Law Commons^™

The Confrontation Clause & State Action, John L. Watts

SMU Law Review

The Sixth Amendment’s Confrontation Clause works in conjunction with the right to counsel and trial by jury to protect the people against the government’s abuse of its prosecutorial monopoly. However, the history of the Court’s Confrontation Clause jurisprudence has not always focused on the Sixth Amendment’s goal of limiting government power and was treated as virtually synonymous with the hearsay rules. In Crawford v. Washington, the Court restored the Confrontation Clause to constitutional significance by correctly identifying it as a procedural guaranty that empowers the jury to evaluate the reliability of government witnesses through live testimony subject to cross-examination. Unfortunately, …

The Myth Of Children’S Online Privacy Protection, Stacey B. Steinberg

SMU Law Review

Digital technology has changed the landscape young people face as they come of age. It has changed how children interact with their parents, schools, community organizations, and the state. Despite many benefits, digital technologies that employ data collection, algorithms, and artificial intelligence pose significant risks for the next generation. Private businesses can collect, use, and sell a child’s data in ways never imagined by their families. Information collected by third parties with good intentions can be stolen through data breaches. Through faulty algorithms, websites can make inaccurate assumptions about young people’s interests, teachers can make inaccurate assumptions about a student’s …

Growing Tensions: Consumer Privacy And Corporate Disclosures, Megan Wischmeier Shaner

SMU Law Review

Data privacy and data security have become key issues for legislators, regulators, and individual citizens. Roughly two-thirds of Americans believe their data is being regularly tracked, monitored, and collected by companies and the government. A majority of U.S. adults also believe their data is less secure today than five years ago, expressing concerns that they have little control over how their personal information is being used and that the entities who control their data are not responsible stewards. In the absence of comprehensive federal regulation, a continuous stream of privacy statutes have been proposed at the state level. Beginning with …

Front Matter

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

Tribute To Professor Joseph Jude Norton, Ross P. Buckley

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

A Tribute To James L. Walsh Distinguished Faculty Fellow And Professor Joseph Jude Norton, Harriet E. Miers

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

In Memoriam: Professor Joseph J. Norton, Douglas W. Arner

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

The Vision And Inception Of The Legal Aid Clinic At Smu School Of Law, Amy Kearney

SMU Law Review

This paper examines the impetus behind the creation of the SMU Clinic and analyzes how the clinic actually worked in its early years and whether the clinic accomplished its objectives. I wrote this paper during my last semester of law school while participating in the SMU Clinic as a student attorney. While researching this paper, I had the pleasure of speaking with some of the first student attorneys that participated in the SMU Clinic, many of whom went on to practice law for decades afterwards. I greatly enjoyed hearing their perspectives, and love that I was able to similarly provide …

Can Criminal Defense Attorneys Be Victim-Centered?, Natalie Nanasi, Demetrice Lopez-Loftis

SMU Law Review

Attorneys defending those accused of intimate partner violence, like all lawyers, owe duties of zealous advocacy and confidentiality to their clients. But is there a place within these ethical obligations for them to also consider the safety of the victim? Defense counsel are often uniquely situated—by virtue of their relationships with their clients and victims—to help mitigate potentially serious harm. This article explores the spaces where defending an accused perpetrator of domestic violence and taking actions to limit further harm to a survivor are compatible. It also identifies areas where defense attorneys can obtain additional resources and data to inform …

75 Years Of Clinical Legal Education: Celebrating The Past While Looking To The Future, Mary Spector

SMU Law Review

In October 2023, the Clinical Program at SMU Dedman School of Law celebrated its 75th anniversary. The occasion provided an opportunity to celebrate seventy-five years of free legal services to thousands of clients over the years: real people with real problems without the means to hire a lawyer. Among the legal services provided were ones that ensured families had safe and affordable places to live, protected the rights of those in the criminal justice system, safeguarded seniors’ financial stability, assisted taxpayers in navigating disputes with the IRS, and ensured that employees obtain the benefits to which they are entitled.

During …

Front Matter

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

Death Is Disparate, Jesse Cheng

SMU Law Review

The high stakes of capital punishment demand heightened procedural safeguards: death is different, so the maxim goes. One such safeguard is the doctrine of individualized sentencing mitigation, which establishes the defense’s right to introduce expansively open-ended evidence about the defendant’s unique life circumstances when making the case for mercy at the penalty trial. But some have criticized individualized mitigation for upending prior efforts by the U.S. Supreme Court to establish consistency and fairness in death verdicts. This Article takes individualized sentencing to its logical limit by considering the doctrinal possibility of “adversarial parity,” whereby open-ended individualization is also extended to …

The War[Hol] Between Artistic Creativity And Commercial Use Within The Fair Use Defense, Morgan Houghtlin

SMU Law Review

In May 2023, the Supreme Court decided Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, articulating the standard for the “fair use” defense under a copyright infringement claim. The Court’s decision significantly narrowed the first factor of the fair use analysis, characterizing “purpose and use” in terms of the commercial nature of a secondary work with little consideration of the art’s creative value. This opinion deviates from the broader conception of “fair use” articulated in Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc. (1994) and introduces various implications for modern-day artists and content creators. Specifically, Justice Sotomayor’s majority opinion and …

Wills & Trusts, Gerry W. Beyer

SMU Annual Texas Survey

This article discusses developments relating to the Texas law of intestacy, wills, estate administration, trusts, and other estate planning matters during the Survey period of December 1, 2022, through November 30, 2023. The reader is warned that not all newly enacted statutes or decided cases during the Survey period are presented, and not all aspects of each statute or case are analyzed. You must read and study each statute or case’s full text before relying on it or using it as precedent. The discussion of most cases includes a moral, that is, the important lesson to be learned from the …

Professional Liability, Shelby Taylor, R. Max Ward, Josh Sherman

SMU Annual Texas Survey

This Article describes and analyzes major developments in professional liability law that occurred in Texas between December 1, 2022, and November 30, 2023.

