Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Articles 1 - 1 of 1
Full-Text Articles in Law
Where Do Constitutional Modalities Come From? Complexity Theory And The Emergence Of Intradoctrinalism, Jesse R. Merriam
Where Do Constitutional Modalities Come From? Complexity Theory And The Emergence Of Intradoctrinalism, Jesse R. Merriam
Jesse R Merriam
This article seeks to shed light on one of the most vexing and important problems in constitutional law and theory: how courts interpret the Constitution. Part I of the article begins by recounting the major theories of how courts should interpret the Constitution. Part I then explains why many scholars agree that Philip Bobbitt's modal approach has best addressed this problem. According to this approach, courts and lawyers use six modalities or methods to interpret the Constitution. Part I concludes by pointing out that Bobbitt's framework, though helpful, fails in two respects: it fails to explain where these modalities come …