Law Commons^™

The Financial Reform Act: Will It Succeed In Reversing The Causes Of The Subprime Crisis And Prevent Future Crises?, Charles W. Murdock

Charles W. Murdock

Summary: The Financial Reform Act: Will It Succeed in Reversing the Causes of the Subprime Crisis and Prevent Future Crises? By: Professor Charles W. Murdock

The current financial crisis, which could have plunged the world into a financial abyss similar to the Great Depression, is far from resolved. The financial institutions, which this article asserts caused the crisis, have returned to profitability and have paid billions of dollars in bonuses, while ordinary Americans have borne the brunt of the meltdown, with formal unemployment hanging around the 10% mark. This has caused some to comment that profits have been privatized and …

Cost-Benefit Analysis Of The Business Judgment Rule: A Critique In Light Of The Financial Meltdown, Todd Aman

Todd M Aman

In 2008, the United States – indeed the whole world – suffered a devastating financial meltdown. We know now that a significant cause of the meltdown was that, in the face of numerous red flags, the managers of several venerable financial firms decided to take tremendous risks in the subprime mortgage market, and the directors of these firms did little or nothing to stop them. However, despite their actions, these managers and directors face little or no risk of personal liability because they are shielded by the business judgment rule and other liability reducing mechanisms, such as director exculpation statutes. …

Lessons In Price Stability From The U.S. Real Estate Market Collapse, Andrea J. Boyack

Andrea J Boyack

The U.S. residential housing market collapse illustrates the consequences of ignoring risk while funding mortgage borrowing. Collateral over-valuation was a foundational piece of the crisis. Over the past few decades, secondary markets, securitization, policy and psychology increased the flow of funds into real estate. At the same time, financial market segmentation divorced risk from reward. Increased mortgage capital availability, unmitigated by proper risk allocation, led to real estate price inflation. Social trends and government policies exacerbated both the mortgage capital over-supply and the risk-valuation disconnect.

The Dodd-Frank Act inadequately addresses the underlying asset valuation problem. Federal regulation may support market …

Relational Integrity Regulation: Nudging Consumers Toward Products Bearing Valid Environmental Marketing Claims, Jeffrey J. Minneti

Jeffrey J Minneti

Over the last two decades scholars have addressed attributes of effective environmental regulation and advocated a wide spectrum of regulatory approaches, from the traditional command-and-control model to a libertarian-paternalism approach. Some writers have used those approaches to advocate for modifications to the Green Guides. This article joins that conversation and accomplishes two goals. First, it harmonizes environmental regulation scholarship, resulting in the creation of a new form of regulation that it terms “Relational Integrity” regulation. Second, in light of the Relational Integrity approach to regulation, the article examines public and private environmental claim regulatory schemes and suggests how those schemes …

Punishing The Penitent: Disproportionate Fines In Recent Fcpa Enforcements And Suggested Improvements, Bruce Hinchey

Bruce Hinchey

The Department of Justice has long promised tangible benefits to companies that voluntarily disclose Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) violations. Justice Department officials have promised that the enforcement of the FCPA is both fair and consistent. Despite these promises, critics question the benefits of voluntary disclosure based on the outcome of a few, isolated cases. In this thesis, forty FCPA cases from 2002 through 2009 are compiled, comparing the ratio between bribes and fines for companies that do and do not voluntarily disclose. The results side with the critics and reveal that there does not appear to be a benefit …

Self Restraint And National Security, Nathan Alexander Sales

Nathan Alexander Sales

Why does the government sometimes tie its own hands in national security operations? This article identifies four instances in which officials believed that the applicable laws allowed them to conduct a particular military or intelligence operation but nevertheless declined to do so. For example, policymakers have barred counterterrorism interrogators from using any technique other than the fairly innocuous methods listed in the Army Field Manual. Before 9/11, officials rejected the CIA’s plans to use targeted killings against Osama bin Laden and other terrorist leaders. Judge advocates sometimes use policy considerations to restrict military strikes that would be lawful. And in …

