Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Institution
-
- Brigham Young University Law School (27100)
- University of Michigan Law School (8664)
- Duke Law (5465)
- Fordham Law School (5367)
- Northwestern Pritzker School of Law (4844)
-
- Maurer School of Law: Indiana University (4443)
- William & Mary Law School (4359)
- Yeshiva University, Cardozo School of Law (4116)
- Southern Methodist University (4102)
- University of Chicago Law School (3709)
- Vanderbilt University Law School (3660)
- University of Minnesota Law School (3596)
- UC Law SF (3532)
- Washington and Lee University School of Law (3435)
- University of North Carolina School of Law (3412)
- University of Oklahoma College of Law (3382)
- Notre Dame Law School (3258)
- Case Western Reserve University School of Law (3090)
- Cornell University Law School (3062)
- American University Washington College of Law (3045)
- University of Missouri School of Law (2950)
- Louisiana State University Law Center (2848)
- University of Washington School of Law (2720)
- University of Colorado Law School (2606)
- University of South Carolina (2536)
- Seton Hall University (2458)
- University of Kentucky (2426)
- University of Richmond (2380)
- Columbia Law School (2345)
- University at Buffalo School of Law (2267)
- Keyword
-
- Law (2283)
- Constitutional law (1759)
- Supreme Court (1521)
- Constitutional Law (1502)
- Criminal law (1253)
-
- Jurisprudence (1232)
- Evidence (1211)
- Discrimination (1206)
- First Amendment (1186)
- United States Supreme Court (1186)
- Constitution (1125)
- International law (1025)
- Copyright (977)
- Privacy (916)
- Torts (902)
- Courts (890)
- United States (889)
- Regulation (886)
- Legislation (864)
- Human rights (854)
- Jurisdiction (837)
- International Law (818)
- Criminal justice (815)
- Contracts (813)
- Ethics (810)
- Due process (795)
- Judicial review (786)
- Civil rights (785)
- Federalism (774)
- Antitrust (769)
- Publication Year
- Publication
-
- Faculty Scholarship (9169)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (1996–2006) (6082)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (through 1995) (5842)
- Articles (5688)
- Michigan Law Review (4186)
-
- Faculty Publications (3974)
- Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (3807)
- Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– 2019) (3460)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (through 1999) (3155)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (2000–2020) (2528)
- Louisiana Law Review (2403)
- Fordham Law Review (2390)
- North Carolina Law Review (2358)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (cases filed before 1965) (2181)
- Indiana Law Journal (2107)
- American Indian and Alaskan Native Documents in the Congressional Serial Set: 1817-1899 (2044)
- Utah Supreme Court Briefs (1965 –) (1976)
- SMU Law Review (1972)
- Vanderbilt Law Review (1872)
- Minnesota Law Review, Vols. 1-106:1 (1917-2021) (1705)
- Law and Contemporary Problems (1683)
- Notre Dame Law Review (1675)
- West Virginia Law Review (1656)
- Kentucky Law Journal (1654)
- Washington and Lee Law Review (1643)
- Washington Law Review (1627)
- Scholarly Works (1590)
- Cornell Law Review (1538)
- Cardozo Law Review (1524)
- Missouri Law Review (1522)
- Publication Type
Articles 1621 - 1650 of 220592
Full-Text Articles in Entire DC Network
Boggs V. Johnston Asphalt, Llc, 334 A.3d 965 (R.I. 2025)., Gracie May Mccall
Boggs V. Johnston Asphalt, Llc, 334 A.3d 965 (R.I. 2025)., Gracie May Mccall
Roger Williams University Law Review
No abstract provided.
