Law Commons^™

Auditor Liability To External Users For Misleading Financial Statements Of Publicly Listed Companies: Two Normative Propositions, John Ja Burke

John JA Burke

In his 2006 article, Professor Eric L. Talley undertook a limited, but important enterprise, to quantify the risk of cataclysmic legal liability faced by audit firms for failure to detect fraud in company prepared financial statements. Drawing primarily from the Securities Class Action Alert database, Professor Talley constructed a “conceptual diagram” to formulate the level of aggregate risk capable of threatening the viability of audit firms sustaining an adverse judgment. The enterprise contributed an objective framework to assist policymakers, both within and outside the United States, to develop appropriate regulatory reforms to address the audit industry’s demand to “limit exposure …

Investing In Distressed Italian Companies Under The Reformed Italian Bankruptcy Law - A Comparison With The Us Bankruptcy Code, Pierantonio Musso

Pierantonio Musso

This article presents a scheme to profitably invest in distressed Italian companies by taking advantage of the Italian Bankruptcy Law in comparison with the US Bankruptcy Code. The risks connected to the insolvency proceeding are analyzed under their economic effects and foreseen in their general appearance. Specific remedies to avoid or mitigate the potential risks are provided. Singular advantages, available only in the proposed investment scheme under the Italian Law, are described. As a result the investment produces a less risky and more profitable outcome than an investment in a non-distressed and non-Italian target company.

When Parallel Tracks Cross: Applying The New Insider Trading Regulations Under Dodd-Frank Derails, Gregory J. Melus

Gregory J Melus

Abstract: When Parallel Tracks Cross: Applying the New Insider Trading Regulations under Dodd-Frank Derails On March 11, 2011, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) brought an administrative proceeding against former Goldman Sachs Director, Rajat Gupta for participating in the insider trading scheme of Raj Rajaratnam. The complaint was the first application of the SEC’s expanded authority under the Dodd-Frank Act to charge an unregistered entity for securities violations in an SEC enforcement hearing. This Comment argues that bringing an SEC administrative proceeding against Rajat Gupta would not succeed because the retroactive application of the Dodd-Frank law would fail the …

The Case Against Credit Bidding: Optimal Creditor Behavior In Chapter 11 Collateral Auctions, Jared Kawalsky

Jared Kawalsky

This paper will attempt to advance some theoretical justifications for recent bankruptcy decisions that have denied the existence of a right for secured creditors to credit bid in the course of a reorganization under § 1129 of the Bankruptcy Code. § 363 of the Bankruptcy Code specifically grants secured creditors the right to bid their credit in a sale of their collateral as part of a going concern sale. However, in a reorganiztion under § 1129, secured creditors are not necessarily permitted to participate in an auction of the collateral underlying their liens. Relying on the broad auction theory literature …

Delaware’S Relevance In Chapter 22: Who Is “Courting Failure” Now?, Ruth S. Lee

Ruth S Lee

This study presents surprising new statistical evidence that contributes to the current “over-heated” academic debate about the Delaware courts’ role in Chapter 11 failure. In 2001, Professor LoPucki published an influential article suggesting that when large corporations file for bankruptcy under Chapter 11, they fail at a dramatically higher rate in Delaware courts than in other jurisdictions. He attributed this to corruption. His article enraged many academics and practitioners, and ignited many articles in the past two decades. This study presents startling evidence that while Chapter 11s filed in Delaware courts did have much higher failure rates from 1991-1996, after …

The Hierarchy That Wasn't There: Elevating ‘Usage’ To Its Rightful Position For Contracts Governed By The Cisg, William P. Johnson

William P. Johnson

The term ‘usage’ generally refers to any practice that is habitual or customary within a given industry, trade or region. Under domestic U.S. sales law, the term ‘usage of trade’ is defined specifically to refer to any practice or method of dealing that has such regularity of observance as to justify an expectation that parties to a particular contract will observe the usage, even though the parties have not expressly incorporated the usage into their contract. Usage of trade can be used under domestic U.S. sales law to interpret, supplement or explain a written agreement. But usage of trade may …

Novel "Neutrality" Claims Against Internet Platforms: A Reasonable Framework For Initial Scrutiny, Jeffrey Jarosch

Jeffrey Jarosch

This Article examines a recent trend in which the Federal Trade Commission and other enforcement agencies investigate internet platforms for behavior that is insufficiently “neutral” towards users or third parties that interact with the platform. For example, Google faces a formal FTC investigation based on allegations that it has tinkered with search results rather than presenting users with a “neutral” result. Twitter, too, faces a formal investigation after the social media service restricted the ways in which third party developers could interact with Twitter through its application programming interface (API). These investigations represent a new attempt to shift the network …