Two Cheers For Feasible Regulation: A Modest Response To Masur And Posner, David M. Driesen

David M Driesen

This response to Masur and Posner's "Against Feasibility" argues that the feasibility principle has normative and practical advantages over cost-benefit analysis. Normatively, it shows that the happiness literature's suggestion that jobs may be much more important than consumption to welfare supports the feasibility principle's emphasis on maximizing pollution reduction without producing widespread plant shutdowns. It shows that the practical problems Masur and Posner associate with feasibility analysis arise under cost-benefit analysis as well.

Utopian Taxation: Covering The Cost Of Living, Maurice A. Echols

Maurice A Echols

This article, “Utopian Taxation: Covering The Cost of Living,” discusses concepts of economics and tax policy with an intent to have its readers consider or reconsider what is truly valuable to them individually and to society as a whole. I discuss the overall workings of Money-Based Economies, Resource-Based Economies, and Mixed Economies with their relation to tax policy and the implications that arise or may arise within them. I believe that the concepts discussed within this article are very interesting and address new and revolving issues of people, government, and the relationships between them.

Prime Property Institutions For A Subprime Era: Toward Innovative Models Of Homeownership, Amnon Lehavi, Benito Arrunada

Amnon Lehavi

This Essay breaks new ground toward contractual and institutional innovation in models of homeownership, equity building, and mortgage enforcement. Inspired by recent developments in the affordable housing sector and in other types of public financing schemes, this Essay suggests extending institutional and financial strategies such as time- and place-based division of property rights, conditional subsidies, and credit mediation to alleviate the systemic risks of mortgage foreclosure. It proposes two new solutions. Alongside a for-profit shared equity scheme that would be led by local governments, the Essay also outlines a private market shared equity model, one of “bootstrapping home buying with …

An Economic Analysis Of Patent Law's Inequitable Conduct Doctrine, Thomas F. Cotter

Thomas F. Cotter

In recent years, patent law’s inequitable conduct doctrine has attracted considerable attention from judges, legislators, patent lawyers and commentators, culminating most recently in the Federal Circuit’s decision to reconsider en banc several aspects of the doctrine in Therasense, Inc. v. Becton, Dickinson & Co. Building on the work of other scholars, this Essay proposes an instrumental view of the doctrine as, ideally, a tool for inducing patent applicants to disclose the optimal quantity of information relating to the patentability of their inventions; it then presents a formal model of the applicant’s choices in deciding how much information to reveal. The …

An Economic Analysis Of Patent Law's Inequitable Conduct Doctrine, Thomas F. Cotter

Thomas F. Cotter

In recent years, patent law’s inequitable conduct doctrine has attracted considerable attention from judges, legislators, patent lawyers and commentators, culminating most recently in the Federal Circuit’s decision to reconsider en banc several aspects of the doctrine in Therasense, Inc. v. Becton, Dickinson & Co. Building on the work of other scholars, this Article proposes an instrumental view of the doctrine as, ideally, a tool for inducing patent applicants to disclose the optimal quantity of information relating to the patentability of their inventions; it then presents a formal model of the applicant’s choices in deciding how much information to reveal. The …

An Economic Analysis Of Patent Law's Inequitable Conduct Doctrine, Thomas F. Cotter

Thomas F. Cotter

In recent years, patent law’s inequitable conduct doctrine has attracted considerable attention from judges, legislators, patent lawyers and commentators, culminating most recently in the Federal Circuit’s decision to reconsider en banc several aspects of the doctrine in Therasense, Inc. v. Becton, Dickinson & Co. Building on the work of other scholars, this Article proposes an instrumental view of the doctrine as, ideally, a tool for inducing patent applicants to disclose the optimal quantity of information relating to the patentability of their inventions; it then presents a formal model of the applicant’s choices in deciding how much information to reveal. The …

