Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Discipline
-
- Engineering (3206)
- Physical Sciences and Mathematics (3078)
- Computer Sciences (1283)
- Physics (961)
- Electrical and Computer Engineering (887)
-
- Aerospace Engineering (787)
- Operations Research, Systems Engineering and Industrial Engineering (741)
- Operational Research (422)
- Business (409)
- Optics (349)
- Signal Processing (343)
- Oceanography and Atmospheric Sciences and Meteorology (284)
- Computer Engineering (243)
- Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics (211)
- Electrical and Electronics (209)
- Environmental Sciences (194)
- Applied Mathematics (189)
- Civil and Environmental Engineering (188)
- Aviation (187)
- Statistics and Probability (185)
- Information Security (181)
- Social and Behavioral Sciences (170)
- Atmospheric Sciences (167)
- Materials Science and Engineering (167)
- Navigation, Guidance, Control and Dynamics (167)
- Plasma and Beam Physics (156)
- Operations and Supply Chain Management (149)
- Electromagnetics and Photonics (142)
- Artificial Intelligence and Robotics (138)
- Other Operations Research, Systems Engineering and Industrial Engineering (126)
- Keyword
-
- #antcenter (259)
- Machine learning (95)
- #csra (73)
- Algorithms (60)
- Kalman filtering (52)
-
- Computer networks--Security measures (51)
- Image processing (50)
- Neural networks (Computer science) (50)
- Computer security (47)
- Software engineering (47)
- Decision making (45)
- Target acquisition (45)
- Global Positioning System (44)
- Optimization (41)
- Adaptive optics (40)
- Neural networks (40)
- #ctisr (38)
- Remote sensing (36)
- Computer vision (35)
- Drone aircraft (35)
- Synthetic aperture radar (34)
- #afcec (33)
- Artificial intelligence (31)
- Atmospheric turbulence (30)
- Genetic algorithms (29)
- Mathematical optimization (29)
- Flight control (28)
- Object-oriented programming (Computer science) (28)
- Wireless communication systems (28)
- Deep learning (27)
- Publication Year
- Publication
- Publication Type
- File Type
Articles 2581 - 2610 of 5606
Full-Text Articles in Entire DC Network
Restoration Of Scene Information Reflected From Non-Specular Media, Mark G. Hoelscher
Restoration Of Scene Information Reflected From Non-Specular Media, Mark G. Hoelscher
Theses and Dissertations
A recently published experiment called dual photography exploits Helmholtz reciprocity by illuminating a scene with a pixilated light source and imaging other parts of that scene with a camera so that light transport between every pair of source-to-camera pixels is measured. The positions of the source and camera are then computationally interchanged to generate a dual image of the scene from the viewpoint of the source illuminated from the position of the camera. Although information from parts of the scene normally hidden from the camera are made available, this technique is rather contrived and therefore limited in practical applications since …
Tof-Sims For Rapid Nuclear Forensics Evaluation Of Uranium Oxide Particles, Hannah E. Hocking
Tof-Sims For Rapid Nuclear Forensics Evaluation Of Uranium Oxide Particles, Hannah E. Hocking
Theses and Dissertations
Because of nuclear proliferation concerns, nuclear material must be safeguarded, and peaceful intentions verified. The field of nuclear forensics addresses these concerns. While established nuclear forensic techniques exist, quicker, more accurate and less expensive methods are of interest for nonproliferation applications. Currently a host of different analytical techniques, requiring a week or longer, are employed to obtain isotopic ratios, chemical abundances and morphology for forensic particulate samples. Time-of-Flight Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) is a candidate technology for rapid evaluation of these properties for small amounts of nuclear materials. After a thorough investigation, this study found TOF-SIMS to be particularly …
Sensitivity Analysis Of Empirical Parameters In The Ionosphere-Plasmasphere Model, Janelle V. Jenniges
Sensitivity Analysis Of Empirical Parameters In The Ionosphere-Plasmasphere Model, Janelle V. Jenniges
Theses and Dissertations