The End Of Mortgage Securitization? Electronic Registration As A Threat To Bankruptcy Remotenes, John P. Hunt, Richard Stanton, Nancy Wallace

John P Hunt

A central tenet of asset securitization in the United States—that assets are bankruptcy remote from their sponsors—may be threatened by innovations in the transfer of mortgage loans from the loan-originators (sponsors) to the legal entities that own the mortgage pools (the Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs)). The major legal argument advanced in the paper is that because the mortgage is an interest in real property, the bankruptcy-remoteness rules applicable to real property, including § 544(a)(3) of the Bankruptcy Code, create a risk to the bankruptcy remoteness of mortgage transactions unless proper recording occurs. We review the traditional mortgage transfer process and …

The Availability Of Takeover Defenses And Deal Protection Devices For Anglo-American Target Companies, Albert "Chip" Saulsbury Iv

Albert "Chip" Saulsbury IV

On July 21, 2011 the U.K.’s Panel on Takeovers and Mergers (the “Panel”) released amendments to the City Code on Takeovers and Mergers (the “Takeover Code”). These amendments, which take effect on September 19, 2011, will have a significant impact on the manner in which companies in the U.K. engage in mergers and acquisitions (“M&A”) and will amplify the differences between British and American deal activity. Because of these amendments to the Takeover Code within the last month, the following Article, The Availability of Takeover Defenses and Deal Protection Devices for Anglo-American Target Companies, is especially timely and will provide …

Voice Without Say: Why More Capitalist Firms Are Not (Genuinely) Participatory, Justin Schwartz

Justin Schwartz

Why are most capitalist enterprises of any size organized as authoritarian bureaucracies rather than incorporating genuinely employee participation that would give the workers real authority? Even firms with employee participation programs leave virtually all decision making power in the hands of management. The standard answer is that hierarchy is more economically efficient than any sort of genuine participation, so that participatory firms would be less productive or efficient and lose out to more traditional competitors. This answer is indefensible. After surveying the history, legal status, and varieties of employee participation, I examine and reject as question-begging the argument that the …

The Ftc’S Proposal For Regulating Ip Through Ssos Would Replace Private Coordination With Government Hold-Up, F. Scott Kieff, Richard Epstein, Daniel Spulber

F. Scott Kieff

In its recent report entitled “The Evolving IP Marketplace,” the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) advances a far-reaching regulatory approach (Proposal) whose likely effect would be to distort the operation of the intellectual property (IP) marketplace in ways that will hamper the innovation and commercialization of new technologies. The gist of the FTC Proposal is to rely on highly non-standard and misguided definitions of economic terms of art such as “ex ante” and “hold-up,” while urging new inefficient rules for calculating damages for patent infringement. Stripped of the technicalities, the FTC Proposal would so reduce the costs of infringement by downstream …

Where Did Mill Go Wrong?: Why The Capital Managed Firm Rather Than The Labor Managed Enterprise Is The Predominant Organizational Form In Market Economies, Justin Schwartz

Justin Schwartz

In this Article, I propose a novel law and economics explanation of a deeply puzzling aspect of business organization in market economies. Why are virtually all firms are organized as capital managed and owned (capitalist) enterprises rather than as labor managed and owned cooperatives? Over 150 years ago, J.S. Mill predicted that efficiency and other advantages would eventually make worker cooperatives predominant over capitalist firms. Mill was right about the advantages but wrong about the results. The standard explanation is that capitalist enterprise is more efficient. Empirical research, however, overwhelmingly contradicts this. But employees almost never even attempt to organize …

"Cost Savings" As Proceeds Of Crime: A Comparative Study Of The United States And The United Kingdom, Richard C. Alexander

Richard C Alexander

The article begins by comparing and contrasting the provisions relating both to asset forfeiture and money laundering under U.S. Federal law and the law of the United Kingdom (in this area, the differences between the provisions of the three jurisdictions making up the United Kingdom are not significant). Some reference is also made to Florida state law, but principally by way of example rather than analysis. It then analyzes the U.S. case law relating to costs saved through the commission of a criminal offense and considers the possible effect of the amendment, made in 2009, to 18 U.S.C. §1956, before …

Demystifying The Determination Of Foreign Law In U.S. Courts: Opening The Door To A Greater Global Understanding, Matthew J. Wilson

Matthew J. Wilson

With globalization and the proliferation of international commercial interaction, U.S. courts commonly encounter issues governed by the laws of other sovereigns. These encounters arise by virtue of private agreements or choice-of-law rules covering contractual relationships, cross-border conduct, tortuous acts, employment matters, intellectual property rights, and various other legal foundations. Because the substantive law applied in an international lawsuit can be outcome-determinative, it is important to accurately ascertain and determine the relevant law. In fact, the proper functioning of private international law in a domestic system is based on the appropriate application of law.