The Rise Of The Corporation, The Birth Of Public Relations, And The Foundations Of Modern Political Economy, Donald J. Smythe

Donald J. Smythe

The rise of the modern corporation was an integral part the Second Industrial Revolution. This important economic and social transformation would not have occurred if business firms had been unwilling to make the large investments necessary to implement the new technologies that drove the industrial growth and development, and business firms would have been reluctant to make the investments without the shield of limited liability and the opportunity to spread their risks across diversified portfolios of corporate stocks. Nonetheless, the rise of the modern corporation created problems. The most successful corporations grew to unprecedented proportions, and the public’s concerns about …

Financial Market Regulation After The Crisis: The Case For Hedge Fund Regulation Via Basel Iii, Wulf A. Kaal Ph.D.

Wulf A. Kaal Ph.D.

Hedge funds have been blamed for their part in the financial market crisis of 2008-09. The exact role and the scope of hedge funds’ involvement in the financial crisis is unclear. Regulators increasingly scrutinize the hedge fund industry worldwide. Regulation of hedge funds could help minimize moral hazard, social externalities and systemic risk generated by the hedge fund industry. The paper evaluates recent regulatory changes including the US Dodd-Frank Act, the European Union Directive on Alternative Investment Fund Managers and other pertinent regulation. Using the methodological tool of New Institutional Economics, the paper provides an impact analysis of regulatory changes, …

From The Schoolhouse To The Poorhouse: The Credit Card Act's Failure To Adequately Protect Gen Y Consumers, Eboni Nelson

Eboni S Nelson

Whether through personal experiences or through the experiences of our friends and family, most, if not all, of us are all too familiar with the credit card industry’s unrelenting attempts to saddle young, naïve college students with debt that they cannot afford to repay. Students thoughtlessly apply for and use credit cards without considering the negative effects credit card debt can have on their academic, personal, and financial wellbeing. In May 2009, Congress attempted to address the pervasive problem of young consumer indebtedness by passing the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure Act of 2009. While this Article recognizes and …

Regulatory Impact Analyses Of Environmental Justice Effects, Spencer Banzhaf

Spencer Banzhaf

Finding an appropriate way to incorporate environmental justice considerations into policy-making has been a procedural challenge since President Clinton issued Executive Order 12,898 over 15 years ago. Moreover, environmental justice concerns tend to be overshadowed by efficiency considerations as embodied in benefit-cost analysis. This article argues that the environmental justice and benefit-cost policies and procedures in EPA's rule-making can both be improved by bringing them closer together, ultimately improving environmental regulations as well. In particular, environmental justice consideration should be incorporated into Regulatory Impact Analyses (RIAs) by drawing on the much older tradition of incorporating distributional effects into benefit-cost analysis. …

Disintermediating Avarice: A Legal Framework For Commercially Sustainable Microfinance, Steven L. Schwarcz

Steven L Schwarcz

Although microfinance has emerged as a key tool to alleviate poverty, the need for microfinance lending vastly exceeds the amount of funds that can be raised from charitable donors. Commercial bank lending is supplementing donor money, but microfinance loans made by banks are expensive and sometimes even exploitive. This article examines how innovative legal structures can enable microfinance loans to be funded directly from lower-cost, and virtually limitless, capital market sources by removing, or “disintermediating,” the need for a bank intermediary. In that context, the article identifies and attempts to resolve the resulting law-and-business issues of first impression and also …

Take This House And Shove It: The Emotional Drivers Of Strategic Default, Brent T. White

Brent T. White

An increasingly influential view is that strategic defaulters make a rational choice to default because they have substantial negative equity. This article, which is based upon the personal accounts of over 350 individuals, argues that this depiction of strategic defaulters as rational actors is woefully incomplete. Negative equity alone does not drive many strategic defaulters’ decisions to intentionally stop paying their mortgages. Rather, their decisions to default are driven primarily by emotion – typically anxiety and hopelessness about their financial futures and anger at their lenders’ and the government’s unwillingness to help. If the government and the mortgage industry wish …

