Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- File Type
Articles 1 - 2 of 2
Full-Text Articles in Law
Unconscious Bias In Legal Interpretation, Anup Malani, Ward Farnsowrth, Dustin Guzior
Unconscious Bias In Legal Interpretation, Anup Malani, Ward Farnsowrth, Dustin Guzior
Anup Malani
What role do policy preferences play when a judge or any other reader decides what a statute or other legal text means? Most judges think of themselves as doing law, not politics. Yet the observable decisions that judges make often follow patterns that are hard to explain by anything other than policy preferences. Indeed, if one presses the implications of the data too hard, it is likely to be heard as an accusation of bad faith—a claim that the judge or other decision-maker isn’t really earnest in trying to separate preference from judgment. This does not advance the discussion, and …
Ambiguity About Ambiguity: An Empirical Inquiry Into Legal Interpretation, Anup Malani
Ambiguity About Ambiguity: An Empirical Inquiry Into Legal Interpretation, Anup Malani
Anup Malani
Most scholarship on statutory interpretation discusses what courts should do with ambiguous statutes. This paper investigates the crucial and analytically prior question of what ambiguity in law is. Does a claim that a text is ambiguous mean the reader is uncertain about its meaning? Or is it a claim that readers, as a group, would disagree about what the text means (however certain each of them may be individually)? This distinction is of considerable theoretical interest. It also turns out to be highly consequential as a practical matter.
To demonstrate, we developed a survey instrument for exploring determinations of ambiguity …