U.S. federal and state courts are presumed …

The Family Smoking Prevention And Tobacco Control Act: Legislation Passed By Congress Or The Tobacco Companies?, Sakineh A. Majd

Sakineh A. Majd

The Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act (“the Act”) was passed by the 111th Congress in June 2009. Granting the FDA substantial authority to regulate tobacco products and how they are marketed, the Act has the power to define the future of the tobacco industry in America, and its passage did not go uncontested. Philip Morris was in support, while competing tobacco firms Reynolds and Lorillard were opposed. With the Act’s controversial passage came accusations that the senators of the 111th Congress voted according to the agendas of the tobacco firms that they were beholden to. I argue that …

“No Fishing Poles Allowed At The Office,” And Other Suggestions On How To Limit “Fishing Expeditions” To An Outdoor Weekend Activity And Away From The Realm Of E-Discovery, Joanna K. Slusarz

Joanna Slusarz

Early settlement is usually encouraged by the courts and welcomed by most parties involved in a lawsuit. However, it may not always be the most favorable result. This idiosyncrasy arises most when the costs of continuing litigation and adjudication on the merits outweigh those of early settlement. On the other hand, early settlement raises the risk of “encourag[ing] additional, low merit cases that might not otherwise have been filed had the company chosen to litigate existing lawsuits.”

The phenomenon of electronic discovery (“e-discovery”) has exponentially increased the occurrence of the latter result. As a result, defendants, particularly large corporations with …

Is There An Efficient Antitrust Approach To Health Care?, Kathryn Ciano

Kathryn Ciano

As American states and the federal government wrestle to find a solution to health care reform, some regulators are looking towards antitrust laws in the international marketplace to govern domestic health care policy. Antitrust principles dictate that antitrust authorities must intervene only when pressures become so great as to interfere with the very operations of the market. Pharmaceutical and health care markets rely on free trade and competitive global cooperation, so there is no efficient antitrust approach to health care.

Mers: Creating Efficiencies Or Clouding Titles? Examining Challenges To The Mortgage Electronic Registration System, Christian Carson

Christian Carson

The Mortgage Electronic Registration System has recently come under fire amidst the recent foreclosure crisis. Since MERS is mortgagee of record to more than 60 million mortgages in the United States, the question as to whether it has standing to foreclose on defaulted loans presents a hurdle to the speedy recovery of the housing market.

It is likely that the MERS framework is a sound one that complies with longstanding principles of property and agency law. Examination of the controlling Supreme Court case Carpenter v. Longan and Restatement commentary reveals that a separation of the mortgage and the note does …

Coerced Debt: An Empirical Examination Of The Role Consumer Credit In Domestic Violence, Angela K. Littwin

Angela K Littwin

When one pictures domestic violence, consumer credit probably does not come to mind. Physical and sexual abuse in intimate relationships has become an acknowledged reality. Structural abuse, which includes tactics such as isolating victims from other relationships and cutting off access to transportation, has also made headway in the public consciousness. Even forms of economic abuse that depress victims’ income have been well-documented. But there is another facet of domestic violence that has not yet been recognized: financial abuse through consumer credit. As consumer lending has permeated American life, violent partners have begun using debt as a means of exercising …

The Global Shadow Bank--Systemic Risk And Tax Policy Objectives: The Uncertain Case Of Foreign Hedge Fund Lending In The United States, Julie A.D. Manasfi

Julie A.D. Manasfi

ABSTRACT: THE GLOBAL SHADOW BANK-- SYSTEMIC RISK AND TAX POLICY OBJECTIVES: THE UNCERTAIN CASE OF FOREIGN HEDGE FUND LENDING IN THE UNITED STATES With the recent financial crisis in the U.S. starting in 2007, much attention has been drawn to the issue of whether and to what extent financial regulation should keep pace with financial innovation and the shadow banking system. However, often ignored is the Internal Revenue Code’s failure to adequately keep pace with this financial innovation. One example of how the tax laws lag behind financial innovation can be found in the taxation of lending into the U.S. …

