And Justice In Parenting Plan Disputes, Jane W. Ellis Jul 1994

The Washington State Parenting Act In The Courts: Reconciling Discretion And Justice In Parenting Plan Disputes, Jane W. Ellis

Washington Law Review

On July 8, 1993, the Washington Supreme Court handed down a decision construing the residential provision section of the Washington State Parenting Act. The case is significant for the children of divorcing parents in the State of Washington, and its importance extends beyond Washington because the supreme court's opinion is the first to interpret a key section of a law that has attracted national and international attention The case, In re Marriage ofKovacs, is an example of the sort of egregious injustice that can occur when a trial court fails to exercise its discretion in an appropriate manner and an …


Fisons: Will It Tame The Beast Of Discovery Abuse?, Barbara J. Gorham Jul 1994

Fisons: Will It Tame The Beast Of Discovery Abuse?, Barbara J. Gorham

Washington Law Review

In WSPIEA v. Fisons, the Washington Supreme Court held that evasive and misleading discovery tactics violate Civil Rule 26(g). This Note examines the discovery tactics used in Fisons against the backdrop of the historic failure of courts to impose adequate sanctions for discovery abuse. It argues that courts must do more to deter discovery abuse by clearly articulating the requirements of the rules governing discovery, imposing severe sanctions for discovery abuse, and closely monitoring discovery in large, complex cases.


Introduction: The Maccrate Report—Heuristic Or Prescriptive?, Wallace Loh Jul 1994

Introduction: The Maccrate Report—Heuristic Or Prescriptive?, Wallace Loh

Washington Law Review

There is a freight train gathering speed on the tracks of legal education, and it is called SSV—Statement of Skills and Values. This SSV stands as the centerpiece of the Report of the ABA Task Force on Law Schools and the Profession: Narrowing the Gap, better known as the MacCrate Report, named after its chair, Robert MacCrate. The MacCrate Report has ignited a rational debate on curricular reform that is becoming increasingly intense. Viewed broadly, SSV may represent the greatest proposed paradigm shift in legal education since Langdell envisioned legal education as the pursuit of legal science through the case …


On Teaching Professional Judgment, Paul Brest, Linda Krieger Jul 1994

On Teaching Professional Judgment, Paul Brest, Linda Krieger

Washington Law Review

To answer the question posed by the conveners of this symposium, of course there is a gap between legal education and the legal profession. There has always been one, and quite possibly it has widened somewhat in recent years, if for no other reason than that the world in which lawyers practice has changed so much while legal education has changed relatively little. The external changes include the internationalization of legal transactions, the centrality of technology to many aspects of practice, increased specialization driven by the proliferation and complexity of statutory and regulatory schemes, and the overloading of traditional systems …


Another "Postscript" To "The Growing Disjunction Between Legal Education And The Legal Profession", Harry T. Edwards Jul 1994

Another "Postscript" To "The Growing Disjunction Between Legal Education And The Legal Profession", Harry T. Edwards

Washington Law Review

"The Gap Between Legal Education and the Needs of the Profession," the subject of this symposium, is a matter about which I have had much to say over the past two years. In the October 1992 edition of the Michigan Law Review, I expressed my deep concern about "the growing disjunction between legal education and the legal profession," in an article with the same title.


Education For A Public Calling In The 21st Century, Phoebe A. Haddon Jul 1994

Education For A Public Calling In The 21st Century, Phoebe A. Haddon

Washington Law Review

A decade ago, an issue of the Association of American Law Schools' Journal of Legal Education was devoted to ruminations on selecting lawyers for the twenty-first century. Although some of the papers in the Journal issue offered congratulatory messages to legal educators and the Law School Admissions Council for their work, others more critically assessed legal education and the admissions process, warning of an impending "mid-life crisis" caused in part by an unreflective period of maturation. Focusing on two decades of "applicant explosion," affording the conscious creation of "a more intellectually elite profession,"' a number of the authors who submitted …


From Sink Or Swim To The Apprenticeship: Choices For Lawyer Training, Lucy Isaki Jul 1994

From Sink Or Swim To The Apprenticeship: Choices For Lawyer Training, Lucy Isaki

Washington Law Review

Our symposium today asks the question: Is there a gap in lawyer training to be narrowed? My answer is: Probably. Is it any greater than the gap that existed twenty or thirty years ago? I think not. Law schools are graduating women and men well prepared to begin the practice of law. True, there is much that new law school graduates do not yet know. But in a short time—two to three years—most new law graduates gain the skills and substantive knowledge needed to be successful.


