Digital Commons Network^™

Toward A Dynamic View Of Corporate Purpose, Dorothy S. Lund

Faculty Scholarship

Scholars debating the corporation’s role in society generally advance the view that there is only one desirable orientation for corporations and their management. Specifically, proponents of a stakeholder governance model contend that focusing management on a broad set of corporate constituents maximizes overall welfare, while advocates of a shareholder-centric directive counter that prioritizing shareholders creates social welfare by rendering the firm most profitable. This Article offers another view: It suggests that the welfare-maximizing purpose for corporations could change depending on external economic conditions, which both of these positions assume away. Specifically, shareholder primacy is likely to promote welfare in a …

Restating The Law Of Children And Youth: The Evolution Of Reform, Elizabeth S. Scott

Faculty Scholarship

A brief roadmap of this article may be helpful. Part I describes the emergence of the Child Wellbeing framework and its powerful role in shaping twenty-first-century youth justice reforms captured by the Restatement. Part II shows how this framework has begun to have a far broader influence on the law affecting children and how the framework and the developmental approach embodied in the Restatement can guide courts and shape the trajectory of the law in the future. Part III explores potential challenges to the Restatement’s effectiveness in attaining a fully integrated system based on the Child Wellbeing framework.

The Imposition Of Constitutional Rights, Alvin Padilla-Babilonia

Faculty Publications

One of the central principles of constitutionalism is that citizenship stands for equal rights under the law. According to this ideal, a U.S. citizen living in Puerto Rico or Guam should have the same constitutional rights as a citizen living on the mainland. However, throughout U.S. history, constitutional rights have been neither uniform nor centralized. While constitutional rights held im- portance, they coexisted with ideals of democratic self-governance and legal pluralism. Today, Supreme Court justices and legal scholars argue that all constitutional rights should apply in the territories. This view upholds citizenship, equal rights, and the rule of law. But …

تحول سياسات العقاب والإصلاح للأحداث في دولة الإمارات: دراسة مقارنة لقانون اتحادي رقم 9 لسنة 1976 بشأن الاحداث الجانحين والمشردين وقانون اتحادي رقم 6 لسنة 2022 بشأن الاحداث الجانحين والمعرضين للجنوح, Hamda Abdulla Almahri

Theses

The Transformation of Juvenile Punishment and Reform Policies in the United Arab Emirates: A Comparative Study of a Federal Law No. 9 of 1976 Regarding Juvenile Delinquents and Vagrants, and Federal Law No. 6 of 2022 Regarding Juvenile Delinquents and those at Risk of Delinquency

This study explores the concept of juvenile criminal responsibility under Federal Law No. (6) of 2022 in the United Arab Emirates, which restructured the legal framework for dealing with juvenile offenders and those at risk of delinquency in line with social developments and international standards. The research focused on analyzing the legal foundations of juvenile …

Do Bans On Conversion Therapy Impose A Governmental "Orthodoxy" About Sex And Gender?, Linda C. Mcclain

Faculty Scholarship

In Part I, this Essay evaluates how orthodoxy arguments featured in Mr. Tingley’s challenge to Washington’s ban on conversion therapy. Part II offers a preliminary analysis of Chiles v. Salazar, ⁴² which the Court will hear during its 2025-2026 Term. I illustrate how the arguments made against Washington’s law by Chiles and her amici draw from the anti-orthodoxy and marketplace of ideas rhetoric found not only in Justice Thomas’s Tingley dissent and his NIFLA opinion but also in Justice Gorsuch’s majority opinion in the 303 Creative decision.⁴³ Woven together with these speech arguments are appeals to the Court’s …

Antiracist Expert Evidence, Jasmine Gonzales Rose, Asees Bhasin, Spencer Piston

Faculty Scholarship

Since 2020, when mass protests against racism swept across the United States, scholars, lawyers, and the general public have become increasingly aware that racism permeates society and the criminal legal system, from overt racial animus to the nuanced effects of structural racism. Demonstrating the influence of racism is therefore vital to the practice of criminal defense, yet many attorneys do not know how to prove racism in court. We surveyed over seven hundred criminal-defense attorneys across the United States, and nearly half had never heard of expert witnesses testifying or submitting written reports on racism—what we call “antiracist expert evidence.” …

“The Gun’S Not Mine!”: The Admissibility Of Defendants’ Exculpatory Hearsay Statements Under Federal Rules Of Evidence 803(2) & (3), Faustino S. Galante

Fordham Law Review Online

Exculpatory hearsay statements made by criminal defendants often warrant admission under the Federal Rules of Evidence (FRE) as excited utterances, under Rule 803(2), or as statements reflecting a then-existing state of mind, under Rule 803(3). Nevertheless, defendants often struggle to have their exculpatory statements admitted pursuant to these rules—even when those statements fulfill their categorical requirements.