Dignity By Design: A Human-Centered Framework For Ethical Ai, Armin Tadayon
Dignity By Design: A Human-Centered Framework For Ethical Ai, Armin Tadayon
Washington and Lee Journal of Civil Rights and Social Justice
The launch of ChatGPT in November 2022 has triggered a global arms race–both among private technology companies and between nation states–for dominance in the field of Artificial Intelligence (AI). If this nascent technology, which is permeating every aspect of our lives as more companies across multiple sectors deploy it for a variety of functions, malfunctions or behaves in unanticipated ways, it can severely affect individuals in their day-to-day lives with broader consequences for society at large. As such, as AI permeates every aspect of our lives, and in some instances, begins to replace humans and human decision-making, it is imperative …
Chevron Deference, Prospective Gay Parents, And The Need For A Centralized Child Welfare System, Mantas Grigorovicius
Chevron Deference, Prospective Gay Parents, And The Need For A Centralized Child Welfare System, Mantas Grigorovicius
Washington and Lee Journal of Civil Rights and Social Justice
For over four decades, Chevron deference allowed federal agencies to exercise considerable discretion in interpreting laws, enabling them to implement broad regulatory agendas. This deference was pivotal for administrative agencies, such as the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), in shaping public policy. However, in 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court decided to overturn this precedent, shifting power from agencies to courts and potentially reshaping the regulatory landscape. This Article examines the implications of this change within the context of child welfare, focusing on HHS’s role in foster care. As states often rely on taxpayer-funded private child-placing agencies to …
Imprisoned Without A Verdict: The Constitutional Crisis Of Pre-Trial Solitary Confinement, Symone R. Gibbs
Imprisoned Without A Verdict: The Constitutional Crisis Of Pre-Trial Solitary Confinement, Symone R. Gibbs
Washington and Lee Journal of Civil Rights and Social Justice
Kalief Browder’s name endures as a chilling reminder of the human cost of pre-trial solitary confinement. His story reveals the constitutional paradox and moral failure at the heart of this practice: Individuals who remain legally innocent are subjected to one of the harshest punishments the state can impose. This practice strips people of their liberty twice over, first through incarceration itself, and again through prolonged isolation that inflicts devastating psychological harm. Despite its severity, the use of solitary confinement against pre-trial detainees remains largely overlooked in legal scholarship and reform, even as it undermines the presumption of innocence, exacerbates systemic …
The Broken Promise Of The Idea: How Delays And Disparities Undermine Special Education Rights, Silvia C. Montiel Morales
The Broken Promise Of The Idea: How Delays And Disparities Undermine Special Education Rights, Silvia C. Montiel Morales
Washington and Lee Journal of Civil Rights and Social Justice
The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) was enacted to guarantee children with disabilities the right to a free appropriate public education. In practice, that promise is too often broken. Students, especially those from low-income families and communities of color, wait months or years for evaluations, attend underfunded schools that lack qualified staff, and face systemic barriers to enforcing their rights. Meanwhile, families with resources can sidestep delays through private testing, attorneys, and advocacy, leaving others behind. This Note examines how systemic delays, underfunding, and inequities in special education services undermine children’s rights under the statute. It argues that these …
Toys As Evidence, Randall K. Johnson
Toys As Evidence, Randall K. Johnson
Faculty Works
This Essay asks and answers a single question, which was posed during a recent symposium at the National Museum of Toys & Miniatures. Could the study of revealed preferences, which is the idea that observed behaviors are the best indicator of one’s beliefs, improve our collective understanding about what constitutes unlawful discrimination in certain U.S. markets? A possible answer, which is informed by the Brown v. Board of Education decision, is the study of revealed preferences may improve our collective understanding for three reasons.
One reason is the study of revealed preferences provides a window into how some producers and …
Revolutionizing The Cross-Border Payment System, Muhui Shi
Revolutionizing The Cross-Border Payment System, Muhui Shi
Michigan Technology Law Review
When you bought your coffee this morning, you probably didn’t notice that many cross-border payments were hidden in the process of shipping beans in Ethiopia to the barista in your neighborhood. Comprising more than ten percent of what U.S. consumers spend, cross-border payments are an essential part of U.S. dollar dominance and commercial competitiveness. Yet, the outdated cross-border payment system—shrinking constantly in reach and struggling with structural changes—is demanding a complete upgrade.
What is the best path forward? Cryptocurrencies? E-money? Stablecoins? Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs)? In this article, I answer the question by uncovering the core needs of the …
Regulating Ai Beyond Product Liability, Shruti Trikanad
Regulating Ai Beyond Product Liability, Shruti Trikanad
Michigan Technology Law Review
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is being used by governments across the world to enforce regulatory mandates, adjudicate benefits and privileges, predict and analyze risks, and much more. Although this has significant potential to increase efficiency and responsiveness, it also comes with several risks of transparency, government accountability, and the amplification of discrimination and bias. It is crucial we oversee and regulate these AI systems effectively. This essay argues against the models that current regulatory frameworks are adopting to govern AI use: those resembling product liability.
