Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Law Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Articles 61 - 85 of 85

Full-Text Articles in Law

Is The Supreme Court Disabling The Enabling Act, Or Is Shady Grove Just Another Bad Opera?, Robert J. Condlin Jun 2014

Is The Supreme Court Disabling The Enabling Act, Or Is Shady Grove Just Another Bad Opera?, Robert J. Condlin

Robert J. Condlin

After seventy years of trying, the Supreme Court has yet to agree on whether the Rules Enabling Act articulates a one or two part standard for determining the validity of a Federal Rule. Is it enough that a Federal Rule regulates “practice and procedure,” or must it also not “abridge substantive rights”? The Enabling Act seems to require both, but the Court is not so sure, and the costs of its uncertainty are real. Among other things, litigants must guess whether the decision to apply a Federal Rule in a given case will depend upon predictable ritual, judicial power grab, …


Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxxiii—Contempt Motions Continued, Gerald Lebovits May 2014

Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxxiii—Contempt Motions Continued, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


New York State Commercial Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure: A Primer—Part Iii, Gerald Lebovits May 2014

New York State Commercial Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure: A Primer—Part Iii, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


Cy Pres And The Optimal Class Action, Jay Tidmarsh Apr 2014

Cy Pres And The Optimal Class Action, Jay Tidmarsh

Jay Tidmarsh

Prepared for a symposium on class actions, this Article examines the problem of cy pres relief in class actions through the lens of optimal claim structure and class membership. It finds that the present cy pres doctrine does little to advance the creation of optimal class actions, and that it may do some harm to achieving that goal. The Article then proposes an alternative “nudge” to induce putative class counsel to structure class actions in an optimal way: setting attorneys’ fees so that counsel is compensated through a combination of an hourly market rate and a percentage of the net …


Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxxii—Contempt Motions, Gerald Lebovits Apr 2014

Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxxii—Contempt Motions, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


The Donau Chemie Case: Access To File As A Guarantee Of Access To Justice In Cross-Border Litigation, Emanuela Matei Mar 2014

The Donau Chemie Case: Access To File As A Guarantee Of Access To Justice In Cross-Border Litigation, Emanuela Matei

Emanuela A. Matei

No abstract provided.


New York State Commercial Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure: A Primer—Part Ii, Gerald Lebovits Feb 2014

New York State Commercial Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure: A Primer—Part Ii, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


Drafting New York Civil-Ligation Documents: Part Xxxi—Subpoenas Continued, Gerald Lebovits Feb 2014

Drafting New York Civil-Ligation Documents: Part Xxxi—Subpoenas Continued, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


Changing Your Name In New York: A Guide For Attorneys And The Self-Represented—Part Iii, Gerald Lebovits Jan 2014

Changing Your Name In New York: A Guide For Attorneys And The Self-Represented—Part Iii, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


New York State Commercial Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure: A Primer—Part I, Gerald Lebovits Jan 2014

New York State Commercial Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure: A Primer—Part I, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxx—Subpoenas, Gerald Lebovits Jan 2014

Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxx—Subpoenas, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


The Political And Professional Context Of Rule Making, Daniel Coquillette Dec 2013

The Political And Professional Context Of Rule Making, Daniel Coquillette

Daniel R. Coquillette

No abstract provided.


Retroactivity And Prospectivity Of Judgments In American Law, Richard Kay Dec 2013

Retroactivity And Prospectivity Of Judgments In American Law, Richard Kay

Richard Kay

In every American jurisdiction, new rules of law announced by a court are presumed to have retrospective effect—that is, they are presumed to apply to events occurring before the date of judgment. There are, however, exceptions in certain cases where a court believes that such application of the new rule will upset serious and reasonable reliance on the prior state of the law. This essay, a substantially abridged version of the United States Report on the subject, submitted at the Nineteenth International Congress of Comparative Law, summarizes these exceptional cases. It shows that the proper occasions for issuing exclusively or …


Morphing Case Boundaries In Multidistrict Litigation Settlements, Margaret Thomas Dec 2013

Morphing Case Boundaries In Multidistrict Litigation Settlements, Margaret Thomas

Margaret S. Thomas

The boundaries of federal multidistrict litigation (MDL) are blurring, as district courts seek innovative ways to facilitate global settlements to resolve multijurisdictional, multidimensional, national mass torts. The techniques emerging from the district courts have mostly evaded appellate review and received little scholarly attention, but they raise important challenges to traditional understandings of the nature of MDL and complex litigation. This Article argues that factually similar cases proceeding in multiple court systems in mass tort disputes create a “federalism problem” for global settlements: global settlements typically benefit from oversight by a single judge, but often there is no single judge who …


Life After Comcast: Reasonable Interpretations Preserve The Rule And Keep Class Actions Alive, Brittni W. King Dec 2013

Life After Comcast: Reasonable Interpretations Preserve The Rule And Keep Class Actions Alive, Brittni W. King

Brittni W King

No abstract provided.