This Comment surveys the different approaches courts take to determine whether exculpatory hearsay statements made by criminal defendants are admissible under Rules 803(2) and (3). It argues that courts too often misapply these rules to exclude defendants’ exculpatory statements. In particular, courts counteract the …

An Electoral College Compromise Constitutional Amendment: Bridging Partisan Divides To Improve Presidential Elections, John Rogan

Fordham Law Review Online

Abolishing the Electoral College in favor of using a national popular vote to elect the president and vice president is unlikely to attract sufficient bipartisan support to reach the high thresholds for amending the U.S. Constitution. However, the Electoral College has flawed features that both Democrats and Republicans might support reforming because those defects can undermine either party’s candidates. This Essay highlights three such defects. First, contingent elections—a process by which Congress selects the president and vice president if no ticket wins a majority of electoral votes—are deeply unrepresentative of the American electorate while also being subject to unpredictable dysfunction …

Evaluating The Ncaa’S Responsiveness To Tampering In The Nil Era, Josh Lens

Fordham Law Review Online

Recent and significant changes in college athletics have led to an increase in the number of athletes who transfer between universities. This requires college coaches to expend significant effort retaining key athletes, especially in the face of widespread “tampering”—recruiting athletes enrolled at other universities who are not in the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) transfer portal. Despite NCAA rules explicitly forbidding it, coaches have been outspoken regarding the prevalence of tampering, with some going so far as to publicly beg the NCAA to more strictly enforce its anti-tampering rules.

This Essay scrutinizes whether the oft-maligned NCAA has been responsive to …

Dei Newsletter 2025 Volume 3 Issue 2, University Of Maine School Of Law

DEI Newsletter

• MAPIL Auction
• Public Interest Law Certificate
• Recent events hosted by Maine Law student organizations
• Resources for Understanding the Current State of DEI
• Introducing the 2025-2026 CO&I Fellow
• Heritage month celebrations
• Living Room Library

The Current Development Of U.S. Copyright Law In Light Of The Current Political Situation And Of The Interests Of Major Stakeholders, Marketa Trimble

Media & Informal Publications

Professor Trimble delivered a presentation at the Law Faculty of Charles University in Prague, the Czech Republic.

Problems Facing The Concert Ticketing Industry: Examining Foreign Laws And What The Us Can Learn From Them, Samuel Baker

Loyola of Los Angeles Entertainment Law Review

No abstract provided.

The Gilded Approach: A Critique Of Constitutional Originalism, Banks T. Eidson

Honors College Theses

The method from which we approach Constitutional interpretation would obviously hold a great deal of significance in our government structure, yet the modern judiciary is plagued by a constant debate between Living Constitutionalism and Originalism. The latter of these ideas has become rather prominent amongst the justices, with six of the nine current Supreme Court justices being self-proclaimed practitioners of originalism. An idea which portrays itself as the only logical way to approach a Constitution, this thesis seeks to prove that despite its popularity, originalism is little more than a tool to expand conservative policies within the courts in precisely …

Cjcr Publishes Volume 26, Issue 2 (Symposium 2024), Jane Perov

Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution (CJCR) Blog

The Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution—the country’s preeminent legal journal of arbitration, negotiation, mediation, settlement, and restorative justice—today published the web edition of Volume 26, Issue 2 (Symposium 2024). The print edition of the issue has also been released.

Accessible at Volume 26.2: Symposium 2024, this issue contains Remarks by Lady Justice Joyce Alouch; Articles by Zachary R. Calo, Diego Faleck, Nokukhanya Ntuli, and Nancy A. Welsh; and Notes by Peri Ayzidor, Jared Man, Yakov Schwalb, and Bayla Zohn.