Through the lens of the European Union's AI Act and Liability Directive, it highlights the unsuitability …
Conversational Ai And Human-Centered First Amendment, Inyoung Cheong
Conversational Ai And Human-Centered First Amendment, Inyoung Cheong
Michigan Technology Law Review
Human-centered artificial intelligence (AI) is premised on the idea that humans must remain the ultimate locus of agency in technological systems. First Amendment jurisprudence has displaced this commitment. By extending speech protection to algorithmic architectures, the judiciary has forged a doctrinal shield that insulates corporate actors from the consequences of their products. Conversational AI deepens this crisis through intimate incursions into the epistemic and emotional registers of the self. Emerging approaches that anchor First Amendment coverage to the controllability or traceability of AI outputs offer no stable solution. Policy-level design choices such as safety guardrails and alignment processes can readily …
Common Schemes, Real Harm: Examining Fraud In Medicare And Medicaid, Hearing Before The United States House Of Representatives Committee On Energy And Commerce, Subcommittee On Oversight And Investigations, Jessica Tillipman
GW Law Faculty Publications & Other Works
The testimony argues that effective Medicare and Medicaid program integrity requires clear definitions, sustained oversight capacity, and incentives aligned toward prevention rather than retrospective recovery. It stresses that “fraud” is a legal determination and should not be conflated with broader measures of improper payments or documentation deficiencies, because that confusion distorts risk assessments and policy responses. It evaluates the current enforcement ecosystem across CMS, HHS-OIG, DOJ, GAO, and state partners, emphasizing coordination, stable resourcing, and accountability in managed care as central to deterrence. It also highlights how advanced analytics and generative AI can both amplify fraud schemes and strengthen detection, …
The Apathy Economy: Patents, Advertising, And Consumer Indifference, Gavin Milczarek-Desai, Derek E. Bambauer
The Apathy Economy: Patents, Advertising, And Consumer Indifference, Gavin Milczarek-Desai, Derek E. Bambauer
UF Law Faculty Publications
Patents function as signals as well as rights to exclude. They inform competitors, investors, employees, and consumers about the invention and its owner. How this information affects consumers is not well understood. Existing studies disagree about how advertising a product or service as patented, or patent pending, affects the price consumers will pay. This Article offers the first major empirical study of that question and finds that consumers behave with surprising rationality: they will not pay any price premium for a patented product. A product’s patent status conveys little information about whether it is superior to competing offerings. The results …
A History Of Vacatur, Benjamin B. Johnson
A History Of Vacatur, Benjamin B. Johnson
UF Law Faculty Publications
Vacatur, a seemingly routine appellate tool, has evolved into one of the Supreme Court’s most potent instruments for declaring law. This Article offers the first comprehensive historical account of vacatur, tracing its roots from English and early American practice through its twentieth-century transformations to its contemporary uses. Historically, courts used vacatur to manage dockets, correct procedural irregularities, or enforce reversals on the merits. Modern usage has departed markedly from these roots. The Court now frequently employs vacatur to declare binding legal rules without issuing judgments, effectively circumventing traditional limits on judicial power. Taking seriously the Court’s own insistence on history …
Beyond Sharenting, Stacey B. Steinberg
Beyond Sharenting, Stacey B. Steinberg
UF Law Faculty Publications
Sharenting—the practice of parents sharing information about their children online—has become mainstream in American society. While most forms of sharenting may be considered benign or even beneficial, some parents harm or exploit their children when sharing online. For example, “mom-influencers” often violate their children’s privacy in their attempts to attract followers to their social media accounts. While traditional forms of parental sharing raise privacy concerns, we are only beginning to understand the dangers and impacts of widespread exposure of children on social media.