Economic Reality Facing 21st Century Lawyers, Thomas D. Morgan Jul 1994

Economic Reality Facing 21st Century Lawyers, Thomas D. Morgan

Washington Law Review

Our predictions of future developments may be wrong, but if we do not at least think seriously about what skills these students will need to participate in the rapidly changing legal profession, we as legal educators will be certain to disserve both our students and their future clients.


Narrowing The Gap By Narrowing The Field: What's Missing From The Maccrate Report—Of Skills, Legal Science And Being A Human Being, Carrie Menkel-Meadow Jul 1994

Narrowing The Gap By Narrowing The Field: What's Missing From The Maccrate Report—Of Skills, Legal Science And Being A Human Being, Carrie Menkel-Meadow

Washington Law Review

I come here today, not to bury the MacCrate Report, but to criticize it, not for what it includes, although that is part of my critique, but for what it leaves out. I also want to situate my critique in the contentious intellectual history of legal education and legal scholarship, that, in my view, has too long polarized both the intellectual value and rigor of "law" (conceived of either as doctrine or theory) and "skills" (those nasty things that real lawyers have to do to express "the law" and represent clients). Among the most recent entries to this debate is …


Back To The Crib?, William B. Stoebuck Jul 1994

Back To The Crib?, William B. Stoebuck

Washington Law Review

First, let me note that this Rembe Lecture honors Toni Rembe, Esq., a distinguished graduate of this law school, class of 1960. Toni and I knew each other as fellow students and members of the Washington Law Review, since I was class of 1959. After graduating here, she took a Master of Laws in taxation at New York University in 1961. Then she joined the premier San Francisco law firm of Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro, where she has long been the head of the tax law division. Toni, who is a Seattle native, has maintained her ties to this city. …


Somewhere Farther Down The Line: Maccrate On Multiculturalism And The Information Age, Burnele V. Powell Jul 1994

Somewhere Farther Down The Line: Maccrate On Multiculturalism And The Information Age, Burnele V. Powell

Washington Law Review

A couple of months ago, sometime after I was invited by Symposium Editor Ruth Kennedy to participate in today's discussion, I got a telephone call from her. She wanted to know the title of my remarks. I, of course, had no idea, what I would entitle these remarks because I was still freshly in the throes of trying to write these remarks. Only moments before the phone rang, I had been preoccupied with several CDs that I had recently purchased and was thinking about the task ahead of me. It did occur to me, however, that there was something I …


Are Oliver Stone And Tom Clancy Journalists? Determining Who Has Standing To Claim The Journalist's Privilege, Kraig L. Baker Jul 1994

Are Oliver Stone And Tom Clancy Journalists? Determining Who Has Standing To Claim The Journalist's Privilege, Kraig L. Baker

Washington Law Review

Most circuits recognize a qualified privilege that provides a partial First Amendment shield for journalists to protect the confidentiality of their sources and materials. Few courts, however, discuss the scope of the class protected by this privilege. This Comment examines who has traditionally been part of the protected class and explores the trends and concerns of courts in granting standing. This Comment also recommends a framework that courts can use to determine whether to extend the journalist's privilege to new formats of communication and applies this framework to two examples.


Lost And Foundry: Forging A New Approach To Patent Licensing Agreements, Lawrence D. Graham Jul 1994

Lost And Foundry: Forging A New Approach To Patent Licensing Agreements, Lawrence D. Graham

Washington Law Review

The Federal Circuit has been inconsistent in its treatment of patent licensing agreements held by foundries. Recently, the Federal Circuit held that a foundry contract is a sale of goods that severs the right of the patentee with respect to the buyer under the patent exhaustion doctrine. In addition, it held that the applicable license would be construed to allow foundry rights unless the patentee could prove otherwise. This Note analyzes a string of Federal Circuit cases involving foundries and patent licenses. It concludes that a foundry contract should be viewed as a sale of services rather than a sale …


"Sexual Motivation" After State V. Halstien: Still Hazy For His Teenage Peers, Robert E. Lipscomb Jul 1994

"Sexual Motivation" After State V. Halstien: Still Hazy For His Teenage Peers, Robert E. Lipscomb

Washington Law Review

In State v. Halstien, the Washington Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of a juvenile statute that provides for a charge of sexual motivation in offenses other than sex offenses. Such motivation, if proven, becomes an aggravating factor that a judge may consider (along with any mitigating factors) in sentencing. In rejecting the argument that the statute was void for vagueness, the court should have clarified the statute by requiring a finding that the defendant manifested a sexual disorder, as well as a finding that sexual motivation was a substantial factor in the offense.