Warranting Rightful Claims, Karen E. Sandrik

Karen E. Sandrik

Damage awards for patent infringement have sky-rocketed and sparked significant debate in recent years. A part of this patent damage debate focuses on non-practicing entities, or so-called “patent trolls.” A patent troll is a patent owner that demands a royalty based on patented technology, yet does not actually make use of the technology to provide an end product or service. Patent trolls are known for their aggressive and opportunistic behavior. Their strategy is simple: create nuisance and inflict fear. Often, patent trolls employ this strategy against the buyers of goods that use the patented technology. Increasingly, those buyers are availing …

Injecting Law Student Drama Into The Classroom: Transforming An E-Discovery Class (Or Any Law School Class) With A Complex, Student-Generated Simulation, Paula Schaefer

Paula Schaefer

Gem Finch, Boone Radley, and Pickle Harris are just three of the characters who play a dramatic – and key – role in my e-discovery focused pre-trial litigation class. I did not originally invite them into the class for the drama. I was interested in their email. In 2009, I was planning a pre-trial litigation class that would include e-discovery issues. But I could not find a pre-packaged case that included ESI – the electronically stored information that is the mainstay of e-discovery practice. The case materials included in most pre-trial litigation books involved car accidents and simple contract disputes. …

Reconsidering The Separation Of Banking And Commerce, Mehrsa Baradaran

Mehrsa Baradaran

This Article examines the long-held belief that banking and commerce need to be kept separate in order to ensure a stable banking system. Specifically, the Article criticizes the Bank Holding Company Act (BHCA), which prohibits non-banking entities from owning banks. The recent banking collapse has caused and exacerbated several problematic trends in U.S. banking, especially the conglomeration of banking entities and the homogenization of assets. The inflexible and outdated provisions of the BHCA are a major cause of this movement toward conglomeration and homogenization. Since the enactment of the BHCA, the landscape of U.S. banking has changed dramatically. The strict …

Should Insider Trading In Credit Default Swap Markets Be Regulated? The Landmark Significance Of S.E.C. V. Rorech, Adam H. Reiser

Adam H Reiser

This paper analyzes S.E.C. v. Rorech by examining insider trading in CDS markets. Until the recent passage of the Dodd-Frank Act, CDS markets were left largely unregulated, and consequently provided a welcoming atmosphere for insider trading. While insider trading in securities markets has repeatedly been judicially condemned, some scholars have defended the practice as an effective mechanism to promote market efficiency and productivity. This paper asks whether the insider trading regulations currently imposed on securities markets should be similarly imposed upon CDS markets.

The Reality And Practical Application Of A Compliance Standard For Examination Of Documents, Jin Ik Chae

Jin Ik Chae

A documentary credit is a bank's undertaking to pay against presentation of documents which comply with the terms and conditions of a documentary letter of credit. The compliance standard of the documents has in fact been mitigated in recent years, both by the UCP and courts. Especially, the revised UCP 600 was formally adopted and has been in effect for over three years and seven months, there are still a number of issues in it has been operated. Thus, this study is to review the changes, the issues and the reality for the compliance standard for examination of the documents. …

Islamic Law And The Great Recession: Shariah-Compliance As A Sound Business Practice, Joseph Victor Schaeffer

Joseph Schaeffer

A discussion of the recent financial crisis, popularly termed the Great Recession, in terms of Islamic principles of finance. This paper suggests that strict adherence to Islamic principles would have mitigated much of the risk-taking that led to the collapse of the housing market and financial industry.

“Globalization Of Islamic Finance: Myth Or Reality?”, Frederick V. Perry

Frederick V. Perry

“ Globalization of Islamic Finance: Myth or Reality?” This paper investigates the question of whether the phenomenon of Islamic finance or Islamic Banking 1 is truly globalizing, that is, spreading as a universal alternative to conventional finance and banking or whether the proponents of such a view are spreading a myth or are themselves simply deluded by their own enthusiasm. The paper addresses various aspects of the globalization of Islamic finance, among others, the issue of the rise of Islamic banking in the West, Islamic jurisprudence and finance, global standards and integration of Islamic finance, and obstacles facing Islamic finance’s …

Islamic Legal Authority In A Non-Muslim Society: Designing The Islamic Credit Union Of Bellevue, Washington, Todd Williams

Todd Williams

This Article examines the current state of Islamic law within a community of Muslims in the United States as it relates to Shari’a-compliant financial products. After briefly reviewing the history of Islamic finance and Islamic authority structures within the United States, I rely on interviews with multiple parties involved in the establishment of one of the first Islamic credit unions in the United States to explore the development of Islamic law within American regulation and cultural mores. I examine the authority structure present among Muslims in the Puget Sound area, and I examine the qualities that define a credible religious …