Oil, Gas, & Mineral Law, Austin W. Brister

SMU Annual Texas Survey

No abstract provided.

Franchise Law, Deborah S. Coldwell, Kristina Pierre-Louis, Sam Mallick, Wilson Miller, Chris Hamborsky

SMU Annual Texas Survey

No abstract provided.

Front Matter

SMU Annual Texas Survey

No abstract provided.

Tribute To Professor Lack Bloom, David O. Taylor

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

A Role Model Among Law Professors, Randy Beck

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

Joseph J. Norton: Friend And Colleague, Christopher H. Hanna

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

Professor Joseph J. Norton: Distinguished Scholar, Outstanding Teacher, Exceptional International Lawyer, And Mensch, Werner F. Ebke

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

Green And Proud: Protecting The Antiquities Act As A Means Of Fighting Climate Change And Promoting American Patriotism, Cameron King

SMU Law Review

This Comment addresses recent developments in Antiquities Act jurisprudence. Given the dearth of serious legal challenges confronting the Antiquities Act for the first 100 years of its existence, the past twenty-five years of near continuous controversy have made the Antiquities Act a hot-button issue in environmental law and politics.

As recently as two years ago, the nature of scholarly interest in the Antiquities Act was vastly different. Then, the issue was President Trump’s reduction of the sizes of two major monuments. Questions surfaced about the President’s ability to make such a reduction. With the election of Joe Biden and the …

A Critique Of The Current Epidemic In Our Criminal Justice System: “Guilty Until Proven Innocent”, Jaclyn Marsh

SMU Law Review

It has been a long-held notion of American jurisprudence that a citizen of this country shall not be deprived of their fundamental rights until required so by law. It is an offshoot of this notion that an American should not be deprived of these fundamental rights through being confined to jail or prison until twelve of their own fellow peers have laid down a finding of guilty. However, this phenomenon is exactly what is happening today, and the issue has been steadily increasing in occurrence since the passing of a federal statute in 1984.

Because of judicial interpretation and government …

In Memoriam – A Tribute To Professor Joseph J. Norton, Rosa Maria Lastra

SMU Law Review

No abstract provided.

Press Freedoms Under Pressure: Clinical Perspectives On The State Of Press Freedoms In Texas In 2024, Peter B. Stefensen, Thomas S. Leatherbury

SMU Law Review

Amid existential challenges to the press as an institution, public accountability journalists in Texas are navigating their own set of difficulties. For those who report on state and local entities, journalists are encountering increasingly constrained avenues for obtaining public information, a greater tendency for government bodies to prioritize image control over transparency, a higher likelihood of retaliation from public officials for performing important accountability work, and a judiciary that seems to respect the press less and less. By surveying journalists, and members of press and legal organizations who support accountability journalism, we use their accounts to evaluate these trends, to …

Insurance Law, J. Price Collins, Janet Tolbert, Ashley Gilmore

SMU Annual Texas Survey

This Article describes and analyzes major developments in insurance law that occurred in Texas between December 1 and November 30 of 2022.

Asset-Based Financing For Space Activities, Francesca Giannoni-Crystal

Journal of Air Law and Commerce

The space industry—whose numbers are already substantial—has undeniable potential for further growth. However, because it no longer consists of only multibillion-dollar companies, the industry needs access to traditional financing. Venture capital alone is insufficient. This Article discusses some difficulties for the space industry’s access to traditional—and especially asset-based—financing. Some are common to all space activities, while some exist only for novel space activities. These difficulties cover a broad range of legal, regulatory, and factual issues (including insurance). While the problems are difficult, ideas to solve them are plentiful, a number of which the paper discusses. The paper also presents ways …

The Case Law Of The Court Of Justice Of The Eu On Art. 17 Of The 1999 Montreal Convention: An Evaluation From A Comparative Perspective, Michael Chatzipanagiotis

Journal of Air Law and Commerce

This paper analyzes the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on Article 17(1) of the 1999 Montreal Convention (MC99) regarding the liability of international air carriers for death or bodily injury to passengers. The interpretational principles and methods applied by the CJEU are examined, accounting also for the particularities of the EU legal order. Furthermore, the results reached by the CJEU are compared with the case law of other jurisdictions, mainly the US, and doctrinal writings. Nonetheless, this paper does not explore the pertinent issues from a de lege ferenda perspective.

The paper concludes …

It Comes With Baggage: The Heavy Weight Implications Of Weighing Airline Passengers, Brooke Sutter

Journal of Air Law and Commerce

The aviation industry is one of the most regulated industries that exists in modern society. Before an airplane can take a passenger from one destination to another, diligent and thorough checks are performed on the aircraft, the runway, the pilots, the crewmembers, the luggage, the route, and the numerous other points of potential risk. Due in part to this diligence, air travel is also one of the safest forms of travel. However, one point of potential risk that is underregulated and overlooked in the safety calculation is the weight of the passengers. The act of weighing passengers is not just …