Digital Commons Network^™

Future Interests-Creation Of A Power By Exercise Of General Testamentary Power Held Valid, William R. Hewitt S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

H in his will created a trust which provided for a life estate for his wife W. The trustee was directed to distribute the corpus of this trust after W's death "to such person or persons as she [W] may limit, nominate, and appoint by her last will and testament." At her death, W's will provided that part of the property over which she had a power of appointment was to continue in trust for S for life, with the power in S to dispose of the corpus absolutely by her last will. S, …

Hayes: The Historical Evolution Of Modern Nationalism., Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

A Review of THE HISTORICAL EVOLUTION OF MODERN NATIONALISM. By Carlton J. H. Hayes.

Rogge: Our Vanishing Civil Liberties., Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

A Review of OUR VANISHING CIVIL LIBERTIES. By O. John Rogge.

Notes, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

The information given in the notes is derived from inspection of the books, publishers' literature, and the ordinary library sources.

Monthly Periodical Index, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

This department lists the articles and comments which appear in leading law reviews. The index embraces material published since the last issue of this REVIEW.

Future Interests-Common Law Rule Against Perpetuities Not In Force In Idaho-Applicability Of Statute Against Suspension Of Power Of Alienation To Option Contract, Howard W. Haftel S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Seller contracted to give purchaser sixty days notice of his intention to sell certain real property, purchaser to have power, in that event, to buy the property for a stated price within the sixty days. If the purchaser failed to exercise the option, seller was then free to convey the property to anyone. Alleging that seller had conveyed the land to others without notice to him, purchaser sued to have this conveyance set aside and the option specifically enforced. The lower court sustained a general demurrer to the complaint. On appeal, held, reversed. The statutory rule against restraints on …

Negligence-Proximate Cause-Plaintiff's Burden Of Proof Where Either Of Two Wrongful Acts Could Have Caused Injury, M. J. Spencer

Michigan Law Review

While walking on a highway, A was knocked down by a car driven by B, and was almost immediately run over by C's car. A was pronounced dead from several injuries, any one of which would have sufficed to cause his death. Plaintiff, A's administratrix, recovered judgment against both B and C for A's death. Held, reversing on other grounds, joinder of B and C was proper. Micelli v. Hirsch, (Ohio App. 1948) 83 N.E. (2d) 240.

Front Matter, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

Front Matter for Volume 47, Issue 8 of Michigan Law Review

Henry Moore Bates: 1869-1949, Paul A. Leidy, Grover C. Grismore, Ralph W. Aigler

Michigan Law Review

Henry Moore Bates, Professor Emeritus of Law and Dean Emeritus of the Law School, was born in Chicago, Illinois, on March 30, 1869. He was the son of George Chapman Bates and Alice E. Bates. He received his early education from private tutors and the public schools of Chicago; in the fall of 1886 he enrolled in the College of Literature, Science and the Arts of this University; he received the degree of Bachelor of Philosophy in June of 1890.

Henry Moore Bates, Herbert W. Clark

Michigan Law Review

There are people to whom any sense of fitness would assign a long life. Henry Moore Bates is one of these. In full vigor of mind until the end and before any physical deterioration had occurred to render his days uncomfortable to himself or his family, he died April 15th, on the sixteenth day following his 80th birthday. At eight o'clock in the evening before he died he was in bouyant spirits, his humor was keen and kindly, as always; his laughter was young. Eight hours later the end came. He was unafraid. "When it (was) time for him to …

Henry Moore Bates, Roscoe Pound

Michigan Law Review

It has been my uniform practice never to read from a manuscript or use notes when I am speaking to an audience, but in speaking of so old and dear a friend I feel a certain inhibition of emotion that stands in the way of an adequate oral speech. Moreover, when I think of Dean Bates' unswerving adherence to exact, accurate statement, his abhorrence of all exaggeration, of all overstatement, I feel that he would not be satisfied with one who followed the relatively loose method of oral statement instead of adhering to a carefully and meticulously prepared manuscript for …

Coming Into Equity With Clean Hands, Zechariah Chafee, Jr.

Michigan Law Review

The preceding article proposed to examine eighteen differing groups of cases which are commonly supposed to present the clean hands doctrine as a maxim of equity, and then proceeded to consider eight such groups. Ten groups still require attention. The first five of those already considered fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of equity, and the next three within the concurrent jurisdiction, which is continued for a considerable part of the present article. After discussing suits for specific performance of unfair contracts and of illegal contracts, I dealt with miscellaneous tort suits by a person charged with crime. We now turn …

Streamlining Conveyancing Procedure, Paul E. Basye

Michigan Law Review

Statutes of limitations have long occupied an essential and important place in every system of jurisprudence. They express a policy that is essential to social progress in a great variety of ways. Their effect is particularly noteworthy in the field of property law where they promote repose and give security to human affairs. "They stimulate to activity and punish negligence. While time is constantly destroying the evidence of rights, they supply its place by a presumption which renders proof unnecessary."