The print edition of the issue has also been released. This post was originally published on the Cardozo Journal of Conflict …

Exploring Education Policy And Resources In Virginia Secondary Education, Gabrielle Lyon

Departmental Honors & Graduate Capstone Projects

The study examines the intersection of federal special education policy within Virginia's secondary schools, specifically focusing on teachers’ compliance with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The study explores educators' awareness and usage of the Virginia Department of Education's hearing decisions index, which documents IDEA violations and due process decisions. Through analyzing federal education legislation, state implementation practices, and teacher perspectives, this study reveals critical gaps in educator preparation and resource awareness regarding special education policy compliance. The findings suggest that while the IDEA violations are being tracked and documented, there remains a significant disconnect between available resources and …

The Revolving Door Of Industry Standards, Zachary Kester, Spencer Rehn

St. Mary's Law Journal

No abstract provided.

Mitigating Discrimination By Businesses: Adopting A "Substantial Amount Of Expression" Test In The Wake Of The Court's 303 Creative Decision, Caleb Kunde

St. Mary's Law Journal

The Supreme Court’s recent decision in 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis[1] balanced Colorado’s anti-discrimination public accommodations law and its burden on a website designer’s right to be free from compelled speech.[2] Choosing to hold for the website designer, the Court decided that Ms. Smith was free to refuse her wedding website service to same-sex couples.[3] Put another way, the Court’s decision granted businesses that are open to the public a license to discriminate through the Free Speech Clause. Not only is this the first time that a business’s First Amendment rights overrode a public accommodations law’s compelling …

De-Weaponizing Snap Removal, Philip Weiss

St. Mary's Law Journal

No abstract provided.

Dynamics Of The Penitentiary System, Transparent And Accountable Handling Of Criminal Cases In Criminal Execution Law In Southeast Asia: Convergence And Divergence Of International Perspectives, Anis Widyawati, Ade Adhari, Ali Masyhar, Bearlly Deo Syahputra, Didik Purnomo

Indonesia Law Review

This research examines the dynamics of the penitentiary system transparent, and accountable criminal case handling in criminal execution law in Southeast Asia, focusing on the convergence and divergence of international perspectives. These countries have diverse approaches to the penitentiary system and criminal law enforcement, including in terms of the implementation of the death penalty and the treatment of prisoners. Some countries, such as Singapore and Malaysia, maintain strict death penalty practices, which often contradict international human rights standards, while others such as the Philippines show inconsistencies in implementing criminal execution laws. This research also examines the three main stages in …

Application Of The New York Convention To International Investment Arbitration Awards: An Analysis From The Perspectives Of Indonesia And China, Luo Yuan Yuan

Indonesia Law Review

Since the 21st century, as countries have increasingly engaged in international economic activities, the economic ties between nations and regions have grown progressively closer, and cross-border investments have surged. Consequently, investment disputes, which often accompany these investments, have emerged as a critical issue that cannot be overlooked by host governments and foreign investors. Currently, the predominant method for resolving investment disputes is through international arbitration. Therefore, the enforcement of investment arbitration awards has become a key indicator of the effectiveness of the dispute resolution mechanism. A significant area of concern and research is whether the New York Convention can be …

Opportunities And Challenges Of Land Sale And Purchase Agreement Transactions In The Digital Era In Indonesia, Sanusi Sanusi, Bha’Iq Roza Rakhmatullah, Erwin Aditya Pratama, Fajar Dian Aryani, Muhammad Wildan

Indonesia Law Review

In this digital era, technology has changed many aspects of life. Land purchase agreements in Indonesia, which were previously carried out conventionally, have begun to shift to digital platforms. Digitalization in land purchase agreements offers various opportunities, but this process also has a number of challenges that need to be overcome to ensure that land purchase transactions can be carried out efficiently and safely, providing legal protection to buyers. The formulation of the problem in this study is how the challenges and opportunities of land purchase agreement transactions in the digital era in Indonesia and how legal protection is provided …

The Role Of Race In Howard Law School's Rankings, Michael Conklin

St. Mary's Law Journal

No abstract provided.

