Law Commons^™

The Constitutional Infirmity Of Warrantless Nsa Surveillance: The Abuse Of Presidential Power And The Injury To The Fourth Amendment, Robert M. Bloom, William J. Dunn

Robert M. Bloom

In recent months, there have been many revelations about the tactics used by the Bush Administration to prosecute their war on terrorism. These stories involve the exploitation of technologies that allow the government, with the cooperation of phone companies and financial institutions, to access phone and financial records. This paper focuses on the revelation and widespread criticism of the Bush Administration’s operation of a warrantless electronic surveillance program to monitor international phone calls and emails that originate or terminate with a United States party. The powerful and secret National Security Agency heads the program and leverages its significant intelligence collection …

The Special Tribunal For Lebanon’S Unique Beginnings, Its Political Opposition And Role As Model For Future Ad Hoc Criminal Tribunals For Terrorism Prosecution, Daniel Runge

Daniel Runge

This article suggests that the Special Tribunal for Lebanon in many respects can serve as a model for future ad hoc international tribunals for the prosecution of terrorism. The article discusses the assassination of Rafiq Hariri and the investigation that followed, leading to the tribunal’s formation. After this background, the formation of the tribunal is analyzed. Initially designed as a hybrid international tribunal based on a treaty between the United Nations and Lebanon, the tribunal was ultimately established unilaterally by the United Nations Security Council following the failure of the Lebanese government to approve the treaty. The article then discusses …

Targeting Anwar Al-Aulaqi: A Case Study In U.S. Drone Strikes And Targeted Killings, Benjamin R. Farley

Benjamin R Farley

Anwar al-Aulaqi is a natural born American citizen of Yemeni descent who was reportedly added to U.S. targeted killing lists in early 2010. The United States argues that al-Aulaqi is a lawful target due either to his role in an ongoing armed conflict between the United States and Al Qaeda or under the auspices of self-defense. In fact, the United States relies on self-defense and armed conflict in general to justify the lawfulness of its targeted killing programs. When applicable, each of these frameworks provides legal authority for a state to use force against an individual. However, neither framework provides …

For God, For Country, For Universalism: Sovereignty As Solidarity In Our Age Of Terror, Maxwell Chibundu

Maxwell O. Chibundu

No abstract provided.

The Federal Government’S Ability To Respond To A Major Terrorist Attack: Issues, Concerns And Inadequacies In The Disaster Law Construct, M. Jonathan Gil

Michael J Gil

The cunning and zeal of the world’s terrorist organizations require that this country prepare itself for large-scale disaster relief operations. As it stands, the Stafford Act, as well as federal and local government policies are lacking. The federal government has floundered in past situations, and Americans have died as a result. In order to remedy these shortcomings, the government should take two different stances: hands on, and hands off. The hands-on approach is designed to address the shortfalls of past disaster response and the current system, while the hands-off approach is designed to allow the entire relief operation to operate …

Reliably Unreliable: The Problems With Piecemeal Federal Transmission And Grid Reliability Policies, Joshua P. Fershee

Joshua P Fershee

In the past, electricity was considered a local concern, but over time major portions of the electrical grid have become regional, national, and even international in scope. Electricity regulation has evolved into a complex web of multijurisdictional oversight, and this evolution has created both tensions and opportunities. National legislation and regulation have helped increase reliability, diversify the fuel mix for electricity generation, and create a more open market for electricity. However, national regulation designed to enhance open markets also created opportunities for abuse. In addition, the increasing level of federal oversight has led to conflicts between state and federal entities …

A Missed Chance For Justice In Court, Tamar R. Birckhead

Tamar R Birckhead

This op-ed argues that Osama bin Laden should have been captured and tried in a court of law, rather than assassinated under circumstances suggesting he was unarmed and posed no immediate threat.

Book Review: The Modern Law Of Marine Insurance, Vol. 3 D. Rhodian Thomas (Ed.) (London 2009), Graydon S. Staring

Graydon S. Staring

Review of a book by several authors on topics characterized by me as follows: An Anglo-American Subject; Multimodal Boundaries; Plumbing the Depths of Indemnity; Anonymous Assureds: When the Principal "Knows" What the Agent Knows; Institute Cargo Clauses 2009; Indefinable Piracy and Other Crimes; Conflict of Laws--A Cruise on Waters of Discord; Conflict of Laws--Pax Romana.

To Transfer Or Not To Transfer: Identifying And Protecting Relevant Human Rights Interests In Non-Refoulement, Vijay M. Padmanabhan

Vijay M Padmanabhan

Human rights law imposes upon States an absolute duty not to transfer an individual to another State where there are substantial grounds for believing he or she will be tortured or subjected to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment. This protection, called non-refoulement, emanates from a theory of human rights that recognizes rights fulfillment requires States to protect those within their jurisdiction from rights violations perpetrated by third parties, including other States. Generally human rights law recognizes that resource constraints and/or competing rights restrict protection duties. But such limitations have not been recognized in the non-refoulement context with limited theorization as …

To Transfer Or Not To Transfer: Identifying And Protecting Relevant Human Rights Interests In Non-Refoulement, Vijay M. Padmanabhan

Vijay M Padmanabhan

Human rights law imposes upon States an absolute duty not to transfer an individual to another State where there are substantial grounds for believing he or she will be tortured or subjected to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment. This protection, called non-refoulement, emanates from a theory of human rights that recognizes rights fulfillment requires States to protect those within their jurisdiction from rights violations perpetrated by third parties, including other States. Generally human rights law recognizes that resource constraints and/or competing rights restrict protection duties. But such limitations have not been recognized in the non-refoulement context with limited theorization as …

The War Of Ideas Revisited, Gabriel C. Lajeunesse

Gabriel C. Lajeunesse

We need to reintroduce the War of Ideas into our policy lexicon and recognize that our national security interests are best served by the spread of liberty and free markets.