This Article is the first to propose a welfare model of child protection to address exploitative and …
Re-Rethinking Asian Exclusion And Color-Blind Immigration, Gabriel J. Chin
Re-Rethinking Asian Exclusion And Color-Blind Immigration, Gabriel J. Chin
SMU Law Review
During Reconstruction, as Congress debated the place of African-Americans in U.S. society, it evaluated how the principles it articulated would apply to Chinese-Americans. Rather than adopting a race-neutral jurisprudence, it began identifying the ways in which the law could be deployed to deny Asians economic and political opportunities, and the right to immigrate. Ultimately, a joint network of federal and state laws denied Asians the right to naturalize, to own land, and to immigrate. In a rare win, a divided Supreme Court held that the children of Chinese people born in the United States were citizens by virtue of the …
The New Assault On Plyler V. Doe, Cori Alonso-Yoder, Gabriel Sanchez
The New Assault On Plyler V. Doe, Cori Alonso-Yoder, Gabriel Sanchez
SMU Law Review
The second Trump Administration has disregarded a history of bipartisan support in avoiding immigration enforcement actions in schools. Certain states have acted to further target children at school—advancing measures to exclude many from public education based on immigration status. While the Supreme Court in Plyler v. Doe affirmed the state and national interests in educating students regardless of status, the Heritage Foundation has called on states to pass legislation to overturn that decades-old precedent. While no state has yet adopted these measures, many states have tried, marking a new attack on the precedent in Plyler.
This Article builds on …
The Pregnancy Draft, Meghan M. Boone
The Pregnancy Draft, Meghan M. Boone
SMU Law Review
By severely limiting or outright banning abortion, states are requiring pregnant people to perform reproductive labor in the service of the state’s own interests. Unwilling pregnant people are compelled, through the force of law, to continue their pregnancies—to perform a task that is difficult, dangerous, and fundamentally alters their life’s course. The state justifies overcoming the pregnant person’s unwillingness by prioritizing its own interests in the continuation of the pregnancy—articulated at various times as an interest in potential life, the protection of health or the integrity of the medical profession, or the prevention of discrimination.
There is only one other …
Racing To Safety: Tax Policy For Ai Safety-By-Design, Mirit Eyal-Cohen, Yonathan Arbel
Racing To Safety: Tax Policy For Ai Safety-By-Design, Mirit Eyal-Cohen, Yonathan Arbel
SMU Law Review
The White House recently announced its vision of artificial intelligence (AI) policy: AI development is a race and America must win it. To that end, a new America’s AI Action Plan directs federal agencies and states to remove regulatory barriers to AI development and accelerate innovation. This approach leaves limited room for regulatory measures that would address the safety risks of powerful AI systems: their behavior in novel domains remains unpredictable, their decision-making opaqueness, and their alignment with human values is uncertain. While experts warn of large-scale accidents, policymakers find themselves in a bind: Regulate AI and cede ground to …
Holding The Debtor’S Fresh Start Hostage: Bankruptcy Courts Incorrectly Interpret Ransom V. Fia Card Services To Deny Debtors A Car Ownership Expense Deduction, Creola Johnson
Emory Bankruptcy Developments Journal
With the passage of the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005, Congress adopted for the first time a standardized income-based test for measuring an individual debtor’s “disposable income,” which is the amount a debtor must pay to unsecured creditors in a chapter 13 proceeding. Under the means test, debtors calculate their disposable income by deducting from income various standard expenses established by the Internal Revenue Service. One of those standard expenses is a vehicle ownership expense, which debtors can deduct if they have auto loan or lease payments.
This Article is about bankruptcy courts who …
The Hidden Cost Of Prescription Drug Discount Programs And The Lack Of Legal Protections To Protect Consumers, Gina Lee
Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal
No abstract provided.
Making The Law Work: Protecting Classical Ballet Choreographers' Artistic Legacies Through Copyright And Estates Laws, Alice Darakhchava
Making The Law Work: Protecting Classical Ballet Choreographers' Artistic Legacies Through Copyright And Estates Laws, Alice Darakhchava
Cardozo Arts & Entertainment Law Journal
No abstract provided.