A sensitivity analysis of empirical parameters used in physics-based models was completed in this study to determine their effect on electron densities and total electron content (TEC) in the ionosphere. The model used was the Ionosphere-Plasmasphere Model (IPM) developed by Utah State University. The empirical parameters studied include the O+/O collision frequency, zonal wind, secondary electron production, nighttime ExB drifts, and tidal structure. The sensitivity analysis was completed by comparing a default run of the IPM to a run with the parameter adjusted for three geophysical cases. Many of the comparisons resulted in nonlinear changes to the model …
Broadband Pumping Effects On The Diode Pumped Alkali Laser, Paul Nathaniel Jones
Broadband Pumping Effects On The Diode Pumped Alkali Laser, Paul Nathaniel Jones
Theses and Dissertations
This research seeks to gain greater insight on the mechanics of The Diode Pumped Alkali Laser through analytic modeling techniques. This work is an extension to a previous model developed by Dr. Gordon Hager, and focuses on the addition of pump-beam bandwidth. Specifically, it seeks to determine the effect that broadband pumping has on laser performance. The model incorporates all the fundamental parameters within the laser system, including alkali concentrations, collision partner concentrations, pump bandwidth, length and temperature of gain medium, transmission, and reflectivity. Baseline operating conditions set Rubidium (Rb) concentrations ranging from 1012 - 1014 atoms/cm3 …
Investigation Of Yag:Ce Scintillating Fiber Properties Using Silicon Photomultipliers, Bradley S. Jones
Investigation Of Yag:Ce Scintillating Fiber Properties Using Silicon Photomultipliers, Bradley S. Jones
Theses and Dissertations
The properties of thin, cerium activated, yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG:Ce), scintillating fiber-shaped crystals were investigated for particle tracking and calorimetric applications such as Compton imaging of Special Nuclear Material from remote platforms at standoff ranges. Silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) are relatively new, efficient, single photon sensitive, solid-state photodiode arrays which are well suited for the readout of scintillating fibers. Using SiPMs, the scintillation decay time profiles of six 400 µm YAG:Ce fiber crystals were measured under alpha and gamma irradiation. Interestingly, the observed decay times in the thin fibers were substantially slower than values for bulk single crystal YAG:Ce reported in …
Characterization Of Neutron-Induced Defects In Isotopically Enriched Lithium Tetraborate, Brant E. Kananen
Characterization Of Neutron-Induced Defects In Isotopically Enriched Lithium Tetraborate, Brant E. Kananen
Theses and Dissertations
Lithium Tetraborate (LTB) is assessed for use as a material for neutron detection. LTB isotopically enriched in either Li-6 or B-10 provides a medium that efficiently captures and transmutes neutrons into more readily detected forms of material or energy. Neutron detection is desirable to detect elicit movement of special nuclear material or nuclear weapons. Single crystals of LTB, Li-6 or B-10 enriched, were neutron irradiated, and electron paramagnetic resonance was used to detect point defects induced by the neutrons. Multiple defects were noted in the irradiated crystals. Two particular defects, perturbed lithium vacancies and lithium clusters are proposed as induced …
Investigation Of Gate Leakage Current In Nitrogen-Irradiated Algan/Gan Heterostructures, Rose E. May
Investigation Of Gate Leakage Current In Nitrogen-Irradiated Algan/Gan Heterostructures, Rose E. May
Theses and Dissertations
Due to commercial and government interest in devices capable of functioning in high-power, high-frequency space applications, radiation tolerant AlGaN/GaN devices have been under study in recent years. Passivation of the AlGaN surface by (Si3N4) prevents electron trapping and enhances the 2DEG, but it also increases gate leakage currents, which can lead to device failure. This study sought information about current leakage mechanisms by introducing displacement damage close to the Si3N4/AlGaN interface. The effects of irradiation damage around the Si3N4/AlGaN interface on irradiation-induced leakage current were investigated for three …
A Comparison In The Accuracy Of Mapping Nuclear Fallout Patterns Using Hpac, Hysplit, Delfic Fpt And An Afit Fortran95 Fallout Deposition Code, April D. Miller
A Comparison In The Accuracy Of Mapping Nuclear Fallout Patterns Using Hpac, Hysplit, Delfic Fpt And An Afit Fortran95 Fallout Deposition Code, April D. Miller
Theses and Dissertations