A Review Of The 2011 And 2013 Digital Television Energy Efficiency Regulations Developed And Adopted By The California Energy Commission, Christopher P. Wazzan

Christopher P Wazzan

In December 2009, the California Energy Commission (“CEC”) adopted on-mode standards for power consumption of televisions, (e.g., watts used) which will go into effect in 2011. Proposed standards are subject to Section 25402(c) of the California Public Resources Code (“CPRC”) which requires that proposed regulations must “not result in any added total costs to the consumer over the designed life of the appliances concerned.” In order to comply with the CPRC, in September 2009, the CEC issued a report alleging consumers would save $8.1 billion from reduced energy consumption. We find that the CEC study is critically flawed and that …

Running For Cover: The Brac Commission As A Model For Spending Reform, Jerry Brito

Jerry Brito

With record spending and deficits come calls for reform. Spending reform, however, is easier said than done, and independent commissions are often suggested as a way to tackle intractable political problems. Not all commissions are created the same, however. While baseball and basketball both employ balls, they are entirely different animals. The same applies to congressionally created commissions. The Base Realignment and Closing (BRAC) commissions of the late 80s and early 90s were successful because of their peculiar structure—not simply because they were independent commissions. In this Article we first look at the roots of BRAC’s success and then compare …

Lessons From Single-Company Event Studies: The Importance Of Controlling For Company-Specific Events, Scott D. Hakala

Scott D Hakala

Single-company event studies are commonly employed in applied practice, such as in analyzing market efficiency, reliance, and damages in securities litigation. However, the presence of significant company-specific events among the observations used to estimate the market model results in significantly biased, overstated standard errors (a well-known omitted variables problem) and less reliable coefficient estimates in such studies. This is a frequently over-looked or neglected issue that renders the statistical inferences in single-company event studies employing using more traditional event study techniques biased and often unreliable. This paper demonstrates through simulation and actual examples that, even allowing for errors in implementation, …

Is Latin American Taxation Policy Appropriate For Promoting Foreign Direct Investment In The Region?, Hugo A. Hurtado

Hugo A Hurtado

Adoption of an appropriate international tax policy in Latin America can promote greater foreign direct investment. Latin American countries should work together on a tax integration process to give foreign direct investment a more regional approach rather than each country competing to attract its own foreign direct investment. Such intraregional competition results in lost tax revenues with no proven effect on foreign direct investment. A tax integration process would reduce the use of advanced tax planning techniques by multinational companies to take advantage of loopholes created by disparities between tax systems; however, it would also provide the foreign investor with …

The Market For Subprime Lending: A Law And Economics Analysis Of Market Failures And Policy Responses, Diego Valiante

Diego Valiante

Subprime mortgages represent a relevant wealth accumulation tool for low-income borrowers, and may promote efficient social policies. However, as recently brought to attention by the financial crisis, origination and distribution services are affected by strong information asymmetries and cognitive biases (rational and irrational). The failure of the subprime mortgages market was triggered by a mixture of irrational and opportunistic behaviours, as well as a lack of regulation, supervision and efficient disclosure. This paper, therefore, sheds lights on four areas of this market, highlighting causes and proposing remedies to structural failures. Therefore, the paper discusses: the financial architecture of the subprime …

Shaping Reforms And Business Models For The Otc Derivatives Market. Quo Vadis?, Diego Valiante

Diego Valiante

Regulators around the globe are setting new strategies to deal with the systemic importance of the €427 trillion ($604 trillion) over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives market. This paper explores the three major sources of disruptive effects in OTC derivatives: liquidity, counterparty risk and legal uncertainty. The author highlights risks that may affect the value chain of a derivative transaction and weaken the economic and legal rationales that justify their widespread use. On the policy side, commitments have been made at G-20 level to draft uniform rules on a global scale “to build a safer financial system”. This paper finds, however, that in …