Inhibiting Patent Trolling: A New Approach For Applying Rule 11 (Working Paper), Young Jeon, Eric J. Rogers Dec 2013

Inhibiting Patent Trolling: A New Approach For Applying Rule 11 (Working Paper), Young Jeon, Eric J. Rogers

Youngsik Jeon

The existing Rule 11 of the FRCP can be immediately harnessed to help solve the patent troll, nuisance-lawsuit problem. Currently there is the perception that too many litigious entities, commonly referred to as “patent trolls,” are creating too much dead-weight economic waste in society. The popular view is that there has been an alarming rise in the number of patent trolls that make no products but try to monetize patents by filing dubious patent infringement lawsuits merely to extract money from commercially productive companies that actually make products and use technologies for society’s benefit. Defining “patent troll” is probably too …


The Practice And Theory Of Lawyer Disqualification, Keith Swisher Dec 2013

The Practice And Theory Of Lawyer Disqualification, Keith Swisher

Keith Swisher

Lawyer disqualification is commonly feared — as a “strategic,” “tactical,” and “harassing” “potent weapon” depriving clients of their trusted counsel of choice. Although disqualification comes with costs, fundamental misunderstandings fuel this common fear. This Article finds that disqualification is a uniquely effective remedy for lawyer misconduct and makes the following contributions to the law and practice of lawyer disqualification: (1) an exhaustive study surveying disqualification cases and refuting the common misconception that disqualification motions are uncontrollably on the rise and uncontrollably bad; (2) an accessible analysis of lawyer disqualification doctrine that permits lawyers and judges to begin assessing common disqualification …


Administrative Arbitrary Embarrassments At Brazilian Social Security Procedures, Carlos Luiz Strapazzon, Maria Helena Pinheiro Renck Dec 2013

Administrative Arbitrary Embarrassments At Brazilian Social Security Procedures, Carlos Luiz Strapazzon, Maria Helena Pinheiro Renck

Carlos Luiz Strapazzon

Within Brazilian constitutional system, Social Security rights are fundamental rights. However, social insurance is divided into two branches: by one side, Pensions Rights (also called Direitos Previdenciários), by the other, the Social Assistance Rights. The former exists to protect some special rights-holders from several social risks (health, death, injury, unemployment, old-age, etc.), through regular payments made by the State. It works as a public insurance system directed by the Social Insurance National Institute (INSS). This paper maintain that several administrative embarrassments disturb too much seriously a regular acess to those payments by the needy citizens (right-holders). Likewise, it maintains that …


Mapping Supreme Court Doctrine: Civil Pleading, Scott Dodson, Colin Starger Dec 2013

Mapping Supreme Court Doctrine: Civil Pleading, Scott Dodson, Colin Starger

Scott Dodson

This essay, adapted from the video presentation available at http://vimeo.com/89845875, graphically depicts the genealogy and evolution of federal civil pleading standards in U.S. Supreme Court opinions over time. We show that the standard narrative—of a decline in pleading liberality from Conley to Twombly to Iqbal—is complicated by both progenitors and progeny. We therefore offer a fuller picture of the doctrine of Rule 8 pleading that ought to be of use to judges and practitioners in federal court. We also hope to introduce a new visual format for academic scholarship that capitalizes on the virtues of narration, graphics, mapping, online accessibility, …


Party Subordinance In Federal Litigation, Scott Dodson Dec 2013

Party Subordinance In Federal Litigation, Scott Dodson

Scott Dodson

American civil litigation in federal courts operates under a presumption of party dominance. Parties choose the lawsuit structure, factual predicates, and legal arguments, and the court accepts these choices. Further, parties enter ubiquitous ex ante agreements that purport to alter the law governing their dispute, along with a chorus of calls for even more party-driven customization of litigation. The assumption behind this model of party dominance is that parties substantially control both the law that will govern their dispute and the judges that oversee it. This Article challenges that assumption by offering a reoriented model of party subordinance. Under my …


До Питання Визначення Принципів Досудового Врегулювання Публічно-Правових Спорів, Sergey V. Kivalov Dec 2013

До Питання Визначення Принципів Досудового Врегулювання Публічно-Правових Спорів, Sergey V. Kivalov

Sergey V. Kivalov

Article is devoted to the formation of the basic foundations of pre-trial settlement of public law disputes referred to the jurisdiction of the administrative courts. The system of pre-trial settlement of the principles of public law disputes are characterized by their types and content specific legal principles study procedures. Puts more emphasis on the content of the principles of neutrality and disinterestedness, equality, voluntariness and confidentiality procedures.


Revisiting The Government As Plaintiff, Elizabeth Chamblee Burch Dec 2013

Revisiting The Government As Plaintiff, Elizabeth Chamblee Burch

Elizabeth Chamblee Burch

This is a symposium essay dedicated to the late Richard Nagareda and written in response to Adam S. Zimmerman's piece, The Corrective Justice State. As Professor Zimmerman recognizes, the debate over governments acting as plaintiffs and “regulating by deal” has shifted from initial questions over whether litigation produces the best public policy and whether executive officials are acting within the scope of their authority to how government actors should pursue and allocate settlements. Yet, as this first wave of controversy suggests, the slate upon which executive officials currently write is neither clean nor uncontroversial. Instead, this new debate is playing …


Consumer-Credit Lawsuits In The New York City Civil Court, Gerald Lebovits Dec 2013

Consumer-Credit Lawsuits In The New York City Civil Court, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


New York Residential Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure—2013-2014 (6th Ed. 2014), Gerald Lebovits Dec 2013

New York Residential Landlord-Tenant Law And Procedure—2013-2014 (6th Ed. 2014), Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.


Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxix—Disclosure Motions Continued, Gerald Lebovits Dec 2013

Drafting New York Civil-Litigation Documents: Part Xxix—Disclosure Motions Continued, Gerald Lebovits

Hon. Gerald Lebovits

No abstract provided.