Four nuclear fallout mapping tools are studied to determine which tool predicts the most accurate fallout dose-rate contours with low computation time and resources. The four programs consist of the FORTRAN95 based Fallout Deposition Code (FDC), the Hazard Prediction and Assessment Capability's (HPAC) Nuclear Weapon (NWPN), the Defense Land Fallout Interpretative Code (DELFIC) Fallout Planning Tool (FPT) and the Hybrid Single-Particle Lagrangian Integrated Trajectory (HYSPLIT) Model. The models were compared to the Defense Nuclear Agency's (DNA) DNA 1251-1-EX, Compilation of Local Fallout Data from Test Detonations 1945-1962 Extracted from DASA 1251, using Warner and Platt's Measure of Effectiveness (MOE) method. …
Immediate And Delayed Drug Therapy Effects On Low Dose Sarin Exposed Mice Myocardial Performance, Joshua T. Miller
Immediate And Delayed Drug Therapy Effects On Low Dose Sarin Exposed Mice Myocardial Performance, Joshua T. Miller
Theses and Dissertations
Recent studies have shown that a single asymptomatic dose exposure to the nerve agent sarin can lead to long term cardiac dysfunction. This study looked at immediate and delayed treatment therapies post exposure on cardiac function. The mice were studied using electrocardiography (QTc, STc, and Tc intervals) and histological techniques (hematoxylin and eosin staining and brain natriuretic peptide (BNP) staining). Male C57BL/6J mice were injected with sarin (0.4LD50) and studied up to 11 weeks. Mice which were given a single dose of the nerve agent treatment atropine/2PAMCL, showed significantly higher cell size and BNP levels than the control (p = …
Analysis Of Plasma Bubble Signatures In The Ionosphere, Omar A. Nava
Analysis Of Plasma Bubble Signatures In The Ionosphere, Omar A. Nava
Theses and Dissertations
Plasma bubbles are large scale structures of depleted plasma density in Earth's ionosphere that disrupt radio and satellite communications, to include global navigation satellite systems. This study used the Ionospheric Forecast Model (IFM) to analyze affected look angles and total electron content (TEC) differences due to plasma bubbles of various sizes for 27 geophysical conditions consisting of different seasons and levels of solar and geomagnetic activity at 421 GPS ground stations worldwide. Overall, different geographic locations and plasma bubble configurations produced different affected look angle profiles. Bigger plasma bubbles, larger density depletion factors, higher levels of solar activity and the …
Combating Biological Terrorism From Imported Food, Jeffrey S. Nelson
Combating Biological Terrorism From Imported Food, Jeffrey S. Nelson
Theses and Dissertations
There is a threat that a terrorist or terrorist organization will use access to the US food supply to kill or sicken Americans by contaminating imported food products from Mexico. The food that Americans eat is coming more and more often from foreign countries such as Mexico. Foodborne diseases infect nearly fifty million people in the US each year, resulting in over three thousand deaths. There are many terrorist organizations that would like to deliberately contaminate American food. Drug cartels and terrorist organizations currently operate in Mexico, one of the leading food importers into the US. The purpose of this …
Cathodoluminescence Of Irradiated Hafnium Dioxide, Emily A. Purcell
Cathodoluminescence Of Irradiated Hafnium Dioxide, Emily A. Purcell
Theses and Dissertations
The purpose of this research is to understand the effect of radiation on HfO2 thin films, and to compare the quality of HfO2 thin films produced by both atomic layer deposition (ALD) and pulsed laser deposition (PLD); PLD samples had varying substrate temperatures during deposition (300°C, 500°C, and 750°C). The entirety of this research was conducted using cathodoluminescence (CL) as the examination method. The excitation source was a Kimball Physics EMG-12 electron gun. The photomultiplier tube contained a gallium arsenide photocathode. Measurements were made with beam energies ranging from 1 to 10 keV and beam currents ranging from …
Nuclear Weapon Yield Determination Through Nano Indentation Of Thermally Degraded Automobile Paint, Michael J. Richards
Nuclear Weapon Yield Determination Through Nano Indentation Of Thermally Degraded Automobile Paint, Michael J. Richards
Theses and Dissertations