Rise Of The Drones: Unmanned Systems And The Future Of War, Kenneth Anderson

Kenneth Anderson

This document is written testimony submitted to the Subcommittee on National Security and Foreign Affairs, for a hearing under the general title of "Rise of the Drones: Unmanned Systems and the Future of War." The hearing covered military, strategic, technological, and economic issues related to unmanned aerial vehicles in military, intelligence, and civilian commercial use. This written testimony addressed certain international law and legal policy issues raised by the use of drones as a means of projecting force. It is primarily addressed to the question of the CIA campaign of drone attacks in Pakistan and beyond, rather than the use …

Fictitious States, Effective Control, And The Use Of Force, Brian C. Finucane

Brian C Finucane

This Article examines state practice relating to violent non-state actors operating from “fictitious” states. Fictitious states are entities that possess international legal personality but not effective control over their territories and populations. As the Article explains, many of the world’s states are legal fictions. Although the problem is most vividly illustrated by the United States’ recent military strikes in Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia, the problem is far broader. This Article shows that the security threat posed by non-state actors operating from ungoverned territory is not new. Lapses in state control have been common throughout history and violent non-state actors have …

Fictitious States, Effective Control, And The Use Of Force, Brian C. Finucane

Brian C Finucane

This Article examines state practice relating to violent non-state actors operating from “fictitious” states. Fictitious states are entities that possess international legal personality but not effective control over their territories and populations. As the Article explains, many of the world’s states are legal fictions. Although the threat is most vividly illustrated by the United States’ recent military strikes in Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia, the problem is far broader. This Article shows that the security threat posed by non-state actors operating from ungoverned territory is not new. Lapses of state control over territory have been common throughout history and violent non-state …

Fictitious States, Effective Control, And The Use Of Force, Brian C. Finucane

Brian C Finucane

This Article examines state practice relating to violent non-state actors operating from “fictitious” states. Fictitious states are entities that possess international legal personality but not effective control over their territories and populations. As the Article explains, many of the world’s states are legal fictions. Although the problem is most vividly illustrated by the United States’ recent military strikes in Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia, the problem is far broader. This Article shows that the security threat posed by non-state actors operating from ungoverned territory is not new. Lapses in state control have been common throughout history and violent non-state actors have …

Book Review Of Counter-Terrorism: The Culture Of Law And Justice After 9/11, Matthew S. R. Palmer

The Hon Justice Matthew Palmer

This is a largely complimentary book review focussing on the theme of law and culture in the context of counter-terrorism law.

Terrorism, State Responsibility And The Use Of Armed Force, René Värk

René Värk

No abstract provided.

Riikide Enesekaitse Ja Kollektiivse Julgeolekusüsteemi Võimalikkusest Terroristlike Mitteriiklike Rühmituste Kontekstis, René Värk

René Värk

No abstract provided.

The Surprising Lessons From Plea Bargaining In The Shadow Of Terror, Lucian Dervan

Lucian E Dervan

Since September 11, 2001, several hundred individuals have been convicted of terrorism related charges. Of these convictions, over 80% resulted from a plea of guilty. It is surprising and counterintuitive that such a large percentage of these cases are resolved in this manner, yet, even when prosecuting suspected terrorists caught attempting suicide attacks, the power of the plea bargaining machine exerts a striking influence. As a result, a close examination of these extraordinary cases offers important insights into the forces that drive the plea bargaining system. Utilizing these insights, this article critiques two divergent and dominant theories of plea bargaining …

The Ghost In The Global War On Terror: Critical Perspectives And Dangerous Implications For National Security And The Law, Nick J. Sciullo

Nick J. Sciullo

In this Article, I set out to discuss the dangerous implications of the Global War on Terror (GWOT) and, more generally, the at- tempts of the United States government to address notions of terror- ism and its effect on the safety of the United States and world citizens. I am primarily concerned with engaging a poststructuralist critique of the GWOT to strengthen legal discussions of terrorism and national security policy. While many in the legal academy have focused on particular issues relating to terrorism, I will engage in a macro-level analysis of the way the legal academy conceptualizes terrorism—not how …

Zizek/Questions/Failing, Nick J. Sciullo

Nick J. Sciullo

In this article I am primarily concerned with presenting Slavoj Žižek3 as a legal theorist. Žižek has been a valuable contributor to critical theory and deserves a place in the pantheon of legal thinkers.

While his diverse writings are often relegated to other disciplines, they also position him as an important contributor to law and public discourse. I seek to illuminate how he mediates and interrogates the law by demonstrating how his scholarship is important to the lives of legal thinkers, questions of success and the law, capitalism, political practice, and terrorism. Because Žižek’s work is interdisciplinary and expansive, this …