Cleaning Up Bankruptcy: Limiting The Dischargeability Of Environmental Cleanup Costs, Sonali P. Chitre

Sonali P Chitre

This article reconciles the joint aims of environmental and bankruptcy law after Judge Posner’s myopic opinion in the Seventh Circuit’s resolution of U.S. v. Apex Oil. These two areas of law represent alternative means to the same end—the equitable distribution of limited resources—and share equity’s traditional emphasis of function over form. Ignoring these principles, Judge Posner ruled in Apex that a cleanup order constitutes a dischargeable “claim” when styled as a legal judgment but not when styled as an equitable injunction. This despite the fact that in either case the liability amounts to the same thing-payment must be made for …

A Model Of Legal Systems As Evolutionary Networks: Normative Complexity And Self-Organization Of Clusters Of Rules, Carlo Garbarino

Carlo Garbarino

The paper draws both on legal theory and network science to explain how legal systems are structured and evolve. The basic proposition is that legal systems have a structure identifiable through a model of them in terms of networks of rules, and that their evolution is a property of their network structure. The paper is based on a model of rules which relies on the tenets of the network theory to describe how legal change unfolds within the network structure of legal systems. Section 1 presents an outline of current literature on the application of network theory to legal systems. …

A Model Of Legal Systems As Evolutionary Networks: Normative Complexity And Self-Organization Of Clusters Of Rules, Carlo Garbarino

Carlo Garbarino

The paper draws both on legal theory and network science to explain how legal systems are structured and evolve. The basic proposition is that legal systems have a structure identifiable through a model of them in terms of networks of rules, and that their evolution is a property of their network structure. The paper is based on a model of rules which relies on the tenets of the network theory to describe how legal change unfolds within the network structure of legal systems. Section 1 presents an outline of current literature on the application of network theory to legal systems. …

Labor Relations And Labor Law In Japan, Manabu Matsunaka

Manabu Matsunaka

This article discusses the relationship between Japanese labor law and employment customs, building on this rationalistic understanding of the Japanese employment customs. Our basic conclusion is as follows. The Japanese employment custom developed naturally through an agreement among the members of Japanese employment society and attained efficient economic performance up till the 1990s. During the time, the Japanese labor law mainly worked toward setting the stage for private bargaining and respected its agreement instead of enforcing the desirable result directly through legal regulations. Through this indirect approach toward labor relations in Japan, at least part of the Japanese labor law …

The Next Stage Of Health Care Reform: Controlling Costs By Paying Health Plans Based On Health Outcomes, Dale B. Thompson

Dale Thompson

The predominant form of paying for health care in the United States (Fee-for-Service) creates inefficient incentives and leads to rising costs. A number of changes were incorporated into the health care reform legislative package of 2010, but these changes will not stop rising costs. Instead, this article proposes that the reimbursement structure for the Medicare Advantage program be revised so that medical plans receive their payments based on delivery of health outcomes, not delivery of health services. This approach utilizes centralized enforcement at the level of the plan, to provide incentives for the plan to encourage its providers to improve …

You Infringed My Patent, Now Wait Until I Sue You: The Federal Circuit’S Decision In Avocent Huntsville Corp. V. Aten International Co., Marta Vanegas

Marta R. Vanegas LL.M.

The Federal Circuit recently held that it lacked personal jurisdiction over a foreign defendant, because neither the patentee’s sales within the forum state, nor their patent enforcement letters constituted sufficient contacts for personal jurisdiction. This Note argues that the Federal Circuit erroneously held that a patentee’s sales in the forum state are irrelevant to specific personal jurisdiction. The Note surveys the legal background of personal jurisdiction in declaratory judgment actions, particularly in the patent context. The Note then argues that the Federal Circuit's recent line of cases incorrectly held that a patentee’s sales of the patented product within the forum …