This work investigated the suitability of automotive clearcoat as a nuclear weapon yield sensor, using the change in elastic modulus as the primary metric. The AFIT Xenon Thermal Simulator (AXTS) was used to simulate a nuclear thermal pulse. The elastic modulus of the clearcoat was measured using a nano indenter. During this research the power density of the AXTS beam was increased from 44.7 to 63.7 W/cm2. The morphological steps through which automobile paint proceeds as it thermally degrades were identified and correlated with temperatures. A computer model was created and used to ensure that the paint’s time-temperature …
Integration Of A Worldwide Atmospheric Based Model With A Live Virtual Constructive Simulation Environment, David B. Simmons
Integration Of A Worldwide Atmospheric Based Model With A Live Virtual Constructive Simulation Environment, David B. Simmons
Theses and Dissertations
Yearly DoD spends millions of dollars on Modeling and Simulation tools in order to accomplish two fundamental tasks: make better decisions and develop better skills. Simulators that are based on realistic models enable the USAF to properly train, educate, and employ military forces. LEEDR is an atmospheric model based on worldwide historic weather data that is able to predict the extinction, absorption, and scattering of radiation across a broad range of the electromagnetic spectrum. Through this study LEEDR models the propagation of 1.0642 micron laser radiation at worldwide locations and through various environmental conditions. This modeled laser transmission output, based …
Branch Point Mitigation Of Thermal Blooming Phase Compensation Instability, Mark F. Spencer
Branch Point Mitigation Of Thermal Blooming Phase Compensation Instability, Mark F. Spencer
Theses and Dissertations
Thermal blooming can have a major impact on high-energy laser (HEL) beam propagation in the atmosphere. In theory, an adaptiveoptics (AO) system can mitigate the nonlinear optical effects induced by thermal blooming; however, when a single deformable mirror is used for phase-only compensation, analysis predicts the possibility of instability. This instability is appropriately termed phase compensation instability (PCI) and arises with the time-dependent development of spatial perturbations found within the HEL beam. These spatial perturbations act as local hot spots that produce negative-lens-like optical effects in the atmosphere. An AO system corrects for the hot spots by applying positive-lens-like phase …
Positron Annihilation Ratio Spectroscopy Study Of Electric Fields Applied To Positronium At Material Interfaces, Ariella C. Walker
Positron Annihilation Ratio Spectroscopy Study Of Electric Fields Applied To Positronium At Material Interfaces, Ariella C. Walker
Theses and Dissertations
The purpose of this research was to develop a new code to analyze the data from AFIT's positron annihilation of radiation spectrometer, PsARS, system. The PsARS was used to analyze positronium formation at the surface of a capillary tube coated with gold. Using energy and geometry filters, the PsARS code determined the ratio of ortho-positronium to para-positronium. An electric field applied across the capillary tube wall forced positrons to move towards the gold surface of the capillary tube and prevent them from dropping into the Ore gap before they reach the surface. Inside the Ore gap, the positrons are more …
Optical And Electrical Characterization Melt-Grown Bulk Ingaas And Inasp, Jean W. Wei
Optical And Electrical Characterization Melt-Grown Bulk Ingaas And Inasp, Jean W. Wei
Theses and Dissertations
A new method to determine semiconductor bandgap energy directly from the easily measured transmission spectra was developed. The method was verified using many binary semiconductors with known properties and utilized to determine the unknown ternary semiconductors were determined at various wavelengths and temperatures. Photoluminescence and Hall-effect measurement were performed to identify various electronic transitions, as well as sample quality. The determination of electrical and optical properties of the material will provide important addition to the database of material properties for future optoelectronic device applications. In the near future, newer materials and their applications need to be developed, and often binary …
Adaptive Imaging Methods Using A Rotating Modulation Collimator (Rmc), Daniel T. Willcox
Adaptive Imaging Methods Using A Rotating Modulation Collimator (Rmc), Daniel T. Willcox
Theses and Dissertations