Global Supply Chain Resilience In Emerging Technologies: A Case Study Of Bitcoin Mining, Kishanthi Parella, Carla L. Reyes
Global Supply Chain Resilience In Emerging Technologies: A Case Study Of Bitcoin Mining, Kishanthi Parella, Carla L. Reyes
Scholarly Articles
The United States has put into motion bold plans in critical and emerging technologies to bolster its national and economic security. For example, the federal government created a national bitcoin strategic reserve and a stockpile of other cryptocurrency; while several states have committed to or are considering similar goals. However, the security of these reserves is dependent on two types of supply chains within the Bitcoin mining industry: analogue supply chains, relating to the physical components needed for Bitcoin mining, and data supply chains, relating to the complex and layered logistical network of actors that create input into …
Re-Examining U.S. Bailouts In The Digital Era: Moral Hazard And Adverse Consequences, Joel Slawotsky
Re-Examining U.S. Bailouts In The Digital Era: Moral Hazard And Adverse Consequences, Joel Slawotsky
American University Business Law Review
Financial institutional bailouts have become the new normal in recent decades. From the savings and loan crisis, to the sub-prime, to SVB and Signature, the U.S. government and regulators have decided that the failure to protect depositors and investors could lead to bank runs, a destabilized banking sector, and ultimately economic turmoil inflicting tremendous monetary and social costs on citizens. However, the mainstreaming of bailouts has led to moral hazard, i.e., the expectation among all stakeholders including financial institutions, investors, creditors, and regulators, that a government rescue is inevitable. The problem of moral hazard is the creation of incentives to …
Incentivized Delegation In Corporate Criminal Investigations: State Action, Unconstitutional Conditions, And Fifth Amendment Erosion., Ying Zhou
American University Business Law Review
This Article identifies and critiques “incentivized delegation,” an enforcement regime in which the Department of Justice (DOJ) conditions prosecutorial leniency on corporations’ completion of specified, prosecution-oriented, internal investigations of employee misconduct. While courts readily find state action when the government formally delegates investigative functions, they have not squarely addressed whether corporate investigations undertaken to secure prosecutorial leniency—without explicit governmental direction—should likewise trigger state-action scrutiny. United States v. Coburn illustrates the blind spot: by insisting that state action requires overt governmental direction and control, the decision exposes a fundamental failure to appreciate how the government can embed investigative mandates within the …
Procedural Good Faith In Investment Arbitration—What Is It And What Could It Be?, Meg Kinnear
Procedural Good Faith In Investment Arbitration—What Is It And What Could It Be?, Meg Kinnear
American University Business Law Review
When I selected the topic of procedural good faith for this lecture, I did not expect it to be as unwieldy as it proved to be. After all, good faith is a fundamental concept for every law student, and it anchors our approach to legal analysis and “thinking like a lawyer.” As counsel, our core belief is that proceedings must be conducted in good faith, and we each have a professional duty to act in good faith in arbitration.
Nonetheless, I am certain that each of you has witnessed conduct during an arbitration—by the opposite party, of course—that struck you …
Creating A Responsible Authorship Culture In Science: Anchoring Authorship Practices In Principles Of Transparency, Credit, And Accountability, Susan Wolf, Véronique Kiermer, Sofia Adams, Kirsten Bibbins-Domingo, Kathleen Hall Jamieson, Joerg Heber, Mohammad Hosseini, Ana Marušić, Beau Nielsen, Magdalena Skipper, Geeta K. Swamy, Yensi Flores Bueso
Creating A Responsible Authorship Culture In Science: Anchoring Authorship Practices In Principles Of Transparency, Credit, And Accountability, Susan Wolf, Véronique Kiermer, Sofia Adams, Kirsten Bibbins-Domingo, Kathleen Hall Jamieson, Joerg Heber, Mohammad Hosseini, Ana Marušić, Beau Nielsen, Magdalena Skipper, Geeta K. Swamy, Yensi Flores Bueso
Articles
Authorship remains the primary currency of academic credit and a cornerstone of research integrity, yet current practices often fail to reflect the collaborative and interdisciplinary nature of modern science and questionable authorship practices persist. We argue that addressing these shortcomings is a collective responsibility shared by researchers, journals, research funders, scholarly societies, and research institutions. We examined authorship guidelines issued by journals and research institutions and found that their recommendations to researchers are highly variable. We propose that fostering a responsible authorship culture requires a shared, principle-based framework grounded in transparency, credit, and accountability. These three interconnected principles highlight when …