Thailand's Board Of Investment: Towards A More Appropriate And Effective Rural Investment Promotion Policy, Michael L. Shain Jun 1994

Thailand's Board Of Investment: Towards A More Appropriate And Effective Rural Investment Promotion Policy, Michael L. Shain

Washington International Law Journal

This Comment analyzes the role of Thailand's Board of Investment in the Thai Government's policy of decentralizing its economy. The Board of Investment is the administrative agency authorized to promote industrial development through the use of investment incentives. In response to the decentralization policy, the Board has created new categories of investment and a new set of upgraded incentives designed to encourage industrial investment in the country's rural provinces. The potential effectiveness of the Board's role, however, is limited. Recent changes in Thailand's tax and trade policy have seriously diminished the value of the Board's fiscal incentives, the backbone of …


China's Gatt Bid: Why All The Fuss About Currency Controls, Chris Brown Jun 1994

China's Gatt Bid: Why All The Fuss About Currency Controls, Chris Brown

Washington International Law Journal

China did not succeed in its bid to join the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) during the Uruguay Round. A key stumbling block was China's mechanism of exchange rate controls. From the mid-1980s to the end of 1993, China used a dual-rate currency mechanism, administering these rates through a loose network of about 100 exchange centers ("swap centers"). The swap centers helped to create partial convertibility of the Chinese currency and were instrumental in creating incentives for China's exporters and in attracting foreign investment. However, the swap centers also caused trade conflicts with the U.S. and within GATT. …


When Body Is Soul: The Proposed Japanese Bill On Organ Transplantations From Brain-Dead Donors, David Forster Jun 1994

When Body Is Soul: The Proposed Japanese Bill On Organ Transplantations From Brain-Dead Donors, David Forster

Washington International Law Journal

Organ transplantations from brain-dead donors have been de facto prohibited in Japan since 1968. Buddhism, Shintoism, the Japanese concept of personhood, Japanese medical and hospital practices, the police, and the Patient's Rights Conference have all contributed to this situation. However, consensus has been growing in Japanese society and government that these operations should be legalized. The Diet began considering a proposed bill to this end on April 12, 1994. This comment argues that the bill ought to be passed. If passed, this bill will save the lives of many Japanese, it will end the difficulties Japanese currently encounter going overseas …


Humanitarian Intervention In Southeast Asia In The Post-Cold War World: Dilemmas In The Definition And Design Of International Law, Bruce Pruitt-Hamm Jun 1994

Humanitarian Intervention In Southeast Asia In The Post-Cold War World: Dilemmas In The Definition And Design Of International Law, Bruce Pruitt-Hamm

Washington International Law Journal

Human rights abuse is a significant problem in Southeast Asia. The end of the Cold War has led to trends toward greater use of international interventionary force for humanitarian objectives. This Comment proposes that rather than defining or re-interpreting international law to allow military intervention for humanitarian purposes, a Southeast Asian regional human rights regime should be formed, involving greater development and acceptance of non-military forms of intervention.


An Agenda For Revising The Taxation Of Philanthropy In Japan, Koji Ishimura Jun 1994

An Agenda For Revising The Taxation Of Philanthropy In Japan, Koji Ishimura

Washington International Law Journal

As the size and scope of Japan's philanthropic activities have grown, so has the need to re-examine Japan's tax policies with regards to charitable giving and volunteerism. In particular, there is a need to review the classification of tax-exempt entities under the Corporate Tax Law to ensure that only bona fide non-profit activities are tax-exempt. Japan should also explore new tax incentives to encourage volunteerism, such as allowing deductions for out-of-pocket expenses incident to charity work, carryovers, and a liberalization of Japan's current system for specific itemized deductions. Finally, Japan's tax policies should be used to encourage more cross-border philanthropy …


Revision Of The Japanese Patent And Utlility Model System, Nobuo Monya, Marvin Motsenbocker, Hiroki Mitsumata Jun 1994

Revision Of The Japanese Patent And Utlility Model System, Nobuo Monya, Marvin Motsenbocker, Hiroki Mitsumata

Washington International Law Journal

As part of the international harmonization of industrial property rights, in the summer of 1992 a U.S. advisory committee published recommendations concerning revisions to the patent system. The Industrial Property Council of Japan also published a report at the end of 1992 concerning revisions to the patent law and utility model law. Soon thereafter the U.S. administration in Washington changed, and the U.S. position on patent law harmonization became unclear. Japan, however, enacted its report into legislation. Japan revised the relevant parts of its Patent Law (Law No. 26 of 1993) on April 16, 1993, and the revisions were promulgated …