The Rotating Modulation Collimator (RMC) belongs to a larger class of radiation imaging systems that rely on either temporal or spatial modulation of incident radiation through collimation to map the location of the incident radiation source. The strengths of these detection systems include their low cost and simplicity. A major drawback is the collection time required for low radiation intensities due especially to the loss of radiation information resulting from collimation. One method of addressing this drawback for the RMC is by applying an adaptive imaging approach. As with most system design theory, there are inherent design tradeoffs for the …
An Analytical Model Of Nanometer Scale Viscoelastic Properties Of Polymer Surfaces Measured Using An Atomic Force Microscope, Jacob B. Goldberg
An Analytical Model Of Nanometer Scale Viscoelastic Properties Of Polymer Surfaces Measured Using An Atomic Force Microscope, Jacob B. Goldberg
Theses and Dissertations
The United States Air Force and the Department of Defense is increasingly interested in nanomaterials. To study these materials, one needs to measure the mechanics of materials on the nanoscale. Over the past few decades the atomic force microscope (AFM) has been used in various methods to establish local surface properties at the nanoscale. In particular, surface elasticity measurements are crucial to understanding nanoscale surface properties. Problems arise, however, when measuring soft surfaces such as polymers and biological specimens, because these materials have a more complex viscoelastic response. This research focuses on modeling an AFM dynamic nanoindentation experiment intended to …
Modeling Of Bacillus Spores: Inactivation And Outgrowth, Alexis X. Hurst
Modeling Of Bacillus Spores: Inactivation And Outgrowth, Alexis X. Hurst
Theses and Dissertations
This research models and analyzes the thermochemical damage produced in Bacillus spores by short, high-temperature exposures as well the repair process within damaged Bacillus spores. Thermochemical damage in spores is significantly due to reaction with water, hydrolysis reactions. Applying heat to the spore causes absorbed and chemically bound water molecules become mobile within the spore. These mobile water molecules react by hydrolysis reactions to degrade DNA and enzyme molecules in the spore. In order to survive the thermal inactivation, the spore must repair the damaged DNA during spore germination. The DNA repair process, as well as other germination functions, is …
Comparison Of Development Test And Evaluation And Overall Program Estimate At Completion, William R. Rosado
Comparison Of Development Test And Evaluation And Overall Program Estimate At Completion, William R. Rosado
Theses and Dissertations
Historically, cost growth regression models analyze aggregate, program-level information. Initiatives by the Office of Secretary of Defense, Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation (OSD CAPE) require direct, centralized reporting of the complete Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) Earned Value (EV) data. Centralized reporting allows access to unfiltered, unaltered, EV data for multiple programs. Using regression, we evaluate if WBS element Development Test and Evaluation (DT&E) EV data is related to program estimate at completion (EAC). Identifying a relationship provides evidence validating pertinence and reliability of low level EV data. Additionally, a relationship between a specific WBS element and program EAC establishes a …
Utilizing Social Network Analysis In Support Of Nation Building, Brandon J. Bernardoni
Utilizing Social Network Analysis In Support Of Nation Building, Brandon J. Bernardoni
Theses and Dissertations
Social network analysis is a powerful set of techniques used by social scientists to study the formal and informal interrelations in a community. Since 9/11 these techniques have been increasingly utilized by the defense and intelligence communities to analyze terrorist networks to aid in thwarting our foes. This study investigates the use of social networks and structural holes to facilitate nation building in failed and failing states. Investigation of the underlying social structure of a community, identifying st ructural holes and gaps within the government, Security Stabilization Transition and Reconstruction Operations (SSTRO) efforts can be focused to strengthen the host …
Optimizing Ground Times For Amc Aircraft In Afghanistan, Eric W. Bucheit Jr.
Optimizing Ground Times For Amc Aircraft In Afghanistan, Eric W. Bucheit Jr.