Need For Harmonized Terminology In Cryopreservation To Support Reproducibility, Regulation, And Translation, Susan Wolf, Lakshya Gangwar, Lowell Wolfe, Nikolas Zuchowicz, Irina Filz Von Reiterdank, Srivasupradha Ramesh, Bat-Erdene Namsrai, Joseph Kangas, Joseph Sushil Rao, Matthew Powell-Palm, Timothy L. Pruett, John C. Bischof, Korkut Uygun
Need For Harmonized Terminology In Cryopreservation To Support Reproducibility, Regulation, And Translation, Susan Wolf, Lakshya Gangwar, Lowell Wolfe, Nikolas Zuchowicz, Irina Filz Von Reiterdank, Srivasupradha Ramesh, Bat-Erdene Namsrai, Joseph Kangas, Joseph Sushil Rao, Matthew Powell-Palm, Timothy L. Pruett, John C. Bischof, Korkut Uygun
Articles
As cryopreservation technologies continue to develop, the need for harmonized terminology across the multitude of disciplines where cryopreservation is applied is becoming increasingly acute. Terminology in cryopreservation remains inconsistent, leading to confusion and barriers to progress. Applications of cryopreservation in medicine, food, agriculture, and conservation remain limited by this lack of consensus. Inconsistent terminology contributes to ethical, legal, and societal issues in translating and integrating new cryopreservation technologies. Here we identify the problem with examples of cryopreservation terminology that demand harmonization. We describe the need for terminological consistency by providing examples of effective terminology harmonization projects in related fields. We …
Making Room For Cultural Humility In An Anti-Dei Space, Shelley Ward Bennett
Making Room For Cultural Humility In An Anti-Dei Space, Shelley Ward Bennett
Indiana Journal of Law and Social Equality
This Article analyzes the intersection of state anti-diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) laws and the American Bar Association (ABA) Standard 303(c)’s cross-cultural competency education mandate and offers suggestions for how these policies can coexist. The surge in anti-DEI laws issued in twenty states over the last four years has created challenges and uncertainty for public law schools and their professors seeking to include cultural competency instruction in their curriculum. Though some have expressed concerns that the requirements of state anti-DEI laws and Standard 303(c) may conflict, this Article proposes that such a conflict should not be presumed because Standard 303(c) …
Reimagining Self-Regulation In Sexual Misconduct Complaints: Trust Through Transfer, Allyson M. Mcbride
Reimagining Self-Regulation In Sexual Misconduct Complaints: Trust Through Transfer, Allyson M. Mcbride
Indiana Journal of Law and Social Equality
To increase trust in the judiciary’s ability to self-regulate, any formal complaints about a judge should not be handled by a colleague down the hall, but a judge from a different circuit. In this Comment, I propose automatic transfer out of circuit to improve the handling of sexual misconduct complaints specifically. I first describe the different ways judicial conduct is regulated in the federal system. I then discuss the problem of sexual misconduct in the judiciary. Finally, I outline why it is problematic for judges to adjudicate complaints about their intra-circuit colleagues and recommend that all complaints be automatically transferred …
Operation Midway Blitz: How Federal Immigration Agents Violated International Human Rights, Sarah Dávila A., Alejandra Palacios, Roberto A. Valdez Jr.
Operation Midway Blitz: How Federal Immigration Agents Violated International Human Rights, Sarah Dávila A., Alejandra Palacios, Roberto A. Valdez Jr.
Faculty White Papers
No abstract provided.
Immortal Justice: Why The Henrietta Lacks Family Merits Restitution Today, Suzette Malveaux
Immortal Justice: Why The Henrietta Lacks Family Merits Restitution Today, Suzette Malveaux
Scholarly Articles
Almost three quarters of a century have passed since Henrietta Lacks had her cells biopsied from her cervix without her knowledge or consent. Upon discovering that Henrietta’s cells were immortal, scientists have been able to solve the most vexing medical problems of modern times and save countless lives worldwide. Aware of the cells’ scandalous origins, big pharma has nonetheless commercialized and wildly profited from the HeLa cell line without sharing the benefit with Henrietta’s family, who has been left traumatized and destitute by the initial theft.
Despite the passage of time, Henrietta’s family is seeking restitution today from pharmaceutical companies …