Newport Manual On The Law Of Naval Warfare, Second Edition, Newport Manual Expert Group

International Law Studies

The Newport Manual on the Law of Naval Warfare, Second Edition, is a continuing effort to restate the law of naval warfare as a purely lex lata exercise. Like the first edition of 2023, it is designed to provide a practical guide for commanders and seafarers, lawyers and officials, and educators and students. In doing so, the Manual includes developments in warfighting technologies in recent decades, which have significantly influenced the nature of war at sea. This second edition has been edited by four of the original authors following an extensive review and revision process.

Human Rights For The Twenty-First Century, Marcus Moore

All Faculty Publications

In this article, I explore the way that traditionally dominant conceptions of human rights have been rendered inadequate in the 21st century through the example of contemporary threats to the freedom of thought arising from the Information Revolution. The sequence of the article is: an initial section provides background on freedom of thought as one of the most fundamental but overlooked of human rights, and reflects on the myriad ways in which it is imperiled by processes enabled or amplified by the current Age of Information. I then draw on this example to demonstrate why it is vital to move …

Breaking The Pipeline: Exploring Exclusionary Discipline, Restorative Justice, And The Attitudes And Beliefs Of Educators, Ericka J. Varnedoe

Honors College Theses

This study explores the connection between exclusionary disciplinary practices and the school-to-prison pipeline. It highlights how exclusionary discipline, including suspensions and expulsions, disproportionately affects marginalized groups such as students of color, students with disabilities, and LGBTQ youth, further contributing to the school-to-prison pipeline. In contrast, restorative justice, a non-punitive approach, offers a promising alternative. Initially adopted from the criminal justice system, restorative justice has been integrated into school environments to foster positive school climates, improve experiences, and mitigate challenging behaviors. This research examines educators' attitudes toward both exclusionary and restorative practices, as well as their awareness and implementation of restorative …

Codetermination’S Moment Of Truth: Overseas Workers, Jens Dammann

BYU Law Review

The idea that employees of large corporations should be entitled to representation on corporate boards, a concept known as codetermination, is gaining ground. Progressive politicians Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders have proposed codetermination regimes that would allow employees to elect between 40% and 45% of board members. Moreover, an increasing number of corporate law scholars are embracing the idea of giving employees a voice in corporate governance.

However, anyone endorsing codetermination must confront a critical dilemma: whether to limit representation to U.S.-based employees or whether to extend it to overseas workers as well. The question’s practical importance is obvious given …

They Managed A Protest: Prohibitory, Ethical, And Prudential Policing Of Academic Speech, David Schraub

BYU Law Review

No abstract provided.

Papering Justices, Michael L. Smith

BYU Law Review

Supreme Court reform is a lively topic of discussion and debate, with scholars, commentators, and politicians debating a variety of proposed Court reforms, such as term limits, additional Justices, and jurisdiction stripping. This Article adds a new idea to the mix: papering Justices. Several states permit each side to a dispute to file one motion to automatically disqualify the judge overseeing their case. These requests are to be granted automatically without any showing of facts, hearings, or further briefing. This is known as “papering” the judge. Drawing from these practices, I propose that each side to a dispute before the …

Artificial Intelligence, Autonomous Creation, And The Future Path Of Copyright Law, Peter K. Yu

BYU Law Review

Most literature at the intersection of copyright and artificial intelligence (AI) has focused primarily on what copyright law is or ought to be. Frequently overlooked is the question of what copyright law will be in the AI space. Understanding this question is crucial because the path of copyright law chosen by the United States will have a major impact on the country’s economic and technological future. This Article begins by scrutinizing two lines of arguments that have been advanced to deny copyright protection to AI-generated works: constitutional and incentivebased. The Article then discusses a third line of arguments— harmonization-based arguments—and …

The Emperor’S New Clothes And § 502(B)’S Unmatured Interest Rule, Jacob M. Hansen

BYU Law Review

When it comes to claims for unmatured interest—most notoriously make-whole provisions—the text of the Bankruptcy Code does not necessarily say what everyone says it does. The common interpretation is that the Code requires courts to disallow all claims for unmatured interest except those involving an oversecured creditor. This Note presents an alternative reading that resolves conflicts within the Code, moves away from unreliable legislative history, and reconciles circuit splits on the enforceability of make-whole provisions and unmatured interest claims in general. As discussed in this Note, this alternative reading is the more accurate one—especially from a textualist perspective.

Due to …