Theses and Dissertations
This research provides insight into the cargo unloading and loading process and times at three airfields in Afghanistan. Using a linear regression model and its prediction capability, a more stabilized environment is produced. This uses the times from seven historical months of continuous operations in Afghanistan and uses this information for the prediction expressions. Using this model, no throughput is lowered and early and late times are lowered by an average of seven minutes per mission. Over the course of a month, this increases planning stability by 74.1 hours. This not only impacts the planning at the downrange location, but …
A Simulation Of The Ecss Help Desk With The Erlang A Model, Michael E. Chua
A Simulation Of The Ecss Help Desk With The Erlang A Model, Michael E. Chua
Theses and Dissertations
During steady states, the Level 1 help desk might expect about 500 to 600 calls per month. That is about 0.39 to 0.46 calls per user per month, which represents the workload once ECSS is established and most of the users have already received training for the system. The optimal level for this workload is about 12 agents to operate the entire 24 hour period. At this level, the Level 1 help desk would minimize the amount of customers that renege from the system to about 15 to 22 percent and still maintain acceptable utilization percentages of about 52% to …
Metric Development For Continuous Process Improvement, Mark A. Degenhardt
Metric Development For Continuous Process Improvement, Mark A. Degenhardt
Theses and Dissertations
Air Force Smart Operations for the 21st Century (AFSO21) is not currently being used as effectively as it could be across the Air Force. Instead of trying to simply save money here or cut man-hours there, AFSO21 tools should be used to help the Air Force "fly, fight and win" better. the Air Force Institute of Technology (AFIT) has developed a methodology to identify specific target areas where continuous process improvement, i.e., AFSO21, can be applied to improve the bottom line of an organization. the first step of this process is to solicit the key performance indicators (KPIs) that best …
Determining Pilot Manning For Bomber Longevity, Jason S. Hamilton
Determining Pilot Manning For Bomber Longevity, Jason S. Hamilton
Theses and Dissertations
In support of US Air Force efforts to conserve resources without sacrificing capability, this research examines the question of whether the 509th Bomb Wing could continue to provide maximum combat capability with fewer assigned pilots. During peacetime, pilot proficiency training comprises the majority of annual flying hours for the small B-2 bomber fleet. Optimal pilot manning will decrease the accumulation of excess wear on the airframes; helping to extend the viable life of the B-2 fleet and preserve the deterrent and combat capabilities that it provides to the United States. The operations and maintenance activity flows for B-2 aircraft and …
A Methodology Using Simulation Results For Test And Evaluation, Jonathon S. Hosket
A Methodology Using Simulation Results For Test And Evaluation, Jonathon S. Hosket
Theses and Dissertations
Each year the Air Force spends billions of dollars on Test and Evaluation to ensure acquisition programs roll out the best possible products. In 1997, the National Research Council assembled to evaluate the overall procedure used in procuring various platforms with system planning, research, development and engineering (SPRDE) and program management (PM) processes. In their final report, they claimed that the full advantages of statistical practices, simulation, model-test-models, and incorporation of prior test information into current test practices have not been fully utilized. To examine one of the report's recommendations, this thesis defines and explores a methodology using simulation to …
Optimal Ch-47 And C-130 Workload Balance, Dustin P. Jones
Optimal Ch-47 And C-130 Workload Balance, Dustin P. Jones
Theses and Dissertations
The Air Force can save thousands of dollars by reducing the number of blade hours on the CH-47 through finding an optimal mixture of CH-47s and C-130s to conduct current operations in Afghanistan and Iraq. Ultimately these savings will relieve maintenance operations for the CH-47 and lengthen the lifespan of the CH-47 airframe. Moreover, incorporating C-130s into the operations will reduce cargo transit time from supply depots. This study looks at the involvement of the C-130 in CH-47 airlift operations to reduce CH-47 usage and increase supply efficiency. The research focus is narrowed to current airlift operations in Afghanistan and …
Measure Of Effectiveness For Jstars Ground Moving Target Indicator: A Value Focused Thinking Approach, Gardner J. Joyner
Measure Of Effectiveness For Jstars Ground Moving Target Indicator: A Value Focused Thinking Approach, Gardner J. Joyner
Theses and Dissertations
As the nature of warfare has shifted from a conventional approach to more guerilla type warfare, intelligence has become more important than at any other time in the history of the United States Military. With the stochastic nature of intelligence gathering, it is almost impossible to know with any degree of certainty where and when the next piece of information that could possibly change the course of the battle or war will be obtained. US intelligence gathering assets have long been plagued with using useless measures of performance rather than measures of effectiveness to determine their worth. This research uses …
Multi Criteria Decision Support Model For The Turkish Air Force Personnel Course/Education Planning System, Cem Malyemez
Multi Criteria Decision Support Model For The Turkish Air Force Personnel Course/Education Planning System, Cem Malyemez
Theses and Dissertations
Many personnel are assigned to different courses and educational opportunities in the Turkish Air Force every year. This daunting process requires a great deal of time and does not currently seek to find an optimal solution. The Turkish Air Force has a database for all personnel information, but the officials use just a few quantitative personnel data points to complete their tasks. Moreover, the matching process is done by hand. Therefore there is a need for a model, which supports the Decision Makers, to cover the some of the other quantitative data points and also add some qualitative data for …