Acquisition Of Evidence By Search And Seizure, Mary Louise Ramsey

Michigan Law Review

What protection do the Fourth and Fifth Amendments afford against acquisition of evidence by search and seizure, actual or constructive? Does an individual have a constitutional privilege against the disclosure of records he is required by law to keep? May police officers search premises on which an arrest is made and seize contraband which they find there? A series of cases recently decided by a closely divided Supreme Court has enveloped this field in the same deep fog of uncertainty which now hangs over so many other areas of constitutional law. The unstable quality of these precedents is attested by …

Pashukanis And Vyshinsky: A Study In The Development Of Marxian Legal Theory, Lon L. Fuller

Michigan Law Review

Reading Andrei Y. Vyshinsky's The Law of the Soviet Union ought to be a stimulating and rewarding experience. It is an exposition. of Soviet legal philosophy and of the theory and practice of Soviet public or "state" law. Throughout it purports to compare the premises that underlie Soviet law with those on which ''bourgeois" legal systems are based. Vyshinsky, a famous world figure and the present minister for foreign affairs of the U.S.S.R., wrote part of the book and supervised compiliation of the remainder. The decision of the American Council of Learned Societies to sponsor a translation of the work …

Corporations-Officers And Directors-Stock Option Incentive Employment Contracts For Corporation Executives, A. B. Perlin, Jr. S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

In the past few decades considerable attention has been directed toward "piecework payment" for corporate executives; that is, compensation based largely upon results rather than upon past or expected performance. The stock option incentive employment contract' is one of the means utilized to achieve that desired objective.

Bankruptcy-Status Of Claims In Bankruptcy Proceeding Following Default In Chapter Xi Arrangement, Myron J. Nadler S.Ed., L. B. Lea S.Ed

Michigan Law Review

A significant question arising under the Bankruptcy Act of 1938 which has not been satisfactorily dealt with by the statute is the relative status, in a bankruptcy proceeding precipitated by the debtor's default under the terms of a chapter XI arrangement, of claims of creditors participating in the arrangement and of those who became creditors after confirmation. Specifically, the problem is whether the old creditors, those who participated in the arrangement, can prove to the amount of their original claims, or merely to the extent of their claims as scaled down by the terms of the arrangement; and whether the …

International Law-International Court Of Justice-Advisory Opinions-Admission To Membership In The United Nations, William C. Gordon

Michigan Law Review

The International Court of Justice is the principal judicial organ of the United Nations, and the Statute of the Court forms an integral part of the United Nations Charter. The Court is essentially a continuation of the Permanent Court of International Justice, which operated in connection with the League of Nations. Like its predecessor, the Court is composed of fifteen judges, nominated in a manner designed to ensure impartiality and elected by the General Assembly and the Security Council voting separately upon a list of nominees.

Bankruptcy-Limitation Of Actions By Trustee As Affected By Section Ll(E) Of The Federal Bankruptcy Act, David H. Armstrong S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Trustee in bankruptcy sued to recover a preference voidable under a state statute which also provided that an action to recover such a preference must be commenced within six months after application for a trustee. The present suit was commenced one year after the bankruptcy petition was filed. Defendant moved to dismiss for failure to comply with statutory limitations. Held, motion denied. Section II(e) of the Bankruptcy Act supersedes the state statute of limitations in this case. Engstrom v. De Vos, (D.C. Wash. 1949) 81 F. Supp. 854.

Labor Law-Relationship Of Federal And State Authority Over Labor Relations, Ralph E. Hunt S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

In three recent cases, the United States Supreme Court has been required to determine the impact of federal labor relations legislation on certain state enactments in this area. The importance of these decisions, concerning a problem which has caused difficulty since enactment of the National Labor Relations Act in 1935, is increased by their consideration of the significance of the amendments contained in the Labor-Management Relations Act of 1947.

(1.) The appellant La Crosse Co., which handled interstate telephone calls, had made a collective bargaining agreement with appellant A. F. of L. union, to continue from year to year. During …

Conflict Of Laws-Domicile Of Child Living With Mother, Charles E. Becraft S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff and defendant, husband and wife, were domiciled in New York. Because of temporary unemployment, plaintiff took his wife and minor child to Connecticut. He later returned to New York and resided in the apartment the family had formerly occupied. The wife and child did not return to New York, and the court found that she had at all times intended to remain in Connecticut and establish a domicile there. Plaintiff at all times intended to make New York his permanent residence. When defendant would not return to New York, plaintiff brought action for separation in a New York court, …

Constitutional Law--Commerce Clause--Is Organized Baseball Interstate Commerce, Charles Hansen

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff contracted to play baseball for defendant ball club. The agreement contained the usual "reserve" clause whereby the player agreed not to perform for a team other than defendant unless assigned or released. By terms of the contract, broad disciplinary power over the contracting parties was accorded the commissioner of baseball, and when plaintiff breached the reserve clause, an exercise of that power resulted in his being barred from Organized Baseball for a period of five years. Suit was brought against the organizations comprising Organized Baseball under the Sherman Act, for damages caused by the consequent deprivation of plaintiff's means …

Constitutional Law-Commerce Clause-Validity Of New York Milk Licensing Law, William P. Sutter

Michigan Law Review

A New York statute required the licensing of all milk dealers in the state, and authorized the refusal of such a license upon a finding by the commissioner of agriculture that its issuance would "tend to a destructive competition in a market already adequately served." Petitioner, an out-of-state corporation, sought a license for an additional plant for the processing of milk to be purchased locally and to be distributed out of state, but was denied a license on the ground stated in the statute as quoted above. Denial of the license was sustained by the New York Court of Appeals. …

Contracts - Municipal Corporations - Revocability Of Offer Submitted Under Statutory Competitive Bidding, Richard H. Conn

Michigan Law Review

In accordance with statutory provisions, the city commissioners of Atlantic City advertised for bids for certain public improvements. Plaintiff submitted a sealed bid accompanied by a deposit of $5,000, as required by the advertisement, to guarantee execution of the contract if it were the successful bidder. When the bids were opened, plaintiff was the lowest bidder by a considerable margin. Investigation disclosed that an appreciable error had been made in the calculation of its bid, however, and before any official action had been taken, plaintiff advised the city commission of the mistake and withdrew the bid. Nevertheless, the contract was …

Constitutional Law-Due Process-Punishment For Direct Contempt Of Court, William R. Worth

Michigan Law Review

Opposing counsel's objection to material in petitioner's opening statement to the jury was sustained. When petitioner rephrased his statement, the trial court, feeling that he was still trying to get inadmissible material before the jury, threatened to "declare a mistrial if you mess with me two minutes and a half, and fine you besides.'' Petitioner took an exception to the conduct of the court, and was immediately fined $25. His protests led to successive increases in penalty, culminating in a $100 fine and three days in jail. The Supreme Court of Texas denied habeas corpus on the ground that the …

Corporations-Right Of Corporation To Exercise Purchase Option After Dissolution, E. Blythe Stason, Jr.

Michigan Law Review

ln 1945 appellant corporation was dissolved. Under a state statute, its officers became trustees, with "full power and authority of [the] company over [its] assets and property," with the duty to settle its affairs for the benefit of creditors and shareholders. Under another statute, the corporate existence was, for this limited purpose, extended three years beyond dissolution. Appellant attempted to purchase land under an option contained in an unexpired lease, but was resisted by the appellee-option or. In an action for specific performance of the option contract, relief was denied. On appeal, held, affirmed. Corporate existence was continued only …

Labor Law-Constitutional Law-Due Process Of Law-State Power To Enjoin Peaceful Picketing, L. B. Lea S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff was a wholesale ice distributor, selling ice to independent contractors. Defendants were members and officers of a union which represented many of the truck drivers employed by these peddlers. In carrying out a scheme to unionize all peddlers, defendants attempted to obtain plaintiff's agreement not to sell ice to non-union peddlers. Such an agreement would violate the state anti-trust law. On plaintiff's refusal, defendants peacefully picketed its plant. Plaintiff immediately suffered an 85% loss of business, and the state court granted it an injunction against the picketing. On appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States, held, …

Future Interests-Effect Of Limited Power Of Revocation In Determining Validity Of Inter Vivos Trust Under Rule Against Perpetuities, Andrew W. Lockton, Iii S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Settlor created an inter vivos trust, reserving to himself the income for life plus an absolute, non-cumulative right to withdraw sums not in excess of $1500 per year. The trust was otherwise irrevocable. Measured from the date of the inter vivos transaction, some of the limitations clearly violated the rule against perpetuities; measured from the date of settlor' s death, all limitations would be valid. The trust fund, some twenty years after its creation, amounted to about $32,000. Held, the crucial date was that of creation. Ryan v. Ward, (Md. 1949) 64 A.(2d) 258.

Legislation-Canons Of Construction-Presumption Of Territoriality, David H. Armstrong S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff, an American citizen, was employed by defendant contractor to work on construction in Iraq carried on under a contract with the United States. Plaintiff brought suit in New York for overtime pay under the Federal Eight Hour Law applying to work done under "Every contract made to which the United States ... is a party .... " A verdict for the plaintiff was upheld by the New York Court of Appeals. On certiorari to the United States Supreme Court, held, reversed. In absence of contrary intent, legislation is presumed to apply only within the territorial jurisdiction of the …

Quasi-Contracts-Landlord And Tenant-Recovery For Overpayment Of Rent In Violation Of Statute, William P. Sutter

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff occupied a dwelling house from 1928 to 1945, paying $35 per month rent until September, 1941. In that month, defendant, his landlord, increased the rent to $75, which plaintiff paid until September, 1945. The property was registered with the Office of Price Administration at a maximum rental of $35, and this fact was known to plaintiff. Plaintiff's suit to recover the overpayment of $40 per month was dismissed. On appeal, held, affirmed. No statute specifically authorized restitution, and the illegality of the contract precludes restitution in absence of statute. Jones v. Chennault, (Mich. 1948) 35 N.W. (2d) …